Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Show of hands. Who hates finishing?

Posts

Show of hands. Who hates finishing?

#1

Show of hands.  Who hates finishing?

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

I hate it. So much so, I am close to throwing in the towel and taking up another hobby, or spending all my free time with my other hobby and selling off all my shop stuff. I am that disgusted.

Wait. I need to take a breath and settle down. *sigh* ok.

I have been working on a little end table for months now. I have completed it and started to finish it. For finish I am using thinned Behlens Rock Hard table top finish.

The base turned out ok. I am dealing with the top now.

I wiped on about 8 coats. Sanded between coats to level with 600P paper. The last coast was perfect except for some dust nibs and was way too glossy for my taste. I let it sit for a week before the final rub out and wax.

I started to sand it with the 600 paper to get that consistent dull look, after which I wax it and it usually ends up with the finish and look I like; baby butt smooth with a nice sheen.

When I was sanding, witness marks appeared. I guess I over sanded. Not sure what happened. I tried all kinds of finer compounds to try and hide them. No joy. I got so disgusted I pulled out the sander and sanded everything off to bare wood again. Planed it too.

Started my finish schedule all over again. Last night I started the final rub out. This time, it looks pretty good. Except I see 2 problems.

Looking very closely at the field of the table I can see hair line marks. Must be left over lines from sanding that I didn't see.

The other problem is shiny spots at the very edge of both ends of the table top. I don't know why. I've tried rubbing automotive scratch remover type compounds on these areas and they are still there.

I think shiny spots implies low areas in the finish that didn't get sanded. Right?

In past years this wipe on rub out method has worked for me. It's always a pita though. I really hate this part of ww'ing. FW makes this stuff look so easy...

Any suggestions on how to get rid of these shiny spots? Sand more at the edges? I bet I go through the finish if I sand more. Uhg.

Thanks.

Re: Show of hands. Who hates finishing?

#2

Moses Yoder

Re: Show of hands.  Who hates finishing?

Moses Yoder

I used to hate finishing until I learned a few different simple techniques that work. For one thing, you are being too picky. Instead of using the 600 grit sandpaper, which you probably had on a block, I would use 0000 steel wool in my hand to buff your finish. This would conform to the surface, which if hand planed should definitely be flat enough to look nice and flat when it's done. Steel wool also will not clog up the way sandpaper does, especially the finer grits. After buffing with steel wool use either compressed air or a tack cloth to clean off the finish. Then wax with a cotton cloth and your done. Keep in mind that if you step back 6 feet and it look good it's good to go. All the mintue details that you notice will not be noticed by people who use it. This is not an excuse to do shoddy work, it's just pointing out the fact that nothing is perfect and to try to achieve perfection takes out the fun in it.

Re: Show of hands. Who hates finishing?

#3

Re: Show of hands.  Who hates finishing?

Barry Irby

I hate finishing also. Part of my problem is that I think it should be easy. I think it should represent an afterthought to building the piece. That's stinkin' thinkin'. People who are good at it will tell you it about half the effort that goes into the piece. As a result of my faulty thinking, I am not equipped for finishing. I have no clean area for it. I have no spray equipment. I have no good quality brushes. I also know very little about the physics and chemistry of what is going on. Now that I think about it, I wonder how I expect to get any good results.

My solution is I take my stuff to a friend of mine who is a pro at finishing and get him to do it.

And Moses is right. There is a viewing distance. The finish needs to enhance the piece, protect it, and look good, but not necessarily with a microscope.

Re: Show of hands. Who hates finishing?

#4

Ellis Walentine

Rubbing out

Ellis Walentine

Joe, the reason you saw those witness marks is because of the way you applied your varnish. You say you wiped eight coats of thinned Rock Hard Varnish on your table. When you wipe varnish, you build it v-e-r-y slowly, probably only half a mil at a time. Eight wiped coats are only the equivalent of about two brushed coats, and you have witness marks waiting to happen every half a mil.

