Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Welding/Repairing Iron Railing questions

Posts

Welding/Repairing Iron Railing questions

#1

Welding/Repairing Iron Railing questions

Barry Irby

I have bought another house at foreclosure and am planning to fix it up and either rent it or flip it.

The front rails have hollow square tube posts of iron about an inch square and they have rusted off. I thought the fix was to have a railing company bring their mobile truck and weld a short piece back onto the bottom. The company I called was hemming and hawing.

I could insert a piece of re-bar inside the square tube and "fix" it with JB weld or Rock Hard Water putty.

What is the repair for this and what if any advice do you have?

Re: Welding/Repairing Iron Railing questions

#2

Re: Welding/Repairing Iron Railing questions

Mark Nowicki

Telling a service company how to do something usually does not generate an enthusiastic response.

I would get a new post, 1/8" X 1" flat bar, and self-tapping screws.

A cheap wire feed or stick welder would come in handy.

Mark

Re: Welding/Repairing Iron Railing questions

#3

Rick L

Re: It's not iron...

Rick L

...sounds more like steel tubing. It might be cheaper to relace the piece if you can find one. Can you take the railing out and bring it to a welding shop? Frankly you don't give enough info to advise a real choice. Might be cheaper to just get a new railing.

Re: Welding/Repairing Iron Railing questions

#4

Re: It's not iron...

Joseph Mulherin, Sr

Barry, why do you try constantly to try to "fix" something when the proper solution is to just replace it with new materials? If the fence is rotted or rether rusted in one place3 it might as well be happening somewhere else in the dence you have not found as yet. Replace it with a new fence and be done with it.

Re: Welding/Repairing Iron Railing questions

#5

Along those lines.....

natleslie comcast.net

Along those lines, my general feeling is that houses built in the last 50 years or so tend to have "useful life expectancies" of around 30 years for most things in and on them (but obviously not everything). If this railing is original and starting to rust out, I would replace the whole thing. You're only talking about 10 or so feet of railing, right? I didn't consider replacing a blower on a 35-year old furnace in my house since a myriad of other probs could have cropped shortly after. I went with replacement.

I can understand not wanting to sink lots of money into a house you won't be living in but I think you need to keep the overall age of whatever you're working on in the back of your mind and whether replacing is the better option than just patching. It's likely that whatever company you contacted hemmed and hawed because you're trying to cobble together a fix on a 40-year old steel railing.

By the way, the "useful life expectancy" line came from the very competent home inspector who did the inspection on my house. He couldn't (as no one could) say that the furnace (for example) will give out in the next year, only that its gone past its "useful life expectancy".

Take another look and decide if you should cobble or replace based on its age.

Re: Welding/Repairing Iron Railing questions

#6

Re: Welding/Repairing Iron Railing questions

Bill Howatt

I'm not overly surprised they were hemming and hawing - often when something fails because it rusted out it means the rest of it might not be far behind. It can be a real problem if you are trying to find something solid to weld.

Given that it is a safety railing there may be concern of liability being assumed by the weldor.

Bill

Re: Welding/Repairing Iron Railing questions

#7

Re: It's not iron...

Joseph Mulherin, Sr

Attempting to cobble something together just to make some money or to save money when it is a SAFETY RAILING is NOT the way it should be repaired. And you call yourself a Home Inspector....

I give you an F for failure on inspecting and your repair thought.

Re: Welding/Repairing Iron Railing questions

#8

Re: Welding/Repairing Iron Railing questions

Barry Irby

Those of you who commented it is probably not iron but steel are probably correct. I am pretty sure they are steel, but are sold locally as "Wrought Iron" rails.

They have rusted off in a characteristic fashion right where they enter the masonry. A combination of the corrosive effect of the masonry and the water held in place by the masonry.

One reason I don't want to replace them is that they are bolted to the house and a premium vinyl siding has been install and conceals the connection. I really don't want to dig into the siding. I know how to remove and reinstall regular vinyl but have no experience with this stuff.

