Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

OT Cancel phone Landline?

Posts

OT Cancel phone Landline?

#1

OT Cancel phone Landline?

John M in Mid Mich

Thinking it may be time to cancel the highly under-utilized telephone landline. Not sure about relying on only the cable and the cell phones, however. Anybody doing this and willing to give some advice? What is your system? Vonage? Skype? Google Voice? Problems, issues, limitations, regrets?

Thanks.

Re: OT Cancel phone Landline?

#2

Moses Yoder

Re: OT Cancel phone Landline?

Moses Yoder

We use only cell phones, Verizon, and have been very happy not wasting the $35 per month on a landline. I am not quite sure why you need a phone besides a cell phone; if you get one you can get one for each member of the family $10 per month per phone.

Re: OT Cancel phone Landline?

#3

Re: OT Cancel phone Landline?

Nat Robison

I have Vonage here in the Detroit area with no complaints. Call quality has improved quite a bit since we first got it. Runs $25/mo. and we've never exceeded our minutes. Like most people, this is in addition to 2 cell phones so it's only used a few times a day but is much better than the $60-$80/mo. we were paying for our landline when we dropped it several years ago.

We had to replace our router at a cost of about $80 but other than that, I'm a big proponent. It has all the features you expect/want and automatically routes calls to a number of your choosing in the event of a power outage.

Re: OT Cancel phone Landline?

#4

Re: OT Cancel phone Landline?

Joe Mohnike

Keep the land line! In case of an emergency and a 911 call the operator can pinpoint your location (address), no can do with a cell. Also much longer time connecting a 911 call to the correct local department than with a land line.

Just my 2 cents worth.

Joe M.

Re: OT Cancel phone Landline?

#5

Re: OT Cancel phone Landline?

Larry in NW OHIO

Moses What do you get from Verison for $10 a month per phone. The cheapest they say I can get Is $35 per, maybe a couple $ cheaper with something else. Thank you Larry

Re: OT Cancel phone Landline?

#6

Re: OT Cancel phone Landline?

John M in Mid Mich

Vonage's web site lists a $9.99 monthly basic package that would seem to be sufficient for us, since we make very few calls. Why did you need a new router?

Re: OT Cancel phone Landline?

#7

Re: OT Cancel phone Landline?

John M in Mid Mich

Mostly I guess I'm thinking of all the family and friends who know our landline number. Do also think about the times when the power is out and all we have is the phone. Not sure how much weight to give the 911 issue.

Re: OT Cancel phone Landline?

#8

Re: OT Cancel phone Landline?

Bruce, a MN Galoot

My wife and I both have and carry cell phones. We also have a land line, and we keep it for two reasons: the first is the 911 business, primarily for health problems. The second is that I don't want anyone other than friends and family calling me on my cell phone, so all our business calls are conducted on the land line. Can you imagine how miserable life would be if fund raisers or telemarketers ever got your cell #?

OTOH, neither of our kids have land lines. They seem to do just fine, and maybe it's just a generational thing.

Re: OT Cancel phone Landline?

#9

Re: OT Cancel phone Landline?

John M in Mid Mich

On our ATT, $10 gets you an _additional_ line on the family plan for which you are paying quite a bit more to start with, and it is only the basic added line with shared minutes, no messaging, no data.

Re: OT Cancel phone Landline?

#10

Re: OT Cancel phone Landline?

David Dircksen

My wife and I dropped our land line about 6 years ago. She kept the land line # for her cell. I got magic jack a couple years ago and it works good.

Re: OT Cancel phone Landline?

#11

Moses Yoder

Re: the 911 issue

Moses Yoder

The 911 issue is a non issue here in Michigan and Indiana I guess. I had an accident once and dialed 911 to get a policeman and they answered the call, had me hang on the line to get GPS position, and the police were there in less than 5 minutes. From all the statements against using cell phones for 911 I guess it doesn't work in some states but I have to wonder.

Re: OT Cancel phone Landline?

#12

reply

Nat Robison

The first router we had just crapped out......probably along the lines of all electronics being somewhat obsolete after 5 years. It was constantly needing to be re-booted so we upgraded to a new router.

Check the website regarding 911 service. It's my take that all the VOIP providers need to provide it, although it's not exactly the same as traditional 911 service. Vonage has a phone you can buy that they claim you can plug into any computer in the world and get calls on it for your number. If you take your phone 2 states away and call 911, how does it know where you are? I'm not sure but you may want to look into it further.

Re: OT Cancel phone Landline?

#13

that depend on the cell plan you have

Bruce, a MN Galoot

my phone is fairly basic (although it takes pics, but not very good ones). GPS is an option and an additional expense.

Re: OT Cancel phone Landline?

#14

Moses Yoder

Re: Additional phones

Moses Yoder

We have Verizon phones. My wife has a touch screen phone with data access on the web, which works pretty good. She gets email and can even access youtube videos. She can order stuff from Amazon and keep our Netflix list updated. I, on the other hand, just use a simple phone. I can take pictures with my phone but am not sure why I would want to. I own several cameras. My daughters both have phones. I think my wife's phone costs us about $80 or $90 per month for 900 minutes and the 3 additional phones I think are about $10 per month. Right now we are paying a cell phone bill and don't pay cable tv, internet, or any thing else for entertainment other than our $19 per month Netflix. I think that's pretty good. The Library has 9 computers with DSL internet we can use for free. If you really want cheap phone service, use a trac phone.

