Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Why don't more people spray finishes?

Posts

Why don't more people spray finishes?

#1

Why don't more people spray finishes?

Bill Tindall

There are so many advantages to spraying a finish. It goes on faster and smoother. Any finish can be sprayed on. Many of the best can only be sprayed on. Clean up is trivial with the 3M disposable cups. Cost does not seem an impediment. Almost any air compressor will power a sprayer. I have even sprayed small things with the tiny compressor I use as a portable for nailing. Son in law bought a nice professional gun for $50 on Ebay.

There is a learning curve but a brush isn't something that can be successfully used the first time either and how much experience does it take to successfully apply shellac?. One can largely learn to spray with a piece of cardboard and a sprayer filled with colored water.

A special environment isn't necessary. I spray on the driveway, even in the winter, anytime it isn't precipitating. The water based finishes could be sprayed indoors with the most rudimentary of enclosures and vent to the outside.

So why isn't spray equipment as common as jointers in a shop?

Re: Why don't more people spray finishes?

#2

Moses Yoder

Re: Why don't more people spray finishes?

Moses Yoder

I have a sprayer and compressor, and a lot of times spray conversion varnish in my shop. However, when I want to enjoy finishing, I mix thirds of linseed oil, polyurethane, and turpentine and apply it with a 20 cent rag. A pleasant aroma instead of unpleasant face mask, no cleanup in the end, no setting up a spray booth, etc. etc. ad infinitum. I guess it's just personal preference.

Re: Why don't more people spray finishes?

#3

One opinion...

doug f, san clemente, ca

My perception has been that the lack of sprayers, and other finishing techniques as a whole, stems from the fact that the majority of woodworkers see finishing as a necessary evil, to be disposed of as quickly as possible. It took me two years of woodworking classes before I got the idea that, for any project, time for the finish equaled time for the construction.

The appeal of a quick, easy finish certainly is tempting after you have spent dozens, perhaps hundreds of hours, making sure that the construction of a project is as close to perfect as possible, but the fact remains that an outstanding construction can be quickly ruined by a mediocre finish, and the opposite is equally true; a mediocre construction can be made spectacular with an outstanding finish.

I have used a sprayer for the last 10 years and produced some outstanding finishes, it's not that difficult. But I also enjoy the feel of hand sanding an oil and varnish mix into the seat of chair to produce that smooth, velvety texture that you love to touch.

Nature of the beast, I guess.

Doug

Re: Why don't more people spray finishes?

#4

Re: Why don't more people spray finishes?

Robert R. Clough

I do spray paint, clear finishes, anything including "finishing" garage doors. If anything is to be finished, especially painting, with a brush, then Sarah does it, not me!!

With a spray gun or a spray can I can get a good, smooth finish reasonably quickly. With spray cans the cost is high, or at least not inexpensive. but the peace of mind and relaxing of mood is worth it.

The only time I enjoy finishing is when I am re-finishing a family piece. Restoration is fun.

Re: Why don't more people spray finishes?

#5

Re: Why don't more people spray finishes?

John Lucas

Bill I do spray although I am still on the learning curve to being able to do it successfully every time. The main reason I have problems is the space. I simply do not have a good area. I simply can't spray during the winter. I spray outside which of course also rules out rainy days. I don't have an exhaust fan so spraying inside is out. That's where all of my tools and my bicycle and motorcycle also reside. I'd say that's probably reason #1 for most people.

Re: Why don't more people spray finishes?

#6

can't argue about the sweet smell of turpentines

Bill Tindall

I mix my wax for cast iron surfaces in turpentine just so the shop smells "woodsy" now and then.

Can't argue with the noxious odor of conversion varnish either. But it does make a durable coating

Re: Why don't more people spray finishes?

#7

you can spray in the winter.....

Bill Tindall

I do it every winter. The gun and finish must be at room temperature and the piece to be sprayed should be at room temperature. Once the solvent is flashed off and the piece can be moved, move it inside to cure. When I had a van, that acted like a greenhouse, I would cure in the van on sunny days.

I get my smoothest coats in the winter when the solvent evaporates more slowly.

Re: Why don't more people spray finishes?

#8

Re: Why don't more people spray finishes?

wilbur

I don't spray because my workshop is in my basement, with very poor ventilation.

I once asked Glen Huey, who is a big proponent of spray finishing, about my shop situation at a finishing seminar. He said, "Good luck."

Re: Why don't more people spray finishes?

#9

Re: you can spray in the winter.....

