Question about Japans (OT)
Larry in NW OHIO
Nuclear power plant. They said the explosions were hydrogen. Where does the hydrogen come from, or is it used somehow in the plant? Why is it there? Thank You Larry
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Question about Japans (OT)
Larry in NW OHIO
Nuclear power plant. They said the explosions were hydrogen. Where does the hydrogen come from, or is it used somehow in the plant? Why is it there? Thank You Larry
Re: Question about Japans (OT)
Bill Turpin in WNC mountains
It comes from breakdown of the cooling water. H2O
Re: Question about Japans (OT)
Larry in NW OHIO
In other words, the plants makes hydrogen from cooling the nuclear rods that makes the heat. Larry
Re: Question about Japans (OT)
Bill Turpin in WNC mountains
Electrolysis of water, which is easily done with a 6V battery, can be demonstrated on your dining room table. It is a high school chemistry set trick. When the core of a reactor goes haywire, the cooling water breaks down into hydrogen and oxygen. The over-heated core quickly exceeds the kindling temp of hydrogen. BANG! Core meltdowns are in excess of 5000�.
Explosions
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
Took place outside of the reactor core and the containment vessels when the hydrogen is vented or leaks into the building space. That's why the photos show the metal skin of the walls and roofs blown off. The reactors have not exploded.
Another reason for Thorium reactors
Craig Daymon
They're safer, smaller, the fuel is more abundant (extremely) and, unlike all the reactors in the U.S. (and currently most of the rest of the world) don't produce a byproduct that can be used to create nuclear weapons. (Because, you know, we really need to be able to incinerate the planet 10,000 times over rather than just 1,000.)
Re: Question about Japans (OT)
Gary Smyth
This is a typical system. The containment building is the final barrier to meltdown problems--the first being the fuel ceramic itself, the second being the metal fuel cladding tubes (which I understand have partly melted), the third being the reactor vessel and coolant system. The containment building itself is typically an airtight concrete/steel structure enclosing the reactor normally sealed off from the outside atmosphere. The steel is either free-standing or attached to the concrete missile shield. While the containment building plays a critical role in the most severe nuclear reactor accidents, it is only designed to contain or condense steam in the short term and long term heat removal still must be provided by other systems.
In Japan it is the other systems that failed/are failing. Likely some melting has already occured but has not breached containment--yet. It's a serious situation and although Japan's is a GE reactor, I know that more than a couple of Westinghouse Nuclear engineers in neighboring Wexford, PA are on alert. By the way, Japanese nuclear engineers are some of the finest in the world according to the guys I know. If it can be fixed I'm sure that at least some of the best are working on it. 
Just to be clear...
John in NM
The hydrogen is not a desirable by product and is not produced during normal operation. The idea is to use the fission reaction to produce just enough heat to make steam from the cooling water and use the steam to run a turbine. All commercial electricity is basically made this way, its just the heat source that varies - coal, waste oil, fission, etc....
Yet another question (OT)
Larry in NW OHIO
Sorry but I am very courious. What happens if they do have a meltdown, I don`t want to find out, but would the core melt through the containment floor and then what? Where would it go, to the other side of the earth? My luck it would end up, or down, burning through the floor of my workshop. Larry
Re: Yet another question (OT)
Bill Turpin in WNC mountains
By using my transit, sextant, gps, and calculator I have determined that your workshop is the direct target after it burns thru the molten core of the earth! Can I buy your tablesaw? I bid a $100.
Call me, 1-888-555-1212 quick
Re: Question about Japans (OT)
Jim Dillon
Larry, I think your shop is safe ...for now
. If you are curious about the production of hydrogen in a nuclear reactor that is behaving badly, google zirconium + steam + reaction, which is where I got the following tidbits of info - some of which may even be true!
Basically, hydrogen can be generated in a nuclear reactor if the fuel rods in the reactor lose their cover of cooling sea water. The tubes that contain the fuel pellets are made of a zirconium alloy. Zirconium will react with steam at elevated temperature and pressure to produce zirconium oxide and hydrogen gas. Moreover, this oxidation reaction is extremely exothermic � that is, it releases a great deal of heat, and exacerbates the problem and raises the temperature in the reactor core even further. At some point, if conditions (temperature, pressure, hydrogen and water/steam concentration) reach a certain critical threshold, a process called deflagration takes place which, in essence, is an out-of-control burning/explosion much, I suppose, like flash-over in a normal house fire.
I read where the initial burning of the zirconium cladding is like a burning sparkler in that the "fire" proceeds along the axis of the fuel rod. In essence, like a sparkler, what one has is a runaway oxidation reaction generating more and more heat. This has sometimes been referred to as a zirconium cladding fire and is well known in the nuclear industry and has been studied extensively. It is NOT something that nuclear power folks like to see in a normally operating reactor.
As I understand it, the modern intact reactor containment vessel is built to withstand the pressure that might be exerted on its walls if a hydrogen explosion occurs. However, if any cracking has occurred due to the earthquake, then the vessel's integrity may be compromised. Newer reactors have two containment vessels to provide an additional level of protection.
Hope this helps put your fears to rest
.
Jim
Re: Question about Japans (OT)
Jesper, Denmark
The production of hydrogen is not strictly nyclear related, only temperature.
