Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Oak or maple for a small Shaker cabinet?

Posts

Oak or maple for a small Shaker cabinet?

#1

JL

Oak or maple for a small Shaker cabinet?

JL

I've been asked to make a small cabinet in the Shaker (or Shaker/Mission) style.

My choice of wood. My choice of design for that matter. The cabinet will have an upper portions with two doors and shelves behind the doors. It will have a small drawer below the doors. I was figuring on using the legs and stiles to frame the sides, back and front.

Question is - what wood?

I have plenty of oak in 8/4 and 5/4. I have plenty of maple in 5/4 and 10/4. I even have cherry - but I would have to resaw it to get it down to thickness.

It does have to be stained to "harmonize" with some existing pieces (sort of a darkish stain). Would oak (red oak) be suitable or should I go with maple?

TIA.

Re: Oak or maple for a small Shaker cabinet?

#2

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Cherry

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

This is just my opinion, But Shaker would look wrong in an open grained wood like oak.

I have made a fair amount of shaker pieces, mostly cherry, then maple. I would choose a closed grained wood first, the look is clean and in keeping with the simple designs of most shaker works..

Take care,

Jim

Re: Oak or maple for a small Shaker cabinet?

#4

3rd cherry vote

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Re: Oak or maple for a small Shaker cabinet?

#5

Re: 4th cherry vote

Virgil Johnson

Re: Oak or maple for a small Shaker cabinet?

#6

Re: Oak or maple for a small Shaker cabinet?

David Yoho

Definitely not red oak!!! Maple or cherry would be in keeping with Shaker style. However, you also said "mission/shaker" which is confusing. Oak is more mission than maple.

Re: Oak or maple for a small Shaker cabinet?

#7

Maple

Todd Nebel

Unless you want to bother with extra care during finishing to reduce blotching and even the tones of cherry. I vote Maple.

Re: Oak or maple for a small Shaker cabinet?

#8

JL

Thanks, will go with maple.

JL

The piece has to be stained to match the existing decor. I DON'T want to do that with cherry. I think walnut might be a bit dark. Hmmm - I could always make two pieces though. I'll have to give it some thought.

Re: Oak or maple for a small Shaker cabinet?

#9

Re: Oak or maple for a small Shaker cabinet?

Rick Lasita

Cherry

Re: Oak or maple for a small Shaker cabinet?

#10

Re: Thanks, will go with maple--Phshew!

Joanne in Point Pleasant

Thank you! You saved me from a rant about staining cherry! Such heresy!

Re: Oak or maple for a small Shaker cabinet?

#11

I'll challenge you to a rant

Bill Tindall

I always stain cherry. I nearly always stain walnut and mahogany too. Staining adds a formality not to be achieved in unstained pieces. The only wood I don't stain is ash, which I use for modern informal pieces.

Unstained cherry has raw look, suitable for some modern pieces but not appropriate for period furniture. Stained cherry looks rich "right out of the box" and gets richer with age.


Now I agree that most commercial cherry stains are gross! And I'll further agree that most finishers don't know how to prepare a surface for staining or how to apply the stain. But these are not reasons to eschew staining altogether.

I stain cherry with an old fashioned mineral pigmented stain. I was about to run out of the Sherwin Williams product I have used since 1970 (and long since discontinued) but General Finishes came to the rescue with an equivalent product made with mineral (iron) pigments. Chromate works well too but only someone with a death wish would use it given what is known about it today. Dye stains can do well but I never learned to use them reliably on cherry. It is not a shortcoming of dye stains but a shortcoming of my perseverance learning.

Re: Oak or maple for a small Shaker cabinet?

#12

Ellis Walentine

Re: Oak or maple for a small Shaker cabinet?

Ellis Walentine

Late to the discussion, but my answer to your question is another question: How important is it that your piece(s) match the existing pieces in the room? You seem to be basing your choice of woods on what you have available, which is fine if the characteristic grain pattern of the wood isn't important. But, even with a stain, it's going to be tricky to make new maple look like aged cherry. You might get the color right, but you'd still have to deal with the grain characteristics if it's important to the customer.

Ellis

PS My advice on staining maple (or anything) a dark color is to use a dye stain first, followed by a pigment stain. You'll get a depth and complexity that you won't get with either stain by itself.

PPS My other comment is that it's not a crime to stain cherry if that's the best way to solve the design problem. I have a friend who restores million-dollar antiques, using antique Cuban mahogany and other priceless woods. He thinks nothing of mixing up a whole regimen of dyes and pigments to duplicate the exact color and finish of the original piece, because the only thing that matters is making the repair undetectable.