Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

FWW/FHB Archives - Big disappointment

Posts

FWW/FHB Archives - Big disappointment

#1

FWW/FHB Archives - Big disappointment

Craig Daymon

OK, I've had these for several months now (Christmas presents) and have read a few of the old articles, but I recently went looking for plans for a few things. Much do my extreme disappointment, NONE of the images in the articles have readable dimensions! The resolution of the drawings (images embedded within the PDF files) has been reduced below what is readable no matter what the zoom level.

This is VERY disappointing. I contacted Taunton and they said it was a limitation of the technology. Well, it's NOT a limitation of the technology, it is a limitation of their implementation of the technology! There really is NO excuse for this and it greatly diminishes the value of the product.

I currently have the Fine Woodworking DVD in my drive. It contains 2.2GB of data. Well, even on a single sided DVD there is at least 4GB of space. That means there was an additional 1.8GB of room, nearly half the disk that would have supported higher resolution images, even without making use of a better, and lossless, image compression.

VERY disgusted. I won't be recommending these to anyone.

Re: FWW/FHB Archives - Big disappointment

#2

Thanks for the heads up.

roger lance

Re: FWW/FHB Archives - Big disappointment

#3

Moses Yoder

Re: FWW/FHB Archives - Big disappointment

Moses Yoder

I think they could have been scanned at higher resolution but it would have taken longer. So it appears to be a typical bean counter decision. If they weren't gifts you should have your money back. I kind of thought about getting this, thanks for the heads up.

Re: FWW/FHB Archives - Big disappointment

#4

Re: Thanks for the heads up.

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

I've noted that none of the "on disk" back issues offers ever mentions the file size.

Re: FWW/FHB Archives - Big disappointment

#5

Re: Thanks for the heads up.

Craig Daymon

I'm not sure what you're referring to about the file size Dave. What I did was to insert the disk into my computer and mounted the file system. Then I brought up the properties of the disk. It said there were something on the order of 25,000+ files and that those files amounted to 2.2GB of data. A formatted DVD will hold slightly over 4GB of data.

On my computer, the disk will not autorun a viewer program, as I believe it is likely to do on most systems. I access the PDF files on the disk using Acrobat Reader directly.

Re: FWW/FHB Archives - Big disappointment

#6

David Barnett

Stay away from the Taunton eBooks, too.

David Barnett

I had a tough go 'round with their customer service about that very problem. As I have vision issues, I'd hoped to magnify the files by at least 25% to make them more readable. Imagine my dismay to find out they were unacceptably blurry and distorted for even people with good vision at normal magnification. Also, the lack of photographic crispness and color fidelity leaves their files with a visual dinginess that is simply sad looking, like faded copies of second-rate, poorly-registered, fledgling four-color process magazines from the late 1940s and early 1950s.

Taunton was totally disinterested (a nice way to put it) and unwilling to refund. I was far more polite than the supervisor to whom I spoke. Just because I have difficulty reading as well as I used to does not mean I should perhaps rethink doing woodworking altogether. That's just a bit too cheeky. Appalling.

I cancelled my online subscription during that same call. I'll never buy another Taunton magazine or book.

Re: FWW/FHB Archives - Big disappointment

#7

Clint Searl

Re: FWW/FHB Archives - Big disappointment

Clint Searl

The Taunton in-house motto is, "There's one born every minute."

Clint

Re: FWW/FHB Archives - Big disappointment

#8

Re: FWW/FHB Archives - Big disappointment

Todd Nebel

I bought the first DVD of all their FWW magazines on disk. I think it was sometime shortly after the 25th Anniversary Edition. I was disappoint to find out it wasn't the magazines scanned, but only the articles and projects they had the rights to. Add to that poor resolution and no navigation or search. That was a total waste of $125. I continue to subscribe to the paper magazine, but will never buy their electronic version again.

Re: FWW/FHB Archives - Big disappointment

#9

Thx! I'm not going to...

Tom Dunlap

...sell my paper copies now. My collection isn't complete but it goes back to year 2 or 3. They are all stored in two apple boxes which are HEAVY!

