Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Planer exit roller marks.

Posts

Planer exit roller marks.

#1

Planer exit roller marks.

Virgil Johnson

I'm setting up my new 15" planer and I'm getting marks in the lumber from the serrated exit roller. I'm not going to mention the brand name until I give the tech support guys at Grizzly time to come up with a solution as not to embarrass them. I've backed off the spring pressure on the roller but still get slight markings. Anyone own a planer with a smooth exit roller or battled this problem? I'm guessing this one is serrated to make sure it works when planing rough lumber. I think I have a piece of steel large enough to make a smooth roller to try. I could turn .03 off the original but I don't want to have that conversation with the tech guys....Do you think a smooth exit roller will work?

Re: Planer exit roller marks.

#2

you must be feeding backwards....

Bill Tindall

just kidding, but I never saw a planer with anything but a cogged infeed roller and a smooth outfeed roller. The primary roll of the outfeed roller is to hold the lumber flat against the table and to effectively accomplish this task it needs to have significant pressure on it. A secondary roll is to continue the feed once the trailing edge of the lumber passes the infeed roller, but it doesn't take cogs to accomplish this task. A cogged outfeed is so ridiculous that one could suspect it was installed by mistake.

Re: Planer exit roller marks.

#3

Re: Planer exit roller marks.

Pat Evans

My 15" Jet will occasionally leave marks, and it has smooth outfeed rollers.

BTW: nice stealth gloat

Re: Planer exit roller marks.

#4

Re: Planer exit roller marks.

Ralph Lipeles

Could your outfeed roller be set too high? The height for the roller on my 15" Sunhill can be adjuted for planing smoothe or rough woods.

Ralph Lipeles

Re: Planer exit roller marks.

#5

Thats it!

Virgil Johnson

Not.

Here is the roller in question. Very fine serrations. Very fine marks in the wood. I stopped in Woodcraft on the way home from my morning run and the exit roller in the PM 15" planer is smooth. The PM exit roller only has the tool marks from a lathe tool taking about a .012-.015 per rev finish cut.




Re: Planer exit roller marks.

#6

My Yorkcraft has the same roller

Henry Higginbotham

This makes me doubt that we both have the wrong part, especially as my planer had a Byrd head installed after it arrived in the US, and I think they would have noticed.

Try backing off the pressure on the outfeed and see if that doesn't reduce or eliminate the problem. I know for a fact that I started having the same marks when I increased the pressure in an attempt to fix some other now-forgotten problem.

Re: Planer exit roller marks.

#7

Ellis Walentine

What does the mfr. have to say?

Ellis Walentine

It's pretty hard to write off that kind of outcome, Virgil. I wonder if Grizzly offers a urethane outfeed roller or some other alternative.

Ellis

Re: Planer exit roller marks.

#8

Re: Planer exit roller marks.

Steve in Phoenix

I just checked my Grizzly 1021Z 15" planer, and the outfeed roller is smooth. Did Grizzly say the outfeed roller on your model was supposed to be serrated, or do they need to get back to you on that?

They might send you a smooth one from another 15" model to try, before you go to the trouble of fabricating one.

Re: Planer exit roller marks.

#9

They are discussing it.

Virgil Johnson

I have been in touch with the tech support guys since last Wed. The gentleman I spoke with on the tech line had not heard of this problem before and is consulting with the senior technician. I backed the spring tension off to zero and still get some marks. I'm playing by the book at this point before I make a new roller or modify this one.

Edit:I should note that I'm not trying to slam the tech guys. I don't mind turning down the roller if that will fix it. I'm not one to wait on someone else to fix a problem when its pretty simple. I have to remove the roller even if they send me a new one. I wanted some feedback from other owners if this was an isolated problem.

Re: Planer exit roller marks.

#10

Re: My Yorkcraft has the same roller

Virgil Johnson

I experimented with the spring pressure before I called. Even at just snug I get marks on a narrow piece. It has to do with PSI. Just the weight of the roller on a narrow edge is enough to mark soft wood.

Re: Planer exit roller marks.

#11

Re: Planer exit roller marks.

Virgil Johnson

The exit roller (powered roller) is set to .020 below the cutter and the bed roller is at .002 above the bed. I don't think its a roller height issue.

Re: Planer exit roller marks.

#12

Re: Planer exit roller marks.

Don Orr

Is it possible the factory could have put in the wrong part for the exit roller by mistake ? Are the 2 rollers the same size diameter? Are they perhaps even interchangeable? Maybe got switched during production? I have heard Grizzly is pretty good about their product support.

Re: Planer exit roller marks.

#13

Re: Planer exit roller marks.

Virgil Johnson

Is it possible the factory could have put in the wrong part for the exit roller by mistake ?

I sent the tech guy the same pics I posted here he said that was not the case.

Re: Planer exit roller marks.

#14

Let us know how it turns out

Henry Higginbotham

I still have the problem with my planer, too, but the marks are lighter than yours appear to be in the photo. They sand out pretty well, but it would still be nice to know if it's considered normal.

Re: Planer exit roller marks.

#15

OK...Que for you.

Virgil Johnson

If you have a way of checking the outside dia. of your rollers can you send me the diameters? I checked the rollers in my planer and the exit roller is aprox .035 larger than the drive roller. These are driven by a chain and turn the same RPM which means my exit roller is "fighting" the drive roller as the drive roller has around 1/8" less circumference. Unless this machine is engineered this way for a reason I have room to turn down the exit roller and would rework yours if you like. (for a very small donation to WC...:-)

Re: Planer exit roller marks.

#16

Re: Planer exit roller marks.

John McGaw

Are both rollers on our planer the same? (i.e. serrated) If so, it makes absolutely no sense to me. My Robland has a wickedly serrated infeed roller but the outfeed has a matte finish -- the only way to get marks from mine is to have the chip collector failing to remove material quickly enough and to have chips embossed into the wood surface by the roller's pressure.

Re: Planer exit roller marks.

#17

I use to work on Machines

Larry in NW OHIO

Similar to this setup for 15 years, only they were 4 headed Maddison. The only way I saw them made were with serreated rollers are first and the smooth AFTER it does the cutting. It only makes sense, the rollers are going to make an imprint no matter how little pressure is on it. For what it`s worth, in my opinion the rollers are turned around. Also don`t you think that if the serreated rollers are in the back they are going to imprint and nomatter how much you sand don`t you think it will raise the grain after it gets wet from staining it. Unless I`m forgetting something here. I could easily be wrong here. but that`s what I think may happen. Good Luck Larry

Re: Planer exit roller marks.

#18

Diameters

Henry Higginbotham

As you said, Virgil, the outfeed roller is easier to measure; mine shows 2.011 inches. The infeed is a knife-edged helical affair, somewhat resembling a large cutter for a mill, and harder to get a definite reading on, but over the course of several tries, I got a range of 1.974 to 1.981 inches. The difference, as you noted, is approximately 0.035 inch.

All this supports my belief that the outfeed rollers are what the manufacturer intended, and installed as intended, too. Whether the engineering is sound, I don't know.

Grizzly's response should be interesting. It appears Wilke Machinery is still in business (but no longer selling Bridgewood and Yorkcraft brands), so I may pose the same question to them.