Empiricism
Ellis Walentine
Something that nobody has addressed here yet is the fact that a circular saw blade at rest isn't flat, so any angle measurements at all are suspect. The blade is tensioned so that it runs flat and true at some pre-determined RPM range, as a result of the centrifugal force at that speed. Granted, it's a tiny amount, but this is why they use machined reference plates and not saw blades to calibrate tablesaw miter and 90� stops.
Even reference plates don't take all the variables into account. The blade insert might be a little bit high or low, the table could be slightly less than perfectly flat, there could be dust or crud under the workpiece, the workpiece could be of variable dimension, the saw could be in need of supertuning (only affects bevel cuts), or you might just be unlucky or careless that day. Woodworking, as someone mentioned, doesn't rely on machine tolerances. Heck, if the humidity is off in the shop, the angle could change before you glue the pieces together.
The title of this post reflects my longstanding preference of determining critical machine settings by the end result and not by the means. In other words, make samples with a particular setting and see how they fit. If you make them a little bit larger than necessary, you can tune them for a precise fit with a couple passes of your hand planes. Or, tweak the blade angle just a hair to get the angle closer to the target.
This doesn't mean that these gadgets are inherently bad at all. In fact, they're very handy for closely approximating critical angle settings, and they will often yield acceptable results on the first try. That's a huge improvement over the grossly inaccurate bevel scales on your tablesaw or mitersaw or radial-arm saw, and I can see how it would pay for itself in saved time.
Ellis




