Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Ah, the "design world" - a little ranty *LINK*

Posts

Ah, the "design world" - a little ranty *LINK*

#1

Ah, the "design world" - a little ranty *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Well, maybe a lot ranty.

Our local paper - affiliated with the New York Times - ran an article on sustainable furniture Saturday that, as so often with these sorts of articles, had me shaking my head. Most of it was inoffensive enough, but I loved this line: "...Daniel Moyer of Brooklyn neglected to mention the source of the wood that made up the rest of his piece. Only eventually did he reveal that it came from 'the branch of a black walnut tree that fell down in Pennsylvania in the ice storm of 2008.' Five or 10 years ago, anecdotes like that were breaking news in the design industry. Today, one has to beg for them."

That someone used found wood was breaking news at one point? In the last five years? This was a new idea?

And, then, one of the "sustainable" pieces pictured in the article is the Facecord chest - a dresser with pieces of firewood fastened on the faces of the drawers and on the top and sides, all ginned up to look like a stack of firewood (though not, as best I can estimate from the pictures, an actual face cord of firewood, 4 by 8 feet). It's not indicated what material is used for the carcase, and the net wood used is significantly more than used in most pieces of furniture, because the firewood "veneer" is in addition to the carcase. It's also about as practical as a five-wheeled car: the top would be awkward as a place to put things, and I don't understand how you'd ever dust it.

The Times article (just one photo in the public online version) is at http://www.nytimes.com/2011/05/19/garden/international-contemporary-furniture-fair-features-sustainable-and-playful-design-notebook.html?pagewanted=2&_r=1&sq=The%20table%20lamp%20is%20laid%20back&st=cse&scp=2

The Facecord chest can be seen at several websites, including the one linked below.


http://www.housemode.net/rustic-furniture-facecord-chest-of-drawers-by-mark-moskovitz/

Re: Ah, the "design world" - a little ranty *LINK*

#2

Re: Ah, the "design world" - a little ranty

Bill Tindall

We seem to get more and more of "this" world view as "city people" become more distant from the land that provides food, shelter, etc.

Re: Ah, the "design world" - a little ranty *LINK*

#3

Re: Ah, the "design world" - a little ranty

Gary Smyth

It's good to rant. People who act on the NYT Home and Garden section (for furniture) often seem to look more toward unique and trendy than practicality and are more than capable and willing to pay for it (no price has been printed for the facecord chest, -- but you can bet that since it appeared in the NYT it will be in the thousands). The good news is that as in gets dusty and the trend falls by the wayside, they can burn the chest in the woodstove. Of course, the cost per split log will be quite a bit more than real real split firewood, but what the hey, it's the price one pays for being a first adopter.

Re: Ah, the "design world" - a little ranty *LINK*

#4

Dale Lenz

Giving credit

Dale Lenz

Did a find job of drying the firewood, don't see seasoning cracks, or maybe it's still green wood, :">.

Re: Ah, the "design world" - a little ranty *LINK*

#5

Further thoughts

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

As an art piece, the firewood chest is fine. I have to confess that "storage" is not my first thought when I see a stack of firewood ("warmth" comes to mind as the first thought), but, as I look at it, I can see the designer staying at a cabin, looking at a well-stacked cord of wood, and seeing the shape resemblance to a piece of case furniture.

And I have no trouble with artsy furniture, although I probably wouldn't put much of it in my house - it wouldn't fit the rooms.

But this guy's selling art as furniture. Furniture, whether traditional, plain, or quirky, needs to function first. Then it can go in whatever direction the designer wants. This piece fails that basic test.

Re: Ah, the "design world" - a little ranty *LINK*

#6

five-wheeled cars

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

And then, it turns out there ARE five-wheeled cars, though non in production as far as I know. Way back in the 1950s, someone in the town next to my home town designed an attachment that lowered the spare wheel down, lifting the rear axle, and swung the back of the car out of tight parking spaces. Apparently, the idea's resurfaced from time to time since.

Well, OK, maybe a bad metaphor...or maybe not.

Re: Ah, the "design world" - a little ranty *LINK*

#7

Re: Further thoughts

FredD

"But this guy's selling art as furniture. Furniture, whether traditional, plain, or quirky, needs to function first. Then it can g in whatever direction the designer wants. This piece fails that basic test."

Very little difference in that from selling Scrap iron as art.

I visited the Fine Arts Museum of the University of Washington in Seattle about 1980 and they had devoted a entire floor to the latest rage in Art(they said) it was called "Heaping ,Piling and Throwing , I kid you not.

