Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Heat for Workshop

Posts

Heat for Workshop

#1

Heat for Workshop

Kelly M. Robison

Hi All, I'm hoping with all of your vast information and knowledge, someone can point me in the right direction. I am having a workshop built this summer. Size: 32 ' X 24' [768 Sq Ft]. I am going to insulate and sheetrock the walls and ceiling. Now my problem: I want to heat it so I can work in it year around. I called my local heating and furnace company to get a quote on a propane furnace with duct work and they told me that it would be ABOUT $6,000.00. Well, you can imagine my shock when I heard that, because that's about 4 thousand more than I figured on, and that will buy a whole ton of tools that I don't need. Any suggestions??? I looked at some heaters in the Northern Tool catalog and they have some propane type that are designed for garages, etc; but I was thinking about a real good wood stove with a fan; that way I could burn my mistakes. I forgot to mention that I live in the Seattle area, so it doesn't get much lower than 40 degrees except in a rare occassion. I was also thinking that with a real good wood stove, I should be able to get it started first thing in the morning and get it warm enough to work in the shop during the day. I also have 3 acres of woods that I can cut down if I can get the war dept to approve the project. I can't go to the budget person [wife] and ask for additional 6 thousand for heat. Please help me!!!

Kelly Robison in Port Orchard

Re: Heat for Workshop

#2

Re: Heat for Workshop

Barry Irby

I have a friend who has a similar sized shop here in Virginia near Richmond and he has a heater that hangs for the ceiling and has a fan in it. I just looked them up and you can buy a similar one for between $500 and 750. Not perfect but does the job. I would think you could get one installed for about twice that. You can put a thermostat on it and set it to come on at a low temp when you are not there and turn it up when you are. It responds very quickly so it will bring the temp fast.

A second choice might be a ductless Heat pump system like the Mitsubishi Mr. Slim. Substantially more expensive but would also give you AC. These system can be split and you could have two or more indoor units. This would not be as responsive as the gas furnace, but will not have a flame. (No ignition source if you plan to do finishing.)

Really cheap would be a tank mounted portable heater.

Re: Heat for Workshop

#3

Re: Heat for Workshop

Gary Camp, Bend Oregon

While I know that a lot of folks don't favor woodstoves in a shop, I love mine. My shop is 24 X 48 and reasonably well insulated. I can get in comfortable less than an hour with a not so efficent stove down near zero. If I know I am going to be in the shop the next day, I might even heat it up the evening before for a couple of hours. Tool arrangement is also a key.

Re: Heat for Workshop

#4

Re: Heat for Workshop

Henry Higginbotham

Seldom below 40�?! You might very well get by with just a couple of 1500-watt ceramic heaters. $30 each at one of the borgs. My shop is also 32 x 24, and if the low's only 40, I usually get by with just one such heater. When it drops to the teens, I use a Mr. Heater Big Buddy portable propane heater hooked to an outside tank. Propane gets expensive.

That said, be sure you do go for as much insulation as you can get. And make the walls 6", not 4". With a 6" wall, you can set the studs at 24" spacing, use windows made to install between 24" oc studs, and dispense with headers, cripples, and jacks, all of which transfer heat more readily than six inches of fiberglass will. I believe you might also no longer need a doubled top plate, as the studs and roof trusses would be aligned.

But then when it comes to houses and shops, I'm at least as much a dreamer as a builder, so ask someone who's done it and actually knows.

Fred Davis, what's your take on that type of construction?

Re: Heat for Workshop

#5

Agree on the insulation

John in NM

Whether you end up with a wood stove or the ceramic space heaters, or the ceiling box (I've used those too, lots of outfits like Grainger sell them) having a well insulated structure makes all the difference.

We heat a 1400 square foot straw house with two 7200 watt heaters, usually set way down to 50% or below. But then we pick up a lot of solar gain that you might not get up there in cloud central. Heating bill for us is about the same as it used to be in Tucson, back when fuel was cheap, and it's much colder here. Spend your money on insulation, not heating (has the added benefit of being super easy to do, so you get a lot more for your money by doing the job yourself).

Re: Heat for Workshop

#6

Re: Heat for Workshop

mdclor

Whatever heat source you decide on, be aware that raising and lowering temps can cause condensation on cold metal tools like your table saw top causing rust. I would either try to avoid temperature extremes or cover steel/iron to keep condensation off my tools.

