Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

OT: Moving from Windows to Mac?

Posts

OT: Moving from Windows to Mac?

#1

Bart Goldberg

OT: Moving from Windows to Mac?

Bart Goldberg

My 4 1/2 year old Dell laptop, running Vista, is really starting show its age, and is getting slower all the time. I'm tempted to finally get off the Windows platform and move to a Mac. I hear that the latest version of the Windows platform is horrible. This is part of my reason for migrating, in addition to the issues of security and viruses.

Can anyone please tell me if you made this move and what issues you encountered in doing so? I may pull the trigger this weekend and go to my local Apple store and get a Macbook Pro.

Thanks

Bart

Re: OT: Moving from Windows to Mac?

#2

Re: OT: Moving from Windows to Mac?

Bill Howatt

Run out and buy the Mac if it will make you feel happy but whoever told you Windows 7 was horrible doesn't know what they are talking about because it is exactly the opposite of horrible. It has received very good reviews.

Bill

Re: OT: Moving from Windows to Mac?

#3

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Re: OT: Moving from Windows to Mac?

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

I have been PC free now for over two years. I replaced a Dell with an IMac and a MacBook Pro and have had no a problem.

PC MS software etc continues to try to get better all the time I am sure so I can not comment, All I can say is that I love my Mac's. :D :D :D :D

Jim

Re: OT: Moving from Windows to Mac?

#4

Re: OT: Moving from Windows to Mac?

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

Did it in 2009. Moved most of my "bookmarks" from Windows 98 (I get a lot of mileage out of my machines) without any problem. I just upgraded to the latest version of OSX without a hitch and their "time machine" app works like a charm on the external hard drive I just bought. I use the Apple version of Word/Excel/Powerpoint called iWork. It lets me import/export Windows docs and spreadsheets but is different enough from the Windows apps that I probably should have paid a little for the Apple version of the MS Office products. My research indicates, however, that the "Dual Boot" (running Windows and OSX on the same machine) option may not be your best bet. I also use the Apple browser, Safari, and find it less troublesome than IE. The iPhoto app is a decent program for basic editing and organizing. No virus or crash problems yet, though I haven't started running processing hogs like Photoshop.

Re: OT: Moving from Windows to Mac?

#5

Bart Goldberg

Re: OT: Moving from Windows to Mac?

Bart Goldberg

Bill, Thanks for the feedback. I am looking for as much unbiased advice as I can get. As I'm sure you know, a Windows laptop is much less expensive that than an Mac. If it is comparable, and Windows 7 is decent, then I need to know so I can make an informed choice.

I know that Consumer Reports has given 2 models of the Macbook Pro the highest rating of all the 15" laptops, with a Dell XPS 15 as the 3rd choice at less than half the price. So, I must understand if a MAC is really that much better to justify such a large price difference.

Regards

Bart

Re: OT: Moving from Windows to Mac?

#6

Re: OT: Moving from Windows to Mac?

Chuck in Mtl.

Bart,

I have to disagree with you about Windows 7. I recently purchased the 64 bit pro version and have been pleasantly surprised at how well it all works. I would recommend this OD to anyone.

Re: OT: Moving from Windows to Mac?

#7

Re: OT: Moving from Windows to Mac?

Jerry Nicholson

Actually it sounds like you have been talking to a Linux fan. Win 7 is far better than any previous version of Windows and in my experience performs as well or better than Linux (Linux fans of course hate hearing anyone say that). I don't have a Mac so I can't give make any performance comparisons there. If you really want to get away from Windows, I would suggest trying Linux (Linux Mint 9 or 10 would be my recommendation) before investing in Mac. This is, of course, very dependent on what you are actually doing with your computer.

I have been using Win 7 since the beta and RC releases and have had no problem with it at all. It seems to require less resources than XP or VISTA. I also use Ubuntu Linux and Linux Mint and have tried dozens of other versions of Linux.

Jerry

Re: OT: Moving from Windows to Mac?

#8

Re: OT: Moving from Windows to Mac?

John McGaw

As Bill wrote, Windows 7 is the opposite of horrible -- for the first time ever Microsoft seems to have gotten virtually everything spot on and it has been completely bulletproof in this i7 machine I built and use daily. And, as an added bonus, it runs every piece of Windows software I've thrown at it, even stuff from Windows 95 days.

I, for one, refuse to pay the (IMHO) exorbitant prices that Apple charges.

Re: OT: Moving from Windows to Mac?

#9

Caution needed!

doug f, san clemente, ca

Bart - I made the switch about two years ago and I have to admit I love the MAC; intuitive, quick, not prone to viruses, it just works the way it's supposed to.

