Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Going to start a FIRST for me

Posts

Going to start a FIRST for me

#1

Going to start a FIRST for me

Larry in NW OHIO

I have some 18/4 walnut setting my garage for the last 4 years just waiting for the right project to came along. Finally it came along as in kitchen barstools. I got it all sanded down to 2" to get it flat and where I wanted it to be to start with. Now I`m ready to start cutting out the parts and shaping them. But first I`d like some opinions as to how to do the butt part of the chair. How do some of you do the carve out the sitting part. That is of course the part that has me most concerned. So I would likethe way you do it. Thank You Larry

Re: Going to start a FIRST for me

#2

Re: Going to start a FIRST for me

Barry Irby

I am the wrong guy to answer this. I have only done one. But, I only wanted to do one and did not want to buy a bunch of tools and take a classic chair making course. Believe it or not, I did it with a Radial Arm Saw and a 5" ROS. I clamped the piece to the table and then lowered the saw and made a light cut with the blade turned 90 degrees to its normal position. Sort of like how you make a cove molding on the TS. I tipped the back of the seat up so I could dish it out deeper and maintain the thickness at the front. I also rotate the seat ninety degrees and took out the bump in the middle. Then I finished sculpting it with the ROS.

My approach was to take the piece of wood and cut away anything that did not look like a chair seat---with the tools I had. Also, I made it out of Osage Orange which is as hard as Woodpeckers lips. I was too intimidated to even try the traditional hand tools. (I can't spell scaup)

I was thrilled with the results. But I had to rebuild the ROS. All the grinding with the edge of the disk wore out the bearings. Twenty bucks fixed that and I don't know that its fair to assign the whole cost to this project, it was fairly old when I started. I think an angle grinder might be a better choice, but I don't own one.

Might be good to post this on the hand tool board.

Re: Going to start a FIRST for me

#3

David Barnett

Kutzall! *LINK*

David Barnett

I just love 4" Kutzall wheels on angle grinders. I know, I know -- loud and dusty, so wear the proper gear, but fun, too. I keep mine mounted on three very cheap (less than $10) disposable (if they'd ever die) HF grinders. Whenever I buy a new one for woodworking (which is rare), the old one goes to work carving stone.

http://tinyurl.com/KutzallCatalog

The 'extreme' wheels will get you there fast, but with plenty of control. For a nearly-there smooth finish, I like the 'original' silver structured tooth' SSG carbide wheels and burrs.

Shop around. Prices vary, and check Kutzall's eBay store, too.

Tip: if they load up, just clean 'em with a propane torch.


If you only get one, I'd recommend...

Re: Going to start a FIRST for me

#4

Pencil + Chainsaw

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Pencil to draw the basic "print" on the seat blank. Then use a Lancelot carver in an angle grinder to do the major removal. Next some hand forming with rasps. Lastly sand through the grits to take out the rasp marks. Sounds like more than it is. The carver takes a lot of wood out quickly. The hand tools give you the most control over the final smoothing of the concave form. Some carver's rifflers would come in handy as well.

Re: Going to start a FIRST for me

#5

Lancelot carver

paul in AZ

Out of curiosity I looked up the Lancelot carver and ran across this. sounds like a great tool if used carefully.

Quote:

Scariest tool I've ever used.

Tried out the Lancelot carver disc for the 1st time today. Evil evil wickedly powerful tool.

Tried it out on a piece of hard maple scrap 1st and as soon I lowered the disc onto the wood it grabbed, ran across the surface and jammed the grinder handle into my stomach, sending me backwards. Whoa!!

Took my time after that. Reread the directions -had to modify the location of my grinder shroud a bit.

Practiced a bit more and then tackled a stool I'm making that will have a tractor like seat.

It's fast. Really fast, and one has to be real careful to not let it dig in and make gouges. I was nervous using it but gradually got more comfortable.

The dust in incredible but less than using a 24 grit sanding disc for sure.

I had the small seat very roughly contoured in maybe 30 minutes. That really fast for a first time user imo.

Anyway, it's a keeper and this is one tool I won't lend out ever. I wouldn't want to be responsible.

Re: Going to start a FIRST for me

#6

Handy Tool

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

I have a couple of Kutzall wheels and they are great. They do a great job of removing wood in a hurry.

Tom

Re: Going to start a FIRST for me

#7

Moses Yoder

Re: Going to start a FIRST for me *LINK*

Moses Yoder

I have the Veritas pull shave that I've tried out and it works very well. You can see it at the link below. I haven't actually built any chairs yet but plan on getting a roundtuit. To mark a seat no matter what method you use, draw a full size top view and side view. Then drill holes from the top down to the depth you want to scoop in various parts of the seat. When you remove the hole you have scooped deep enough.


Veritas Pull Shave

Re: Going to start a FIRST for me

#8

Re: Lancelot carver

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Sounds about right :D

It takes a light touch and two handles to control. It also requires face protection, and I suggest it be used outside, usually where your mulch beds may be getting a bit thin ;)

Re: Going to start a FIRST for me

#9

David Barnett

Lancelot's earned its place at the Round Table

David Barnett

They're not that bad. Granted, there is a learning curve, and no, it's not a casual tool for the less-than-focused craftsperson. It's more about being mentally prepared than a control issue, though. I've seen little old ladies handle a .44 magnum with glee after they got over the initial shock and awe -- kind of a scary thing in itself.

