Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Recent project completed

Posts

Recent project completed

#1

Ellis Walentine

Recent project completed

Ellis Walentine

Last evening, I finished a pair of bedside tables that I have been working on sporadically since November. As with most projects I undertake, these tables were a design exercise for me. First, I considered the function, which is pretty obvious. Next, I considered the general style, which I wanted to fit in with our old farm house and our antique hodgepodge of bedroom furniture, primarily two antique maple dressers.

Then I considered the value and hue I wanted for these pieces. Value is the lightness/darkness, and hue is my catch-all term for the color characteristics and shading -- reds, yellows, browns, warm, cool, etc. Basically, I try to have the hue harmonize with the surroundings or with other furniture that it is intended to complement. Here I decided to go for an ochre/brown, medium value finish, on maple, to harmonize with the other maple in the room and to pick up some accent colors in a large tapestry on the wall over the bed. I also decided on using figured wood to add some sizzle, and a minimalist style, based on classic Shaker occasional table design, with a proprietary little double-radius detail carved on the corners of the tops.






When I dug out some curly maple that had been out in the shed for over 30 years, I found that there was some powder post beetle damage. I didn�t want to waste otherwise lovely wood, so my challenge was to render the holes invisible, or nearly so.

I came up with a sequence of operations to accomplish this. First, I blew out all the dust and frass from the beetle holes with a blowgun outfitted with a soccer-ball inflation needle. It worked wonderfully. Then I shopped around for a filler that would level well, dry fast, resist shrinking and take stain acceptably. My brother, who was my right-hand man in my woodworking business for many years, said he had had good luck with plain old Elmer's Carpenter's Wood Filler, from the borg, so I gave it a try. I was pleased with the results.

Next, I figured out my staining and finishing regimen. First, let me say I don't generally like to stain hardwoods. I'd rather choose them for their color and finish them naturally. But, I couldn't wait a couple hundred years for my maple to mellow to the shade I had in mind, so coloring was in order. I considered nitric acid, which darkens maple beautifully, but I didn't have any handy, and I don't like handling it, breathing the fumes and neutralizing the wood afterwards. Plus, nitric acid and any neutralizing solution are aqueous, which means raised grain and repeat applications, so I decided to find a stain combination instead.

Maple is a closed-pore wood so I wasn't worried about pigment stain turning it into a garish caricature of grain, as it does on oak, but I wasn't satisfied with the shallow depth of color that it produced on this dense maple. So I decided to use a sequence of dye and pigment stains. I chose General Finishes "Amber" dye stain followed by General Finishes "Candlelight" pigment stain for these tables. In my test samples, I found that if I applied the dye first, followed by the pigment stain, it produced the appearance I was after, plus, this sequence made the bug hole repairs almost invisible, whereas the pigment-first routine made them darker than the surrounding wood. You have to experiment to find these things out. I topcoated everything with a wiped coat of spar varnish cut with naphtha followed by two rubbed coats of Seal-A-Cell, which is similar in composition to my old favorite, Waterlox Original (Transparent) except that it isn't quite as amber in appearance.




Note that the drawers are unstained. This was an on-the-fly change of plan prompted by a couple things: First, my wife thought it might be an interesting twist on this fairly common design; and second, it would save me from having to selectively stain the exposed areas of the drawer fronts. That�s a design compromise I�ve never been fond of, as I don�t think there is a decent resolution.

Anyhow, the drawers are Port Orford cedar, with 3/8� thick sides and bottom and a 5/8� curly maple front, with turned ipe pulls tenoned through. They are dovetailed with two half-blind tails in front and three through tails in the back. The bottom rides in a 3/16� x 3/16� groove in the front and sides and passes under the back, with a single slot screw holding it fast. I used very thin shellac followed by Clapham�s Beeswax Polish inside and out, except for the exterior surfaces of the front, which have three wiped and rubbed coats of Seal-A-Cell on them.

It is a great relief to have some room to move in the shop again. I wonder what will be next on my agenda?

Ellis

Re: Recent project completed

#2

Re: Recent project completed

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Very very nice Ellis.

The color looks great on my monitor.

Well done.

Re: Recent project completed

#3

Very nice.  Informative write-up a plus.

