Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Don't buy that stationary saw just yet.

Posts

Don't buy that stationary saw just yet.

#1

Don't buy that stationary saw just yet.

Gary Smyth

This is a pass through and my take on a story this AM on NPR's morning edition. I'm just advising about what I heard.

Federal Consumer Products Safety Commission (FCPSC) is now drafting legislation for public comment about 90 days from now concerning stationary power saw safety. (It is on the fast track for responding to comments and drafting legislation for pre Christmas release.)

They have seen the �Saw Stop� system and they like what they saw.

They (FCPSC) equate this push in the category of early opposition, but now essential safety legislation, like safety belts, air bags, and non locking refrigerator doors. The "benefit" is to prevent the annual 4000 power saw related amputations of fingers and hands.

Big manufacturers of saws are scrambling to come up with better blade guards to make the Saw Stop technology moot. You can expect lots more conversation, and probably new safety product introductions in the next 120 days. The manufacturers seem to think that the problem will resolve itself without the need for legislation by developing new products and, even better, if Mr. Gass, the patent owner, will donate the technology to them freebe.

With all that going on behind the scenes, publicly, saw manufacturers say that the technology costs too much ($100-$150) per saw, and it would double or triple the price of a saw. Unfortunately, instead of taking an average of mid-range saws, they used the base price of a saw as $100-$200 to come up with the double or triple cost estimation. (Editorial comment. Please. How many of you out there have a stationary power saw that (new) cost $200?)

At any rate, expect a bunch of information about stationary saw safety coming at you soon. Editorial for magazines is about 90 to 120 days in advance of publication so about August/September there will be a lot written about this matter.

Re: Don't buy that stationary saw just yet.

#2

Moses Yoder

Re: Don't buy that stationary saw just yet.

Moses Yoder

I wonder how long it will be before the government mandates that toilet seats be left down to preven people from falling into the toilet? Or maybe they will pass legislation that people may only pee at 6 am, noon, and 6 pm to save water.

Re: Don't buy that stationary saw just yet.

#3

Re: Don't buy that stationary saw just yet.

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

While they are at it, they need to pass legislation to require "Chisel Stop" systems. That was the last tool I cut myself with. It wouldn't have happened if there was a device that exploded the cutting end of my chisel off when it came in contact with my skin. Should I be consulting a lawyer?

T.

Re: Don't buy that stationary saw just yet.

#4

Re: Don't buy that stationary saw just yet.

Jesse Cloud

Don't hold your breath. The saw manufacturers have had what, 50 or 75 years to come up with a decent guard, but have only been able to make them crappier than what came before.

If this is implemented, I suspect it will be pretty much the way they did the riving knife requirement - all saws redesigned after xxxx date (probably 2 years after the rule is published) have to have the new stuff. So we are probably looking at 10 years or so before they become prevalent. I suspect they will just wait for the Saw Stop patent to expire...

Re: Don't buy that stationary saw just yet.

#5

Re: Don't buy that stationary saw just yet.

Wesley

I see a law governing band saws and planers coming. I got it! How about a law on reading the owner's manual and using the saw properly? It may change but, I have been using a table saw for over 20 years. To date, no one has had to say, Keep fingers away from the circular thing with teeth protruding through table spinning @ 1700 RPM. Perhaps it should be mandated there be a safety course before purchasing these machines. Maybe I'm too old school ;)

Re: Don't buy that stationary saw just yet.

#6

OSHA will get giddy over this

Yonak

It will, likely, not stop there. OSHA will have a field day with this and will want to include this technology on every industrial cutting, grinding and stamping machine there is.

Re: Don't buy that stationary saw just yet.

#7

Why not?

John in NM

I could see the logic if one had a large business running several saws, governed by the ever changing, inscrutable, and arcane whims of your friendly OSHA representative.

For the individual, any legislation passed will only effect what is available for purchase after it is implemented, but not what they already own.

If one wants to avoid the new saws, just buy a used one. If one wants the new and improved version, but needs a saw now, just buy one now and re-sell it when the improved ones come out. There should be a little bit of a bump in pre-safety saw value and demand for a couple months after any new safer designs hit the market.

Re: Don't buy that stationary saw just yet.

#8

Re: NOT WHY NOT - WHY??

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I for one feel I am intelligent enough to take care of myself, so far I have never seen anyone in political office that I think I want to tell me how to run my life. Anyone that feels that they should have a Sawstop - more power to them. I DON'T and I sure think it should be left up to the more intelligent people (woodworkers) not lawyers/politicians to decide. There is no one forcing anyone to use any table saw. If you or anyone feels they are to dangerous, there are hand saws or other hobbies for people - or buy a sawstop - just don't make me use an old saw because you don't like the dangers.

Re: Don't buy that stationary saw just yet.

#9

Re: NOT WHY NOT - WHY??

Larry in NW OHIO

Larry That is what Big Brother is for, it`s to protect you and keep you safe and tell you what`s good for you. Haven`t you heard of the food police, they want to tell you what you can have to neat, because we little people are to stupid to know what is best for us so we live healthy. LONG LIVE BIG BROTHER. Larry

Re: Don't buy that stationary saw just yet.

#10

Re: Don't buy that stationary saw just yet.