Chain-carvers? Not for everyone, no, but they have their place -- well away from Mr. Mushroom, to be sure. Just use common sense (and a Kevlar codpiece, maybe). :)

Re: Going to start a FIRST for me

#10

David Barnett

Re: Going to start a FIRST for me

David Barnett

That seems like such a nicely made and useful tool and even though I probably don't need one, I'll admit to wanting one. It's back on my queue again, thanks to you, heh.

Re: Going to start a FIRST for me

#11

Re: Going to start a FIRST for me

Larry in NW OHIO

Thanks to everyone who replyed so quickly. That Kutzal looks very intriging, I may have a closer look. The lanclot, is that the angle grinder with a chain saw chain on the end. I think that would be to much for me. But I can see where that would cut some serious wood. I forgot to ask about the 40 grit flap wheels that I see in klinspor, they also look like they would cut wood fairly good and be a little safer. Larry

Re: Going to start a FIRST for me

#12

Re: Lancelot's earned its place at the Round Table

John Lucas

I have one and used it for years. One trick I use is to move the blade guard around a little so you can use the blade guard as a bevel. In other words you touch the blade guard to the wood and then tilt the blade into the wood. That lets you control the depth.

for the most part I use sort of scraping cuts, kind of like using a sandpaper disc. This still removes a lot of wood and is loads safer.

The big discs made by Kutzall work a little better for what your doing. You can't reach into thin areas like you can with the chainsaw or carbide cutters but it also might not cut you as deep if it gets away from you.

always use 2 hands as was mentioned before.

I learned to do seats using an inshave and scorp. then I rigged up a way to do it with my router for a small production run of stools. Now I would use the arbortec (more like a carbide tooth saw blade but fits the angle grinder) to rough it out and then smaller Kutzalls on my flex shaft for finer shaping and then switch to sanding discs and hand sanding.

Re: Going to start a FIRST for me

#13

David Barnett

Those flappin' wheels

David Barnett

Flap wheels and discs can be useful for finishing up, Larry. They're generalizers, though, best for blending and consolidating broad areas -- not what you'd call finesse tools. Another thing, you can leave unwanted ridges at the flap edges if you're less than careful -- not exactly the tool's fault, but watch out for it.

To be candid, now that I've been fair, I pretty much hate them, would consign them to Hell, and consider them less than artful tools, but that's just me. I could say they're good for rust and paint removal, but that's really not my thing, and I've never liked them for that, either. I wasn't going to say anything at all about them, but I loathe them so much I couldn't hold back.

Yes, I've heard luthiers and others have used flap wheels to good effect, but I'm not buyin' it. Others may differ.

Of course they'd be dead wrong.

Re: Going to start a FIRST for me

#14

Re: Going to start a FIRST for me

John Lucas

Larry for a while my good friend Brad Sells who carves everything in a big way, switched from the Lancelot style cutters to 24 grit paper on an angle grinder. He said it was just as fast and a lot safer. He has now switched to a custom machine he had modified. it has 2 of the big Kutzall flat cutters mounted back to back with a lancelot mounted inbetween. It is extremely aggressive.

Re: Going to start a FIRST for me

#15

Re: Those flappin' wheels

Larry in NW OHIO

Come now David, tell me how you really feel, just let it all out. Larry

Re: Going to start a FIRST for me

#16

Re: Going to start a FIRST for me

Larry in NW OHIO

John Boy I`d love to see that outfit your friend made. Do you think you could take a pic of it, if he would let you. Larry

Re: Going to start a FIRST for me

#17

Re: Going to start a FIRST for me

John Lucas

I'm going over there in a few days to look at some wood he just got from a tree that went down on campus. I'll ask if I can take a photo. He might be leary, it looks like some medieval torture device.

Re: Going to start a FIRST for me

#18

Ellis Walentine

Nice mince job, David 

Ellis Walentine

>:)

Re: Going to start a FIRST for me

#19

David Barnett

Re: Nice mince job, David 

David Barnett

[bowing]

As you might guess, Ellis, there's a back story to that, which I'll not go into. Blasphemy and cussing were intricately involved. :)

Re: Going to start a FIRST for me

#20

David Barnett

I guess it's fairly obvious I suck...

David Barnett

...at flap wheels. I will begrudgingly amend my remarks to say I don't hate them quite so much when they're scaled down to the 2" discs from Foredom...

http://tinyurl.com/2inchFlapperDiscs

...and the 1" and 1 1/2" Klingspor wheels are okay, I suppose, for inside lathe-bored cylinders (although I'm usually happy enough with sandpaper around my finger), and concavities of varying radii in sculpture and other likewise convoluted wood, metal and stone objets d'art. But I'll give no ground on the bigger ones. If you can't kutz it with Kutzall, you don't needz to Kutz it at all.

http://tinyurl.com/1inchFlappers

http://tinyurl.com/1andahalf-inchFlappers