Taking issue, No. 2 -- toxicity
David Barnett
Let me take issue with your following statement in two parts, which I will highlight in bold.
"Toxicity is an irrational fear given the multitude of persons that spray with much greater frequency than a hobby woodworker and suffer no ill effects."
That sounds hauntingly like statements once uttered about cigarette smoking. While certainly not advocating for outright panic over finish toxicity -- and yes, there's plenty of overreaction to occasional exposure to industrial chemicals -- we should consider that not only is it "the dose", but also the cumulative and/or repeated exposure -- the effect over time.
Calling concerns, even fears over toxicity "irrational" is a bit sweeping and cavalier. There is rational fear and irrational fear. History has shown that rational fear (and sometimes even irrational but nevertheless correct fear) can be a positive survival adaptation. To err on the side of caution when it comes to environmental exposures is not always such a bad thing.
And let me state right here, I'm not advocating for enviro-nanny statism and unbridled regulatory controls -- far from it. There should, however, be informed and intelligent protocols for producing, using, and monitoring that to which we expose ourselves and others. As far as I'm personally concerned, if one wants to breathe colloidal silica from grinding Uranium glass while vaporizing zinc, one has the right to go for it. Win that Darwin Award. Just don't make me do it.
While I'm certainly no tree-hugger, you did leave out the effect on the environment, and while what the average hobbyist is apt to contribute compared to full-blown industrial contributions may be viewed as mostly insignificant, there will be those who will differ from you me in this respect. Some may be more knowledgeable than we are, too. So what may seem "irrational" to non-experts such as ourselves, may look very different through trained eyes. I know I've learned much from specialists in industrial and mine safety and from various NIH experts.
Also, don't think I'm saying that spraying is 'the bad thing' and other application methods aren't. Spraying, however, especially where application venues are often temporary or makeshift for hobby or infrequent use, can be lax in minimizing toxicity. The very nature of sprays and spraying can increase exposure to solvents, and amateurs may actually receive greater exposure during application and subsequent drying and curing, due to prolonged exposure times, improper equipment, poor training in the use of such equipment and exposure-minimizing techniques, and unsupervised compliance in following safe guidelines.
Also, saying toxicity is an "irrational fear" doesn't state what a rational fear or concern might be. You also don't address what happens when you take the mask off, immediately and in the longer term.
The U.S. Green Building Council:
Toxic and polluting ingredients such as toluene and xylene are common solvents; carcinogens such as arsenic, beryllium, and cadmium are sometimes used as drying agents in linseed oil; and toxic glycol ethers may be used as solvents in many water-based sealers.
Lacquer:
Because lacquer usually has high solvent and VOC content and often contains the solvents xylene and toluene, conventional lacquer is not considered environmentally preferable. In fact, conventional lacquer is one of the worst clear finishes in terms of emitting VOCs into your home; only varnishes are worse.
Natural oils:
Check the material safety data sheet (MSDS) for lead and for the carcinogens arsenic, beryllium, chromium, cadmium, and nickel, and the probable carcinogen lead, which may be used as drying agents. Cobalt and zirconium are less toxic drying agents.
Varnishes:
Varnish is toxic to handle, and cleaning up requires harsh solvents that release more VOCs into your home. And the high levels of petroleum-derived solvent content mean the manufacture of varnish is environmentally damaging.
Conversion varnish:
"There are, however, two downsides to this finish. The first is that as the finish cures, it gives off formaldehyde, which is toxic and carcinogenic."
Now let me respond to another part of your statement:
"Toxicity is an irrational fear given the multitude of persons that spray with much greater frequency than a hobby woodworker and suffer no ill effects."
Except for several I know that have had to quit occupations and avocations where they suffered effects due to such exposure. Except for friends who died from such exposure, one of them from very short-term and 'mild' exposure. Except for thousands of others who've had their careers and lives adversely affected and shortened from such exposure, even when complying with safety regimens in place at the time of their exposure.
Aside from the logical fallacy, this is simply not borne of the facts and is refutable, in spite of your other statement:
"All the common solvents are used industrially where workers are exposed to vastly greater amounts than anyone spraying. Hence, there is a great body of toxicity information about them and none of it suggest any problem to the hobby woodworker."
...which I also believe to be incorrect.
So I must conclude, based on "the multitude of persons that spray with much greater frequency than a hobby woodworker and suffer no ill effects", inasmuch as far too many do suffer from ill effects, that fear of toxicity is not irrational -- not in itself -- and that one should distinguish between rational and irrational reactions to fact, and yes, toxicity is a fact.
And if you still believe it's all too rare and irrational, I'm one of those no longer allowed (advised against) by industrial pulmonologists, two allergists, two endocrinologists and four cardiologists to spray. My internist (and close friend) says "Go ahead. Spray away. You don't want to live forever. And if you live too long I'll never get your damned fishing rod." By the way, I also have to avoid areas where finishes have been applied weeks, months, and even years in some instances. Remember, it is the dose, to paraphrase Paracelsus. Don't dismiss, too, that allergic sensitivities can build, not just to cocobolo dust but to finishing chemicals, too.
"This is a mighty small amount of time to recoil from the unpleasantness of wearing a respirator."
Well, we sure do agree on that point, and I'm the first to don a respirator anytime I'm finishing with anything stronger than water and wax, and that's wax at room temperature without solvents. Even when you think you're not sensitive to solvents or other aromatic and volatile components of finishes, you're nevertheless absorbing them, taking them in, through the skin and respiration, and they can have unforeseen cumulative effects, which I believe are far more prevalent than you seem to suppose.
I would also advocate for supplied air systems wherever possible, although I realize this is unfeasible for many and for most might suck the fun right out of their favorite pasttime. But if you're sensitive to solvents, VOCs, and fine dusts, one could view that it allows for long-term enjoyment of that pasttime.
Lastly, again let me say that I take no issue with spraying or sprayers. None at all. I just don't want to gloss over real and valid concerns regarding toxicity in all finishing, all chemicals, all application methods.
None of what I've said is meant to be contentious, but just as you said:
" ...I don't want undecided others to think your arguments have technical merit such that they would be dissuaded from consideration."
...neither would I want others to be persuaded without considering an alternative viewpoint.
I do know that you've often sung the praises of experts employed in various woodworking-related industries, and would expect you to have ready facts to back up your position -- I'm not trying to debate advocacy for spraying or for the chemical safety of finishes sprayed or otherwise -- but would suggest there is considerable contrary opinion and evidence for responsible precautions and safety equipment -- which I fully know you advocate -- and for proper disposal and environmental stewardship, which is why I was somewhat surprised at such a blanket statement.
Perhaps I misinterpreted your meaning, and if so, please forgive me. But if I misinterpreted it, so might others.