Mounds of Barb Wire and scrap iron fastened to the wall , one of the stated criteria of the Art form was it had to be sound enough structurally to not sag or collapse or fall off the wall.

I was especially overwhelmed on entering a room which had a Docent explaining to a group the meaning of a single row of 16"sq. Copper floor Tile that ran across the room from the entrance and up two tile high on the wall.

My Sister-in-Law said "that does it, I'm getting my money back" and we left.

FredD

Re: Ah, the "design world" - a little ranty *LINK*

#8

Art as furniture...

John in NM

This has always been one of my pet peeves (read pointless peeves). Furniture should be both functional and attractive, art has the option of being the latter alone. Whether or not a piece is attractive is subjective, whether it is functional is not, and artists who try their hand at furniture often forget this.

I once went to a local furniture show in Tucson (I was not enough of a muckity muck to be in it :D). Along with all the functional and not especially artistic furniture there were a pair of concrete barcaloungers. As sculpture, they were by far my favorite thing in the show. But they were not furniture, and thus did not belong in the show.

Re: Ah, the "design world" - a little ranty *LINK*

#9

Every minute...

John in NM

As in, how often the suckers are born :D

"...Daniel Moyer of Brooklyn neglected to mention the source of the wood that made up the rest of his piece. Only eventually did he reveal that it came from 'the branch of a black walnut tree that fell down in Pennsylvania in the ice storm of 2008.' Five or 10 years ago, anecdotes like that were breaking news in the design industry. Today, one has to beg for them."

Without a doubt, both the artist and the author require that any meat they eat died quietly of old age on a nice pastoral farm upstate. People are just dying to believe anything that makes them feel good, regardless of whether it is likely or not. This is not a new phenomenon, as evidenced by the used car salesmen assuring the potential buyer that the car for sale was gently driven by an old lady to church and back every Sunday.

The only thing more common than people desiring this sort of sentiment is the ways that have been devised to take advantage of it.

Re: Ah, the "design world" - a little ranty *LINK*

#10

Clint Searl

Re: Further thoughts

Clint Searl

Frank Lloyd Wright got away with designing some of the most functionally god-awful furniture to furnish his houses, and it's considered great ART.

Clint

Re: Ah, the "design world" - a little ranty *LINK*

#11

Wood through the brush chipper

Tom Dunlap

For over 35 years I've been an arborist. I've sent tons of wood through a brush chipper. Some of my cuttings have been salvaged..chips as mulch, firewood, turning wood and lumber. Nothing new, just trying to get the oink out of the pig.

The firewood dresser is beyond rustic. Heck, the wood isn't even stacked right. Anyone who stacks wood knows how to stack a tight pile.

When I see twig furniture I cringe. How many thousands of dollars worth of creation do I send through the chipper in a half hour of chipping.

If anyone finds that they're in short supply of wood find any arborist, they'll be happy to give you a life time supply!

Re: Ah, the "design world" - a little ranty *LINK*

#12

Re: Ah, the "design world" - a little ranty

Thomas S Stockton

I want to know what happens when all the creepy crawly things that I find in my wood pile crawl out. Love to see the look on the clients face when they find a baby garter comes out of the piece. Otherwise it really doesn't do anything for me.

Tom

Re: Ah, the "design world" - a little ranty *LINK*

#13

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Ah, the "design world" - a little ranty

Jesper, Denmark

The sustainability part is likely that one would quickly get tired of looking at it and use it for it's two original purposes: Warming the house and fattening the wallet of the builder.

Re: Ah, the "design world" - a little ranty *LINK*

#14

Well... There's a positive side..

Hikmet C. Sakman Victoria, BC CDN

if you make a dinner table out of that, it would provide an extra source of protein for your clients and they will be thrilled with that Tom!!!! Don't you think?

Chico...

Re: Ah, the "design world" - a little ranty *LINK*

#15

Marketing

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

I'm seeing a lot more referrences by fellow furniture makers to words like "sustainable" or "environmentally conscious" etc. In terms of marketing they make for great buzz words.

I'm not really sure how much more environmentally friendly one form of hand made furniture is over another. If one strives to recycle materials then that's great. But in the big picture of our planet I am not sure that handmade furniture is a significant factor compared to commercial manufacture.

The majority of furniture made and sold in America is made abroad....much in Asia. From what I have read, production of furniture in Asia is quite un-environmentally friendly. From deforestation to chemicals etc. the big box stores are loaded with shoddy furniture made under the worst of conditions.

Perhaps if Americans were really interested in more responsibly made products they would spend a few bucks more for hand made furniture made by folks who could really use the business right now.