Re: FWW/FHB Archives - Big disappointment

#10

A contrary opinion- I find it most useful

Bill Tindall

I never build anything from plans so the dimensions being unreadable was not noticed. But then surely I would have noticed....... so I just rechecked some of the things I have looked up recently and......I have no problem at all reading the dimensions. Indeed details are not crisp and if that is what was expected then disappointment is understandable. But for the price of a few years subscription lets examine what one does get.

Formost, one gets a useful search engine for finding anything that was ever written in FWW. And once found in short order one can go look at what was found. For me this was the primary reason I sprang for a 2nd hand copy. The issues appear to me to have been especially thoroughly indexed and I have been able to quickly find anything I was looking for whether it be in the articles or letters.

Recently I was wanting to build a table and the quest was to see what tables were to be seen in the FWW issues. Before I has the searchable DVD this was an onerous task of wading through my hard copies.

The bottom line is that this DVD has been of great utility for readily finding information in back issues of FWW. For those that have the DVD and aren't getting good value from it, sell it on the classified.

I don't subscribe nor do I buy their books or visit the web site so it is not like I am a fan of this organization.

Re: FWW/FHB Archives - Big disappointment

#11

David Barnett

I'm only too happy...

David Barnett

...to be diddled now and then -- even pay for it -- although I do expect some reciprocity in the arrangement.

Re: FWW/FHB Archives - Big disappointment

#12

Re: Thanks for the heads up.

Dan Donaldson

Not sure, but I think the file size reference was to the size of the picture files. Making them too small is why they are unreadable.

Re: FWW/FHB Archives - Big disappointment

#13

Re: Thanks for the heads up.

Craig Daymon

Yes, that is certainly the end result, but I suspect it is because the firm hired to create the DVDs chose the defaults, which I suspect makes use of a lossy image compression line JPEG. It should be possible to either set the quality to a maximum or specify the use of a lossless compression and I'm guessing they didn't bother to try to do either...resulting in smaller byte content and lost clarity. The way the images appear, it seems more likely it was the chosen compression rather than a simple change to the image dimensions.

Re: FWW/FHB Archives - Big disappointment

#14

File Size

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

My reference was to the total amount of data on the DVD. Is that actually the size of the volume?

Re: FWW/FHB Archives - Big disappointment

#15

This Report Not Good For Taunton's Image

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Re: FWW/FHB Archives - Big disappointment

#16

Re: File Size

Craig Daymon

Yep. There is 2.2GB of files on the DVD, which potentially can hold 4GB. In the root there are 11 files related to autorunning the archive when you pop the disk in. These take up 83.8MB.

Then there is a folder, "FWW Archive". In that is another folder, "Data" and nothing else. In that folder is ANOTHER folder, "Data-FWW" and nothing else. In THAT folder are 2 folders, "Issues" and "Thumbnails".

"Thumbnails" contains JPEG images of over 24,000 pages in a very low resolution, about 117x160. Definitely thumbnail images and not remotely readable. (These are not the images I have issue with. Those images are embedded in the PDF files of the issues.) The thumbnails take up 182.2MB of space.

All the important stuff is in the "Issues" directory. In there are 215 PDF files, one for each issue, taking up 2.1GB of space.

This is the breakdown of the Fine Woodworking archive disk. I have not checked, but I have no reason to believe that the Fine Homebuilding is organized in a like fashion.

Re: FWW/FHB Archives - Big disappointment

#17

Re: A contrary opinion- I find it most useful

Craig Daymon

I'm not saying there isn't a lot of useful information on the DVD, but I think it speaks to a lack of professionalism by the firm that created the DVD (I believe Taunton outsourced this project) as there really is no reason not to have had the images included at a higher resolution and there are a number of programs available that offer lossless image compression for inclusion in PDF files.

For Taunton's part, I believe it speaks to a lack of quality control, opposite of what Taunton's reputation is known for. They should have had someone knowledgeable of the technology inspect the final product and this should have resulted in clear, legible, images in the PDF files.

Re: FWW/FHB Archives - Big disappointment

#18

Glass half full

Bill Tindall

I see your point. I was delighted with what I got for the price. But if I could have gotten more resolution for the same price, indeed I was short changed and didn't know it.

Re: FWW/FHB Archives - Big disappointment

#19

David Barnett

The outcome remains unclear

David Barnett