HTH,

Merle

Re: Heat for Workshop

#7

Re: Heat for Workshop

Barry Irby

Not Fred, but I agree on the construction you mention. Forty years ago it was called Arkansas Framing. Supposedly developed by the power company in Arkansas. I built a bunch of houses using the techniques they espoused. I still agree with all of it. 2X6 studs on two foot centers with the trusses set right on top of the studs using a single top plate. Windows fit between the studs.

I could go on and on, but it was a neat system and produced houses with remarkably low HVAC bills and little additional cost. One problem was that you had to be careful about the siding. It had to be rated for studs on two foot centers. Another downside was when the code started to require Egress Windows. They did not fit between the studs.

Regardless of all that, insulate the heck out of your shop. Quieter, less heat in winter and less AC in summer. You can buy smaller HVAC equipment and save enough to up grade the insulation.

And, I agree abut the wood stove if its properly installed. A nice way if you make a mistake to turn those SOBs into BTUs.

Re: Heat for Workshop

#8

Clint Searl

Electric heat pump - AC

Clint Searl

Re: Heat for Workshop

#9

Re: Heat for Workshop

BillTurpin in WNC mountains

Any fired un-vented heater will add moisture to your shop. Not good with steel tools. Insulation is a one-time cost.

Re: Heat for Workshop

#11

problem with wood burner

Jerry Gibbs

I had a double barrel wood burner. In addition to being inefficient for non-continuous use, the thing took far too much space. especially when it is hot, because you need con-combustible space around it. Replaced with a hanging unit gas heater. Store cabinets under it. keep shop at 45 in winter and air heats to 60 quickly. Use fans in the summer. shop is 24x24x9 and insulated.

Re: Heat for Workshop

#12

Re: Heat for Workshop

FredD

Kelly since your going to do this only once more then likely , do the best you can , point out to the budget dept , that a little more spent now on insulation and forced air heat will pay off big time.

A well insulated building with 2x6 walls ten feet high , double , not single top plate and scissor trusses to vault the ceiling is a good start.

The quote on the forced air sounds way to high given that the building will be snug.

You should have no trouble heating the shop with the smallest available high efficency furnace, installed in it's own closet , or like mine, in the tool room to avoid open flame combustiblity.

Stud spacing is better in the long run for a bunch of reasons set at 16" O.C and ten foot sheets of 5/8ths T -111 is sold all over the West coast , being the strongest and least costly of exterior wall cladding.

Get more then one HVAC shop to quote you on the heat, with the vaulted ceiling , you can run a central trunk down the center of the shop above the ten foot line and have however many registers blowing down that is needed.

Enclosing the ducting in the floor or ceiling naturally cost's more , but esthetics give way to practical approaches in a shop enviroment, so exposed ducting actually is more efficient then one in the wall or ceiling or floor.

You haven't said anything about the floor system , but that is a important component of the shop.

Make it easy on your feet and legs, any questions about that , feel free to email me.

FredD

Re: Heat for Workshop

#13

Re: Heat for Workshop

Mark Nowicki

Two 2500 Watt electric baseboards, one electronic thermostat and some #12 wire would cost me (in Montreal) less than $200. Even with the connection cost the whole system would probably cost less than a $1000.

Re: Heat for Workshop

#14

Re: Heat for Workshop

Joseph Mulherin

Along with what Fred has proposed, you can buy insulation sheeting which can be scored to fold and make your own ducting. Try to Google to find an explanation for how to do it. Grills can be cut in anywhere you need them.

Another way to heat the large room would be to install some in-floor PEX tubing and use a 50gal waterheater and a small circulating pump. And electrical outlets and dust collection could also be installed at the same time for the various machines you will be using...without having long cords and dust tubing hanging around in the air or underfoot.

Re: Heat for Workshop

#15

Re: Heat for Workshop

Joseph Mulherin

Follow-up: Johns Manville has a pdf on explaining the entire process on how to make and install.

