Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Sawstop

Posts

Sawstop

#1

Sawstop

FredD

Quote from FWW email

"SawStop technology won't save you from kickback.

This week, news emerged that Consumer Products Safety Commission Chairwoman Inez Tenenbaum has directed her staff to draft a new tablesaw safety regulation package, which will be released for public comment in September."

FredD

Re: Sawstop

#2

True But

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

The true riving knife will. Not a "splitter" nor useless set of pawls that everybody throws in a drawer anyway, but a true riving knife. Ask a European woodworker about "kickback" and most will look at you with a puzzeled expression of "What's that?" That's because all Euro saws have had integral riving knives for decades; they don't get kickback.

Funny, until Gass and his company started making saws with real riving knives here, American manufacturers never incorporated them.

Re: Sawstop

#3

Re: True But

FredD

It was a quote Mark ,from FWW email free to speculate .

FredD

Re: Sawstop

#4

Re: True But

john lucas

My worst kick back would not have been prevented by a splitter, or saw stop. I was cutting 3" square blocks to length using a 3/4" spacer block between the fence and wood and before the blade so set the repetitive cuts. This is what I learned in some book or magazine to keep the wood from pinching between the rip fence and miter gauge. It has worked perfectly for many years.

Well one day I was cutting these pieces and the saw vibration made one of them rotate. Diagonally the 3" block is longer than 3 3/4" and the blade grabbed it and hit me in the chest so hard it took my breath away and left a bruise. This was a pine 3x3x 3/4 block. I can't imagine getting hit by an Oak piece a foot long (of course that's a different cut anyway and riving knife would work)

I now use a 6" spacer block between the fence and miter gauge to do this kind of repetitive cut.

Re: Sawstop

#5

Re: True But... really not true

Sgian Dubh

"That's because all Euro saws have had integral riving knives for decades; they don't get kickback."

Mark, kickback can and does occur even with a riving knife. The phenomenom is (I'd say) relatively rare compared to, say, a saw fitted with a splitter. Similarly I'd guess that incidents of kickback are statistically insignificant for saws fitted with a riving knife compared to the number kickbacks that occur with table saws used with no guards at all.

However, as a European that has spent nearly forty years in the furniture making industry using European saws fitted with European safety devices, ie, riving knife, crown guard and short set rip fence, I can report that I have experienced a couple of incidents of kickback; I am also aware of other European woodworkers using similar European saws that have experienced kickback-- but the incidences of are indeed rare.

I also lived and worked in the USA for ten years. During that time I used a couple of European style saws and a small selection of standard US style unguarded cabinet saws. I witnessed several incidents of kickback in that ten year period-- I can't recall how many exactly, but perhaps two incidents per year, and all of those kickbacks happened when the user was using the unguarded US style saws.

My (perhaps) imperfect recollection is that about 95- 98% of all the kickback incidents I've witnessed or know of in workshops I've been involved with over my working life occurred in that ten year period when I lived and worked in Texas. Slainte.

Re: Sawstop

#6

Re: Repeats

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

on small parts are perhaps the most dangerous because concentration can more easily waiver.

For what you describe, John, I use a cross-cut sled with stops (instead of the rip fence) and hold-downs so that the wood on both sides of the blade is "controlled" during and after the cut.

Re: Sawstop

#7

Thanks Sgian

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

I've updated my data base from "never" to "rare" :D Serves me right for writing in absolutes. Given Mssrs. Murphy and Cohen, I should know better.

Guess it goes to show that there ain't no such thing as "foolproof" or "completely safe" when it comes to machinery.

peace

Re: Sawstop

#8

Re: Sawstop

Dave Paine

Saw Stop will also not help if the person wants to use a smaller blade. Some of us will use 7in circ saw blades at times. I do this if I have a glue up which needs to be cut into strips and I want the thinnest blade to minimize waste.

Also will not help for dado blades. I feel using a dado is less risk of touching the blade due to not making a through cut, but still could cause kick backs.

I agree with the splitter vs riving knife. My previous saw had a splitter. It prevented some kickbacks. The wood closed on the splitter. I really prefer the riving knife. On my saw it can be adjusted to be just below the top of the blade, so would not need to be removed for dado cutting. It would need to be removed for use with dado blade.

