Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

OT-Full View Storm Doors

Posts

OT-Full View Storm Doors

#1

OT-Full View Storm Doors

Jennifer Indy.USA

Hey everyone,

We're wanting to install a full view strorm door on the front of the house. The kind with the retractable screen. We're looking at the Pella, Larson, and Andersen. Does anyone have any expreience with any of these doors for an extended period. It seems most reviews are from people who have just installed them. Not much about wear and tear and the if the retractable screens hold up. Anybody ever have to replace a screen in one? The Larson seems to get the highest reviews and the Andersen get surprisingly the lowest for recent installs.

Thanks for any feedback!

Jen

Re: OT-Full View Storm Doors

#2

Re: OT-Full View Storm Doors

Terry Quiram

I have one on my front door going on two years. It mostly stays open in the winter and shut in the summer. My entrance is covered. We have not had any problems. I don't remember the brand. Bought it at Lowes.

Re: OT-Full View Storm Doors

#3

Re: OT-Full View Storm Doors

Ralph Ambrosio

Jenifer,

I have had the the Pella "Roll Screen" on our side door which is open and uncovered for about 5 years. I initially went to Pella because I needed an unusual size. I am satisfied enough that I will be replacing the front door storm with a Pella in a few years. I went to Central College in Pella, Iowa, many years ago, otherwise, no connection.

Ralph

Re: OT-Full View Storm Doors

#4

Re: OT-Full View Storm Doors

DP

I've had a Larsen door for 10-11 years and am happy with the door although the brass hardware looks tarnished and pretty shabby (the protective coating wore off fairly soon) and I've not had any success in polishing or restoring it. Other than that the door looks and operates as good as it did when it was new. FWIW I just had a Pella patio door installed by a Pella contractor who told me that the quality of the Pella rollscreen products has cheapened significantly recently and he did not recommend them. I have no personal experience with them one way or the other.

Re: OT-Full View Storm Doors

#5

Thanks Guys....

Jennifer Indy.USA

I think we're leaning towards the Larson. Lowes is storing it for us until be decide :)

Jen

Re: OT-Full View Storm Doors

#6

Andersen

mdclor

We had a 3-4 year old Anderson door that developed a problem and the company was zero help. When we built a new house, I didn't even consider Andersen. FWIW.

Re: OT-Full View Storm Doors

#7

Re: OT-Full View Storm Doors

Jim Dillon

Jennifer,

We have had excellent luck with roughly 11 Anderson patio doors and large multi-paned windows installed 16 years ago. No leaks or problems whatsoever. However, I have no experience with their recent products. Back then, if one was willing to wait for a "truck-shipment" every six weeks or so to the local Borg or lumber yard, a discount of about 35-40% off retail was offered which we took advantage of. Things (and quality, perhaps) change with the times, I guess. At the time, Pella seemed overpriced and less attractive, while Peachtree and Marvin appeared to be of lessor quality albeit in a subjective sort of way.

Jim

Re: OT-Full View Storm Doors

#8

Re: OT-Full View Storm Doors

jared

The Pella storm doors are now made by Larson, I know some of them are made in the larson plant in Brookings SD. The hardware on the pella doors is very simlar if not exactly the same as the high end larson doors. I have two of the pella doors with retractable screens. Both doors are in protected areas so are not exposed to the full blast of the weather but so far are holding up real well. I really like the way the screens allow you to open as little or as much as you like to allow fresh air in. Jared

Re: OT-Full View Storm Doors

#9

Re: OT-Full View Storm Doors

Ron Jones

Hi Jennifer,

We have 2 Larson doors with the disappearing screens. One is sheltered and 1 is not. The sheltered door has been there about 5 years and is like new. The unsheltered door has been there 3 years and on the west side, unshaded in the afternoons. It too is still like new. The brass hardware on both is still in great condition. I have one full view without disappearing screens that stays storm door all year that is sheltered and about 12 years old. I plan to follow Larson's directions to recondition the hardware this summer. Bottom line is I would buy them again.

Re: OT-Full View Storm Doors

#10

I'll second the Larson

Mike Farinella

Have one on my other house (rental) on a Northern exposure. 5 years old and still looks pretty good. It was around $300.

Re: OT-Full View Storm Doors

#11

I appreciate all the replys....

Jennifer Indy.USA

You all have been so helpful. I think the Larson wins. When the weather breaks we're installing one. Suppose to snow here tonight.....again.

Jen

Re: OT-Full View Storm Doors

#12

On a different note....

Barry Irby

What kind of door do you have and what direction does it face and does it have a roof over it. What I am thinking about is that most metal doors do not recommend a glass storm door over them. If the sun gets onto a glass door over a metal door, the space in between will get so hot it may melt the weatherstripping and any plastic parts or decorative panels on the door. One more thing to double check.

Re: OT-Full View Storm Doors

#13

Re: On a different note....

Jim Dillon

Barry,

I had forgotten this. I actually had that happen on a metal storm door that I purchased from the local Borg. It had a retractable window/screen that slid up and down into the lower half of the door. Sounded like a good idea and the door appeared to be well-made (don't remember the brand). Well, after the winter, come time to slide the screen up and the window down, the window wouldn't budge! Had to take the entire door off the hinges, and apart. Never saw so many screws in my life! Anyway, the plastic weather gasket that surrounded the window had sealed itself right to the window frame. I unsealed it with difficulty and some tearing, but the same thing happened every season. I finally got rid of it which was a shame because it was expensive and well-made.

Jim

Re: OT-Full View Storm Doors

#14

You were "lucky"....

Barry Irby

it ruined the storm door and not the door to the house.

If your house door has glass in it or some of those decorative plastic panels, they can be ruined. I see it frequently on my inspections.