Re: Heat for Workshop

#16

Re: Heat for Workshop

Joseph Mulherin

website for JM pdf: www.specjm.com/files/pdf/AHS-30.pdf

Re: Heat for Workshop

#17

Re: Heat for Workshop

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I built my 30 X 30 workshop about 6 years ago - my sons' and friends helped. The only work I contracted was the concrete floor finish. (Now I wouldn't have done that). Couple suggestions - first build it with 2X6 construction on 16 centers. I figured the cost of lumber and it was less than $300 versus 2x4. This allows you to use thicker insulation and you can hang anything on the walls you want. Second thing I did was to have trusses built that provided a room upstairs. This is an 8' high X 30' X about 10' wide (with knee walls) that provides a great wood storage area. I installed my own natural gas forced air furnace with central air in the upstairs area. I dropped an area of the ceiling about 4" between 2 trusses and ran an 8X24" trunk line in that recess to both sides of the shop. then I connected a trunk line to that and ran it on top of the trusses end to end of the shop then ran my hot/cold air registers from it. The furnace is a sealed combustion style that pulls air in from outside to burn in a 2" pvc pipe. The chimney is also 2" pvc that goes out the end of the shop. The cold air inlet is in the ceiling. I had to have a much larger unit than you need as I live in central Indiana with down to -15 or so temps. This whole system (with our labor) cost me around $3500. One other thing - when you build your shop, add as many concrete blocks as necessary to the foundation to get the ceiling height you want. I have (as I remember) 3 courses of 8" blocks exposed - this with standard studs and wallboard gives me a 10' ceiling. I also installed a 9' high garage door - makes it a little easier to bring in big equipment etc. Put in all the electrical outlets you think you will need - then add about 50% more - they are cheap and easy to install when you are building but expensive and difficult later.

Re: Heat for Workshop

#18

Re: Hanging forced air woodstove

Chuck Lenz

The neighbor and I built and installed a hanging forced air woodstove in my shop quite a few years ago, and I still use it to this day, it's been a great source for heat up here in the Dakotas where it gets plenty cold.

Re: Heat for Workshop

#19

Re: Another tip - windows

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

If you are building your own shop, you can purchase "offsize" custom windows for about 1/4 to 1/2 the price of comparable factory standard windows. I went to a surplus house and bought my entry door and 5 high quality double pane vinyl windows for under $450. I don't plan to ever replace them so didn't matter to me if they were 1 or 2" off standard size. Most Window replacement businesses have a whole room full of off size windows that either were not built to the spec, or the installer measured wrong and returned them. They are real happy to give you a great deal to unload them.

Re: Heat for Workshop

#20

Steve Strickland

12k BTU Window Unit

Steve Strickland

I use a 12k BTU window unit that both heats and cools for a 24 x 24 x 11 room in my shop. It cost $450 and does a nice job. The front panel pops off so that the coils can be cleaned very easily and quickly. On super cold mornings I use a propane tornado heater for 30 minutes to jump start things.

Re: Heat for Workshop

#21

Re: Another tip - windows

FredD

Thinking along Larry's line of thinking, I made my entry door and the double four foot by eight foot high doors from the same T 1- 11 siding I clad the outside with.

Make a frame from 1/6 Pine, using a center rail for the lock, cut some rigid insulation for the inside of the door and clad the outward facing side of the door with the siding and the inside of the door with 1/2" AC plywood.

Makes the strongest door possible and blends with the siding for a uniform look to the building.

One other thing that is relatively inexpensive are double glazed Shklights over areas where you want a lot of light, I put four in my shop .

FredD

Re: Heat for Workshop

#22

what about insurance

John Lucas

My insurance company won't let me have a woodstove in the shop. I used one for several years in the house until they tried to drop us unless I removed the woodstove. I know I could us it safely and I have tones of scrap and downed trees to draw from. it's frustrating not using one to heat with.

Re: Heat for Workshop

#23

Thanks for posting that....

Barry Irby

I know Joe Lstiburek. Have taken a class from him and attended several seminars. I like to think he is the best building scientist in the country. That article brought back a lot of memories.

I wonder if they will ever get my local county to adopt such framing. The local Code guys "invented" braced wall panels. They are so proud of them I thought they might burst during the presentation. They basically want the entire house skinned with OSB. There were about fifty builders and a few home inspectors watching their presentation on their pet project. Finally, Somebody had the nerve to ask what problem they were trying to solve. Had there been a rash of house collapses we had missed?

Re: Heat for Workshop

#24

Re: Thanks for posting that....

Steve Schoene

Yes, there were a bunch of house collapses--they were associated with either seismic events, or hurricanes. Worrying about shear strength does make a lot of sense in regions subject to those events. I suspect large tornados are beyond building to withstand, except for a "safe-spot".

Re: Heat for Workshop

#25

Re: Thanks for posting that....

Barry Irby

I have been building or associated with building for forty years, actually more. All that time we braced the corners with a sheet of plywood or OSB. Occasionally we used the metal strap braces. We occasionally get hurricanes, probably about once every five years and rarely get tornadoes. Significant seismic events are very rare. In no way am I suggesting we should ignore those things or shear strength of buildings. OTOH we have heat loss or gain nearly every day. Perhaps we should strive for buildings that will survive likely shear stresses and function well thermally.