A TV program the other evening talked about the 101 gadgets which changed the world. One was a chain saw. It mentioned 28,000 injuries a year from people using a chain saw and typical injury required 120 stitches. Feels like a bigger potential benefit if these injuries could be reduced than the table saw community.

Many tools have potential hazards. Some design elements make sense, like the riving knife, large stop button. I am not sure about Saw Stop. When I purchased my new saw last year I could have purchased a Saw Stop. I chose another brand.

Re: Sawstop

#9

Re: Sawstop

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

I have three personal friends whom have lost fingers and mangle their hands on the TS, using Dado blades. All of them broke my self-imposed rule, which is, "Never feed the wood through any tool, with the force of your hands directly into the blade, if the wood wasn't there." You can feed forward and into a fence before, beside, and behind the cutter, without ever directing your effort right into the blade.

Those friends all were plowing a groove, by pushing down while running their hands right over the top of the blade. All of these guys were professional woodworkers, two with ~ 30 years experience, and the other ~15. I had warned one of them, but since he had done it that way for many years, he wouldn't listen.

I believe we have covered this before, and that Saw Stop has a special part for dado heads.

I also heard that the heads of most of the other tool makers of TS were heading to DC to lobby against new regulations. However, I hope they know they will be no match for the insurance lobby, if they decide they can save $$$$$ on pay-out, which will mean more money in the pockets of for their chiefs. .

Re: Sawstop

#10

Moses Yoder

Re:Where are you getting your info?

Moses Yoder

Why wouldn't the Saw Stop work with a dado blade? One of the shops that builds cabinets for us has a Saw Stop and uses it with dado blades a lot, and the operator was once saved from a nasty cut with a dado blade because he touched the blade. Who says the Saw Stop doesn't work with a dado blade? I don't agree that the government should force us to use the Saw Stop technology, but when you look at buying a Saw Stop dado to use with their saw for $300, $175 to replce the brake cartridge, versus $10,000 to get your fingers sewn back onto your hands it's kind of a no brainer, especially if you are running a business.

Re: Sawstop

#11

Ric Taylor

$175??  No Way

Ric Taylor

The brake cartridges are available for $69 on line at many websites. Searching might find it cheaper.

Ric

Re: Sawstop

#12

Re: $175??   Way

Neal in San Jose

When my SawStop saved my finger, I spent the afore mentioned $69 plus tax for a replacement cartridge and counted the $100 cross cut saw blade as ruined. At least, I'm not going to use it again after the violence it saw when the brake fired! I think that's where the $175 number comes from.

Re: Sawstop

#13

Ric Taylor

Re: $175??   Way

Ric Taylor

That part does make sense.

Ric

Re: Sawstop

#14

Re: $175??   Way

Nelson

$69 for cartridge, $100 for blade + tax = $175 plus.

Re: Sawstop

#15

Re: Thanks Sgian

Sgian Dubh

"it goes to show that there ain't no such thing as "foolproof" or "completely safe" when it comes to machinery."

Add 'idiot proof' to that list Mark. There's no such thing because there is, as we all know, a dumber idiot, ha, ha. Slainte.

Re: Sawstop

#16

SAWSTOP provides FREE cartridge

North of the Border

if you send the activated one back to them for analysis and if indeed the Sawstop was activated by the contact with flesh....Of course, you can't use your TS in the meantime.

Re: Sawstop

#17

Re: SAWSTOP provides FREE cartridge

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I imagine this would be worth doing even if you buy a cartridge to keep in production - the freebie would then be the backup.

Of course, it's better never to put any hot dogs, fried chicken, etc., into the blade.

Re: Sawstop

#18

Re: SAWSTOP provides FREE cartridge

Larry in NW OHIO

I don`t understand how they could tell if it was a hot dog or a finger. Larry

Re: Sawstop

#19

Re: SAWSTOP provides FREE cartridge

North of the Border

http://www.sawstop.com/report-a-save/

Apparently, SAWSTOP's analytical program can tell the difference (from the electrical charge that went through the circuit?) between human and non-human activations. I know of a SAWSTOP user who did receive a free cartridge after submitting his "finger saving" package. He is a very experienced woodworker and is trying to convince everyone he knows to get a SAWSTOP because of his personal experience. Here in Canada, many commercial shops and public schools have been replacing their tablesaws and I believe the insurance costs are lowering in that respect.