Hal

Please, oh please, get the gov't out of my life. I have been using table saws for over 60 years. The first two had blade guards with anti-kickback pawls that were so useless and in the way that I amputated (no pun intended) them. My present saw is an old Enlon (predecessor to Griz's G1023 line) with any safety device long since gone. I have used "yellow wheels" mounted on the fence for many years as well as zero clearance inserts. My only injury (relatively minor) in this time was due to absolute, unmitigated stupidity on my part and could have been prevented with a zero clearance insert. If someone wants a SawStop, fine and dandy, but leave me with my yellow wheels, zero clearance inserts and an assortment of push sticks. Hal

Re: Don't buy that stationary saw just yet.

#11

Re: Don't buy that stationary saw just yet.

John Lucas

I see no reason to force it on other manufacturers. If consumers want it, they will put enough pressure on the manufacturers to add it to their saws. I don't need the government telling me I have to do it.

Look at all the crap on my car that I don't need, can hardly afford to repair when it goes bad, if in fact it can be repaired.

In the NPR segment he mentions the refrigerator door, but how much did that actually cost the manufacturer.

I am thinking about upgrading my table saw and will seriously look at the saw stop saws. I think it's a good technology. However my budget is limited and it simply may not fit in.

Re: Don't buy that stationary saw just yet.

#12

Re: NOT WHY NOT - WHY??

FredD

Worse then you may have thought Larry...

"haven`t you heard of the food police, they want to tell you what you can have to neat, because we little people are to stupid to know what is best for us so we live healthy. "

When I see all of the two legged Rhinos leaving the Supermarket with a cart full of Potato chips and soda pop , you gotta think something is wrong and it's starts early with the youngsters weighing more then us as adults.

CNN had on this morning the sad fact that we as a country rank 50th in Life expectancy at 78 years.

Monaco was tops with 89 years.

The Government study linked this sorry statistic to smoking, overeating and no exercise.

FredD

Re: Don't buy that stationary saw just yet.

#13

Good grief....

John in NM

Read more carefully, I'm not taking either side or looking for a fight.

The question was "why not buy that saw just yet?" Nothing in the OP made me think there was any reason not to buy a stationary saw if one were in the market, unless they are unfortunate enough to fall under OSHA jurisdiction. That was the question, nothing more.

So settle down a bit and quit shouting at me dammit :D

Re: Don't buy that stationary saw just yet.

#14

Chain brakes on chainsaws, seatbelts, helmets

Tom Dunlap

The list can go on and on...the Gov is already in our lives, good or bad, right or wrong.

There are always examples of more dangerous safety issues that could be discussed that would save more lives.

Why are tobacco products even allowed? It's one form of legalized drugs that has support. More people would be alive and in better health if tobacco weren't around. There's NO compelling reason to even have the product available. There are plenty of reasons to have table saws.

Re: Don't buy that stationary saw just yet.

#15

Re: Don't buy that stationary saw just yet.

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

Thanks for posting this, Gary. However, I should point out that only the legislature can legislate; what the FCPSC (a part of the Executive branch) is doing is called Rule Promulgation. When rules are adopted, however, they do carry the force of law.

(start of soapbox moment)

I am concerned that so many of us are willing to condemn the Commission without actually hearing what is being said. This same hearing process led to seat belts, air bags, PTO guards, safety interlocks, etc. that have clearly had a beneficial impact on our lives. If you are so concerned that these rules are detrimental, (or if you really think they should be adopted) look up the contact data associated with the proposed rules and make your comments known directly to the Commission. They are required to read them.

(end of soapbox moment)

Re: Don't buy that stationary saw just yet.

#16

One I can answer...

John in NM

"Why are tobacco products even allowed? It's one form of legalized drugs that has support. More people would be alive and in better health if tobacco weren't around. There's NO compelling reason to even have the product available."

Simple, people enjoy them. They aren't healthy, but the users like the stuff, same as booze. Last attempt to ban booze benefited no one but the mob and politicos, banning tobacco would do the same.

I've known no less than three people in my lifetime seriously injured or killed while either rock climbing or hiking in rough terrain. Going to ban that too? All three were doing so for no compelling reason than enjoyment. But that is a pastime that is currently PC approved, whereas smoking and chew are not.

Re: Don't buy that stationary saw just yet.

#17

Re: Chain brakes on chainsaws, seatbelts, helmets

Larry in NW OHIO

The only reason tobacco is still around is because of MONEY, the government gets an enormous amount of taxes off of it, so they can have the money to tell us what is good for us. Larry

Re: Don't buy that stationary saw just yet.

#18

The part that bothers me.....

Barry Irby

is the fact that any of us can have this technology if we want it. SawStop table saws are there for the purchasing. This is not like some technology that could be implemented but is being withheld for some reason. (Like the 100 MPG cars we are sure they are hiding from us)

Re: Don't buy that stationary saw just yet.

#19

Yes

Ron

and we should add that not only can we choose among saw features (like having this safety feature or not), but insurance companies can choose to apply different premiums to for-profit woodshops depending on whether they have this safety feature on their equipment. That's all good. If premiums price in the lower hazards of Saw-Stop, good decisions can be made by everyone. Those decisions will vary across saw buyers and insurance buyers, because preferences and conditions vary.

You know that messes such as this are the consequence of us holding our elected officials responsible for every darn thing (the economy, unemployment, etc.). Stuff happens; why can't we accept that?

ron