Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Shuffled board problems (Long)

Posts

Shuffled board problems (Long)

#1

Shuffled board problems (Long)

Bill Lordan, Auburn NH

As I fully expected, this shuffleboard refinishing project is turning into a real PITA. A week ago, we put on two coats of wb polyacrylic finish and as soon as the coat looked dry everyone wanted to give it a try. I knew this was not a good idea but went along with it. We put on a coat of paste wax and barely buffed it out. The puck was going too slow so we slathered silicone all over the table - still to slow. In order to fix this I figured we could remove the wax and silicone and repair the finish where needed. Two guys wiped the table down with denatured alcohol during the week and said they got all the wax and silicone off. I came down to sand and rewax Friday - I live 54 miles away from the club. I wet sanded the finish from 400 to 1000 grit - not skipping any grits in between. I applied a paste wax buffed it out and left figuring this was about all I could do, They tell me the table is still way to slow and they can get a streak with their fingers on the wax -still silicone remaining?. In addition, we did have a local sign maker do a couple of vinyl club decals which we did not fully imbed in the finish because they wanted to use the table on super bowl Sunday. I told them this was not the way to proceed but they didn't care. Anyway, they have decided that the next fix is they need a liquid past wax and to put another coat of poly on to bury the decals. My question is what can I use to remove the wax and silicone and should I use something other than a paste wax for the top? Any suggestion to speed up the top would be appreciated. My temptation is to walk away and leave this to the "know it alls" but I volunteered for the task and am determined to see it through to the end.

Re: Shuffled board problems (Long)

#2

Clint Searl

You can't win; give it up

Clint Searl

Re: Shuffled board problems (Long)

#3

I think you already know the answer

Bill Tindall

What an astonishing tale! These don't seem like very desirable people to hang out with. Actually they sound like managers......

Re: Shuffled board problems (Long)

#4

Re: I think you already know the answer

Bill Lordan, Auburn NH

In all fairness, this is more my fault than anyone elses. These guys don't know what is going on and all I had to do is put my foot down and no one would have questioned my decision. I guess this is why my response this morning sounded to whinny (sp), I was a lot more upset with myself than any one else. Once again, I'm in this to the bitter end, and I want to do the best job I can. I believe I can use naptha to remove any trace of silicone and denatured alcohol to remove the wax. Does this make sense to anyone.

Thanks for your responses and I accepted the no win scenario the minute I volunteered.

Re: Shuffled board problems (Long)

#5

a worrisome possibility........

Bill Tindall

I have had grim experiences removing silicone.

For what it is worth......I refinished a set of kitchen cabinets some years ago that had been waxed with silicone containing wax. Sanded to bare wood, re-stained and then sprayed with lacquer. Still got occasional fish eyes. Had to add "fish eye" additive to lacquer to get a good finish.

The fact that there were noticeable differences in friction before and after refinishing I would fear that the finish needs to be a very hard finish for this application. There are huge differences in finish hardness among the possibilities. I used to work for a company that made varnish and they had more than a hundred formulations that varied in hardness and other attributes.

I know nothing about water based finishes other than I never saw one that I considered hard. They may be available but I don't know a product to recommend. You might try calling Target Finishes tech service.

Re: Shuffled board problems (Long)

#6

Ellis Walentine

A few questions and some possible answers

Ellis Walentine

As you suspected, the key is to be methodical and not let anyone rush the process. When it's ready, that's the time to try it out. Actually, waterborne finishes, especially catalyzed waterborne floor finishes, are among the most abrasion resistant finishes out there, and they dry very hard. I don't know where your polyacrylic finish fits into the hardness range. Regardless, two coats is probably nowhere near enough for this type of application, as waterborne finishes tend to be rather thin and slow to build. Most shuffleboard finishing regimes I've heard of involve multiple coats of high-build urethane or even self-leveling epoxy finishes, especially if there are decals to be enclosed in the finish.

Did you get good adhesion with your acrylic finish? If any of it has peeled or flaked in the course of all the rest of the fixes you tried, that would indicate that the wood surface may have been contaminated with wax or oil or silicone residue from its previous life. A barrier coat of shellac would have sealed those contaminants in and allowed your finish to adhere properly. And, yes, naphtha is a better solvent for wax than alcohol. Planing or sanding to bare wood is the best, though.

