Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

woodcraft store's close

Posts

woodcraft store's close

#1

woodcraft store's close

del schisler

I don't know if all will close but the one in popano beach florida i belive is one. At least it will not open up on line any more. I got a flyer a while ago and it said store closed. Sign's of time i guess.

Re: woodcraft store's close

#2

Clint Searl

Belly up in ABQ, too

Clint Searl

Re: woodcraft store's close

#3

David Barnett

Sarasota, now Ft. Myers

David Barnett

I'm amazed they stayed in business as long as they did. The Sarasota store lasted maybe 3 or 4 years. I won't miss 'em.

Re: woodcraft store's close

#4

Re: Sarasota, now Ft. Myers

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla

For a number of years I would drive 25 miles to the Woodcraft in Casselberry, Fla. The store was nice, the people were nice but the prices were in some cases ridiculous. I started shopping on line and saved a bundle with great service. It has been at least 10 years since I last visited that store.

Re: woodcraft store's close

#5

Santa Rosa, CA one closed in March

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I think this economy is just beating the daylights out of stores providing stuff that people don't HAVE to have.

Fortunately, we have a well-established, broad-range hardwood supplier in the area. And for me personally, I'm beyond pretty well tooled up, so I don't need an immediate retail presence of good woodworking tools (for those fairly rare tools that I buy new...).

Re: woodcraft store's close

#6

Re: Santa Rosa, CA one closed in March

John Lucas

We currently have 3 in Tennessee and they are all going strong. I will be demonstrating for a vendor at their National managers meeting in about a month. I'll probably know more after that how they are doing. I am certainly doing my part to keep them in business. At least my bank account is.

Re: woodcraft store's close

#7

David Barnett

I think Clearwater's holding out on the West Coast

David Barnett

The Casselberry store/s sprung up after I left the area. Back when was in Winter Haven, there wasn't a Woodcraft yet in the Orlando area. You could get a few carving and sculpture supplies at Pearl in Altamonte (on 436), but that was about it for amateur woodworking.

I'm sure there's lots of variation with franchisees. You can't just be an old guy with a hobby, life savings and a dream, though, and make a store happen if you're narrow in focus or don't have particularly good merchant and people skills. You might last longer in more prosperous times or the 'perfect' location, but in the long run you've got to have more than just a dream and that franchise. Stock helps. Even well-run stores in solid demographies can fold in times like these, of course.

At any rate, I really didn't have much use for a walk-in Woodcraft, although I tried to give them my business. They'd offer to order, but that wasn't the point. It helps to have stock. It helps to know what Waterlox is. Things like that.

Re: woodcraft store's close

#8

Re: woodcraft store's close

Gary Bindel

I drove by the Chardon, OH store this morning and it had a for sale sign out front.

Re: woodcraft store's close

#9

Re: woodcraft store's close

Howard Norman

I wonder what the percentage of Woodcraft stores is that have closed in the last year.

Re: woodcraft store's close

#10

Moses Yoder

Re: woodcraft store's close

Moses Yoder

If I remember right, they wanted $250,000 to start a Woodcraft franchise store. Yet they can still sell stuff online or call and buy it out of their catalog for the same price, or maybe a little less. With a building and inventory you would probably end up with a couple million dollars invested. I bet you would be lucky to sell $200,000 per year in one of their stores, which is really just a hobby shop. Half of that is cost of goods, so how do you keep the store going? My wife wants to start a little tea shop and thread goods shop but until we have a couple billion dollars in the bank I see no way to keep a little operation like that going. A person can start an internet business and run it out of their garage, but to have a store you need some serious cash to keep it going.

Re: woodcraft store's close

#11

Gary?

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

That store in Chardon is the Eagle America store, right? I just drove by it Saturday and didn't notice the sign. I wasn't looking though.

The picture of my dog in Weekend Accomplishments was taken in Chardon (actually Hamden) Saturday.

Joe

Re: woodcraft store's close

#12

Easy to make a small fortune

Neal in San Jose

with a woodworking store. Start with a large one!

Re: woodcraft store's close

#13

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Gary?