I agree with Moses about using 0000 steel wool to cut the gloss. It conforms to the surface of the film, whereas sandpaper on a block (even a soft block) will want to flatten the surface regardless of contours.

This begs the question of wiping varnish. Woodworkers without dust-free finishing environments have flocked to wiping finishes over the past three decades because they go on thin and dry faster with less chance of embedded dust. They also like the close-to-the-wood look of a hand-wiped film. The penalty, as you have discovered, is that it takes a long time to build an equivalent (some would say adequate) film thickness. Pros don't have time to fuss over a finish in this way, so they blow a couple coats of lacquer or conversion varnish and get on with the next project.

Rubbing out, whether to a gloss or to a satin finish, requires more film than you were able to build by wiping. I've applied as many as 15 coats of Waterlox on projects that required a high-build, rubbed finish. You might have avoided the problem by brushing the first couple coats, then lightly white sanding with 220 or 320-grit paper, then wiping a coat or two of thinned product over that, with only a light steel wooling after the final coat is hard. I'd suggest you practice this on a piece of similar wood and see if it works out the way you'd like.

Anyhow, that's my take. Your mileage may vary.

Ellis

Re: Show of hands. Who hates finishing?

#5

buying a sprayer lead to a love of finishing

Bill Tindall

Learning to sand properly led to easily being able to stain well. No stress there any more. Buying spray equipment led to quickly and easily being able to apply top coat materials have superior properties such as durability, leveling and quick drying.

It may be that your problems stem from using a product in a way it was not intended to be used.

Re: Show of hands. Who hates finishing?

#6

finishing

del schisler

Finishing is more that half of the product. I like to finish you need to get a finish that will work for you. Most people make a big job which should be easy. Their are lot's of finish's out their that fit every type you want. I use a HVLP sprayer and spray lacquer sealer first. than sand with 400 grit with my hand not a sanding block. that way you get all the nub's if any. Than 2 coat's of cabnet grade lacquer. And i am done. This work's for me for yrs. now. Now if wou want a mirrow finish more steps are required. Maybe shellac? I know their are lot's more finish's that i could use but why change?? The lacquer i use is M.L.CAMPBELL and their lacquer thinner. This is not the box stuff. I don't like box stuff. I belive the more you pay for stain dye's finish product's and thinner the better the finish will be. Just my 2 cent's

Re: Show of hands. Who hates finishing?

#7

Re: Show of hands.  Who hates finishing?

Jesse Cloud

Rockhard is a tough finish to apply. It needs a thick build to provide the protection that we buy it for. I apply four to six coats with a good quality brush. The first coat should be thinned 50 percent, subsequent coats only 10 per cent or less.

Though its hard to do, especially if you are waiting for a check, it really needs to fully cure before rub out, I let it sit for 2 weeks. Final rubout then is with automotive products (I use Menzerna) or a mixture of mineral oil and thinner. I use abralon products on a random orbit sander to apply.

For products that won't take a lot of abuse, try a few coats of spray can shellac, then rub on a good wax with steel wool. Whole process takes a couple of hours and it looks great.

Re: Show of hands. Who hates finishing?

#8

Re: Show of hands.  Who hates finishing?

Howard Acheson

The first step to a good finish is to sand the surface perfectly flat. Use a straightedge and make pencil squiggle marks on the high spots. Sand these spots and again mark any high spots. When your panel is flat, sand up to 150 to 220 depending on the wood. I don't like ROS sanders for this part as they tend to not keep a surface flat. I use a 1/2 sheet random orbit sander. Always hand sand the final grit with the same grit as you last used in your sander. Mount your paper on a felt or rubber surfaced hard sanding block. Sand in the direction of the grain. This should eliminate any visible sanding marks. But, to be sure, wipe the surface with a rag dampened with mineral spirits or better yet, alcohol. This will preview the color the wood will take when a clear finish is applied and will highlight any glue marks or sanding miscues.