BUT, before you make the leap, do some careful checking on the programs you use all the time. I use Quick Books and Quicken and have found that the MAC versions of those programs are not of the same caliber as the PC versions. Pages and Numbers, the MAC equivalents of Word and Excel, also fall somewhat short of the mark. However, programs that are created for the MAC like Garage Band, IPhoto and others are excellent.

It's all a matter of compromise, ease of use versus versitility and abundance of programs. Look at what you want to do with the computer, try both and bite the bullet.

Good luck with your decision.

Doug

Re: OT: Moving from Windows to Mac?

#10

Re: OT: Moving from Windows to Mac?

Jerry Nicholson

Office 97 doesn't run properly. I assume that Microsoft did this so people would have to buy their newer Office products. I don't like Office 2007 and 2010 but I got a couple of Office 2003 packages from E-Bay

I'm running some pretty old stuff with Win 7, including DesignCad 2000.

Jerry

Re: OT: Moving from Windows to Mac?

#11

A.J. Hamler

Re: OT: Moving from Windows to Mac?

A.J. Hamler

My first computer was an Apple --- a waaaay old one: Apple II w/ 16K of RAM, and you had to save programs on a cassette recorder and use an adapter for an old TV as a monitor because they didn't have floppy drives or monitors for Apples yet... yikes.

After that though I switched to PCs and had them for the next nearly 30 years. Due to a freelance editing job in 2008, I had to get a Mac for server/software compatibility. Let me tell you, I was dragged kicking and screaming into the Mac world. At the risk of offending my PC friends, it was the best thing that ever happened.

I've had one problem with it -- the hard drive went wonky after about two years and I had to replace it -- but it is otherwise a dream to use. It's approaching its third birthday this June and it runs literally as fast and as well as the day I took it out of its box. I could never say that for any PC I've owned, as they all start getting slower and sluggish after a while.

There are some weird differences between Macs and PCs you'll have to get used to -- buttons in the "wrong" place, dragging operations are somewhat different, etc. -- but I'm certain that for my main machine I will always have a Mac from now on. I could easily type a list of all the great things about it over PCs, but you've seen all the TV spots so I won't.

This is not to suggest there's anything wrong with PCs, because there's not. In fact, the laptop I bought last summer is a Toshiba PC running Windows 7. It's an excellent machine, and as others here have said W7 is the best Microsoft OS in years, far better than Vista.

Just my .02.

A.J.

Re: OT: Moving from Windows to Mac?

#12

In general, I agree.

Bruce, a MN Galoot

The part I agree with is that the Mac equivalent to Windows software may not be set up as well as its Windows equivalent.

We switched from Win XP Pro to an iMac two years ago. I was fed up with MS in general, although I didn't really have problems with XP. What I didn't like was MS scanning my computer each time they sent out a new service pack. I just don't like that level of intrusiveness. Apple doesn't do that. So we made the switch.

I've been using computers for roughly 25 years and had been briefly employed as a customer service tech for Gateway. I'm fairly familiar with Windows OS. That was part of the problem of my switch to an iMac. For every operation I wanted to do, I had to first think of how I would do it in Windows and then rehink how to do it in MacOS. That took some time. My wife is much less adept at computers, and she took to the iMac like the proverbial duck to water -- she got it right away, and still does. She needs much less help than with the Windows box. The Mac OS is highly intuitive, so I would have to conclude that the less you know of Windows, the easier your adaptation to the Mac OS.

Having said all that, we just got Windows 7 at work, and I like it fairly well. It is integrated better than XP Pro, but doesn't handle legacy programs as well, IMO. I think it's probably the best OS that MS has made so far.

There are things the Mac does that are vastly superior to anything Windows has ever done. If you're on a Windows machine, go to the search function and look for a file. It'll take minutes. If you do the same thing on a Mac, the search literally will be complete by the time you finish typing the search string. And then there's the graphics. I've never had a computer that does graphics like the iMac. And then there's the virus issue. It's just not been a problem. One more thing is (and some don't consider this an advantage) that Apple maintains very tight controls over third-party software developers and absolutely insists that all software written for the Mac adhere to some fairly strict protocols. Of course, the advantage of this is that you don't have to wonder where the controls are, because they are all the same from one program to the next.

My advice is go go spend some time on both machines. See what you like. Buy it. I like my Mac.

Re: OT: Moving from Windows to Mac?

#13

Linux

Bruce, a MN Galoot

my son is software developer. His personal computer is a quad processor power machine of unbelievable ability, much more advanced than the one he has at work. He has it dual booted with Win7 and Linux. He actually prefers Linux to Windows 7 (although he says that with Win7, MS has finally gotten it right), but he says to make it work you have to know what you're doing. It's not a plug-and-play OS. OTOH, he tells me that there are some great open-source programs for Linux.