Terry in Edmonton

Well Bill, I guess if you live somewhere that you don't get a real winter it's OK, but I find that trying to spray outside at -30 doesn't work. Running an exhaust fan in my basement workshop at those temperatures drives my already high heating bills through the roof. Spraying for me is limited to summer.

Re: Why don't more people spray finishes?

#10

David Barnett

Let's see...

David Barnett

Six reasons I don't spray:

1. I don't like sprays. That is, the very nature of sprays; the atomized particles and the need to control them, which includes overspray.

2. I don't like sprayers. That is, the whole technology of spraying; the hoses, compressors, cans, cups and nozzles. I don't like the equipment setup or cleanup.

3. I don't like spraying. That is, the very act of spraying, and I've done a lot of it.

4. I don't like masking. I really don't like masking.

5. I tend not to like the finishes that are sprayed. I don't really like films that look like films and use them only when I can't avoid it, and I've found lots of ways to avoid it. I don't really like varnishes, lacquers and even shellac (unless it's used as a sealer). Catalyzed varnishes turn me off completely. I don't like lacquer on guitars -- not even french polish unless it gets a thoroughly matte rubbing out. I don't like flatteners added to finishes.

6. I often make small items; jewelry, knobs and pulls, boxes and very small chests, frames, clocks, lamps, treen, carvings, objets d'art, interior fixtures, and what I do make doesn't usually get a film finish, and when it must, it's usually far easier to brush it or wipe it on. Also, many things I make combine materials, and I prefer the control of brushing if I have the need to isolate materials that might be adversely affected.

I don't mind if anyone else likes to spray, though. Sensibilities vary, kumbaya, and all that twaddle.

Re: Why don't more people spray finishes?

#11

so is mine.....

Bill Tindall

which is why I spray outside.

Re: Why don't more people spray finishes?

#12

I spray lacquer all the time

del schisler

I have been spraying lacquer for yrs now. That is the only finish i like. I dry's fast. Once you master that you can finish product's fast. I wouldn't use poly it is to slow for me. I use HVLP with 30 lbs of air and almost no over spray work's for me. I thin lacquer about 10 percent for the M.L.CAMPBELL sanding sealer and the over coat simi gloss. The nozel is 2mm in size. 2 coat's most of the time sometimes 1 coat will be enough.

Re: Why don't more people spray finishes?

#13

Re: I spray lacquer all the time

Jesse Cloud

I share lots of the reasons above - distaste for the toxicity of solvent based lacquers, dislike of respirators, etc.

Also my garage shop provides an alcove for a gas water heater and a gas furnace - not good for flammable sprays.

Space is, of course, an issue.

The outdoors in New Mexico is often inhospitable. Windy, dusty, 2 or 3 per cent humidity (lacquer dries very fast) and either hot or cold. Planning to finish outdoors introduces a great deal of uncertainty into the schedule, e.g. waiting for a day that not too hot or cold and not too windy.

I agree, though, that spraying is fast and can make a beautiful finish - it just needs too much infrastructure.

Given the time and $$ I would love to build a spray booth in an outbuilding....

Re: Why don't more people spray finishes?

#14

I don't have a better reason than

R. Payne

I just don't want to right now. Some day I'll likely give it a try but for today I don't want to. That's good enough for me.

ron

Re: Why don't more people spray finishes?

#15

response

Bill Tindall

I accept that you just don't like it for personal reasons but I don't want undecided others to think your arguments have technical merit such that they would be dissuaded from consideration. Humidity has no effect on solvent evaporation rate unless you are spraying water. And while it is certainly hot and windy at times there are most certainly times when conditions are ideal. Any summer morning would be cool enough and many winter afternoons would be warm enough. Toxicity is an irrational fear given the multitude of persons that spray with much greater frequency than a hobby woodworker and suffer no ill effects. All the common solvents are used industrially where workers are exposed to vastly greater amounts than anyone spraying. Hence, there is a great body of toxicity information about them and none of it suggest any problem to the hobby woodworker. And then there is pumping gas that exposes one to all the aromatic solvents. I don't see people fearing this task, even in CA.

It took about 2 minutes to spray the table I posted earlier. This is a mighty small amount of time to recoil from the unpleasantness of wearing a respirator. My solvent exposure was certainly less than anyone brushing. BTW, water based finishes are 30 or more % coalescing solvent so one should not think that they are avoiding solvent by using this approach by brush or spray.

Re: Why don't more people spray finishes?

#16

2 minutes and done

Bill Tindall

The table I posted earlier had one coat of finish applied in under 2 minutes. A total of three coats were applied with sanding between 1 and 2. Not counting sanding it was 6 minutes and done. It took longer to buy the finish! The finish result is glass smooth.