Re: OT Cancel phone Landline?

#15

Yes, depends on the state

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Here in California, cell phone 911 is handled by understaffed Highway Patrol (state police) dispatch centers. Hold time can exceed five minutes. If I were considering getting rid of my landline, I'd research current and planned 911 response time.

I've had to call the police once or twice from my cell phone; I call my small town's general line, and they patch me through right away to the appropriate dispatcher. Kind of a silly solution, but it winds up working for me.

Re: OT Cancel phone Landline?

#16

Re: OT Cancel phone Landline?

Yonak

The only reasons I keep my land line are for fax services and for the few times when my internet service went out and I resorted to using dial-up service.

Regarding mobile 911 service, I heard recently that, by law, 911 service must work on all cell phones regardless of whether there is an active account attached to the phone or not (maybe this is only true in Georgia). Has anyone else heard this ?

Re: OT Cancel phone Landline?

#17

Re: that depend on the cell plan you have

Dan Donaldson

Also depending on how old your phone is. Whether you subscribe or not, most newer cell phones have a GPS module in them that could be activated as long as the phone is on.

Re: OT Cancel phone Landline?

#18

true, but...

Dan Donaldson

It is true that you must be able to dial 911 regardless of service, but that still can leave the issue of getting the location correct and being connected to the proper dispatch center.

Re: OT Cancel phone Landline?

#19

Re: OT Cancel phone Landline?

FredD

I agree, where we live in rural Kansas , in the summer the power goes out frequently but the landline phone still works and in addition to that our DSL and my phone are on the same line.

I can only imagine what some of our friends with teenagers who all have cell phones have to pony up every month for a service that drops calls when you least expect it .

I have a friend in Erie, Kansas who has to go outside to find a spot he can receive in.

The best cross country phone I ever used is the Satellite phone OnStar has in my Pickup.

A friend and I went out to Washington to see my Sister-in-law and when we got into that deep Canyon going into Washington, his Cell phone was dead, Onstar was clear as a bell.

Lastly ,I don't like the idea that a Cell phone account charges you for calls received , as well as the person making the call to you.

FredD

Re: OT Cancel phone Landline?

#20

Re: true, but...911Cell versus IP/Internet

David C. Lykins - Dallas GA

YES, you MUST be able to dial 911 and as someone mentioned earlier, depending on your cell service provider and whether or not your cell has GPS, though ALL the smart phones do and I believe most of the newer NON smart phones do also have GPS. Keep in mind that GPS is Tranmitted and Received via Satelite thus why OnStar would work in almost ALL locations, however, general cell phones transmit and recieve to CELL Towers of which are just geographically placed for best transmission and reception.

As far as the IP/VOIP phones that you can take ANYWHERE, since they ARE NOT dictated via satelite tramission and reception and are essentially transmitting and recieving over the Internet, 911 service would NOT know where you are. In short, your IP phone has a MAC Address (Media Access Control address) specific to that phone, and that MAC address is electronically tied to an IP address of which your service provider marries to the MAC address of the phone. So as long as you plug into the Internet somewhere the network doesn't care/know where the IP Phone is physically.

Gee, all this knowledge in telecom and I'm still unemployed....LOL....:^)

Re: OT Cancel phone Landline?

#21

Lee Grindinger

We haven't had a land line in nearly 3 years

Lee Grindinger

Ruthie has ATT, I have a Tracfone and we have had no issues come up in which we wished we had a land line. Ruthie's IPhone will send FAXs scanned with the phone.

Re: OT Cancel phone Landline?

#22

Re: OT Cancel phone Landline?

John M in Mid Mich

So how about this: cancel the landline, transfer the number to an additional ($10/mo) cell line, and have the home phone simply be a cell phone line? Seems to me I've seen lots of handsets that look and feel like the landline sets, but can connect through the cell connection. Then the "house" would have a number, in addition to each of us with our personal cells. Hmmm...

Re: OT Cancel phone Landline?

#23

Been mobile for 7 yrs...and...

Tom Dunlap

...one phone number but 8 zipcodes. It's much easier to change zipcodes than phone numbers.

I can't see any reason to ever have a landline again.

About two years ago I bought an iPhone so the cost is sorta high but the value is sure there!

Re: OT Cancel phone Landline?

#24

Re: Been mobile for 7 yrs...and...

John M in Mid Mich

Giving up on the idea of the landline makes all the _logical_ sense in the world, but somehow I can't quite get there -yet-. We, too, are happy to have iPhones. Just feeling burned every month as I pay that $30 landline fee. I started this thinking that some additional technological fix relating to my cable modem would be the answer, but lots of comments may steer me otherwise. Maybe if we simply went cold turkey on the landline we'd get over it pretty quickly. That is why I posted this: trying to find out what has worked for others.

Re: OT Cancel phone Landline?

#25

Jesper, Denmark

Re: that depend on the cell plan you have

Jesper, Denmark

The emergency services do not locate your cell phone by it's GPS, but by the location of the cell tower it connects to. So even the most basic cell phone can be located to the proximity to the tower it communicates with.