Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Question on CFL bulbs and Sensors

Posts

Question on CFL bulbs and Sensors

#1

Question on CFL bulbs and Sensors

Barry Irby

I just put up two fixtures on my son's house that have dawn to dusk sensors. These are electric eye type things that don't allow the bulbs to come on unless its dark. So, you can leave the switch on and the light comes on when it gets dark. I did not know any better and used CFL bulbs in them. Put them up and to be sure they work, I put my finger over the sensor and the lights came on but rather poorly. It was cold, so I assumed they would warm up and be fine, but I did not stand around waiting for the blessed event.

So, Are these the type of sensor that ruin CFLs?

Re: Question on CFL bulbs and Sensors

#2

Re: Question on CFL bulbs and Sensors

Bill Howatt

The real problem is how the power is switched. If it is a relay then there is no problem, if it is a solid-state device like a triac then you can have trouble but I thought the latter would cause the light to not come on at all.

If you heard a faint click when you covered the sensor then it was very likely the relay contacts closing and it should be fine.

I'm interested in hearing other replies since I have not put any CFLs in automatic lights yet.

Bill

Re: Question on CFL bulbs and Sensors

#3

Re: Question on CFL bulbs and Sensors

Stuart Johnson

I have them in mine and have not had any problems. For whatever reason they don't come on when I stick my finger over the sensor but work fine in normal nightly use.

Re: Question on CFL bulbs and Sensors

#4

New Types

Al Goldstein

Years ago I tried a CFL in a photo cell for an outdoor light and the CFL failed. I figured that by now photo cells have been developed that could control a CFL.

I went to a local electrical supplier and asked for a photo cell that would work with a CFL. The one I bought is clearly marked "Outdoor Dusk-to-Dawn Compact Flrourescent Light Control" (Westek SLC5BCB, www.amertac.com). The package also states "CFL Compatible".

So I probably could have bought a photo cell at the local borg if I had read the package carefully. I haven't replaced the photo cell in my outdoor fixture yet, but since my CFLs have a stated minimum starting temperature of minus 20 degrees F I hope everything works fine.

I'm always smarter after the fact.

Re: Question on CFL bulbs and Sensors

#5

Re: Question on CFL bulbs and Sensors

Jim Pugh

Barry, I have two photocell controlled lights in an overhang in front of my garage doors. For years I used the high strength filament bulbs used in drop lights and such. Even so, the vibration from the garage doors opening and closing killed those bulbs in short order. About 18 months ago I went to 40W CFL bulbs and have only replaced one since. I live in northern Ohio and the bulbs have never failed to come on.

Re: Question on CFL bulbs and Sensors

#6

Re: Question on CFL bulbs and Sensors

Bill Howatt

I had the same problem and found that "rural 130V" filament lights lasted quite well in the openers. Not what I expected, thought the rough-service lamps would have been better.

Good to know your experience with CFLs.

Bill

Re: Question on CFL bulbs and Sensors

#7

Re: Question on CFL bulbs and Sensors

Paul Leuba

I purchased several photo cells at the local Borg for use with CFL bulbs. The photo cells were not marked as CFL compatible, and as a result they did not work properly. At dusk the CFL bulbs woud flicker on and off repeatedly until it was totally dark. After a couple weeks, the bulbs failed, I believe due to the thousands of on/off cycles before it was fully dark each night.

I purchased replacement photo cells at the Borg that were marked as CFL compatible. These have worked without further problems.

Paul in Hunt Valley, MD