Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

OT: Moving from Windows to Mac?

Posts

Re: OT: Moving from Windows to Mac?

#26

Mac hacks

Bill Howatt

You can find more info on the Pwn2Own competitions but this Wikipedia article somewhat sums them up. It shows the Apple products are not invincible and have often been the first to fall.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pwn2Own

Bill

Re: OT: Moving from Windows to Mac?

#27

Re: Mac hacks

John in NM

But can they hack out of the login running the browser?

Even running windows, I've had good success un-doing malware and such because the normal user accounts are set to not have admin permissions.

I think this has more to do with MS windows problems and linux's lack of them - MS defaults new accounts to admin (or they used to), and most sensible OS's do not.

Re: OT: Moving from Windows to Mac?

#29

Re: Mac hacks

John in NM

That doesn't answer the question. Taking control of a machine through an admin login is not as difficult as one that only has user permissions. Given that the industry "standard" is set by the geniuses at Microsoft it would not surprise me if the competition had the browser to be hacked running in an admin account.

The last time my XP machine caught some malware it was trivial to undo because all the damage was limited to a single user account and no significant registry changes could be made (as far as I know - I'm by no means an expert in such things). I was able to clean up the problem by simply deleting all files time stamped after the infection.

Re: OT: Moving from Windows to Mac?

#30

Re: Mac hacks *LINK*

Bill Howatt

I would say that the machines in the contest were running as they normally run - the contest has nothing to do with MS.

http://www.virtualofficexpress.net/about-me/are-safari-and-mac-osx-the-untouchables/

The real issue here is that the Mac is not immune from getting hacked. This isn't what most lot of Mac users think is the case.

Bill


Another Link for Mac Hack

Re: OT: Moving from Windows to Mac?

#31

No one claims either are immune to attack...

John in NM

Both links said they got in through the browser, started the calculator program, and wrote a file to disk. Any user will have permission to do those things, but they can only write to areas of the disk that they "own". They cannot typically make system wide changes, format disks, delete important system files, or any of the other stuff that malware likes to do - make registry changes if you're running MS. While hacking into a root account through a limited account is not impossible, as far as I know it is still very difficult. I would be genuinely interested to hear if this is not still the case.

Malware isn't scary at all if you set your accounts up to make it easy to deal with. All my computers use limited accounts for everyday use, and so far any and all problems have been likewise limited to the account that was in use when the malware started. This is an old, simple, and effective method for avoiding hacks, and while it would not stand up to a determined attack, it will weed out 95% of the problems. I think the default setting on user accounts has the most to do with the "invincible" reputation of some OS's and similarly MS's horrible reputation.

Re: OT: Moving from Windows to Mac?

#32

Re: OT: Moving from Windows to Mac?

iew

Do it! Your gonna love it. You will wonder why you haven't done this a long time ago. I made the switch about 4 years ago when the Intel based Mac came out and never looked back. Congratulations for clear thinking.

Re: OT: Moving from Windows to Mac?

#33

Re: No one claims either are immune to attack...

Bill Howatt

Hi John,

My final word on this now drawn out chain is that while maybe nobody who knows about such things claims either OS is immune the are many, many Mac users who do indeed think they are immune from malware and buy the machine for that reason only.

While the hack this year may have been running the calculator and writing a file they did bypass at least 2 of the OS's security walls.

Nice talking with you,

Bill

Re: OT: Moving from Windows to Mac?

#34

Re: Mac hacks

wilbur

Is OS X immune to attack? Of course not.

But saying that OS X is a safer OS overall than the various Windows environments out there, and that it's easier to maintain security on OS X than on Windows are pretty fair statements to make.

And Pwn2Own competitions aside, there's still no wide spread OS X virus despite the fact that OS X has been around for close to 10 years now.

Re: OT: Moving from Windows to Mac?

#35

Shhhhh....

John in NM

All these windows guys are content in running slowly from the bear - why tell them they can run faster if they wear shoes? :D :D :D

Re: OT: Moving from Windows to Mac?

#36

Re: In general, I agree.

Kurt

What Bruce says is true of Linux as well. The better you know Windows (or any other O.S.) the more difficult it is to learn something entirely different. Unless you need to collaborate with other MSO users, Open Office/Libre office works on all flavors of Linux, Windows and OSX. Open Office will save and import .doc, docx, xls etc. but I've heard complex fomatting doesn't make the trip flawlessly. I would recommend to anyone with curiosity to download a live CD from Ubuntu or better yet, Linux Mint. Ubuntu won't play flash videos or do some other things from a Live DVD, Mint will. A live CD/DVD runs 100% off the CD, it will not touch your hard drive unless you choose to install it. In fact if someone is REALLY paranoid, this seems like a really secure method. Everything that is stored is stored in volatile memory. Once the machine is restarted, anything that was uploaded or downloaded is GONE! No passwords stored, no spyware, no keystroke loggers, no nuthin' no kiddin'. This of course assumes networking is supported out-of-the-box and newer wireless adapters can be a problem. The office apps are included and you can store and retrieve stuff from a mountable drive like an external drive or USB drive. It'll also run on modest hardware; I'm running Ubuntu 10.10 desktop on a 800 mhz. PIII notebook with 512 Mb. RAM.