Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Milestone on the French Footed Chest

Posts

Milestone on the French Footed Chest

#1

Milestone on the French Footed Chest

Bill Tindall


It is finally finishing time. It is stained . The stain is a home made mixture of Japan Colors burnt Umber(12% wt. per cent) diluted in General Finishes "clear" oil stain.


The stain is applied with a wad of cotton rag, like a shellac rubber. Applying this way I can control the development of the color. Almost none is wiped back off. Only 60 mL (2 oz) was sufficient to do the whole chest and drawers.

I have one coat of thinned varnish sprayed on (Benjamine Moore alkyd varnish I got in Canada). Not sure if EPA allows it in US, like varnish contributes any measurable assault to the environment. It is 80 degrees here today and it was dust free in just a few minutes. It will be hard enough to scuff sand tonight and then another coat of less thinned varnish will be applied. I'll see how it looks at this point and maybe not apply a 3rd coat. I don't want to build up a thick coating.

Re: Milestone on the French Footed Chest

#2

Re: Milestone on the French Footed Chest

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Good Afternoon Bill,

Everybody would be proud to say they made that lovely piece. It is evident how much care and thought went into it, as well as experience necessary to convert a mental image into external reality. Beautiful.

George

Re: Milestone on the French Footed Chest

#3

Re: Milestone on the French Footed Chest

Joanne in Point Pleasant, PA

Wow! It's looking fantastic, Bill. Although, I think I'd prefer it if the 'finials' on top were on the bottom. Hey, they could even serve as feet! (Just teasing! I DO know it's upside down now) Nice job on the carving. Is this the first major carving you've done or have you incorporated it in your work before?

Re: Milestone on the French Footed Chest

#4

Re: Milestone on the French Footed Chest

Bill Tindall

I hired the carving done, May May. I can't/don't carve. I requested whimsical. I was pleased with result. Are you suggesting I have the plans upside down?!?

Re: Milestone on the French Footed Chest

#5

finials.....

Bill Tindall

I chuckled all day a that flash of humor.

Re: Milestone on the French Footed Chest

#6

Just wondering

Mike Farinella

Bill, I guess you fill the nail holes after finishing?

Re: Milestone on the French Footed Chest

#7

good question and a philosophical answer

Bill Tindall

I presume you are referring to the nail hole in the drawer cock bead. I can think of three nail hole approaches.

Fill and disguise- I would do this approach if the nail hole was where it would show from the outside of the piece. I would do at least some filling before finish and some touch up after. I would shape the hole to not be obviously a round nail hole.

Fill and let it look like a filled nail hole- I have about quit this approach. But if I was to do it I would fill before finishing. I have come to accept that an unfilled nail hole is more honest than an obviously filled one. So now I leave them unfilled if they don't obviously show.

Re: Milestone on the French Footed Chest

#8

Ellis Walentine

Honesty in finishing

Ellis Walentine

Your comment begs another question: "How does honesty enter into the design equation?"

Ellis

Re: Milestone on the French Footed Chest

#9

Ellis Walentine

Questions on stain color and technique

Ellis Walentine

I'm always interested in how people decide on the final value (on the light/dark continuum) and hue that they want their furniture to have. You've chosen a rather light and cool color for this piece, which I'm sure will be a fine solution for the assembled dresser and its surroundings, but I'm wondering what decisions you made en route to this look? Sometimes people are motivated to match a color that is suggestive of a period or style or type of wood; other times, they start with an open mind and experiment with different colors and finish combinations until they are satisfied or impressed by one in particular.

In the case of a piece with "French" connotations, I could see wanting to mimic the hues of French walnut antiques, which would be similar in value and perhaps only a bit warmer. But, I'd welcome your insights.

Also, I was wondering if you had compared the stain color and complexity produced by your "rubber" technique versus brushing or wiping on a full coat and then wiping off the excess. It would seem that the muslin might tend to retain a lot of the pigment, allowing a higher ratio of vehicle to be deposited on the wood and less pigment in the pores. If so, this could be a good thing depending again on your intentions.

Please tell us more.

Ellis

Re: Milestone on the French Footed Chest

#10

Re: good question and a philosophical answer

FredD

"Fill and let it look like a filled nail hole- I have about quit this approach. But if I was to do it I would fill before finishing. I have come to accept that an unfilled nail hole is more honest than an obviously filled one. So now I leave them unfilled if they don't obviously show."

Following that line of analogy to it's logical conclusion , then you wouldn't stain the wood to look like something it isn't naturally , would you ????

Just wondering is all , ;-))

FredD

Re: Milestone on the French Footed Chest

#11

you are correct.....

Bill Tindall

which is why I don't stain the wood to look like something else. Unstained walnut can look like ash after it bleaches out, or just plain ugly if the wood bleaches and the finish yellows.

Re: Milestone on the French Footed Chest

#13

Gasp again!

Bill Tindall

I had to take a deep breath after these questions. The answers to your questions will be disappointingly prosaic.

