Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

OT - question of "morals"... and apologies

Posts

OT - question of "morals"... and apologies

#1

JL

OT - question of "morals"... and apologies

JL

I opened my big fat mouth.

Someone in a "position of responsibility" "stored" material from the old church kitchen. Coincidentally, she happens to have a catering business. Not all of the stuff that was supposed to be in the storage locker actually made it into the locker - it made its way to the place she works out of. Some of it didn't make its way back to the church. She was informed that some of the material didn't make its way back (we had a pictorial inventory).

Yes - she eventually has returned most of it. But some stuff is still missing. In my eyes that is theft. I don't care if she has "health problems" - it still isn't right to take things and "borrow" them without asking.

So - how do I apologize for calling her a thief - without being hypocritical?

Re: OT - question of "morals"... and apologies

#2

Re: OT - question of "morals"... and apologies

Doug Reynolds in Seattle

Isn't there some quote about, "a rose by any other name is still a rose." Or, "if it looks like a duck, walks like a duck and quacks like a duck..."

Doesn't matter her motive, rationale, personal circumstances, etc. She took property in her care that was not hers to keep.

Re: OT - question of "morals"... and apologies

#3

Re: OT - question of "morals"... and apologies

steve mackay

I'm old and crusty ahead of my time. I wouldn't. But thats me. If you stole, you stole.

Re: OT - question of "morals"... and apologies

#4

Re: OT - question of "morals"... and apologies

mdclor

"I am certain that there was a misunderstanding...you didn't really mean to steal anything and I didn't really mean to call you a thief." :D

Re: OT - question of "morals"... and apologies

#5

Re: OT - question of "morals"... and apologies

Larry in NW OHIO

If I stored something for someone, I would not even use the stuff without asking. No two ways about it, she stole it. No wander she stored it for you. The way she sounds, I`m surprised she didn`t charge you for storage. You have nothing to apologize about. knowing she had a catering buisness, I`m surprised something wasn`t said before hand. Larry

Re: OT - question of "morals"... and apologies

#6

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Re: OT - question of "morals"... and apologies

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

That's a good way of putting it.

Sometimes when some one takes advantage of you and refuses to own up to making things right it's just a clear picture to what lengths they will go to take advantage of a honest persons efforts to help. When asked to help when a person is in need it takes a special person to step up and offer help, when the person who takes the help and they refuse to return what is not theirs, that is wrong. When the person who was given help goes so far as to even deny that what they have done, well.... as my grandmother used to say, pity them, they have such a selfish view of them selves as to place the need to take advantage over you than be an honourable person. In this case, taking from you says a lot about that need.

Life's too short to waste time on the dregs of this world.

Take care,

Jim

Re: OT - question of "morals"... and apologies

#7

Re: OT - question of "morals"... and apologies

Jesse Cloud

Has anyone told her that you are still short according to your inventory?

I don't think you owe her an apology, but don't let her rent space in your head either. I would let the senior clergy know the situation and just move on past it.

Re: OT - question of "morals"... and apologies

#8

Re: OT - question of "morals"... and apologies

Bill Howatt

I don't know why you feel a need to apologize.

How about, "I was very upset over the loss of church property and I regret how I expressed it to you."

Seems like your minister needs to step up the intensity of his sermons and lessons! :D

Bill

Re: OT - question of "morals"... and apologies

#9

JL

Thanks, I'll borrow that one.

JL

Re: OT - question of "morals"... and apologies

#10

Ellis Walentine

Diplomacy

Ellis Walentine

Seems to me, JL, that you are grasping for apologetic words that don't really exist in your heart. Those are hard ones to find. Why not be true to the facts of the case and to your own righteous indignation and confront the woman with your feelings and your moral dilemma? E.g., "I need to talk with you, Ms. X. When I called you a thief, I was reacting to the fact that church property ended up in your hands and you didn't acknowledge it. Only you know whether it was an honest mistake or not, but church property belongs to the church, and it would be the Christian thing to do to return the remaining missing items and to acknowledge your mistake. I, for one, won't be comfortable until you do." Let her save face if you want to be a real diplomat, but try to convey your feelings honestly, or else it'll nag you forever.

My 2�.

Ellis

Re: OT - question of "morals"... and apologies

#11

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Don't open it again....

Jesper, Denmark

The person you refer to has put herself in a category of unethical behavior. You don't need to waste any effort on that, and you cannot really change it.

Any further discussion with her on that subject will just make things worse, not better.

Re: OT - question of "morals"... and apologies

#12

I agree...

John in NM

While the individual has no doubt come up with some rationalizations for her behavior, it is still basically theft.

You might regret being blunt about it, but there is no need for an apology, that will ultimately just re-enforce the rationalization.

Re: OT - question of "morals"... and apologies

#13

Re: OT - question of "morals"... and apologies

TomD

When you called her a thief, what was in your heart. Was it a tactic, and angry insult, a love for precision in language? What she thought she was doing when she "stole" (confused, stupid, sloppy, oblivious, larcenous...) determines whether she is a thief or not. What was in your mind when you called her a thief may have bearing on whether you should be considering a climb down. WWJT

Re: OT - question of "morals"... and apologies

#14

Moses Yoder

Re: Read the Bible

Moses Yoder

When Jesus cleaned out the temple I think He called a bunch of people thieves, and I don't recall Him ever apologizing for it. I can look it up for you if you want me to. I think she owes your church an apology, and the rest of the items she took. Just taking something is different from asking if you can have it or borrow it.

Re: OT - question of "morals"... and apologies

#15

I agree...just drop it

paul in AZ

Re: OT - question of "morals"... and apologies

#16

Re: OT - question of "morals"... and apologies

Yonak

2� : If hard feelings continue between the two of you and if you've got any sort of on-going relationship with her, business, social, or you just have to walk past her every day, you've got to say something to help work it out and let her respond. I don't think you can just let it go and continue to see her regularly.

Re: OT - question of "morals"... and apologies

#18

Re: Diplomacy

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

Dude, you need to run for office!

Re: OT - question of "morals"... and apologies

#19

Re: OT - question of "morals"... and apologies

Hikmet C. Sakman

Hi Jerome,

I know this is late, but can be read anytime, used or not...that would be depend on the reader.

First of all, when and if something is screwed, it is impossible to unscrew. In practicality, you can put your driver in reverse and unscrew the screw but the hole will be made and no matter how well it is repaired it will not be the same as the state/shape that it was before.

Second of all, breaking hearts is so easy. Just like the description above, it is irreversible. So, when one finds some wrong-doing, the intent behind it should be the determining factor than the end result.

In this case, since she has control of the inventory which is easily replacable by a simple visit to a grocery store, no need to create a big fuss without giving the chance for replacement, therefore fixing the problem.

It the missing items were irreplaceable, than that is another story which also reveals that "intent" was not innocent.

That is my take on this.

We are all human, it happens, it is ok as long as it does not keep repeating itself.

Chico