John Pappas

Re: Recent project completed

#4

Re: Recent project completed

Andy Lincoln,in Dearborn MI

Ellis,

The tables look almost as nice on my screen as they did last week in person.I've got 2 sets of

Shaker style tables,1 set in cherry and 1 set in walnut,both half complete.How about if I send all the parts to you and I'll drop by when they are done : ).

I like the contrast of the colors between the dark knob,natural maple and the stain/dye results.

Andy

Re: Recent project completed

#5

Re: Recent project completed

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Well, in case any newcomers here wonder if our host can actually woodwork, let this serve as the answer. He sure can!

It's a beauty Ellis.

T.

Re: Recent project completed

#6

Re: Recent project completed

Bob in NE Ohio

Ellis

If I were half as talented it would make me a very happy woodworker!

Bob

Re: Recent project completed

#7

Most Importantly...

David Yoho

Beautiful work, Ellis. What I appreciate more is reading the thought process you underwent in the planning and finishing stages. While there would be any number of ways to go about completing tables like these, I like seeing the "what's and why's" of the end result. Thanks for a great write up!

Re: Recent project completed

#8

That's a really lovely table, Ellis

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I'm glad to see that other people struggle over what to do with stain/no stain on drawer sides. I prefer your solution.

Good job!

Re: Recent project completed

#9

Nice x 3!

David McDonnel "Mac"

Nice table, Nice details, Nice writeup! Love the figured maple, it's one of my favorites.

Mac

Re: Recent project completed

#10

Re: Recent project completed

Jennifer Indy.USA

Ellis they look great! I really like the drawers being unstained. Nice touch.

I don't know how you get anything done with all the other stuff boiling on your burners :)

Jen

Re: Recent project completed

#11

Re: Recent project completed

Dave Paine

Ellis,

It is not finished. What colour are you going to paint it? :D Sorry could not resist.

Very nice piece. I like the drawer being natural. Nice contrast.

Thanks for the pics and the story which helps to appreciate the piece even more.

I have two boards of curly maple, just waiting for inspiration for a project. Perhaps these may become table tops.

Re: Recent project completed

#12

Beautiful work, Ellis!

Stuart Hough

I like the contrast between the drawers and the rest of the table. The grain realy "pops", too!

Re: Recent project completed

#13

Re: Recent project completed

Virgil Johnson

Nice work Ellis.

Re: Recent project completed

#14

Outstanding in every way !

Don Orr

Re: Recent project completed

#15

Re: Recent project completed

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

Ellis, just beautiful. You took some gorgeous wood and created two incredible pieces! I have a couple of questions-

Were the double radius corners all hand carved? Please explain why they are "proprietary."

It looks like there is a 1/4" 45 deg. chamfer around the top edges and a steep chamfer/back bevel on the bottom? I guess your double radius corners makes it hard to do the often seen wide/shallow bevel on the bottom?

Thanks for sharing.

Re: Recent project completed

#16

Re: Recent project completed

charlie belden

Working with highly figured wood is a real challenge when multiple boards are needed to create a wide panel or table top. This can require a lot of flipping and slipping and sliding and rotating and often some trimming to get a better line up of figures. And even when you work out something that looks good in the bare wood it may not when stains or dyes are applied. So your tops (plural) must've taken a leap of faith. You went for it anyway - and succeeded nicely.

The table top corner treatments are a nice touch and not trivial to do since a router bit can only get you part way to the final result. Cutting in the inside corner involves working acrossed end grain and with side grain. It's very easy to overcut - and recovery from a mistake is even trickier.

3/8" drawer sides and pressumably back makes for a light and delicate drawer, and the fine pins stand out subtley because end grain absorbs more finish and darkens. Did you sand the end grain to a finer grit to reduce the darkening?

Fitting the shelf to tapered legs could be another challenge. Are the legs tapered on all four faces or just on the two show faces?

That's a lot of nice wood - used really well.

Now about that proprietary corner treatment . . .

Re: Recent project completed

#17

Clint Searl

Elegant!

Clint Searl

Very classy, Ellis. The corner detail and chamfered edge elevate an iconic design.

Clint

Re: Recent project completed

#18

Done Good, Boss

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

I'm sure SWMBO is pleased.

