Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Magnetic switch for TS question

Posts

Magnetic switch for TS question

#1

Magnetic switch for TS question

Tom Dunlap

A couple of days ago I bogged down my TS and it kicked the breaker.

The service panel is a long way from the TS, which is probably good. When I flipped the breaker the TS turned on! I forgot to manually flip the switch before going to flip the breaker.

On the way back to the TS I decided that it was finally time to but a magnetic switch on the TS. When I went into the WC archives and then Google I found some stories about how mag switches can flip on if the tool is jarred.

Now I have to wonder...which is more dangerous? It seems the if bumping the TS could start it then I may not want one.

Are there mag switches that have been designed to not start from being jarred?

Re: Magnetic switch for TS question

#2

Re: Magnetic switch for TS question

Larry in NW OHIO

Tom The magnetic switches that I used to work on, when I use to work, could not start just by a jar or jiggle. The starter has a block of metal in it and when you push your start button that energizes a magnet and pulls that metal block UP and and in turn pushes the contacts with it and starts your machine. So if you can follow my explanation, if so maybe you can explain it to me :D , the machine can not start without going against the law of physics. The block of steel can not go up without a magnet to pull it up. At least that is the way they worked years ago. They may be different nowadays. Larry

Re: Magnetic switch for TS question

#3

Re: Magnetic switch for TS question

Bill Howatt

I'm only going by an impression but there seemed to be more reports of that happening a few years ago - could be the problem was noticed and fixed.

The problem was caused by the contacts in the open position being too close together such that a bump would cause them to momentarily make and once that happened they sealed in and the tool kept running.

One might guess that if you examined the switch and saw how far apart the contacts were you could make some sort of a value judgement but it might not be easy. Better still find somebody who has one like you are interested in and give it the whack test.

I think Grizzly sells them and I'm sure there is a lot of experience on this forum with their products.

Bill

Re: Magnetic switch for TS question

#4

Re: Magnetic switch for TS question

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Tom, I was an Engineer at Emerson Electric for over 39 years. At that factory I did quite a bit of machine design and debug. We had hundreds -if not thousands- of magnetic relays on machines. In all those years I can't remember of any machine starting by being bumped or jarred. If it had happened, I would certainly have been informed and required to determine why it happened and required to provide a permanent foolproof fix. I have heard of this occurring on the web, I feel certain that if this happened (and I believe it probably did) it was the result of a poorly designed custom relay produced to a particular customer specification with either inadequate contact spacing and/or too weak springs used to return the contact block. I believe that if you use any major brand switches and relay for your retrofit you will be perfectly safe. Normal design for this circuit is that you have a single Normally open momentary "Start" switch wired in series with one or more normally closed "Stop" switches (may be momentary or on/off). One end of this start switch is connected to Line 1. The other end of the circuit (last stop switch) is connected to the coil of the relay (other end of the relay coil is connected to Line 2. The "pilot" contacts of the relay are wired to parallel the "start" switch. The circuit function as follows: When the Stop switches are closed and the start switch is momentarily depressed to close the contacts the relay is energized This causes the pilot contacts to close holding the relay closed - when either the stop buttons are pressed or the power interrupted the relay will immediately drop out stopping the machine. A single pole may be used for 120 Volt applications with the "Hot" line opened with the relay contacts. In 120 Volt applications Line 1 is the hot line and Line 2 the neutral. (240 Volt - both L1 and L2 are "Hot").

A double pole (with pilot contacts) with 240 Volt coil is required for all 240 Volt applications so both "hot" lines are disconnected from the motor when the relay is off (most if not all shop equipment does not have a neutral line fed to the machine so a 240 V coil is required.

Re: Magnetic switch for TS question

#5

Re: Magnetic switch for TS question

Phil Joines

I have 6 of the Griz switches in different sizes in my shop and have installed others in industrial shops. After hearing about the jar problem I tried hitting them with my fist from every angle I could to test them. None of them started.

Re: Magnetic switch for TS question

#6

Re: Magnetic switch for TS question

FredD

You have seen what can happen without a Magnetic switch to protect you , forget the scare stories and get one for your saw , the sooner the better.

FredD

Re: Magnetic switch for TS question

#7

Re: Magnetic switch for TS question

Jay Lombardo

Go ahead and install the mag starter. I have installed magnetic starters and contacts for more than 40 years and NEVER have seen one initiate from a bump or a blow of any kind. However, I have inadvertently started my Unisaw. This is not a story told to me, I actually did it and you can't make this stuff up. Fortunately the blade was under the table and I had a piece of plywood on the saw as I was using it as a workspace (I know, I know!!!). As I leaned over the saw it suddenly started! Scared the crap out of me! as I looked at the switch to figure out why I found that a half roll of life savers in my pocket had lined up with the start button, which is recessed, and when I leaned in the roll acted like your finger and pushed the start button. I think sometimes something like this could be reported as "bumping into" the starter when in fact the button was indeed pushed. Like I said, you couldn't make this stuff up.

Be careful,

Jay

Re: Magnetic switch for TS question

#8

Not an urban myth...

Tom Dunlap

Here are some seemingly legitimate threads about bump starting:

http://tinyurl.com/4l697o5

http://tinyurl.com/4fovhmr

There were others too. I did notice the age of the threads too.

Now I'm off to Grizzly to see what I need, thanks!

Tom

Re: Magnetic switch for TS question

#9

Self Activating Switches

Howard Acheson

The was a legitimate issue a few years ago. Go to the site referenced below and scroll down the list of article until you get to the one about magnetic starters.

Rick Christopherson is a long time respected woodworker and author.

http://www.waterfront-woods.com/

Re: Magnetic switch for TS question

#10

I read his article first

Tom Dunlap

When I googled switches I found his article close to the top. That is what got me thinking about this issue.

Re: Magnetic switch for TS question

#11

If you can find an improved model...

John in NM

By all means go with it. If not, don't hesitate to install one just because of the chance of a bump start. The circumstances under which you might experience a dangerous bump start are far more rare than the chance of a dangerous power drop and restart condition with your current set up.

For what its worth, my bandsaw has a mag starter that won't shut off if you hit the button too hard - basically the same condition where one might get a bump start. I've never had it start accidentally, even with the thing on wheels the switch just never seems to get bumped. Maybe I should try intentionally one day, see what it would take.

Re: Magnetic switch for TS question

#12

Re: Self Activating Switches

Rick Christopherson

Long time woodworker and author, yes....respected...well that's up for debate. But thanks.

The issue isn't so much with the switch, but with how it is mounted. With a solidly mounted switch, the risk is very low. It also appears to be related to the quality of the contactor.

The intent of the article wasn't to make people shy away from magnetic starters, but simply as a warning for something to look out for on some machines. Some manufacturers did take notice of this warning years ago, but I have also seen some of these same manufactures reverting back to their previous flimsy support brackets.

You shouldn't hesitate putting in a magnetic switch. Just pay attention to how it is mounted, especially if it is a low-cost contactor.