Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Car Repair, I am amazed......OT

Posts

Car Repair, I am amazed......OT

#1

Car Repair, I am amazed......OT

Barry Irby

I had a fender bender during one of the many snow storms. Somebody bumped into the front of my Honda CR-V. They were going so slowly it didn't fire either their airbags or mine. They hit the front of my car at an angle and caved it in, Including the radiator. For those of you not familiar, this car has a big plastic or rubber bumper. The insurance guy pulled it off to get a better look. Turns out there is nothing behind it except the radiator and the radiator (condenser) for the AC. Actually, there is a bumper reinforcement below the radiator. I am going to work on it myself, something that I only have a passing acquaintance with. I bought the parts online. This reinforcement is a beam looking thing and the local dealer wanted $178 for it. On line it was $54 delivered. I ordered the big rubber nose, the reinforcement, a head light, and two front finder liners. Today, when I got home today there was a box big enough for me to stand up in leaning on my house. I lifted it and it was so light I assumed it had only the rubber nose. Not. Opened it and found all the stuff. The label says the box weighed 34 pounds. The "reinforcement is so light I can lift it with two fingers. I am amazed that this represents the front of my car and is all that is between the radiator and the world.

Wonder if it would be a good idea to reinforce the reinforcement with a nice sturdy piece of oak?

Re: Car Repair, I am amazed......OT

#2

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Car Repair, I am amazed......OT

Jesper, Denmark

Hi Barry, you do copme up with the most diverse posts here.

The soft nose is there as the initial crumbling zone, mainly to protect pedestrians on frntal impacts. adding an oak beam wold disturb the designed-in crumbling zone, so risky in case you have another incident. Horror stories, like the insurance company denying claims come to mind.

Re: Car Repair, I am amazed......OT

#3

Good thought.....

Barry Irby

I was thinking in terms of protecting me, not them. I guess I will let the radiator cushion the blow.

Years ago a we were creeping down the street, caught in the traffic assembling for a parade. A Woman bumped the back of my pickup at about 1 mile and hour and DESTROYED the step bumper. I was so shocked at how it just fell apart, I replaced it with an oak beam. A year or so later I was sitting in traffic, waiting for a chance to make a left turn. There was a fellow stopped behind me. A car hit him so hard it knocked him forward into me. The oak beam did a much better job than the step bumper. But them I am not thinking in terms of crumble zones.

Re: Car Repair, I am amazed......OT

#4

Re: Good thought.....

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Good Afternoon Barry,

When I bought my old 1980 used Mercury Cougar Wagon it came with a trailor hitch which I decided to retain. Over the 17 years I drove the car, I was rear ended twice with no damage to my car. Good protection.

George

Re: Car Repair, I am amazed......OT

#5

Re: Good thought.....

FredD

Colonel , I have found over the years that the ball hitch on my pickup is a excellent range finder when people have parked closely fore and aft of me , you just listen for the contact . ;-))

FredD

Re: Car Repair, I am amazed......OT

#6

Re: Car Repair, I am amazed......OT

Dan Donaldson

A few years ago, I had a Ranger pickup and was driving in a snowstorm on the way to work. A driver came out of a store parking lot and hit me in the side hard enough to make me sway over a lane. I pulled over out of traffic and took a look at my truck, expecting the worst. I could not then (and never did) find any mark telling me exactly where he hit me. For him, it was very strange. The entire front end of his car, back to the the radiator was laying in the middle of the road in pieces. Bumper, grill, and the facia around the front end of the car. Weirdest thing I ever saw.

Re: Car Repair, I am amazed......OT

#7

Re: Car Repair, I am amazed......OT

Barry Irby

I see a rubber bumper laying on the side of the road every now and then. I guess they depend on the air pressure to keep them on. If you get a really strong tail wind, some of your car's parts might go faster than the car.

Sort of like the guy who did not do a good job of hitching his boat that the truck and was driving down the road. Glanced over and thought "that's a really good looking boat there beside me. Holey crap! That's my boat!"

Or, we went to see my son at Ft. Campbell. turned into the parking lot of a store and there was a car backing out of a parking place. We waited, (no place to go) and blew the horn and cringed. Turns out there was no one in the car. The owner thought he should not have to pay because it "was not his fault" even though the car was not in park and the brake was not set. He had just gotten out and walked away and it took it a few seconds to start to roll.

Re: Car Repair, I am amazed......OT

#8

Re: Good thought.....

Kevin Stanbary in McHenry, IL

The crumple zones are there to protect you more than the other guy. In slow-speed collisions it is not as big a deal, but in a harder hit, the energy of the collision goes into crumpling the car. If you had it reinforced, rather than crumpling, it would transmit all of that energy to the pieces behind it (perhaps even to you.)

This is the same reason Indy cars basically disintegrate in a crash; the car falling apart absorbs the energy of the collision, better protecting the driver.

Re: Car Repair, I am amazed......OT

#9

Obviously, you had a Power Ranger  *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA


http://www.powerrangers.com/