Re: Ah, the "design world" - a little ranty *LINK*

#16

Dale Lenz

Re: Marketing Green

Dale Lenz

Tell folks your work will out last the cheaper wood products out there, by a long shot... save future trees. You can see the lightbulb click on in the customer's eyes. Will it seal a deal, ?

Have a great day.

Re: Ah, the "design world" - a little ranty *LINK*

#17

Re: Well... There's a positive side..

Thomas S Stockton

Yeah invite your friends over for chocolate fondue with free range bugs from your furniture, dibs on the stink bugs

Re: Ah, the "design world" - a little ranty *LINK*

#18

In a way....I do....

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

I know where my lumber comes from....mostly Indiana and Ohio. It is not harvested from clear cutting areas and some of it is "urban forested" (trees cut down in people's yards etc). I can honestly tell them that the wood comes from sustainable sources. But moreover, you are right...I would expect my work to out-live big box furniture several times over.

I'd like to say that I do all that to be an environmentalist but quite honestly I have worked that way for years. But if mentioning it seals a deal then I'm all for a little self promotion.

The only fault I have is that I polish all my furniture with the skins of clubbed baby seals......KIDDING! ;-)

Re: Ah, the "design world" - a little ranty *LINK*

#19

If you ask me...

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

all this natural-artsy-fartsy stuff started with the "live edge". It always looks to me as if the maker forgot to rip both sides of the top. Now, people even want it on their counter tops.

Re: Ah, the "design world" - a little ranty *LINK*

#20

Re: In a way....I do....

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

yeah, nothing is better for hand rubbing a wale oil finish than a baby seal skin.

I think you hit the nail on the head about if it helps seal the deal why not. I have been building almost exclusively with wood I mill with a chain saw since 1994. It didn't start out of any environemtalism but out of being poor. I could not afford the cost of making all the spec work I make out of the materials I do if I had to float the cost of materials. I have a pair of small tables made out of highly figured claro walnut that would cost me $1800 each if I had to buy the wood but for me it cost a day of my time and a few bucks worth of gas.

The truth is that to get that one fantastic walnut tree I have had to mill a lot of nice but not highly figured trees, so in real terms I may not be saving any money. Even so I now have over 100 2" thick slabs of walnut and I would have a very hard time putting together a stock pile like that if I was paying cash on the barrel head.

Robin

Re: Ah, the "design world" - a little ranty *LINK*

#21

Not unique to woodworking

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

At some point - not sure when, exactly, but the recent evolution seems to have started in the 1950s* - the crafts folk figured out that the artists were getting a lot more prestige and even making more money for the time spent in production, and started looking at the art elements of the crafts they practiced. There wind up being lots of parallels among the crafts: Dale Nish and his super-rough wood turnings (these have kind of faded from view, not a bad thing in my opinion) have strong parallels with a potter named Peter Voulkos, for instance. Both of them produced work that, by the traditions of the crafts they practiced should have been thrown out; but they both made national reputations as artists.

There's been a real tension for a long time now between the crafts practitioners and the arts practitioners. As so often in these sorts of philosophical discussions, the dichotomy is false (in my opinion); but people get all wrapped up in one or the other.

I happen to like natural edges, although the idea was done so many times it got to be a cliche (living here in the land of redwood burl coffee tables in the 1970s, I can testify to the cliche), although I'll never have a natural edge coffee table in my house - wouldn't fit. But I do want my tabletops to be flat enough to set something on. And I'm always past bemused by the dining room tables with little gaps in the middle just wide enough for food and schnitzels of various kinds to get trapped but too narrow to clean effectively. Nice in the showroom, maddening five years later when the gap looks like a slice of the nearest dump, when you can see through the spiderwebs in it.

*although finding a starting point for darned near anything isn't easy; you could just as logically pick the Arts and Crafts movement as a starting point. It's kind of like (digressing here) those newspaper stories that implicitly set the beginning of the civil rights movement in the 1950s (or, even worse, 1963), ignoring 150 years of struggle on the subject.

Re: Ah, the "design world" - a little ranty *LINK*

#22

OK, trying to get my head in the right space here

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Functionally, this appears to be a gatepost masked off so I can paint the building it's next to. But I'm thinking of titling it "Ghostpost" and trying to sell it. What do you all think?


Re: Ah, the "design world" - a little ranty *LINK*

#23

Maybe insted of a fake rock or soup can

kellyanderson72

you are supposed to put it outside with the rest of your fire wood and hide your valuables in it. Who would ever think of looking in a stack of fire wood for a diamond necklace or a bunch of money. Could be better than a safe, and if your house ever caught on fire then all of your valuables would be outside and out of harms way.