My inspection is visual and not technically exhaustive, but it appears that only the bottom couple of inches of the steel tube. When did it become fashionable to throw away 90% of something because the other 10% succumbed to the elements? I got into the house today. The toilet leaded and rotted out the floor around it. Would the suggestion be to tear down the whole thing and start all over? I believe I can fix it but there is safety to consider. It would be a shame to plunge through the floor with an errant potty.

Re: Welding/Repairing Iron Railing questions

#9

Welder/weldor

Tom Dunlap

Not too many people know the difference between the welder and the weldor!

I have three welders...four if you count my hot glue gun! I would put my welding up against any weldors treework and see who meets the spec :)

Re: Welding/Repairing Iron Railing questions

#10

Re: Welding/Repairing Iron Railing questions

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

Unless the floor joists under the toilet are rotted you should be able to cut out the rotted section of floor and sub floor back to the good area on the joists and replace it with identical layers of plywood. You may need to add some additional blocking where the edges of the new pieces join the existing to give a solid floor.

Lee

Re: Welding/Repairing Iron Railing questions

#11

Thanks Lee.....

Barry Irby

I know how to make the repair. Not my first trip to this rodeo. Its deja vu all over again. Nearly identical to the last hose I bought and that's exactly how we fixed the last one. In this case the damage extends under the wall into the laundry closet. In the last one the damage was concealed under the kitchen cabinets. The only "trick" was finding the identical plywood to make the thicknesses match perfectly. Unfortunately what passes for plywood these days (OSB) is often metric or at least thinner than the stuff they used in 1977.

My comment about tearing the house down and starting all over was sarcastic. I am some what at a loss to grasp our disposable society. If this railing is sound other than the bottoms of the posts have rusted off due to neglect, isn't repairing them as good as or better than replacing them? Reusing the existing rails seems to be better to me than trying to recycle them or tossing them in the dumpster.

I face this with my son. I'm a pack rat and he borrows my stuff. He throws things away then minute they have served the immediate purpose. He does not have anything for me to borrow. I like the idea of taking nothing and making something out of it. He likes to take something and turn it into nothing.

I was a little surprised that here on Wood Central, a place populated with people who make things, that the idea of repairing something would be ridiculed and me along with it.

Re: Welding/Repairing Iron Railing questions

#12

Re: Welder/weldor

Bill Howatt

When I was starting to learn stick welding I spent time reading a welding forum and they were quite quick to point out the distinction.

You sure can learn a lot of things from forums!

Bill

Re: Welding/Repairing Iron Railing questions

#13

Re: Welding/Repairing Iron Railing questions

Stuart Johnson

It would be a shame to plunge through the floor with an errant potty.

Well, it would take care of any constipation problem.

Re: Welding/Repairing Iron Railing questions

#14

"Down The Tube"

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Just took on a whole new meaning.

Re: Welding/Repairing Iron Railing questions

#15

Re: Thanks Lee.....

Larry in NW OHIO

Like I said in one of my answers to a post a couple of days ago," You`d have to have a GPS" to find your way out of my shops for all the so called junk I collect. I`m also a pack rat, Barry, I try to fix things before I through it away. I was brought up that way. I like it and I don`t care what other think. I just kind of laugh when one of my children brings me something and asks me if I can fix it. Larry

Re: Welding/Repairing Iron Railing questions

#16

If you are flipping it..

Mark Nowicki

... don't forget to mention to the potential buyers the the railing has been repaired in a "green fashion"

Trust me, they will be happy to pay extra for that, especially if you fix it with "rock hard water putty"

Mark

Re: Welding/Repairing Iron Railing questions

#17

Re: If you are flipping it..

Barry Irby

I am a little confused by the Green thing, but I just saw a business that was something like "Your Green Home". I am going to stop in there and see what they have to offer. I find the idea of have to replace three thousand dollars worth of batteries to save $2000 worth of gasoline to be weird. I'm like the actor searching for the motivation.

Another thing I find strange is all the houses I find on my inspections where they replace the existing HVAC without bothering to upgrade their 1960's insulation. How Green/Smart do you have to be to spend a thousand on insulation and then save most of it by getting smaller equipment and then saving forever on your utilities bill?