Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Rocklers "dust collector"

Posts

Rocklers "dust collector"

#1

Rocklers "dust collector"

Thomas Norton

I see Rockler has come out with their version of the Dust Deputy.

Any thoughts?

Re: Rocklers "dust collector"

#2

Re: Rocklers "dust collector"

David Hay Denver

Could you provide a link? I wasn't having any luck finding it on their website. All I was able to find was the Oneida Dust Deputy.

David

Re: Rocklers "dust collector"

#3

Re: Rocklers "dust collector"

Larry in NW OHIO

Do you mean that barrel? Larry

Re: Rocklers "dust collector"

#4

Re: Build a Thien

Chuck Lenz

Re: Rocklers "dust collector"

#5

Re: Rocklers "dust collector" *LINK*

Galen Vetterick

I don't see how it could create much of a vortex with the interior nozzles pointing in the opposite directions and only a small center depression in the lid. Looks like it would drop out heavier chips just by the fact of the reduced air velocity with the large volumn bucket.

Unit is shown on the front of the March Rockler catalog I just got as well.

I have the Dust Deputy and it works fairly well and does catch some of the finer dust as well. Works better on one of my vacs that is noisier and probably high air flow than the other. I use a sand bag in the lower bucket to keep it upright but still need a beter way of keeping strain off the unit by the hoses.


http://www.rockler.com/product.cfm?page=30068

Re: Rocklers "dust collector"

#6

Re: Rocklers "dust collector"

Dave Paine

I concur this appears to be a bad design.


The inlet stream and outlet streams are in opposite directions. This will cause a lot of inefficient turbulence.

Units like the Dust Deputy have the outlet in the middle, which makes sense since the flow is lowest in the middle, so it helps to settle more of the particles.

This will also likely consume a lot of pressure drop.

Re: Rocklers "dust collector"

#7

Re: Rocklers "dust collector"

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

Bad design, yes, but direction of inlet vs outlet is not really wrong, when you think about it.

Granted, turbulence will be bad and separation efficiency poor at best, compared to a cyclone, but you want the inlet flow to avoid the outlet- pass over, around- be aimed anywhere but directly at the outlet to give the dust as much chance to fall out of the airstream and to the bottom of the drum. Their solution is to just turn the outlet around- a slight improvement, but overall it was designed by someone who doesn't really have a clue about centrifugal separators. A center-mounted outlet with an opening facing downward like a cyclone would be better.

This design, somewhat like a cyclone, requires the air change direction before exits. In a cyclone, when the flow decelerates enough and reaches a/the reversal point in the cone it changes direction towards the center of the cyclone and the outlet tube - initially perpendicular to the rotation and angled up from the downward spiral.