Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Bandsaw purchase dilemma?

Posts

Bandsaw purchase dilemma?

#1

Bandsaw purchase dilemma?

Stephen Kirk

So, I find myself in a quandary. As I purchase new tools for the shop I always aim to go bigger than I currently need, mainly so I don't have another upgrade in the near future. Right now I'm on the hunt for a bandsaw. I had always thought of going with a good 18" model and a powerful motor. But now I have a job coming up that I could really use a bandsaw for doing a lot of curve work.

So, now I'm wondering if I shouldn't look at a nice PM 14" model with a riser block. That will easily handle my curve tasks and let me resaw up to 12". Then, when I'm in a bigger shop I can add a big bandsaw and leave it dedicated to resaw tasks while I keep the smaller one for curve jobs.

So, does that actually sound like a good plan?

Re: Bandsaw purchase dilemma?

#2

Re: Bandsaw purchase dilemma?

McKay

I am a retired woodshop instructor and have had access to a number of bandsaws. I personally own a pm 14". It is a good saw. I prefer the Laguna over any other saw. At school I had a 36" yates/american that was a fantastic saw. I had a 20" ricon that was...shall we say... less than impressive. The walker/turner was in poor shape when I got to the school 30 years ago and so I would not be able to evaluate it properly. The 20" Delta was an ok saw. As I stated above, the Laguna was the most powerful, least likely to need maintenance. I liked the ceramic guides. The thing that I did not like was the need for a number of allen wrenches to change the blade when a simple twist knob would have done the same operation. Like most bandsaws, the throat plate could be better. It is adjustable, but the center of the plate often sags. The pm is round like many others and has no adjustment at all to make it flush to the metal table.

Re: Bandsaw purchase dilemma?

#3

Re: Bandsaw purchase dilemma?

paul in AZ

Far be it from me to tell you what you should buy but i do have some comments.

For the curves you mention a narrower blade -depending on how tight the curves are- will work on any saw you could get.

For resawing, the prime considerations to me are a really good [sharp] blade with a reasonable amount of H.P. My Jet 18" with 1.5 HP has not struggled with anything I've thrown at it, but thats just me. But power is like closet space- even if you don't need it, more feels nicer.

I would ask about wanting to resaw 12" or larger lumber. That was a factor for me in getting the 18" vs. a 14" but it proved to be an unfounded concern. Where can you get nice lumber that width and how likely are you to ever resaw that width?

I like to get a fresh clean face between slices. Will you get a 12" or bigger jointer to surface the face of big boards between slices if you do it that way?

In retrospect I could have done everything I need to do with a 14" saw but am perfectly happy and have no regrets with the 18'.

check your local Craigslist. Something unexpected may sing to you and also save you some bucks.

Re: Bandsaw purchase dilemma?

#4

yes

Bill Tindall

In the mean time you can be on the lookout for an old 20"; they are common and cheap. I got one for $500. You will love its big table. It has a 1957 huge 1 HP motor and I have never slowed it resawing.

Re: Bandsaw purchase dilemma?

#5

Re: Bandsaw purchase dilemma?

Jesse Cloud

A second bandsaw is a great thing. Tune one for resaw, another for curves. I also would like a second one so I can keep a sharp new blade in one for resaw and a not so great blade in another for plywood, mdf, etc.

Re: Bandsaw purchase dilemma?

#6

Laguna mid-range?

John M in Mid Mich

Several years ago I went through the same dilemma: needed the goldilocks bandsaw- not too big, not too small, plenty of power, etc. Opted for the Laguna LT16. 3hp Baldor motor. Has been great, though I do a lot more resawing than curves. For curves I put on a 1/4" blade and it is fantastic, but for resawing 8-12" oak, ash, and cherry, I love the carbide tipped 1" blades. I have only limited experience with other bandsaws (grizzly 15, delta 14) and this is a clear step up from those. The Laguna LT14 gets high praise in almost every review I've ever read, and isn't a bad value. Good luck.

Re: Bandsaw purchase dilemma?

#7

Re: Laguna mid-range?

