Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Question on finishing to H. Acheson....

Posts

Question on finishing to H. Acheson....

#1

Question on finishing to H. Acheson....

roger lance

Howard....like most woodworkers starting out, I knew a little about working the wood but nothing about finishing....so I went thru the phase of acquiring tools and making shop furniture etc....and I spent time trying to learn about finishing....but my TV teacher and guide was only applying a very simple finish in the last minute of the show and there was not much emphasis on finishing....and I wasn't learning that much....finally out of a desire to get making real furniture, I built a king size arts and crafts /mission bed patterned after one sold under the Stickley brand that has 46 slates in both foot and head boards (there are about 200 m/t joints in the bed) and I left the bed unfinished (but sanded to 220) as I went on to make other a & c pieces that were simpler....and I began to use Jeff Jewitt's finish schedule including a water based dye and found that I really like this finish except that it is very difficult to control the dye step in the neat manner required by this bed....I've evolved to the point of finishing parts and pieces of my furniture prior to assembly which is what I should have done with the bed....now, finally, comes my question to you....I'm thinking that this summer I will fume the bed to establish that uniform light brown tone that is made by the dye....and then continue with a coating of de-waxed shellac, coat of oil-based walnut gel stain, and protective coats followed by a wax rub out....so what say you about the fuming ??....will this work ?? ....I'm unsure that I'll find 26% ammonia but Ace sells 10%....should take more time but establish the tone I seek.

Re: Question on finishing to H. Acheson....

#2

Re: Question on finishing to H. Acheson....

Steve Schoene

Dye isn't all that hard to control even on largish objects like a headboard. If there is a secret it is to use plenty of dye--really wet the object. I generally apply it with a sponge. Start from the bottom up. Runs and drips, and there will be some with so many spindles, just run onto already wet surfaces where they can just be wiped up with a swipe of the sponge without leaving an overlap mark. It's just when dye runs onto already dry dye that you get an overlap that you have to work to remove. Wipe up puddles with the wrung out sponge. The darkness you achieve will depend almost entirely on the concentration of the dye mix, not how you apply it.

To this end, the only dye that dries slowly enough to accomplish this is water soluble. And, since there is a hand applied shellac coat in the schedule, that would rule out using TransTint mixed with water since it is also soluble in alcohol. So use a powdered watersoluble dye such as TransFast.

Re: Question on finishing to H. Acheson....

#3

Re: Question on finishing to H. Acheson....

Howard Acheson

>>>> I'm thinking that this summer I will fume the bed to establish that uniform light brown tone that is made by the dye..

I don't do fuming and I never recommend it to others. Fuming was discontinued in furniture manufacturing 75-100 years ago because of its danger to finishers. In the shop I owned, our insurance coverage specifically excluded fuming operations.

In addition, fuming can lead to very inconsistent results. Unless the boards are carefully selected and matched, each individual board can color differently.

With today's stains, there is no up-side to fuming IMO. Stick with dyes and pigment stains.

Re: Question on finishing to H. Acheson....

#4

I feel very much like the kid who....

roger lance

wanted a BB gun but was always told, "You'll put your eye out kid !" I'll simply do some experimenting on scrap like any other finishing task and see from there. I would not be considering fuming if I didn't already know that the controlling of the running of water dyes on a project this big and with this many surfaces would be next to impossible....you will be getting spotting and double dyeing that will show in the final finish....like any other flaw in a project, the maker of that project is always very aware of them and since this bed will be with me for awhile, I'm trying to keep those flaws to a minimum. To do the fuming, if the experimenting is positive, I'll build a tent in the back yard....outside....and use a mask with appropriate filters. Shellac is one of the substances that, when applied to a fumed piece, remove the gray caste and reveal the brown color of the fuming process. I am not a proponent of fuming....just a guy trying to avoid a little heart ache. No reply needed.

Re: Question on finishing to H. Acheson....

#5

Re: I feel very much like the kid who....