Shuffleboard sites recommend liquid wax after the initial finish is dry, followed by silicone, followed by powdered wax. I have no idea whether applying silicone over wax is advisable, but it sounds suspicious, as the solvents in the silicone could dissolve some of the wax and result in the sticky surface you describe. It could be that a good buffing would take care of it, so I'd try that first and then just use the regular powdered wax that they sell for shuffleboard tables.

If that still isn't fast enough for you, I'd sand the finish again, with 180 or 220 grit stearated paper, then shellac with a couple thinned coats of Seal Coat shellac, sanding after each with 320 grit paper. Follow up with several more coats of the finish and let them dry hard before proceeding with any further treatments.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Shuffled board problems (Long)

#7

Lee Grindinger

I remember

Lee Grindinger

The ones I've played on have a generous dusting of corn meal the puck slides on, it may be worth a shot.

Re: Shuffled board problems (Long)

#8

Re: Shuffled board problems (Long)

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

I don't play shuffleboard so take this for what it is worth. I think you are over finishing the surface. If you sand down to 1000 grit the puck will make contact with a larger surface area than if you sand to only 150 grit. I am sure there is an optimum level of finish but I would be surprised if it is more then 180.

I would also not be inclined to use a "floor" finish. Most floor finishes are abrasion resistant and they become abrasion resistant by adding things like aluminium oxide. Think about it, do you really want to add sandpaper to a surface that is supposed to be slippery?

Robin

Re: Shuffled board problems (Long)

#9

Re: Shuffled board problems (Long) *LINK*

del schisler

Are they using the shuffle board wax ?? it comes in a can that you sprinkle on the board. I have played shuffle board over the yrs. And this has to be used or else the board will be slow. No matter how slick a finish you put on the board. This stuff is granular so that the puck glides on the stuff and not on the board it self. here is the link


http://www.shuffleboardfederation.com/

Re: Shuffled board problems (Long)

#10

Re: A few questions and some possible answers

Bill Lordan, Auburn NH

Ellis

We originally sanded the finish down to bear wood; someone had tried to finish the table years before and they had the problems you described. I then laid down two coates of dewaxed shellac - I had a terrible time with brush marks with the shelac and just used the Miniwax polyacrylic directly on the bare wood. I tried to paint on the lines but they bled through the tape and we needed to repaint them. This is where the sign maker offered to make up the vinyl lines and club logo decals. I mentioned that the vinyl decals looked great - I was just using water slip decals - but it would take much more finishing time to imbed them.

We do have the shuffle board wax/granules and used them but they said the table was stilll to slow - these guys play on several other tables in the area and want to start a club shuffleboard league - so I have to believe they know what a table needs to feel like. We have sent away for the recommended liquid wax but I don't see how that is going to perform any better than the paste wax I applied - except the wax I applied doesn't seem to have hardened correctly. I am blaming this on trace amounts of silicone being left behind. This is why I want to make sure I remove all traces before I start this procedure all over again.

Any further thoughts will be greatly appreciated.

Re: Shuffled board problems (Long)

#11

Re: I remember

Bill Lordan, Auburn NH

Lee;

We use the recommended wax granules on the table and it still appears to be to slow.

Re: Shuffled board problems (Long)

#12

Re: Shuffled board problems (Long)

Bill Lordan, Auburn NH

Robin:

I am not using a floor finish just Minwax WB polyacrylic. Your over sanding idea is interesting but the puck is riding on wax granules that are spread all over the table. That is why I figured the smoother the better.

Re: Shuffled board problems (Long)

#13

Re: Shuffled board problems (Long)

Bill Lordan, Auburn NH

Del;

Thanks for the link; yes this is the material we are using.

Re: Shuffled board problems (Long)

#14

Re: Shuffled board problems (Long)

Gabe Doyle

I'm no shuffleboard expert, but make sure you're using the right wax. Below is a link to a company that sells different "speeds" of wax. Every table I've played on used salt, which seems to rely less on the quality/smoothness of the finish.

http://www.sunglocorp.com

Re: Shuffled board problems (Long)

#15

Re: Shuffled board problems (Long)

Don Orr

I am certainly no expert but I have played some shuffleboard over the years. I can't recall any kind of film finish on the tables. To the best of my recollection they appeared to be fairly bare wood or maybe a penetrating oil of some type. The lines were inset or inlaid I believe. The wax granules provided the slip. Every table was different. It took a few practice throws to judge the speed of each table. Wood (hard maple in this case) is fairly slippery on its own. I think you might be overthinking this whole thing possibly.