Now you are ready to apply the first coat of finish. Remember that the first coat of any finish will end up causing wood shards to swell and create an un-smooth surface. Let the first coat fully dry and using 320 paper and your hard sanding pad, lightly sand in the direction of the grain. This will remove these raised shards and create a smooth surface for subsequent applications of finish. Carefully apply your clear coats using whatever application technique you are familiar with. I use a brush or I wipe on oil based finishes. I use a brush for waterborne finishes and I use a padding-on technique for shellac.

Depending on the finish you are using, you may or may not have to sand between coats. If you sand, again use 320-400 grit mounted on a sanding block. Never use steel wool or other flexible non-woven abrasive. These abrasives will not keep the surface flat.

Couple of final points. Never finish in the same room as you sand if you can avoid it. Certainly don't finish right after you sand. The process I used to teach was to sand then vacuum up the sanding dust not only on the project but on any surrounding surfaces. Get your materials out and under a sheet. Now get out of the area for a couple of hours. Turn on your air cleaner if you have one. After a couple of hours, change your clothes (dust coming off the finisher is one of the largest culprits), go back into the finishing area being careful not to stir up the dust. Wipe the project surfaces down with a rag lightly dampened with mineral spirits. Carefully apply your final coat. Now get out of the finish room again for 4-6 hours. You should have minimal or no dust on your finished surfaces. Of course, if you plan to rub out the surface, you don't really have to worry about dust as much.

Finishing is a key part of woodworking. It's the area the gets the "oohs" and "aah", not the construction. Pick one method and learn how to use it. I used to teach two methods which would cover almost any finishing need. Don't be jumping around looking for the magic bullet or someone else's favorite method or finish. A good finisher will make any finish work.

Re: Show of hands. Who hates finishing?

#9

Re: buying a sprayer lead to a love of finishing

FredD

"Learning to sand properly led to easily being able to stain well. No stress there any more. Buying spray equipment led to quickly and easily being able to apply top coat materials have superior properties such as durability, leveling and quick drying."

This is certainly true especially if you do large projects or Multiples like a Kitchen Cabinet set.

FredD

Re: Show of hands. Who hates finishing?

#10

that's one reason I took up turning.

John Lucas

I used to build furniture. The wood was incredibly expensive. Sanding and finishing took forever, and then I couldn't sell it around here for the time and expense I had in it and it was too expensive to give away.

With turning I can make something that takes 30 minutes, finished and all or I can spend as much as 20 hours or more. I rarely have much money in what I do, (not counting machinery of course). It's been quite a bit more relaxing although I am getting back into furniture more.

Re: Show of hands. Who hates finishing?

#11

Or you learn to hate a spray gun!

Barry Irby

Re: Show of hands. Who hates finishing?

#12

Howard....its good to have you around

roger lance

i'd like to ask you a finishing question....but don't want to take away from this posting....if you e-mail me, we could go from there

Re: Show of hands. Who hates finishing?

#13

I did once but now I love it

David Yoho

There was a time years ago when I felt the same way about finishing. What changed that? I realized that finishing was a whole other skill-set in itself, beyond working the wood, and that it was the part of any project that would make it or break it.

I started like many - brushing polyurethane. While I learned a lot about making a brushed finish look as good as one sprayed, it wasn't good enough for me. Where I went wrong after that was bouncing around trying this technique or that.

What I did right was find several finishes I liked and the best way for me to apply them. Since then I've stayed with this and it works. Whenever I get ready to begin a new project I already know which finish I plan to use and how it will be applied. The results are predictable and prevent surprises at the most critical part of completing a project.

Re: Show of hands. Who hates finishing?

#14

Re: Show of hands.  Who hates finishing?

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

"For one thing, you are being too picky."