I'm always interested in how people decide on the final value (on the light/dark continuum) and hue that they want their furniture to have. ******Burnt Umber pigment leaves walnut looking like walnut. Since it is a mineral pigment it doesn't fade so the walnut stays the same color, probably forever.

You've chosen a rather light and cool color for this piece,*****I'm no artist but my daughter is. I think she would disagree with "cool". Burnt umber is a bit reddish on walnut, which when combined with the yellow of the varnish I think results in a color she would call warm. But that's all beyond me. I just think it looks good and most important will continue to look good.

But I'm wondering what decisions you made en route to this look? ****see above

In the case of a piece with "French" connotations*****, " French Feet" I have no idea where that name came from. French feet are common on American Federal Period furniture, which is what this chest started out to be. French feet are not uncommon on some modern stuff too. This thing is headed for a girls bedroom. The dainty feet and whimsical skirt should be appropriate.

Also, I was wondering if you had compared the stain color and complexity produced by your "rubber" technique versus brushing or wiping on a full coat and then wiping off the excess.******the rubber can result in a more uniform, lighter staining. Especially effective on cherry where I use a different mineral pigment.

It would seem that the muslin might tend to retain a lot of the pigment, ****don't think so. Compared to the size of the pigment particles the pores in the fabric would look like barn doors, open.

Re: Milestone on the French Footed Chest

#14

Ellis Walentine

Shades of honesty

Ellis Walentine

Since you feel that leaving holes unfilled is a "more honest" approach than attempting to hide them (or to hide them poorly?), I simply questioned the term "honesty" as it pertains to design decisions like this. I'm always looking for design dimensions I hadn't thought of, and honesty is one of them; unless it is in other, more understandable, terms.

Ellis

Re: Milestone on the French Footed Chest

#15

Ellis Walentine

Thanks

Ellis Walentine

I really hadn't expected surprising answers, Bill, but I thought that, regardless of how prosaic your deliberations were, the process and the reasoning was worth coaxing out of you for the benefit of others.

You confirmed what I expected to hear about your color choice, i.e., your preference for natural looking wood, but what "looks good" to you could have been influenced by other, unspoken preferences.

My reference to the color temperature had to do with the fact that freshly cut black walnut has a decidedly bluish cast which of course fades with time and oxidation. But, even when tinted with a warm pigment like burnt sienna, it retains a slightly purplish hue that renders it a bit cool to my eye. It probably doesn't help that I'm looking at a photo of unknown color and brightness fidelity, on a monitor that may or may not be calibrated correctly. If it solves the design equation, including looking good to you, that's all that counts.

Ellis

Re: Milestone on the French Footed Chest

#16

a stab at your question

Bill Tindall

When I look at even the highest quality Period furniture, I see the makers didn't feel the need to hide or disguise features of construction that were already "hidden" inside the piece. It got me to thinking that if something is a necessity of design or assembly and it doesn't distract from the appearance or utility of a piece, why not let it remain in its natural state.

A tiny nail hole in a drawer's cock bead is a perfect example. It is most expeditious to fasten on the cockbead with a few brads, 3-4 on even a long drawer, to hold it all in place while the glue dries. One could go to extra effort to glue and clamp the cock bead and eliminate the need for brads entirely. But if one chooses to use a brad or two, only to be seen upon opening the drawer, why attempt to hide the fact that a brad was used? Is there something sinful about the use of a brad or two that it should be hidden? I think not, so there they will be for all to see upon opening the drawer. ( More likely never noticed by anyone other than a curious woodworker.)

Re: Milestone on the French Footed Chest

#17

More

Bill Tindall

Some will remember some years ago I hand scrapped an oak floor. The scraper left an occasional ripple that I could have readily removed with a bit of follow up sanding. But I thought, hey, I just finished this floor the old fashioned way by hand scraping it. Why hide this fact? So I left the scraper imperfections. They are only noticed upon very close inspection. I hope that someone from Antiques Road Show will buy the house and one day exclaim, "Holy cow, someone hand scraped this floor!".

Re: Milestone on the French Footed Chest

#18

more on color

Bill Tindall

I was tempted to post something just on this color issue. I get out the soap box every time someone starts on the superiority of air dried walnut because of its superior color. Baloney. I had the example to debunk that notion! But then I didn't have the motivation to drag that issue out again.

It has taken me forever to build this thing. The bow front introduces a myriad of complexity at every turn, finally ending when I had to carve the applied feet to blend with the skirt to follow the conflicting curvature of the foot and bow. I didn't think I had it in me to accomplish this task but necessity is also the mother of motivation.

Anyway, this walnut is air dried and it has that purplish color some rave about(personally I hate it). But, in the time it took me to complete the drawers the purples were long gone(even in a basement with no windows), to be replaced by typical walnut brown, air or kiln dried, it doesn't matter. However, when I carved the applied front feet the fresh surfaces regained the purple shades again. Looked like hell against the aged surfaces, I might add. But not to worry, even a few minutes in the sun and it was all the same again.

