We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
I think it ought to resist the frat boys. It is 1" cherry with pinned bread board ends. The legs are 1.75" square. The aprons are 1" x 2". The side stretchers are 5/4" and the center stretcher consists of three 1" x 2" pieces.
... if the table is to resist extreme use, are the apron joints and the breadboard tenon details. The rack resistance of the table depends on the shoulders and the tenons of the apron rails. Since the shoulders are short (2"), a lot depends on the strength and penetration of the tenons themselves. Cherry is hard enough to resist compression at the shoulder pretty well. As long as the tenons can't pull out or break, you should be fine.
The breadboard concern only has to do with some big galoot sitting or standing on that wide breadboard end. You'd want strong, deep tenons to offset that likelihood.
Of course, welded I-beams would be a better solution.
Nice job, by the way. I know those boys will appreciate your workmanship.
If this table was in my fraternity house back in 1988 it would need to withstand a lot of beer-pong, quarters, 3-6-9 (drinking dice game), and of course (judging from the size in your picture) 3-4 people dancing on it. And we were a service fraternity, can't image what you can expect from a social fraternity. Go with a hard waterproof finish and what happens happens
It looks like it will hold up to the rigors that a Frat house can deliver. I'm sure you've thought about a finish that repels alcohol. It's a great looking table.
That's a good looking table and I would be proud to have it in my home, but my house is not a Frat House.
YOU know about the details of the M&T joints. If they are massive, perhaps they will be fine. (I would consider some reinforcement/angle braces between the legs and rails.)
Think of a diving board. Give some thought to a big ol' frat boy standing on that breadboard on tippy (tipsy) toes getting ready to do a back flip into the carpet. I don't know how deep the tendons are, but I would consider trimming the width of the bread board down until the tenons nearly penetrate them.
Don't use shellac for a finish. It's soluble in alcohol, like some of the frat members.
This has been an interesting story to watch. Thanks for posting. And with considerable reluctance I am going to offer a suggestion.
There has been a lot of angst over the survivability of this table. What got built and finished is a handsome table that would look at home in many living rooms, and look well there for years to come. Indeed, that is where I would be putting it.
Then I would make a second table out of a material that is shall we say, "less refined" than cherry, and that would be oak. Reduce the vulnerable bread board ends which may not survive sitting on. Stain it fairly dark, finish with conversion varnish and the product will have the optimum of survivability and remain looking good even with some dings and scratches, which cherry will not.
How about you ship me that table and I will make something similar out of, say, 2x6 studs from Home Depot and I will ship that to your fraternity house? That is a great looking table but don't count on the current membership having a ton of appreciation for what goes into creating such a piece of furniture, or preserving its current condition. That's just how young males are. All of the furniture in my old house in college looked like it came from Salvation Army.
I second the motion about building one from red oak. I'm hoping you don't get a call in 6 months asking for some repairs. Nice job.
Just for giggles I'll jump into this one. Agree with Bill that this one is much too nice for a frat house; and that oak would have been my preference. Unless maybe this is an elegant, genteel frat that won't abuse good furniture.
But... rather than staining the oak I'd be inclined to emulate some very old tables I've seen in pubs. White oak, with no stain or finish -at least any remaining finish. These have survived generations of revelry and abuse and will probably live for many generations to come.
It was made out of #2 common cherry. The cost to me was a 320 mile round trip (or 32 gallons of gas so - $100 or so) and time. I've still got a LOT of the cherry.
I viewed this as a "design" opportunity. I got to play with some design elements that I wanted to try out. I also have a place where it can go. Now I can refine the design and build one for my living room.
I draw up a lot of things on paper. When I design or modify a spindle for turning, I typically make up 3-4 before I settle on a design. If they work - I keep them. If they don't work, they go in the burn pile (or get raided by a friend who likes turned objects). I have more of an "emotional" attachment to the furniture I build. I can't burn that. I have donated tables and furniture that was "experimental" to one of the local charities thrift stores.