Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

I'm Drowning!!! Where do you draw the line?

Posts

I'm Drowning!!! Where do you draw the line?

#1

I'm Drowning!!! Where do you draw the line?

Robby Wright in San Marcos, CA

With scraps. I hate to toss those small pieces, but it is getting ridiculous. I have tossed a bunch, but it seems like every time I toss a piece, I need it the next time I am working on something.

What are your criteria for what is tossed and what is saved? Does the type of wood matter to you? Species? Thickness?

Thanks for your help.

Robby Wright

San Marcos, CA

Re: I'm Drowning!!! Where do you draw the line?

#2

Moses Yoder

Re: I'm Drowning!!! Where do you draw the line?

Moses Yoder

I save smaller pieces of exotic wood like ebony or cocobolo. Other than that, just about everything goes in the burn pile. Unless you have tons of room to store something you will probably never use, toss it out. Have a wiener roast and put it to good use. Definitely if it's less than a foot long it goes out. If it's 2 foot long, it depends on the species and whether I think I'll have another project for it soon. The stuff grows on trees.

Re: I'm Drowning!!! Where do you draw the line?

#3

Move

Dan Donaldson

I usually base it on type (exotics etc.) along with size. The only way I have found to really sort it out is to move ;) Then I have to decide if it is worth packing.

Re: I'm Drowning!!! Where do you draw the line?

#4

Re: I'm Drowning!!! Where do you draw the line?

clay foster

I used to save cut offs that were as short as 1', but I eventually realized space was more valuable than the wood I was saving. I picked out the ten best pieces and put them in a trash can. Whenever I had more cutoffs I couldn't throw away, I put them in the trash can. When the trash can got full, I dumped them all out, kept the 10 best pieces, and started all over.

Re: I'm Drowning!!! Where do you draw the line?

#5

Re: I'm Drowning!!! Where do you draw the line?

Jesse Cloud

Give up! I guarantee you anything you throw away, you will need next week. So its throw it all away or keep it all.

Anybody know of a 12 step program for this??

Re: I'm Drowning!!! Where do you draw the line?

#6

Dan has a good point

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

With each piece, imagine that you'll have to pack it and pay $4.25/gallon for gasoline (in a truck that gets ten miles per gallon rolling downhill with a tailwind) to move it to another state. If you say, "Yep, worth it," then keep it; otherwise, not.

So easy to say...I need to take the same approach.

Re: I'm Drowning!!! Where do you draw the line?

#7

ways to minimize the problem

Bill Tindall

If it is common wood it gets burned if it is much less than a foot long or less than an inch wide.

I don't accumulate much stuff that is of a size greater than what I burn and less than full boards. Lumber like walnut that is not attractive enough to use in exposed areas gets turned into drawer bottoms, furniture framing, etc. Drawer bottoms can be assembled from assorted widths.

Much less odds and ends are generated to begin with if one has a large quantity of lumber to pick from. I buy #2 common poplar 500 bd ft at a time and it yields almost no waste because I can select boards that will yield the cuttings I need with little waste. If I need 22" drawer sides I find pieces that are about 22 or 44" between knots, for example. If you have the room and cash waste minimization is one of many reasons to buy a large quantity of a favored species you expect to work over time. I doubt anyone regrets buying a quantity of walnut, cherry or mahogany 20 years ago when it was much cheaper and higher quality.

Re: I'm Drowning!!! Where do you draw the line?

#8

Ha!  I've seen your lumber stash......

Bill Tindall

Folks, he is more frugal that me when it comes to saving lumber and I thought I set the standard for frugal. I may have even seen pencil shavings tucked away in a coffee can.

Re: I'm Drowning!!! Where do you draw the line?

#9

Re: I'm Drowning!!! Where do you draw the line?

Bater Kari

Like Moses, I don't keep cutoffs if they are under 12 inches. If I don't need to make a small part for a project, I toss them into the scrap pile. The longer pieces I hang onto, regardless of species. Eventually I find a use for them.

Re: I'm Drowning!!! Where do you draw the line?

#10

Another possible way to minimize....

roger lance

is to take up segmented turning.

Re: I'm Drowning!!! Where do you draw the line?

#11

Or, in my case, make smaller boxes.

