Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Any 4-H Woodworking Leaders here?

Posts

Any 4-H Woodworking Leaders here?

#1

Any 4-H Woodworking Leaders here?

Ranbir Chawla

Hi everyone, I know it's been many moons since I've posted, I've spent the last few years lurking on and off. My 12 year old daughter has been working with me for a while now in the shop and has decided to do the 4-H woodworking project alongside her usual lamb and cake projects. We're trying to figure out if what type of projects are considered reasonable for the first 2 levels which are hand tools only.

She can cut nice dovetails by hand, but the state folks here said that it's 'impossible to do that without powertools' - sigh... She's thinking of a nice Krenov style plane, but we're wondering if that's enough to be hold the judges interest.

Anyway, comments and suggestions are welcome. Thanks in advance. Hope it's okay to cross post.

Ranbir

Re: Any 4-H Woodworking Leaders here?

#2

Re: Any 4-H Woodworking Leaders here?

Dan Donaldson

I would argue with them about "impossible dovetails and offer to demonstrate for them.

Re: Any 4-H Woodworking Leaders here?

#3

Re: Any 4-H Woodworking Leaders here?

Randy Johnson

4-H must be a lot different where you live. Around here everyone builds the same projects for the first few years. Since my only exposure is what I see at local county fairs I�m not sure how many years are required before the kids can build something that is unique.

Apparently the first year project in Indiana is a simple box. Even with such an easy project, I�ve seen a few that were pretty awful. I also have to say that on more than one occasion I have wondered how much the judges knew about woodworking.

I don�t know if there is a �no power tool� requirement or not. Around here, if one of the first year boxes featured dovetail joinery it would beat out all comers in that division.

Maybe something simple like a rack for CDs or DVDs? Build it like a scaled down bookcase. I don�t think they can say that dados are impossible by hand.

Re: Any 4-H Woodworking Leaders here?

#4

Re: Any 4-H Woodworking Leaders here?

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I like that idea, or ratchet it up and have Ranbir's daughter give a demonstration.

Re: Any 4-H Woodworking Leaders here?

#5

Re: Any 4-H Woodworking Leaders here?

AZ in Colorado Springs

Wow. Sounds like you're dealing with some ignorant people. The pyramids were built without power tools, but no one can cut a dovetail by hand?

Seems like these folks know what they want to see. If you go around their boundaries, it may turn out less pleasant, and more frustrating for your daughter, than you're hoping for.

I don't mean to read too much into what you've posted, but it seems that the leaders have little knowledge in this area.

Re: Any 4-H Woodworking Leaders here?

#6

Re: Any 4-H Woodworking Leaders here?

Larry in NW OHIO

It sounds like you have some snooty know it alls, that need a lesson taught to them. You should have your daughter, as Bruce said, cut dovetails right in front of them, and not tell them what she is doing. Or bring something that they want and a couple of other boards and a saw and she can tell them that she would like to show them how she did it, because she did it kind of different. ;) ;) :D Larry

Re: Any 4-H Woodworking Leaders here?

#7

Re: Any 4-H Woodworking Leaders here?

Ranbir Chawla

Thanks everyone for your support :-).

First decision she made was to skip level one and start @ the next level, which was 'okay' by the extension agent.

What we decided to do was to make the nice krenov type planes, she'll make 2-3 bodies and use one iron (she's cheaper with her cash then even her dad is :-) - and then she's going to make a nice carrying box for them using simple rabbet joints made with a cross cut saw and cleaned up with a plane. For the slide off top she's going to make it a small shooting board/bench hook.

She's also going to document the 4 dovetailed window boxes she's making for the barn out of poplar and include all the pictures in her record book before she paints them and installs them. (so there! )

And I think there might be a cool little project for the 'Open' competition for State Fair where she goes all out, but that might depend on how other kids stuff goes.

Thanks again for the support. I'll post pictures as we go along.

Re: Any 4-H Woodworking Leaders here?

#8

Re: Any 4-H Woodworking Leaders here?

Ron Jones

It seems that we should understand what the 4H program involves. Take a look at these links to see what is expected. It must be remembered that the beginning levels are very elementary for kids with no experience in woodworking. These are Indiana examples--other states may vary.

Requirements:

http://www.ag.purdue.edu/counties/grant/Documents/Project%20Requirements/state%20woodworking.pdf

Projects for level 1:

http://www.four-h.purdue.edu/downloads/Wood%20Science/Level1%20-%20Woodworking%20Plans%20Measuring%20Up.pdf

I suggest checking with your local 4H leaders and county extension office officials who deal with this on an annual basis. You will see that your daughter is, from your description, far advanced for level one. Maybe you can show some of her work to gain advanced standing.

No, I am not a 4H leader, but I did 4H woodworking 50 years ago. It was a valuable experience. I know it has changed. I also know that the young lady in this situation is not your normal beginning woodworker. Your situation is one that does not occur often I'm sure. Remember that 4H leaders are volunteers and are not experts in each project area. I hope that I have not violated forum rules by posting these links. If so, Ellis, please remove my post.

Re: Any 4-H Woodworking Leaders here?

#9

Re: Any 4-H Woodworking Leaders here?

KM

My eldest daughter will turn 35 this year. I started with her when she was 8. For her and her two younger sisters, we did woodworking for the next 10 years as a parent and I was the club's ww advisor. I did judging at a nearby county during this time. My daughters and often one of their fellow club members went to state every year. And every year, they won a top 20% award. Since my daughters graduated out of it, have done judging at the state level every year except for a couple when I could not do it for health reasons. I was also on the state committee when we revised the curriculum a few years ago. So...

I'd say a lot of it is variable base both on the state, local, and the individual sitting behind the desk, We have had some reasonable judges and some not so much. But they are volunteers.

We instituted a "skills demonstration" that was a simple project that must be completed within 10 minutes at the judging. This was a serious attempt to get a real estimation of the kid who brought in a curly maple and walnut jewelry box, largely made by dad or grandpa, who could not even cut a straight line or hammer in a nail using pine. I and judges that I have worked with, could usually determine with a few questioning just how much of the project the member did.

And yes, one year was a music stand with three legs with sliding dovetail joints.