Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Beall tilt box

Posts

Re: Beall tilt box

#26

Ellis Walentine

Empiricism

Ellis Walentine

Something that nobody has addressed here yet is the fact that a circular saw blade at rest isn't flat, so any angle measurements at all are suspect. The blade is tensioned so that it runs flat and true at some pre-determined RPM range, as a result of the centrifugal force at that speed. Granted, it's a tiny amount, but this is why they use machined reference plates and not saw blades to calibrate tablesaw miter and 90� stops.

Even reference plates don't take all the variables into account. The blade insert might be a little bit high or low, the table could be slightly less than perfectly flat, there could be dust or crud under the workpiece, the workpiece could be of variable dimension, the saw could be in need of supertuning (only affects bevel cuts), or you might just be unlucky or careless that day. Woodworking, as someone mentioned, doesn't rely on machine tolerances. Heck, if the humidity is off in the shop, the angle could change before you glue the pieces together.

The title of this post reflects my longstanding preference of determining critical machine settings by the end result and not by the means. In other words, make samples with a particular setting and see how they fit. If you make them a little bit larger than necessary, you can tune them for a precise fit with a couple passes of your hand planes. Or, tweak the blade angle just a hair to get the angle closer to the target.

This doesn't mean that these gadgets are inherently bad at all. In fact, they're very handy for closely approximating critical angle settings, and they will often yield acceptable results on the first try. That's a huge improvement over the grossly inaccurate bevel scales on your tablesaw or mitersaw or radial-arm saw, and I can see how it would pay for itself in saved time.

Ellis

Re: Beall tilt box

#27

Re: Empiricism

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

You forgot about how much torque is put on the arbor nut, how wide the pressure washers are, and how clean the blade's teeth are. :D

I'm reminded of a classic thread on Badger Pond having to do with tuning table saws to the tolerance of a gnat's eyelash.

Re: Beall tilt box

#28

Re: Empiricism *LINK*

Bob Lang

If you're so inclined, you can take this a step further, as seen in the tool review linked below. When you get to that level of trying to measure something, the furnace kicking on or a truck driving by can make the readouts on the less expensive angle measuring devices jump back and forth.

The Bridge City Angle Master Pro is an amazing piece of work, and that kind of work comes at a price. I used it to set the fence on our sliding table square to the fence, and for the first time ever I felt sure that I had it right.

but you still need to make test cuts and see how the pieces fit.

Bob Lang


PopWood Blog entry on angles to the nth degree

Re: Beall tilt box

#29

ironic

Tony - Memphis

i ust got an email from Lee Valley offering the Tilt Box II. Lee Valley reports the accuracy at 0.2�,b ut the Beal web site claims 0.1� accuracy fo rthe Tilt Box. Hmmm... I have one and like it. But I have to agree with Ellis. There are lots of variables. For example, my old Delta Contractor's saw had a nice dip in it right next to the blade. I could measure the angle on either side and get a different value! That made me scratch my head a while. I use the Tilt Box to set lots of things, including my PM200, but I always check. Lucky for me, I am getting good results with this tool and method. I bought one of those flat plates (Master something?) and it is not really that flat. It is handy since it gives a broader surface to check the miter gauge against, but it will make you scratch too since it isn't "perfectly" flat. I try and get things as close as I can get them with the tools (I have a TS Aligner Jr too - very nice tool), but I still check. And I still scratch my head when things don't go as they should - "This SHOULD be square &^%&&%&%&^^&^$$#@!@@" Can be frustrating at times. I quit trying to make joinery on the TS a long time ago. I do get lazy or in a hurry and take things off the saw, but it is really easier to use hand tools to bring home the fit rather than fuss with the TS (or other power tools). I will say though that the PM2000 is a night and day difference from the old Contractor's saw. It tends to stay put!

Tony

Re: Beall tilt box

#30

Re: Empiricism

FredD

I have mentioned reference plates here before and it's like you say , the really only good and quick way to get a accurate reading and it's the way I always use to check for things like runout and parallelism to the miter slot and fence.

That being said if your Wixey or Beall tilt box is calibrated each time , it will give a degree of accuracy suitable for any woodworking operation, far closer then many can cut a miter joint for instance.

Sneaking up on a close fit is a time honored way of getting one and also the slowest way to do it.

FredD

Re: Beall tilt box

#31

Re: Caveat

del schisler

no need to run it thro the cal. each time you use it. I have had mine sence they first came out. I ran it thro the cal. and it still work's. I use mine all the time to check blade setting and drill bit to table and band saw blade to table . Every thing goes togother no gap's ect. so it must be close enough for gov. work.

Re: Beall tilt box

#32

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Beall tilt box - Accuracy

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

No matter what it reads, the advertised accuracy is �0.2�, so you still shouldn't expect 'dead on' results.

Re: Beall tilt box

#33

digital caliper

Phil Joines

I find the calipers handy for checking thinks that are already in fractional sizes IE, drill bits, metal rod, etc. I don't use it to cut things to that size, as you say too much slop for that.

Re: Beall tilt box

#34

Re: digital caliper

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Mine reads in fractions, but also in .01" and .01mm. I use it a lot for making stock of uniform thickness.

Re: Beall tilt box

#35

Dial Calipers

Jon

I've always liked/used dial calipers. Vernier calipers took too long to read.

Re: Beall tilt box

#36

The problem with Dial Calipers

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

I used to have a set of dial calipers in my shop that I used for measuring thickness of boards when planing. They died after about 2 years due to sawdust getting into the rack and pinion gearing that does the measuring. I now have a digital set that is more than 8 years old and still going strong since there is no gearing to get contaminated with sawdust.

Lee