I am happy to endure a respirator and what ever other inconvenience for this amount of time and result. I am in one for an hour to spray the orchard and another hour to spray the fence rows. Now that is annoying. So is a half hour of colonoscopy.

For those more curious, I have a lazy Susan affair I built from two pieces of plywood and a lazy Susan mechanism. I put stuff to be sprayed on it so that I can stay in one place and turn the piece. I sprayed all the faces that faced me, turned ninety degrees and repeated. Two more rotations and done. In reality it was more like one minute to do the table. Actually faster than dusting it. One hour to dry, scuff sand and repeat. Done. Remove the 3M disposable cup, rise gun with 10 mL solvent twice and put gun away. For those that dislike finishing this speed and quality of results is compelling.

Re: Why don't more people spray finishes?

#17

Re: response  thanks bill

del schisler

Bill i spray in frount of a 36" exhaust fan on low and it take's out the fume's. I smell nothing. And it doesn't afect the spray patern. I know most people just have the wrong thought about most finish's. I have been doing spray work over the last 40 or so yr's not ever day but i have had 4 complete wood shop's. I use lacquer because of the fast drying time. The M.L.CAMPBELL lacquer is a cabnet grade lacquer and is a hard finish. The poly is good but to slow for me. Ane blo is out for my stuff. Thanks for posting I agree with you. The cost is very low to get started . And good result's can be got . del

Re: Why don't more people spray finishes?

#18

Re: 2 minutes and done

del schisler

that is what i use is a Lazy Susan . This sure cut's down the time to turn by hand . Like you said 2 min. and done. I make jewelry box's and 15 sec. for the bottom and 15 sec. for the top and 20 sec for the box part. Sure goes fast. I have made probly 500 or so. I sell at a craft show every week. So i have to be making some every week. I am retired so i do when i want to or not do any thing. thanks again del

Re: Why don't more people spray finishes?

#19

No need for me...

John in NM

I use tung oil, Waterlox, and milk paint, maybe a little shellac. The shellac is the only thing I could see improved by spraying. If I used a lot of varnish or lacquer, I would be spraying it.

I've never hated finishing the way so many seem to do. Wipe it on, let soak, wipe off. Wipe on just enough Waterlox in one pass and leave it alone. Too easy :D

Re: Why don't more people spray finishes?

#20

Fan Question

Hank Knight

Del,

Is your 36" exhaust fan an explosion proof fan? If not, do you worry about touching off volatile solvents with a spark from your fan? This issue is one of the major reasons I don't spray. Explosion proof fans are expensive and most of them are larger than I need. We had a young man here, a piano restorer, who was killed several years ago when the furnace in his shop ignited fumes from the contact cement he was using. He died from severe burns. That got my attention and has kept me from pursuing a spray finishing set-up in my basement shop. What little spraying I do, I do outside. I don't care for bugs and leaves in my finish.

Hank

Re: Why don't more people spray finishes?

#21

Agree with you on one point!

Jesse Cloud

No argument. Spraying the worst of the flammable toxics is nowhere near as bad as a colonoscopy.

Re: Why don't more people spray finishes?

#22

Re: so is mine.....

wilbur

Well, the trees in my yard dump enough stuff year round that any gain that I might get from spraying I would lose from the added organic matter that might embed itself in the finish. ;)

Re: Why don't more people spray finishes?

#23

David Barnett

Taking issue, No. 1 -- humidity

David Barnett

In your response to Jesse Cloud, you said:

"I accept that you just don't like it for personal reasons but I don't want undecided others to think your arguments have technical merit such that they would be dissuaded from consideration."

Well, that's dismissive. :) And rhetorically effective. I know what you mean, though, and it's a fair point.

Actually, I do appreciate your enthusiasm for spraying finishes and although it's not something I wish to do (for "personal' reasons" stated earlier in this thread), I certainly don't mind that others choose to do so. However, I would hope your enthusiasm doesn't cloud* the issues involved in spraying, technically speaking, or more importantly, as regards safety attitudes and practices (covered in my next post).

"Humidity has no effect on solvent evaporation rate unless you are spraying water."

While this is true, sort of, it's hardly the whole picture. Speaking of humidity without speaking of temperature is misleading and incomplete. It's usually more relevant to speak of heat and humidity when talking about finishing and finishing challenges. It should be realized that temperature and humidity affect all finishes -- not just sprayed, of course. Spraying, however, doesn't usually occur in a vacuum, so is subject to ambient considerations.