Water is used to produce steam and for cooling. If the temperature of the water gets high enough, the water H2O, splits into two separate components, hydrogen and oxygen. This mixture is easily ignited and a rapid combustion or explosion occurs.
I suspect that what has occurred is really not technically an explosion, but rapid combustion like in a car engine, with a flame front propagation around 20 m/second. A true explosion, like in dynamite, has a flame front that travels much faster, say around 200 m/second.
OT: this may be worst than the chemoblyl *LINK*
del schisler
read this link And it is not over yet. Read the goodle new's also . Also i watch the ALJAZEER tv for new's . This is fta tv so not everbody watch's also RT tv and PRESS tv all new's all over the world. You will here news their before other's have it.
http://www.ibtimes.com/articles/122849/20110315/japan-nuclear-disaster-may-be-worse-than-chernobyl.htm
Re: Question about Japans (OT) *LINK*
Gary Smyth
Yesterday I posted a much simplified graphic of a typical nuclear reactor. I took a guess. As it turns out there are two types of reactors and the Japanese type in this instance is as that above.
Note in this graphic that "spent" rods are stored in a floor ABOVE the reactor vessel. They are stored there to cool them for eventual disposal after up to two years for a "cool down".
One of the additional threats now is what will happen if that storage vessel is damaged and the rods become exposed and then fall down toward the reactor vessel. Is there enough fuel then to begin form a catastrophic unrestrained reaction?
For anyone with continued interest, I found a site that appears to provide recent information in more detail.
Also with the expanded radius (20km) for safety now in effect, keep in mind there are 50 people that remain on site. The risk of dangerous radiation poisoning for them is infinitely higher.
Additional info updates
Re: Yet another question (OT)
Larry in NW OHIO
Bill Thanks for the information and I hope I do not have to wait for it. This could not have happened last Jan. when we were having 0 degrees and 2 feet of snow. I could have sold the heat. Except for the bad drawbacks it wouldn`t be to bad.
Larry
P.S. About my TS, I`ll take the $100 prepaid, since that is where the core will end up burning through right under the saw. So if you want the blob of molten metal and I`ll even include the core with it, post paid. I`ll take cash. Larry
Re: Yet another question (OT)
Bill Turpin in WNC mountains
My bid is only if I arrive before the event.
I was attempting to add a little humor to an event that is being possibly, mostly over-blown by a lot of un-educated media types! Everybody fears radiation, because they know nothing. We get radiation, every day, from our sun. Enough of it, and you will surely die! Not enough and you will surely die! I guess that makes radiation bad.
Re: Yet another question (OT)
Larry in NW OHIO
Thanks Bill, there`s always room for humor, it all depends how it`s taken. I would never make light of something so terrible and really mean it. My heart goes out to all the people that are in that area and the surronding area. Larry
Re: Yet another question (OT)
Bill Turpin in WNC mountains
Larry I was not trying to say that you were making undue humor. I think that I was making fun of all the reporters that are talking without engaging any knowledge. My wife works in a small pharmacy here in WNC. They sold out of potassium iodide this afternoon due to all the hype. I will contribute to Samaritan's Purse's relief fund in the morning after my SS deposit is made.
A fine distinction
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
From what I understand, the events blew roofs off and walls down. Even if it's not technically an explosion, it's a rather fine distinction.
My thoughts are with the workers who are in there risking their lives trying to bring things under control.
And everyone in Japan right now.
Re:Yes, Bill......
Jesper, Denmark
The people on site are only effected by the devastating results.
My point was to clarify where the hydrogen came from and the resulting reaction. My fear is that lack of understanding will lead to sensational and incorrect conclusions. Linguistically, some idiot will make the link to "hydrogen bomb", which is something completely different and not in any way related to this disaster.
Fortunately (for them) my connections in Japan are all on the South Island of Kyoshu, and not physivally hurt by the event. Psycologically, all Japanese are very much stunned that this could happen.
The nuclear power industry has lost a lot of face by not having anticipated that the emergency generators could be damaged by the Tsunami - the power plants handled the earthquake OK, but the generators were flooded. Doesel engines do not work well under water.
Re: Yet another question (OT)
Larry in NW OHIO
Bill I didn`t think that you thought I was trying to make fun of a bad situation, I just wanted to verify it to everyone esle. Thanks Bill Larry
Thanks for the link!
Lee Grindinger
Gary, thanks for this link, reliable information about what's going on is kinda hard to come by.
Lee
Good info!
Lee Grindinger
Thanks Del
Re: Question about Japans (OT)
Mike Cutler
You have the correct picture. That is a GE designed BWR.
The spent fuel pool is on the upper floor to facilitate refueling the reactor, and fuel storage.
In a BWR the control rods are inseted from the bottom, up into the reactor. To refuel the reactor a transfer gate is opened between the spent fuel pool and the actual reactor once the reactor head is removed. The reactor and the pool are flooded up to a very high level and fuel assemblies are removed from the core and transferred to the spent fuel pool under water.
Jesper hit the nail on the head. The real problem has been the lack of an emergency diesel generator power source. The design of this reactor is such that a total shearing of the largest pipe will not cause a meltdown.
The available inventory of water in the Torus, natural circulation and low pressure high flow pumps would have kept water circulating, and isolated the problem to the Reactor vessel and the Drywell. However, pumps are required and with no diesels, there was no available power.