The drawer with the rag on it looks accurate to me in the picture as it comes up on my computer. Warm reddish brown. Doesn't have the yellow varnish applied yet in the picture. The varnish subdues some of the reddish. In the end it looks very much like a mid 1800's family walnut piece that seems to be varnished, or stuff I see in museums.

I am not crazy about the color of dichromate on walnut. Just as well because only a fool would choose to use it in the way it is normally used.

Re: Milestone on the French Footed Chest

#19

Re: Milestone on the French Footed Chest

Joanne in Point Pleasant, PA

I like it, too. I don't know that I'd have thought of "whimsical" to describe it, but that is a very good word. Classy, but it makes me smile. Not quite so formal as to look stuffy and not quite so casual as to look sloppy or silly. Just right. Whether it's upside down or not. :-)

Re: Milestone on the French Footed Chest

#20

Re: finials.....

Joanne in Point Pleasant, PA

Ah, that's why I'm here! So happy to provide a smile for someone when I can! Can't wait to see this piece all together. I know you can't either.

Re: Milestone on the French Footed Chest

#21

that is what I got for hiring an experienced woman

Bill Tindall

to do design and carving.....just right. Sometimes it is good to know ones limitations. It goes in a young woman's bed room and I think it will look just right there.

Re: Milestone on the French Footed Chest

#22

Dale Lenz

Making people smile/laugh...

Dale Lenz

is a good thing. Seen a person on one of my friends FB page, wrote her, she did not remember me, still doesn't, as it's been since the mid-60's in Sunday school class, she also went to different public school than us, once again only saw her on Sundays. Told her she made me laugh a lot. She was very please with that outcome, as she still trys to make people smile. You and her, Carol, makes the world a better place, Thank You.

Re: Milestone on the French Footed Chest

#23

Re: more on color

FredD

A couple of things about KD versus air dried , which I am sure you know

I can tell steamed Walnut from across the room if the Kiln operator was trying to blend the Sapwood into the Heart color.. a pitiful process and a muddy result.

I frequently use Black Walnut with a Water clear Lacquer and since I make the furniture for inside use , have not had the yellowing you describe , though anything is possible. I will say anything with Varnish on it , has a tendency to yellow on Dark wood.

The colors you guys are talking about , like the Purple and Greenish Blue streaks in Walnut seem to start about Eastern Missouri and continue East.

The Black Walnut in Kansas does not have that coloration , though Kansas is one of the four states with a large native Walnut stand in it's original range.

Wood in it's aging process will do what it will do , which you strive to avoid with a pigment stain.

That works , but it is a step I don't feel necessary for me at least.

On the other hand , one of my favorite all purpose woods is White Ash and I will stain that nearly every time for the reasons you ascribe to Walnut, only it will turn Yellow much faster left natural then Walnut.

FredD

Re: Milestone on the French Footed Chest

#24

Ok, I accept the challenge....

Bill Tindall

"I can tell steamed Walnut from across the room if the Kiln operator was trying to blend the Sapwood into the Heart color.. a pitiful process and a muddy result."


The two pieces of walnut in the picture were cut adjacent to one another. One was steamed equivalent to the steaming process used to color the sapwood in a commercial operation, while the other piece was simply air dried. After steaming the steamed piece was the typical sooty black. Each piece was planed after drying. The two pieces sat in a sunny room for a month. Then the picture was taken.

Which one was steamed?

BTW, walnut is not steamed in a kiln. Kilns can't make enough steam to do the job. Walnut is steamed in a sealed building or even an autoclave with dead packed lumber. The process is described in my Hardwood Production article in the Articles section. The requirement is to get the wood temperature up to about the boiling point of water without drying the wood (hence the need for steam heat) at which time the sap wood miraculously colors nearly as dark as the heart wood.

Re: Milestone on the French Footed Chest

#25

Re: Ok, I accept the challenge....

FredD

I don't know what to say Bill , but the boards are a strange color for Black Walnut.

About the steaming process , when J. E Higgins was in Union City, California their Kiln was loaded with flatcar loads on a rail line that the wood was brought into from SP RR.

Leo Wofford a friend of thirty years ran the kiln and when I would be at Higgins waiting for the Truck to be loaded , I hung out with Leo and he showed me things about Dry Kilns , I never would have had the opportunity otherwise to see, which certainly doesn't make me a expert on Kilns , but I always was a fast study.

The building was certainly sealed , equipped with power vents, giant sized boiler and if any steaming was done at Higgins , that's where it was.

White Brothers in Alameda ,Ca had a similar operation though much older and decrepit.

This does not count the sawmill near Ruth Dam , in the sixties when I and another Carpenter in the Winter time in two feet of permanent snow installed new 4"x6" double T @G sheathing on the roofs that the saw mill made.

This was a wonderful job in the Winter when nobody was working in construction and it was so warm on the roof, from the adjacent Kilns that we worked without shirts to stay cool.

Stayed all week in the Sportsman Lodge and ate there , all on the Saw mill tab.

Memories

This of course may be different then what you describe.

FredD