Phil Stevenson, founder of the American Wood Finishing Institute (AWFI), states:

"Heat will increase the speed of the solvent�s evaporation rate from a liquid to a vapor. Most finishes are formulated to work best in ambient temperatures from 70 to 80 degrees Fahrenheit."

As for sprayed lacquer, he writes:

Lacquers are very susceptible to blushing during the spray application of the material under hot and humid conditions. This blush defect will look like a whitish cloud-like haze. Millions of small micro-bubbles of moisture become trapped in the finish to cause this defect. To minimize the problem, use thinner coats of lacquer with ample dry time between coats. If the blush continues to persist, use 2-4% butyl cellusolve to retard the evaporation of the lacquer. If the lacquer needs to be reduced and retarded, use methyl amyl ketone at 5-15% of the mixture.

Is this something you enjoy? :) I don't. And again, while one may argue it's still a matter of personal preference, just because it's personal doesn't mean it discords with fact or lacks technical merit, as those very technical factors dissuade me (and others, I'd suppose) from wanting to deal with them.

As for conversion varnishes and pigmented catalyzed finishes, he goes on to say:

Temperatures exceeding 90 degrees F and 80% humidity can cause varnishes to trap solvents in the finish. When �solvent entrapment� occurs, the top surface of the film is drying too fast to allow the solvent to rise to the top and escape out of the coating material. The solvent will form vapor bubbles, causing visible defects. When this occurs, the only way to remove the defect is to sand down through the finish to remove the bubbles and then to recoat. To prevent the solvent trapping from re-occurring, use 2-4% butyl cellusolve retarder in the coating mixture. Xylene works very effectively to reduce viscosity of the coating.

"Acrylic and waterborne varnishes "dry" upon evaporation of the water but experience an extended curing period."

Of course, acrylic lacquers are often sprayed because:

"They sometimes lack the brushability and self-levelling qualities of solvent-based varnishes."

_______________________________

* Moisture trapped in the surface of the lacquer from the spray equipment or atmosphere. Read: Moisture and "Blushing", Russ's Corner, Finishing Secrets, WoodCentral :

http://www.woodcentral.com/russ/finish11.shtml

Re: Why don't more people spray finishes?

#24

David Barnett

Taking issue, No. 2 -- toxicity

David Barnett

Let me take issue with your following statement in two parts, which I will highlight in bold.

"Toxicity is an irrational fear given the multitude of persons that spray with much greater frequency than a hobby woodworker and suffer no ill effects."

That sounds hauntingly like statements once uttered about cigarette smoking. While certainly not advocating for outright panic over finish toxicity -- and yes, there's plenty of overreaction to occasional exposure to industrial chemicals -- we should consider that not only is it "the dose", but also the cumulative and/or repeated exposure -- the effect over time.

Calling concerns, even fears over toxicity "irrational" is a bit sweeping and cavalier. There is rational fear and irrational fear. History has shown that rational fear (and sometimes even irrational but nevertheless correct fear) can be a positive survival adaptation. To err on the side of caution when it comes to environmental exposures is not always such a bad thing.

And let me state right here, I'm not advocating for enviro-nanny statism and unbridled regulatory controls -- far from it. There should, however, be informed and intelligent protocols for producing, using, and monitoring that to which we expose ourselves and others. As far as I'm personally concerned, if one wants to breathe colloidal silica from grinding Uranium glass while vaporizing zinc, one has the right to go for it. Win that Darwin Award. Just don't make me do it.

While I'm certainly no tree-hugger, you did leave out the effect on the environment, and while what the average hobbyist is apt to contribute compared to full-blown industrial contributions may be viewed as mostly insignificant, there will be those who will differ from you me in this respect. Some may be more knowledgeable than we are, too. So what may seem "irrational" to non-experts such as ourselves, may look very different through trained eyes. I know I've learned much from specialists in industrial and mine safety and from various NIH experts.

Also, don't think I'm saying that spraying is 'the bad thing' and other application methods aren't. Spraying, however, especially where application venues are often temporary or makeshift for hobby or infrequent use, can be lax in minimizing toxicity. The very nature of sprays and spraying can increase exposure to solvents, and amateurs may actually receive greater exposure during application and subsequent drying and curing, due to prolonged exposure times, improper equipment, poor training in the use of such equipment and exposure-minimizing techniques, and unsupervised compliance in following safe guidelines.

Also, saying toxicity is an "irrational fear" doesn't state what a rational fear or concern might be. You also don't address what happens when you take the mask off, immediately and in the longer term.

