We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
I've been asked to build a small desk (24" x 36"). I really should call it a small table with a drawer as there isn't going to be any other drawers.
Now I know that someone (sooner or later) will sit on this desk. I was thinking about having side stretchers at about 12" from the floor. I was also thinking about either having a back stretcher or an offset center stretcher.
I've sketched it up and I'm reasonably happy with doing it either way. An offset center stretcher (4" from the back legs) gives plenty of room for a chair.
Here's how I made a 26x40 desk to show off a pretty piece of maple. The drawer hangs from the top, and they float on inset levelers mounted on the base. The drawer opens from either side.
The question is, "How do I design the understructure of this piece so that it will resist racking when someone of less than X pounds sits down on it in such a way?" The short answer is "shoulders." Rails provide rack resistance proportionate to the height of their shoulders. If you want to protect against side racking, you'll need rails front and back with tall enough shoulders to resist the design load (plus whatever safety factor you decide on). Since you need a kneehole in this desk, you can't have a front rail, so you'll have to compromise. One reasonable compromise would be a center stretcher between side rails, as you proposed. The closer it is to the centerline of the table, the more evenly its rack resistance will be distributed front and back. And the amount of resistance will vary with the height of the stretcher, so think in terms of rails and stretchers that are taller than they are wide.
All design is compromise, so you'll have to decide how to reconcile your engineering requirements with the aesthetics and the likelihood that someone will actually sit on the piece.
Most design is a series of compromises so one of the first things to address is what you can�t compromise. This list is usually topped by function and will often include color and some elements of style, i.e. Craftsman, Federal, Shaker�. Rarely will this list include things like "tables must be able to function as chairs"
Not only is it reasonable to expect adults to not sit on a table, a 30" tall table is not a comfortable chair. I understand wanting your table to hold together if someone sits on it but it does not need to be designed to be sat on day in and day out. It is also important to note that when sitting on a 30" surface you are not subjecting it the same loads and stresses you do when sitting on a 15" tall chair with arms and a back.
When I approached this same design problem my solution was to use a substantial apron joined with mortise and tennon and forgo any lower support structure. I further complicated my design by floating the top above the apron by 1". To solve the problem of how to attach the top as well as how to keep it flat I added stretchers between the front and rear apron. These stretchers are the full width of the apron and attached with blind mortise and tennons. The top is attached to the stretchers with blind segmented sliding dovetails. I don't think this adds any racking resistance but the table is very strong and is used regularly in our home as well as traveling with me when I do craft shows.