Re: OT: Moving from Windows to Mac?

#14

Apple prices

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I don't know about a lot of the other products, but I priced out a Windows box from Dell (not their basic product, but a business quality machine) when I bought my iMac, and by the time I loaded up the Dell with equipment equivalent to the iMac (much better video card, sound card, ram and a 24" flat screen monitor), the Dell was just as expensive.

Re: OT: Moving from Windows to Mac?

#15

Re: OT: Moving from Windows to Mac?

woodenleg

I agree with Bruce's last statement, in the respect of figure out what you want your computer to do, with that info go to both stores that let you "play" with the machines. My wife uses a PC at work and a Mac at home, we have a tower and a Mac Book, she sometimes comes home really pissed because she could not get the PC to what she needed (she is the computer nerd for her department). We bought the tower with graphics in mind along with the proper monitor for graphics. With all that said it boils down to what you are planning to do with the computer.

Dave P.S. I have never been hit with a virus in 20+ years with Apple products.

Re: OT: Moving from Windows to Mac?

#16

Re: In general, I agree.

Bill Howatt

Your comment about the less you know about Windows or maybe it's computers in general is often mentioned. If you are happy taking defaults or letting the app put things where it wants then the Mac is great. If you want to do your own thing then it isn't so great. I don't really fault the concept and Windows PCs are getting more and more like that but you still have more hooks to do your own thing. Let's face it, you don't need to know how the transmission works to drive the car.

The prime importance is that the machine can run the applications you need properly. You can have the best HW in the world but if it won't run the program you want then it is just a boat anchor.

Bill

Re: OT: Moving from Windows to Mac?

#17

Re: OT: Moving from Windows to Mac?

Jim Dillon

Bart,

My 15 month old home built Windows 7 64-bit quad core 8GB RAM system has been rock solid and a joy to use. The Windows antivirus program has worked flawlessly (knock-on-wood). I do like the older email program better, but that is no big deal for what I do. So I would question, based on my own experience and other reviews, anyone who said Win 7 was "horrible". Folks who own Macs love them as well. Give each a spin.

Jim

Re: OT: Moving from Windows to Mac?

#18

Advantage - Mac

David Yoho

I wanted to add my two or three cents to this discussion in hopes it helps folks understand better.

First, as already pointed out, Win-7 is the best OS that MS has brought to market yet. XP-Pro was before that. Vista was never a contender.

Second, I think many make the mistake of "mixing" the machine (computer hardware) with the Operating System (software) when discussing computer platforms. In our house there are six computers - four PCs running Win XP Pro and two Macs (a 17-inch Mac Book Pro and a 27-inch I7 iMac). If you look under the hood of today's iMac you will find the exact same hardware found in many Windows based PCs. So, if the hardware is basically the same, what is so different between a PC and a Mac? It's the Operating System and that's where I find Apple out performs Windows-based machines. As good as Win-7 is, it still does not and can not do what the Mac OS does. Again, the point I'm making is that hardware is hardware but it's the OS that really makes the difference.

Third, there is the assumption that Macs because they're Macs are immune to virus problems - WRONG. They can be plagued just as badly if the virus creators were targeting them. Since the majority of computers used and sold today are still those running the Windows OS, they are a bigger and easier target. Make no mistake about it, if the bad guys (and they do to some extent) started focusing on the Mac platform, there would be more users scrambling to get anti-virus software than usual. Don't be fooled into thinking because you use a Mac you can't be infected with a virus.

Forth, in general, a Mac costs more than a PC. Try loading up a 27-inch iMac with the various upgrades available and see what that baby costs! Is it worth it? I think it depends on what you're doing or need it for. My son earns his living using one and it's worth every penny. I would add that my experience is that you'll buy at least two Windows-based computers in the time you own one Mac. Try adding the cost of two PCs when comparing the cost of a Mac and then decide if there's value there or not!!

I'm a long time PC user that's built them and bought them. I've used Windows from the Win 3.0 days till now. I've seen what a well appointed Mac can do and believe me even with their best foot forward with the release of Win-7, MS still can't hold a candle to the Mac OS - PERIOD.

I get a bit of enjoyment from tinkering with PCs and their problems and don't mind troubleshooting and solving them. However, if you want a computer that works and allows you to get to work straight away, you're better off with a Mac. I've even been thinking about jumping the fence whenever this HP box running XP bites the dust.

Re: OT: Moving from Windows to Mac?

#19

Clint Searl

Big expense for no gain

Clint Searl

Re: OT: Moving from Windows to Mac?

#20

Re: OT: Moving from Windows to Mac?

