Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Tree Identification?

Posts

Tree Identification?

#1

Tree Identification?

Bill Tindall


Is this tree a Hornbeam? Leaves looked like a birch. There were several of these trees with this distinctive bark. Trunks were 4 to 16" diameter. What ever it is I have never seen it before . Location, about 3000' elevation in Smoky Mt park. They were growing among and under the yellow poplar.

Jon Arno would have known.....in memory of Jon.

Re: Tree Identification?

#2

JL

Shagbark Hickory??

JL

Re: Tree Identification?

#3

Re: Tree Identification?

Dale Stansbery

It looks like a photo of a Hop Hornbeam (ironwood) that I have in a book published in 1935 on Ohio Trees. The book indicates that a hornbeam larger than 12" dbh is not common, but they did cite several up to 24" known in the Dayton Park system back then. Several other facts are that it doesn't usually occur in groups or groves, but is interspersed singly in a woods. It also tends to have a twist in the trunk and and is a favorite of sapsuckers in the spring and will often show sap running from the damage.It's wood is only slightly lighter than hickory by a whisker.

Re: Tree Identification?

#4

Ellis Walentine

Biltmore hawthorn

Ellis Walentine

Re: Tree Identification?

#5

Re: Tree Identification?

Mike Foster

Doesn't quite have the look of the hophornbeam that grows around us in VT. Looks more like shagbark hickory to me as well.

Mike

Re: Tree Identification?

#7

leaves

Bill Tindall

The leaves were waaay up in the air, too far for a picture. But, at the time they looked to me like a birch leaf, which is consistent with your identification. The bark was unique. Never seen bark anything like it. Thin scales. Reminiscent of cherry but more brown, larger scales and more loosely attached.

Re: Tree Identification?

#8

no

Bill Tindall

The hickory is more gray and the peeling bark is thicker and the "shags" longer than on these trees.

Re: Tree Identification?

#9

Re: For you doubters :-) ?

Dale Stansbery

These are from Some American Trees, An Intimate Study of Native Ohio Trees, By William B. Werthner, Macmillan, 1935. By far, the best tree descriptions I have ever seen for native trees in Ohio and so covers a lot of eastern US. I seldom have a doubt about an ID after consulting it.

Of course, when it comes to non natives and cultivars, all bets are off.




Re: Tree Identification?

#10

Re: no

Larry in NW OHIO

I was going to say the same thing as Bill. The sagbark hickory we have around here in Northwestern Ohio have alot bigger shags than in the picture. They are 3-4 inches wide plus and can be over a foot long. So I don`t think it`s a shagbark. It looks more like a Birch, except the bark is more gray than white. Larry

Re: Tree Identification?

#11

I would have to agree

Bill Tindall

These are growing in a location where the poplars are up to 5' in diameter and the maples 4' so it is not surprising that this trees stature is larger and taller than typical. I would love to have this log at the saw mill to see what it was like inside. These trees were limbless for about 40' and they would have sawed some nice lumber. I could be the first in the block to have a hornbeam table.

Thanks for the posting.

Re: Tree Identification?

#12

Bill, What trail was this on?

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

I remember reading something about these trees on some of the trails where there was "old growth" timber, but it seems like there are two other things that I can't remember. Maybe yellow birch, but there was something else that drops a very easily identified seed or flower.

If you have been up to Ramsey Cascades, I'm going to be jealous. ha

Re: Tree Identification?

#13

Re: Bill, What trail was this on?

Bill Tindall

Ramsey Cascade is my #1 trail for big trees. Sadly the huge 4 1/2' cherry was down the last time I was there but its numerous 4' neighbors are still standing. But, this time I was on the trail to Albright Cove. The trail is a few miles north of the Ramsey Cascade trail.