O.T.-Undercoating
Thomas Norton
Now that I have a new truck,a Ford F-150, I am really considering undercoating it. What experience have you guys had about having it done or DIY?
Thanks
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
O.T.-Undercoating
Thomas Norton
Now that I have a new truck,a Ford F-150, I am really considering undercoating it. What experience have you guys had about having it done or DIY?
Thanks
Re: O.T.-Undercoating
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
With all the plastic screwed to new vehicles in addition to factory rust coatings, I rather doubt it's of a great deal of use unless you're operating in a seriously corrosive area like alkali / salt flats, etm.
Now, doing the topcoated bedliner thing is a different story. Have friends with working trucks, pickups and 6-wheel, that swear by that deal.
Re: O.T.-Undercoating
Clint Searl
There's a bridge across the East River for sale that would be a better investment.
Clint
Re: O.T.-Undercoating
Larry in NW OHIO
I did a Z-Bart underline back in around 75 when I bought a Vaga. We put over 85000miles in about 6 years and when we traded it in the dealer could not believe how nice it looked because they were noted for rust. There was not a bit of rust on it. But I haven`t done it since. I still have not traded anything in that was rusty,except for an overseas LUV truck. The car manufacturers must have started doing the rust coating around then. It`s a waste of money, like said before, unless you live in a salty area. Larry
Re: O.T.-Undercoating
FredD
Because of Factory rust inhibiting coatings applied at the factory, about the only benefit you would notice is a reduction in road noise.
Your Mechanic hates the stuff when he greases your vehicle and finds the grease zerts covered with undercoating.
FredD
Re: O.T.-Undercoating
Gary Smyth
How long are you going to keep the truck? Where do you live? What type of undercoating? Please, not the spray kind, especially if they drill holes and then plastic plug where the wand went in. While undercoating does work in the short term while it is flexible, it is worse than no undercoating in the long term especially if you live where there is abrasive roads or salt. What happens is that with time and road wear the undercoating hardens and cracks and gunk gets into the crack. The crack lets in moisture. Now the moisture is trapped and if it contains salt, or simply lays there, it starts to rust from the inside. If you attempt to power wash it makes things worse as it frequently increases the size of an opening and drives the moisture deeper under the coating. In addition, the sprayed undercoating plugs the engineered factory drain holes (and fittings). Honda, for example, consistently advised that no undercoating be used. But�they then undersized their weep/drain holes in the fenders, quarter panels, and doors and when ordinary dust, hair, leaf litter worked its way in the holes plugged them and accomplished the same result � again with the best of intentions. I suggest not installing anything that can�t be removed once a year to check for rust. In my opinion the only effective rust preventer is a electrostatic coating on the frame before any body work is added. To do aftermarket is paying to shorten the life of the vehicle.
Re: O.T.-Undercoating
Clint Searl
When I dealt with a company that ran a painting operation for GM, I visited their plant and lab that had a demo and development production line setup. At the start of the line was a swimming pool filled with rust inhibitor and primer that every vehicle, completed frame and body, was totally dunked in before final assembly and painting. Aftermarket coatings are superfluous.
Clint
Re: O.T.-Undercoating
Bill Howatt
The manufacturer's have significantly improved rust resistance and I doubt if it really is necessary on a modern vehicle buy rust never sleeps and is always looking for a foothold.
The other things include how long do you plan to keep the truck and where do you live regarding salt.
My personal favorite is the annual oiling since it is replaced every year and creeps into almost every location and there is always the hope that if rust has started coating it with the oil wil stop or slow it down. On the downside, it is a nuisance to have to get it done annually and the cost does mount up.
In fairness, I think modern undercoat products should not be confused with the old tar-like products of years ago.
Bill
Re: O.T.-Undercoating
Moses Yoder
Obviously the general concensus is that it is a waste of money, so I would get it done. Most of the time the majority of people are wrong. In this case I have to ask myself if cars are so well protected against rust, why do I see so many rusty cars?
corrosion 101 and relevance to coated steel
Bill Tindall
One of the most insidious forms of corrosion occurs when steel is coated with something and there is a defect in the coating. The classic example is chipped paint. A further requirement is that the chipped spot is wet. A "battery" is established between the exposed steel and the adjacent coated steel. Oxygen from the air gets reduced to water at the exposed steel. The electrons to reduce the oxygen come from the iron under the adjacent paint. This iron oxidizes(rusts). No doubt you all have observed a blister of paint adjacent to a defect and under the blister is rusted metal.
The picture shows an example of a coated spring from the front of a Ford Escort. There was a defect in the coating and the coated part of the spring rusted until it got so thin it broke. I have stripped away the coating to reveal the rusted steel. Note how thin it got.
Bottom line. Undercoat if you wish but it better be perfect and stay perfect or you will be much worse off that had you no coated at all.

Re: corrosion 101 and relevance to coated steel
pete labelle
Most car bodies are built these days with a steel called galv-aneal. It is a galvanized steel that will accept paint. Regular galvanized steel will not hold paint.
Yes, most car bodies are dipped in a primer prior to finish paint. This coats all the back sides of the steel.
Cars back in the 70s had to be undercoagted, as they would rust out from the inside out. These days, it is not really the case. Rust these days starts on the outside (from paint abraison, or trapped mousture in the bottom of doors & tail gates.
My GMC Sierra is on its 8th Michigan winter and only have some rust behind the rear wheel from stone pecs that will have to be addressed this spring.
I also bought a couple cans of aresol grease when the truck was new, and reached in thru various openings to spray the lower internal seams of the doors and tail gate. Oily/greasy surfaces normally don't rust. This has soaked into the bottom water catching seams and is doing a good job thus far.
Undercoating is only good if it is 100% coated. Most people I have spoken to who used to be in the undercoating industry will all tell you the blind spraying they did was very sporatic in coverage.
Spend your money some place else.
Pete
From the original Poster
Thomas Norton
I appreciate ALL the replies and I think I will let this idea slide!
Thanks
Re: O.T.-Undercoating
FredD
"Obviously the general concensus is that it is a waste of money, so I would get it done. Most of the time the majority of people are wrong. In this case I have to ask myself if cars are so well protected against rust, why do I see so many rusty cars?"
Wow Moses , what a Philosophical Theory .
Correct me if I am wrong , but statistically speaking wouldn't you possibly be in the Majority who are wrong and if so , wouldn't that invalidate your Theory?? Just wondering is all 
About rusting vehicles, around here if your too lazy to run your vehicle through a good car wash after each Winter storm and wash the road Salt off, you will have Rust.
FredD
Unless the car wash recycles water
Bill Tindall
Re: Unless the car wash recycles water
FredD
Bill ,
they all do and if you were to see my 8 year old pickup with not one blemish on it anywhere , you would see the benefits of a regular washing and waxing and Rain X on the glass.
I guess it depends on how snug you are. 
FredD