Dave Paine

I have a Dell Zino using Windows 7 and upgraded the wife's PC to new hardware and Windows 7.

I have to say Windows 7 appears to be stable.

I have been building my own PC's since the mid 80's. The Dell Zino and a Lenova laptop are the only PC's which were purchased as complete systems.

Windows 7 has some issues with accessing hardware on earlier Windows platforms. This can be done, but is not instantaneous.

So far my wife has been happy.

If you want the MAC, go for it, but I feel Windows 7 is performing better than Windows XP, which I like a lot and am presently using on my home PC and also at work.

My biggest gripe with any Windows upgrade is learning where MS "moved" the menu's or functions.

Re: OT: Moving from Windows to Mac?

#21

Pay yourself for the PC hassles

Tom Dunlap

My brother shared this insight about the price differences between the two.

Cost out what you want in PC and Mac. PC is likely cheaper. If you buy the PC put that difference in a jar. Now, everytime you have a hassle with the PC pay yourself back at a wage that you're comfortable with. In a short time the 'savings' will be gone. After that, you're on deficit spending.

After having a MacBook for five years and having to spend part of my life in PC I am money ahead because I just don't have the amount of hassles. Even rebooting when Mac does bog down...which is rare. It takes about two minutes to get back to where I was. In PC...its taken up to 8-10, usually at least five. Sure minutes aren't that long but it is a pain!

I'm using Windows for Mac/Firefox and this thing is as dependable as any of my shop tools.

Re: OT: Moving from Windows to Mac?

#22

Jesper, Denmark

Re: OT: Moving from Windows to Mac?

Jesper, Denmark

I have two machuines, both running Windows 7 Professional. Microsoft Security essentials and malawarebytes are the only security programs running - both free versions. The PC is wired to the router and the laptop connects WIFI to the router.

I have had no issues with Windows 7 and no security problems.

Malaware never finds any problems when scanning. The Security Essentials occasionally catches something and removes it.

The PC is an HP and the laptop Acer. Both commercial grade nad 3 and 1 year old respectively.

No issues whatsovver.

Re: OT: Moving from Windows to Mac?

#23

Re: OT: Moving from Windows to Mac?

wilbur

Here's one really geeky technical difference between Windows and OS X to consider. Windows 7 still uses the registry. As Windows machines get used, stuff like data that programs store for their own use gets added to the registry, which gets bigger and bigger with time. Anyone who has used a Windows computer for a period of time has experienced a slow down in the responsiveness of the computer. This is due to the increasing size and amount of data in the registry, sometimes called "registry bloat". Many times stuff that goes into the registry never leaves, even if you delete the program that installed the stuff in the first place.

OS X (and other *nix based systems) stores the same sort of information in individual files, and the data is accessed as needed. As a result, there's no equivalent to registry bloat on a Mac, and a Mac remains responsive over its lifespan. You can still have these files remaining on your computer, but instead of being part of a registry that gets bigger and bigger, these are just text files that occupy a minuscule amount of space on your hard drive, and don't do much harm, as opposed to unused parts of the Windows registry that will take up RAM.

Now, you can get around this on a Windows computer by cleaning the registry, but that's just another thing that I would have to do. So why not get the computer that saves you work? That is what computers are supposed to do, isn't it?

I am typing this on a MacBook Pro that is over 5 years old, and just as snappy as the day I bought it.

One other thing about Mac viruses: it's been said many times that the reason that virus writers don't target the Mac is because their market share is too small. I don't buy that at all. First, I can't believe that there isn't a virus writer out there with an ego big enough to really want to be the first one to successfully make a Mac virus. Secondly, the current installed base of Macs is probably comparable to the number of PCs back in the 1980's when the Jerusalem virus broke out. The Jerusalem virus was considered to be one of the most successful computer viruses ever, and it was passed around on floppy disks. So even though the market share might be low, the total number of targets is big enough. Not to mention that the vast majority of Macs are hooked up to some sort of high speed internet connection, which makes them much more available than transmitting a virus by floppy disk.

Re: OT: Moving from Windows to Mac?

#24

You're Right On

David Yoho

Wilber, the one thing I should have mentioned in my earlier response but didn't was exactly what you brought up about the Windows Registry. It's probably the main reason PCs on Windows slow down over time. And, yes, one can clean it, but why should we have to.

On the virus note, I have been wondering of late why there hasn't been a problem with a virus outbreak in the Mac community, given the increased numbers of users out there now. One reason might be that Windows is still just too easy a target and it's not so much to do with the numbers today.

Re: OT: Moving from Windows to Mac?

#25

Ironically...

John in NM

I don't much care for Mint and all the other Ubuntu derivations, they're just too windows-esc for me :D