JimG

I have the PM. It's a very good saw. I don't have a table saw so I use it alot. But it's not a GREAT saw. If I had to do it over for that much money, I would go for a better/beefier saw. One reason I got it was because I don't have 220 in the garage. Now I would pay to get 220 and get a beefier saw. FWIW.

JimG

Re: Bandsaw purchase dilemma?

#8

Re: Bandsaw purchase dilemma?

Thomas S Stockton

I see some real nice bandsaws on craigslist for not a whole lot more than the PM new. I think the biggest drawback of the 14" saws of that style is that adding a riser and all the bells and whistles is really stretching the design tolerances of the machine and by moving up to a laguna or minimax style machine you are getting a much beefier design that is not nearly as stressed.

I used to resaw on a 14" saw without a riser and it was pretty stressful, I then got a 18" saw and it was so much easier and the results were much more consistent.

I would get a big saw first and then when the time is right buy a 14" if you still feel you need it because the bigger saw will do everything you want it to do.

Tom

Re: Bandsaw purchase dilemma?

#9

Re: Bandsaw purchase dilemma?

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

I'm not sure I follow your thinking. I have used some really nice 34" or larger bandsaws that were capable of running a narrow blade and cutting intricate curves.

If you are refering to a resawing need as having a saw with a blade larger than 1" and a stock feeder then I would say you need two bandsaws and the smaller should come first.

I have a vintage Craftsman/Parks18" with a 12" resaw capacity. I keep a 1/2" woodslicer blade mounted on it and find it very capable of resawing as well as holding a line on curves. I mill all my own wood with a chainsaw mill so I tend to resaw every thing I use. Most of my work also incorperates complex curves. I like the larger saws for their larger tables and I would have a larger saw if I had the room.

Robin

Re: Bandsaw purchase dilemma?

#10

Re: Bandsaw purchase dilemma?

Stephen Kirk

My jointer is only 8", so I knew I wouldn't resaw much bigger than that. While I do some resawing now (on the TS) I don't do a lot. I will likely do more curve cutting work.

My thoughts recently were around if I really needed the size and power of an 18" model right now. I'm kinda thinking, no.

Re: Bandsaw purchase dilemma?

#11

Re: yes

Stephen Kirk

You make me envious. I'd have trouble fitting a saw like that in my garage workshop! I agree though, maybe start with a smaller, but still very capable saw and then give it a big brother later.

Re: Bandsaw purchase dilemma?

#12

Re: Laguna mid-range?

Stephen Kirk

The Lagunas are nice, but they are a bit pricey. I don't know if that kind of saw is in my budget.

Re: Bandsaw purchase dilemma?

#13

Re: Bandsaw purchase dilemma?

Stephen Kirk

I've been looking at these new models which allow up to 12" resaw with no riser block. Seems like they removed some of that hassle. At the moment, I'm just not sure, though.

Re: Bandsaw purchase dilemma?

#14

Re: Bandsaw purchase dilemma?

Stephen Kirk

I was more worried about constant swapping of blades. If it's not a quick and easy process, changing setups gets to be a pain.

Re: Bandsaw purchase dilemma?

#15

Re: Bandsaw purchase dilemma?

paul in AZ

Swapping blades is not inherently difficult and can be sometimes quick but sometimes fiddly and time consuming.

I recently put on a 3/4" blade to slice a mesquite log and was not getting the results i wanted. In one of those 'what the hell' moments i put on a new, sharp 3/8" timberwolf and got beautiful veneer slices both from the mesquite and some 6 inch oak I used as a test piece. It just took a little longer than it would with a more aggressive blade.

The point is you don't always need a great big blade in a monster machine.

Re: Bandsaw purchase dilemma?

#16

Re: yes

Bill Tindall

the footprint on an old 20" Delta is 32 x21", not excessive by my thinking. Tittering lumber on the tiny tables of modern saws is hardly convenient for resawing.

Re: Bandsaw purchase dilemma?

#17

Re: yes

Stephen Kirk

Fortunately my normal need is resawing smaller pieces for veneers or inlays. I also do some slightly thicker resawing, say to get two half inch boards out of one 1 1/4" board. I wouldn't expect to heft many logs onto it. Then the bulk of the work will probably be curves, feet, other profiles, etc.