Re: Recent project completed

#19

Ellis Walentine

Re: Recent project completed

Ellis Walentine

Hi Alan,

The chamfer is actually about 1/8" and the underside edge is an elliptical curve created with a table edge bit in a router table. There's nothing proprietary about the double radius -- bad choice of words. I've played with the double-radius theme on a lot of pieces over the years, sometimes in plan like this, sometimes on table edges, occasionally with a quirk of some kind between the two radii, so I kind of think of it as a recognizable, or even signature, detail, but I certainly can't claim ownership of it. I've just can't recall seeing it anywhere else. A big part of the rationale for using it here was so that we wouldn't have sharp corners on our bedside tables. This seemed like a sweet way to resolve this issue.

Here's a view from below. I made the double radius with a 3/8" roundover bit raised up 3/8" above the router table, with the workpiece held vertical against a tall push block. Then I chamfered the top edge and ran the bottom edge vertically across an elliptical table-edge bit. The underside of the two little bellies was carved with a progression of safe-edge floats and flat files.

Ellis


Re: Recent project completed

#20

Re: Recent project completed

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

Thanks for the explanation and pics!! Even using a mix of power and hand tools, the execution is flawless.

Here I thought I could copy those corners and tell everyone- they are "Walentines." :D Of course, who knows, in 10-20 years after we are gone they could be called that!! Like a Maloof rocker, etc.

Re: Recent project completed

#21

Re: Recent project completed

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

Not Ellis, but it looks to me like the legs are tapered on the inside two faces, with the taper starting just below the shelf.

Re: Recent project completed

#22

Ellis Walentine

Re: Recent project completed

Ellis Walentine

Working with highly figured wood is a real challenge when multiple boards are needed to create a wide panel or table top. This can require a lot of flipping and slipping and sliding and rotating and often some trimming to get a better line up of figures. And even when you work out something that looks good in the bare wood it may not when stains or dyes are applied. So your tops (plural) must've taken a leap of faith. You went for it anyway - and succeeded nicely.

Yeah, it isn't always easy to compose with highly variable figure. In this case, I got away with it because both tops came from one board, which had dense figure along one edge and not as much along the other. I oriented the boards so that the figured edges would be at the front and back edges of the table, where they would not be hidden by lamps, alarm clocks, drinking glasses, reading materials, etc. Still, I needed another 3" of material in the middle, between the two main pieces, so I cut up another board that had pretty uniform curly figure and didn't worry too much about the transitions.

The table top corner treatments are a nice touch and not trivial to do since a router bit can only get you part way to the final result. Cutting in the inside corner involves working acrossed end grain and with side grain. It's very easy to overcut - and recovery from a mistake is even trickier.

Floats and files are the key -- much better control.

3/8" drawer sides and pressumably back makes for a light and delicate drawer, and the fine pins stand out subtley because end grain absorbs more finish and darkens. Did you sand the end grain to a finer grit to reduce the darkening?

Yes. First, I hand planed all the surfaces of the drawers, including the sides, to get the final fit in the drawer openings. Then I hit both sides with some 600-grit sandpaper, but it really didn't add much polishing to the hand-planed end grain.

Fitting the shelf to tapered legs could be another challenge. Are the legs tapered on all four faces or just on the two show faces?

The legs are tapered from the bottom of the shelf to the floor, only on the two inside faces.

That's a lot of nice wood - used really well.

That wood was from a 40"-diameter curly hard maple tree we cut down in 1978 and milled ourselves with a Sperber mill. In fact, a photo I took of the occasion became the cover of Sperber's first catalog. The wood has been at the bottom of a big pile in my shed since then, hence the beetle problem. If I had been making these tables for a paying customer, I would have purchased fresh lumber, because the effort to salvage this stuff was more a labor of love than sanity.



Now about that proprietary corner treatment . . .

Answered above in response to Alan's first query. Sorry for the lapse. Editors are supposed to be precise.

Re: Recent project completed

#23

Re: Recent project completed

FredD

Ellis , let me echo everyone's comments , particularly the chamfered edge rather then a rolled one and of course the how and why is very good reading also.

FredD

Re: Recent project completed

#24

Re: Recent project completed

Chuck Lenz

Nice job on the tables, I also really like the style of the corners of the table top, I've never seen that before and makes it standout.

Re: Recent project completed

#25

Very Nice!

Todd Nebel