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Yeah, Eagle America is in Chardon. The woodcraft store is in Oakwood Village, South of Cleveland, Just off Route 480.

Re: woodcraft store's close

#14

Re: Gary?

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Right, been to both places a number of times.

I called the WoodCraft store yesterday to see if they had a particular hand plane in stock. They didn't, so they didn't get a sale... I do like the store though. They recently moved to that location. Hope it works out for them.

We (Cleveland) lost Rockler a couple years ago, hope WoodCraft can hang in there.

Joe

Re: woodcraft store's close

#15

Re: woodcraft store's close

Carol Reed, Strawberry, AZ

Indeed, it was $250K. The other start up costs exceeded $500K, at least in the San Diego area, about ten years ago. A friend and I looked into it. Had capital lined up but the kicker was in the details. Excessive signage requirements that flew in the face of local mandates. Franchiser inventory control that did not allow for local variances and interests. Franchiser computer control of sales and ordering with restrictive access to the franchisee. There were a few other things. The bottom line seemed to be buying a 'job' but with no salary!

According to our investors, this franchise was more controlling than most. In the end, none of us felt that we could pay back our investors within 5 years, much less even one of us taking a salary in the same period of time. We did the whole business plan and glad that we did. It told us that it was a 'no-go' from the beginning.

And in that same ten year span, no one else bit for the franchise either. We had the world's largest woodworking club there plus a top notch community college woodworking program. We also had people with some woodworking notoriety on a national level as part of the equation.

I can only wonder how some of them held on until the end of their building leases.

Re: woodcraft store's close

#16

That's the 2nd one near there…

Rod Peterson�Ormond Beach, FL

There was a nice one in Deerfield Beach ten years or so ago, right on 10th a mile or so east if I-95. I was surprised it folded, although at the time I think it was a company owned vs franchisee owned issue (I think they bailed on all the company owned stores about that time).

I was surprised later to see the Pompano store open, although I never went there. It was on Federal Highway, as I recall, and just not convenient to get to from Hollywood.

Re: woodcraft store's close

#17

Casselberry store moved…

Rod Peterson�Ormond Beach, FL

within the last year (or a bit). They're now right on 17/92 south of Semoran in Fern Park (I'd never heard of Fern Park before). It seems a little smaller than the one on Semoran, but it has decent stock, perhaps a little more lumber, and the staff seems good to work with. As someone else said, I'm pretty well tooled up, so shopping at Woodcraft is more of a curiosity tour for me.

When my daughter lived in Jacksonville I'd split time between the Casselberry store and the one at Regency Square (helped that there's a CompUSA next door, although there's one on Semoran, too).

She's since moved to Atlanta and we drove by a Woodcraft one day last Fall. It wasn't convenient to stop and it wasn't near her home so when we got back to her house I looked on the internet to find others. The one I saw is the only Woodcraft in the entire state of Georgia! Fortunately, there's a place called Peachtree Woodworking not to far in the opposite direction which is nice to visit.

Re: woodcraft store's close

#18

David Barnett

Pretty hard for a bricks-n-mortar franshise...

David Barnett

...to compete with a catalog where everything's in stock, especially in these days of expedited (and sometime free) shipping. Only reason I'd ever buy from a store is to get it even faster than ordering and to save on shipping. Whenever possible (which is always), I'll even get someone to pick it up for me to avoid going myself.

Re: woodcraft store's close

#19

also Highland Hardware in Atlanta

roger lance

Re: woodcraft store's close

#20

Re: woodcraft store's close

Jerry Samsen

Wonder why they keep promoting their franchises. Can't say I haven't thought of buying one.

Re: woodcraft store's close

#21

David Barnett

Even monkeys fall out of trees

David Barnett

"Wonder why they keep promoting their franchises. Can't say I haven't thought of buying one."

Why wouldn't they? They're a perfectly good company with great product lines and support. They have some thriving stores, a solid track record, a great name and a terrific catalog. I surely don't begrudge their expansion efforts nor the risk takers willing to give it a go. I have nothing but respect and high hopes for both. I'm sure the company upholds their end of things, as you'd expect. But some franchisees are better cut out for it than others, some places better suited than others, factor in the intangibles (if only you could), and then there's this economy.