You are probably right about that. A number of years ago I was at Jeff Jewitt's shop (just down the road from me) and he told me I was too anal... :)

I started out with 0000 Liberon steel wool but thought the scratch pattern was too pronounced so I ended with 600p paper.

Thanks.

Re: Show of hands. Who hates finishing?

#15

What is the advantage then?

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

If you have to wipe on 15+ coats, what's the advantage then other than quicker drying and less chance of dust which you would remove sanding anyway.

Is this just a way to fill magazines with articles? Why not then just brush on a few coats and be done with it?

I always try to get a finish that doesn't look like a thick plastic coating. That's why I usually wipe on. By the way, somebody mentioned Rock Hard is hard to apply. This is only the second time I've used this. Normally I don't have so much of a problem. Don't think I'll use this anymore.

Thanks.

Re: Show of hands. Who hates finishing?

#16

Spraying

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

I don't do enough ww'ing to justify the cost (don't know what that would be though) of buying spray equipment. It is tempting though.

Thanks.

Re: Show of hands. Who hates finishing?

#17

Thank you...

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

for taking the time to write this up. Good info.

Thanks.

Re: Show of hands. Who hates finishing?

#18

Re: Rubbing out

Steve Schoene

There is a way to use wipe on varnish that actually lets you have your cake and eat it too. That is to apply the wipe on coats in "sets" applying the next coat just as soon as the previous one is dry to the touch so that the next coat doesn't drag and pull up the lower coat. This usually allows you to apply about three coats in a day. Put on so closely spaced, the coats cross link together.

After about each set of three coats you do need to let them cure. You have no more material than you would have with a brushed coat, so there is no risk of having top coats cure without letting the lower coats cure. After that overnight cure, you do need to sand before applying another set, just as with a brushed on coat. (You couldn't sand between coats within the set, they aren't nearly set up enough.)

You need to accomplish all your finish leveling before you start your final set.

Then after you apply a final set of three, you should wait as long as feasible before beginning the rub out process. If you are aiming for a gloss finish, waiting three weeks or a month is not too much. But, now you do have enough film thickness to complete a normal rubbout process since within a set you will have had enough cross linking to avoid witness lines. You have essentially the equivalent of a full brushed coat to work on.

Re: Show of hands. Who hates finishing?

#19

Re: Howard....its good to have you around

Howard Acheson

I would prefer that you posted your question in a new public thread. That way other who may have the same issue or questions could jump in and all could benefit. Of course, that's providing I have an answer. :\

Re: Show of hands. Who hates finishing?

#20

Ellis Walentine

Re: What is the advantage then?

Ellis Walentine

If you have to wipe on 15+ coats, what's the advantage then other than quicker drying and less chance of dust which you would remove sanding anyway. Is this just a way to fill magazines with articles? Why not then just brush on a few coats and be done with it?


Exactly. When you're planning on rubbing out, you might as well just build the requisite thickness by brushing, as long as you are able to do it evenly. Wiping minimizes the potential for drips and brush marks, but it takes much longer to build.

I always try to get a finish that doesn't look like a thick plastic coating. That's why I usually wipe on.

Thick and plastic are not necessarily synonymous. I've found that polyurethane varnishes tend to look and feel more plastic than Waterlox and spar varnishes. Thickness is a requirement if you want a solid, rubbed out finish. For this, the minimum thickness isn't necessarily the best solution.

Ellis

Re: Show of hands. Who hates finishing?

#21

OK....see above

roger lance

Re: Show of hands. Who hates finishing?

#22

Re: Rubbing out

FredD

Below is a excerpt from Bill Nelson's article on "Finishing with Polyurethanes"

Presumably it would not apply to oil based Varnish.

"Due to environmental regulations water borne formulas are starting to appear. These formulations are not as durable as solvent based formulations but have some good points, quick drying, low smell, and water clean up. The reason they are not as durable is because the cross-linking occurs before the resins are put in the water carrier and when the water evaporates the molecules coalesce to make the film."

FredD