The U.S. Green Building Council:

Toxic and polluting ingredients such as toluene and xylene are common solvents; carcinogens such as arsenic, beryllium, and cadmium are sometimes used as drying agents in linseed oil; and toxic glycol ethers may be used as solvents in many water-based sealers.

Lacquer:

Because lacquer usually has high solvent and VOC content and often contains the solvents xylene and toluene, conventional lacquer is not considered environmentally preferable. In fact, conventional lacquer is one of the worst clear finishes in terms of emitting VOCs into your home; only varnishes are worse.

Natural oils:

Check the material safety data sheet (MSDS) for lead and for the carcinogens arsenic, beryllium, chromium, cadmium, and nickel, and the probable carcinogen lead, which may be used as drying agents. Cobalt and zirconium are less toxic drying agents.

Varnishes:

Varnish is toxic to handle, and cleaning up requires harsh solvents that release more VOCs into your home. And the high levels of petroleum-derived solvent content mean the manufacture of varnish is environmentally damaging.

Conversion varnish:

"There are, however, two downsides to this finish. The first is that as the finish cures, it gives off formaldehyde, which is toxic and carcinogenic."

Now let me respond to another part of your statement:

"Toxicity is an irrational fear given the multitude of persons that spray with much greater frequency than a hobby woodworker and suffer no ill effects."

Except for several I know that have had to quit occupations and avocations where they suffered effects due to such exposure. Except for friends who died from such exposure, one of them from very short-term and 'mild' exposure. Except for thousands of others who've had their careers and lives adversely affected and shortened from such exposure, even when complying with safety regimens in place at the time of their exposure.

Aside from the logical fallacy, this is simply not borne of the facts and is refutable, in spite of your other statement:

"All the common solvents are used industrially where workers are exposed to vastly greater amounts than anyone spraying. Hence, there is a great body of toxicity information about them and none of it suggest any problem to the hobby woodworker."

...which I also believe to be incorrect.

So I must conclude, based on "the multitude of persons that spray with much greater frequency than a hobby woodworker and suffer no ill effects", inasmuch as far too many do suffer from ill effects, that fear of toxicity is not irrational -- not in itself -- and that one should distinguish between rational and irrational reactions to fact, and yes, toxicity is a fact.

And if you still believe it's all too rare and irrational, I'm one of those no longer allowed (advised against) by industrial pulmonologists, two allergists, two endocrinologists and four cardiologists to spray. My internist (and close friend) says "Go ahead. Spray away. You don't want to live forever. And if you live too long I'll never get your damned fishing rod." By the way, I also have to avoid areas where finishes have been applied weeks, months, and even years in some instances. Remember, it is the dose, to paraphrase Paracelsus. Don't dismiss, too, that allergic sensitivities can build, not just to cocobolo dust but to finishing chemicals, too.

"This is a mighty small amount of time to recoil from the unpleasantness of wearing a respirator."

Well, we sure do agree on that point, and I'm the first to don a respirator anytime I'm finishing with anything stronger than water and wax, and that's wax at room temperature without solvents. Even when you think you're not sensitive to solvents or other aromatic and volatile components of finishes, you're nevertheless absorbing them, taking them in, through the skin and respiration, and they can have unforeseen cumulative effects, which I believe are far more prevalent than you seem to suppose.

I would also advocate for supplied air systems wherever possible, although I realize this is unfeasible for many and for most might suck the fun right out of their favorite pasttime. But if you're sensitive to solvents, VOCs, and fine dusts, one could view that it allows for long-term enjoyment of that pasttime.

Lastly, again let me say that I take no issue with spraying or sprayers. None at all. I just don't want to gloss over real and valid concerns regarding toxicity in all finishing, all chemicals, all application methods.

None of what I've said is meant to be contentious, but just as you said:

" ...I don't want undecided others to think your arguments have technical merit such that they would be dissuaded from consideration."

...neither would I want others to be persuaded without considering an alternative viewpoint.

I do know that you've often sung the praises of experts employed in various woodworking-related industries, and would expect you to have ready facts to back up your position -- I'm not trying to debate advocacy for spraying or for the chemical safety of finishes sprayed or otherwise -- but would suggest there is considerable contrary opinion and evidence for responsible precautions and safety equipment -- which I fully know you advocate -- and for proper disposal and environmental stewardship, which is why I was somewhat surprised at such a blanket statement.

Perhaps I misinterpreted your meaning, and if so, please forgive me. But if I misinterpreted it, so might others.

Re: Why don't more people spray finishes?

#25

David Barnett

Re: Agree with you on one point!

David Barnett

I'm a visual, as they say, and I really didn't need spraying and colonscopy to occur in the same image.