My point is, know your market. Carol Reed (above) did due diligence, did her homework and made a sound decision based on her risk profile. Well-run franchises in areas with a strong tradition of woodworking trades, a culture of craft, good demographic fit and healthy-enough economies are probably better candidates than areas where there's not so much that culture and heritage. Aside from the encouraging local economic factors, check that median age, check the seasonals. Sarasota wouldn't have been my first choice for a Woodcraft. Plenty of prosperity? You bet. Great place to live. No argument there. Arts? Boucoup. Something in the milieu that says 'woodworkiness'? Lost on me.

Re: woodcraft store's close

#22

Re: Even monkeys fall out of trees

Carol Reed, Strawberry, AZ

LOL! That was generous, David.

More like the risk profile of the investors. Given that San Diego county is more than a moderately expensive place to live and do business, my partner and I simply didn't have the personal reserves to persevere. Back then the economy wasn't considered a negative factor. Today I would even bother with the effort of due diligence. Due to the economy and the diminishing amount of disposable income for most people, it's a no-go on the surface of things.

We were fortunate in that we had investors who were mucho savvy about money and business and we were blessed with just enough intelligence to listen to them. Not a bad combination.

It is true that you need money to make money.

Re: woodcraft store's close

#23

Re: Belly up in ABQ, too

mdclor

I am sorry (but not surprised) to hear that the ABQ store closed. I would go there to pick up items that I hadn't anticipated needing, but was usually disappointed that the item wasn't in stock. Also, when I did find something to purchase it seemed to take an eternity to pay for it and get out of the store. I am sorry for the franchisees; it seems to me to be a systemic failure rather than a personnel issue. :(

Re: woodcraft store's close

#24

David Barnett

The Falling Wallendas

David Barnett

"Back in my trading days, when I often worked without a net, things could get exhilarating", he'd begin.

Seriously, sometimes it's good to have realists (or, at the very least, pessimists) holding the purse strings to curb that rush of enthusiasm. And nothing will quite curb it like rising interest rates, tight payback plans and profitability turnarounds measured in mere years. Sometimes it's survival instinct, sometimes just luck. Whatever the forces, seen and unseen, that surrounded you, Carol, color yourself very lucky, as I see you have.

"Back in '87", he'd go on, "You couldn't jump. The trading room was only two stories up and you couldn't open the windows. The smell of fear was sickening."

What may seem brilliant in the all-or-nothing in-and-out cut-and-run flashes I live for, would soon be exposed as financially bipolar if I were to stretch my time frames. Homey don't play that. So when I say some aren't cut out for that long-term franchise kind of thing, that means me first and foremost. And yeah, sometime the slower instrumentation those money guys use indicates properly. Other times the converse.

You said, "...we were blessed with just enough intelligence to listen to them. Not a bad combination."

Amen. A thousand times amen. It takes both kinds to make it work, but those who can handle the long commitments get my utmost respect, my awe. All my kind will ever contribute is liquidity.

Know thyself. Timing is everything, sure, but if you don't have that working for you, knowing oneself is a damned good runner up. That's pretty much it. I never married. Several women should be very grateful. For those days that I love woodworking, I wouldn't want to spend them running a Woodcraft, and for the days I hate woodworking, I really wouldn't want to spend them running a Woodcraft. I'm pretty sure you could've, though, times having been a bit more favorable.

Re: woodcraft store's close

#25

Re: The Falling Wallendas

Carol Reed, Strawberry, AZ

Thanks, David,

The times were fine then. The payback picture did not have a very good probability. One asset not to be overlooked when building a business, is to have a business to be able to viably sell at some point. That simply did not appear on our horizon. The return on sweat equity was dismal. And sweat equity was not all two of us would have had in it. The vote to not proceed was unanimous.

One really does have to look very far down the road to have an accurate yardstick by which to measure one's progress.

I did learn a ton about business and the business of money in those days. For that I am thankful. My two partners, one silent, have since passed away. Money people can always be found. But my passions have moved on. Money was never one of them. Still isn't. Money is just a necessity to live; a means to an end.