Steve Schoene

I still don't see why you are so down on your ability to use dye with double staining and drip spots. It's absolutely not necessary, if you just keep the surface wet, making it particularly easy if you start from the bottom and work up. And, if you do get a double stain spot there is no reason for that to end up in the final result. Clear water will redissolve and let you redistribute excess. Or, for that matter, you can remove the dye almost entirely with household bleach. Dye is easy. Dye can be manipulated at any time up to the point when you seal it with a top coat.

If you are still set on fuming, make sure when you test that you get a really good sample of scraps. Boards from different trees may take fuming differently, so you need some samples from each board you used. Further, even if all the boards are from the same tree, heart wood and sapwood will also color differently. And, if the fuming isn't as you hope--something goes wrong, your done--no practical way to undo it. You have only one chance to get it right. That alters the risk/reward ratio dramatically. That's why neither Howard and I recommend fuming.

Given manufacturer's record in general about protecting workers unless force, I don't think it is a given that industry discontinued fuming because of the hazards, I'd be more willing to bet it was because it was more expensive, or less reliable to use.

Re: Question on finishing to H. Acheson....

#6

Steve....appreciate your comments....

roger lance

I come to the conclusion that water based dye would lead to problems in this case from experience in using it on other projects....even Jeff Jewitt will break a project down into its parts if possible and then flood each piece with dye (his description of the technique he uses to apply his product of TransTint dyes - see a Fine Woodworking article he did on a book case)....the problem with the bed is that it is too big and no person is able to be in all places at all times with all those surfaces both front and back and all the multiple side surfaces....what will start out as "a" wet edge will soon multiple into dozens of edges....etc...etc....I even thought of getting a number of friends together, give every one a pail of dye some cotton rages, place people on both sides of the footboard, blow a whistle, and go like .... The potential beauty of fuming is that it gets every place....all surfaces....all cracks and crannies....and there is no runs or drips....there will be a difference in the tannin content in the different boards in the piece and as a result there will be a difference in the tones produced by the fuming on those boards but that is also a result of dye on boards from different trees....this difference in tone will be moderated, to some extent, by the glazing step when walnut gel stain is applied. There are some very successful furniture makers today that use fuming as their method of choice for arts and crafts furniture ( see Kevin Rodel of Maine). What I was interested in is will fuming chemically change the wood in such a way that the additional steps of applying de-waxed shellac, oil-based gel glaze, and protective finish be harmed or marginalized....and that does not appear to be the case.

Re: Question on finishing to H. Acheson....

#7

Re: Steve....appreciate your comments....

Howard Acheson

>>>> What I was interested in is will fuming chemically change the wood in such a way that the additional steps of applying de-waxed shellac, oil-based gel glaze, and protective finish be harmed or marginalized.

The only finish I would have any worries about would be shellac. Shellac and waterborne finishes are damaged by ammonia. What I don't know is how much, if any, residual ammonia is left in or on the wood after fuming.

I don't know the specifics of our project but in the shop I used to own, the finisher was always involved with the initial meeting about the project. He would provide input regarding construction as it may affect his ability to apply the finish effectively and efficiently. There was always some way to build in sub-assemblies to alleviate potential finish issues.

In my finishing classes, I used to strongly suggest that the finishing plans be virtually finalized before before starting the project. It's too late to deal with some issues if the project is complete and assembled.

Re: Question on finishing to H. Acheson....

#8

Howard....I'm in complete agreement....

roger lance

with the idea of planing/knowing your finish format as you begin to build a piece....and working in sub-assemblies or parts that are easy to finish prior to assembly....unfortunately, this bed is the piece that taught me that truth....now, I approach a piece looking to finish parts and pieces as I go....its a definite part of the process....the bed would have been simple to finish in this manner....there was a thread on the turning board regarding the value of making multiples of a project, I'm always feeling like I'm making prototypes and afterward know of many ways I could have improved the build (finish)....I've changed my finishing approach....and now I hope to do right by the bed and not diminish it with a poor finish....so I'll do some experimenting....and let my scraps off gas for awhile before applying the shellac....and we'll see.....have to get on with it, there are a lot of things to make....the house is big and empty.