DizD

Re: I'm Drowning!!! Where do you draw the line?

#12

David Barnett

Everything but the squeal

David Barnett

If it's too small for earrings or a bead, then and only then may it be considered scrap. Not a lot of shop stoves in my part of Florida.

Re: I'm Drowning!!! Where do you draw the line?

#13

Re: I'm Drowning!!! Where do you draw the line?

myrafox647

And the next question is: If you decide to keep it, what's the best way to organize and store it?

Re: I'm Drowning!!! Where do you draw the line?

#14

Caught me; I was expressing how I wish I decided

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Re: I'm Drowning!!! Where do you draw the line?

#15

The scraps will always be with you

Bruce, a MN Galoot

or so it seems. I had gotten so bad that I would waste a lot of time looking for just the right size piece to make something that it became a lot more trouble than it was worth. Scrap pieces had taken over my life.

My family has always camped a lot in the summer, so that became the new reason for saving scraps - they went into burn boxes. The worst was when we hauled a couple boxes of scraps all the way from MN to Banff only to find we couldn't use them and had to haul them back. The yolk's on me.

I still have the boxes and while it pains me to burn stuff, I haven't missed what I've thrown. My wife had always been after me to reduce my wood supply, so now I've found my revenge!! I have her throw stuff onto the fire, and when SHE finds something she deems to be worth keeping, she has to recommend a use for it, and not just another box. Sometimes we return from a camping trip with useful pieces.

Re: I'm Drowning!!! Where do you draw the line?

#16

Make long boards from short ones

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

When you get enough scraps, rip them to the same width, and glue them end-to-end with long carrier boards glued to each side. When the glue is dry, joint one face and plane the "segmented plank" to desired thickness and rip off the carrier boards for reuse. Leave it as a plank- stores easier- then snap off a few pieces to make a box or other small project.


Re: I'm Drowning!!! Where do you draw the line?

#17

Re: I'm Drowning!!! Where do you draw the line?

Barry Irby

I have a small shop and the packrat gene, a bad combination. I am also a turner. Turner's can use even the tiniest scraps, so I save pieces the size of a finger.

I used to have a box under the wing on the RAS and threw scraps into it. I needed to reorganize and emptied the box and found there wasn't much in it worth saving and yet some of it had been in here for years. the box is replaced with a roll around cart that has storage in the bottom and a grid top that is a downdraft table and can be used for assembly. Now I try to only put what appear to be useful pieces in the cart.

So, periodically, I make a bunch of cutting boards to use up scraps. And small boxes. And turnings. The problem is that if you are not careful you end up letting the scraps dictate what woodworking you are doing. I want to drive rather than being driven.

I recently cut up a bunch of stuff and sent to someone who turns pens. They paid the shipping. I felt better about that than burning it. they posted a picture. Kinda cool to have some wood grown on my family farm in Alaska.

So, once in a while you have to be ruthless and throw some of that (s)crap away. If you know somebody that turns, you could give them a shot at it first.

Re: I'm Drowning!!! Where do you draw the line?

#18

Re: Make long boards from short ones

Pat Evans

You have WAY too much time on your hands!

Re: I'm Drowning!!! Where do you draw the line?

#19

Use them to experiment finishes on

Ray Thompson - Middletown, in

Cut a set of 3-4" pieces, grouped by species, and put different stains and finishes, any combination that strikes your fancy. Drill a small hole in the corner and put them together with a long cable tie after documenting on the edge with a Sharpie. Hang them on your wall of experiments for future reference.

Ray

Re: I'm Drowning!!! Where do you draw the line?

#20

This is going to hurt!!

Robby Wright in San Marcos, CA

Since my burn barrel and the fireplace are both full and many of the scraps are little pieces of plywood, I think I am going to take the one foot advices and anything that isn't at least a foot long and three inches wide is going to get trashed at the end of the work day tomorrow.

Is there a program for wood hoarders? My name is Robby.....

Thanks all for your comments.

Robby Wright

San Marcos, CA

Re: I'm Drowning!!! Where do you draw the line?

#21

It grows IN trees, not on 'em 

Tom Dunlap

Re: I'm Drowning!!! Where do you draw the line?

#22

sorry, no program, but you can talk to us! 

Bruce, a MN Galoot