Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

New Year's Plane

Posts

Re: New Year's Plane

#26

Maybe next one...

John M in Mid Mich

This isn't, but I have some elm in proper dimension and was thinking of giving it a try. Elm may be less stable, however, so I'm not sure it is plane material.

Re: New Year's Plane

#28

Re: Maybe next one...

FredD

Aromatic Red Cedar ??

FredD

Re: New Year's Plane

#29

Wrong color

John M in Mid Mich

Have never seen red cedar that didn't have some "red" in it. This is simply caramel (at least it is once oiled).

Re: New Year's Plane

#30

The mystery answer is...

John M in Mid Mich

Betula alleghaniensis. Yellow Birch. Slightly less hard than the more traditional oak or maple for planes, although this piece seemed to be notably hard and heavy. I think yellow birch is under appreciated, in general. Furthermore, I had a piece of suitable dimension, and like I said above, I love the appearance of YB with a bit of oil. If it was for daily hard use by a pro, maybe YB isn't ideal. The oohs and aahhs last evening when the gift was given suggest that my choice was not misdirected. And the recipient has a day job, as I do, so I'm sure the birch will far outlast his need to shave wood. I shaped the second blank today, much like the first. No finish yet, and maybe there will be none. Thanks to all for the fun conversation.

John

Re: New Year's Plane

#31

not the first to use it

Bill Tindall

I met the cabinet maker at the Fort in Thunder Bay , ONT some time ago and he made his planes from yellow birch. Claimed it to be better than maple.

I suspect what fooled folks was the heart wood color usually not associated with yellow birch.

Re: New Year's Plane

#32

Re: not the first to use it

John M in Mid Mich

This project was so much fun that I can see a future here. I've already got some white oak, ash, and cherry blanks drying. Thinking that ash with an Ipe sole would be awesome. Cherry with white oak? So many woods, so little time!! What do you think of the suggestion of Elm?

J.

Re: New Year's Plane

#33

elm-poor

Bill Tindall

It is both soft and particularly unstable. But then if you are making them to admire it doesn't matter.

We have made whole planes from Ipe. Kinda hard on tools but it makes a durable plane that slides especially well on the wood to be planed. On the other hand my maple planes do just fine and it is easier to work. For what ever reason I have needed to keep diddling with the Ipe block plane to keep its sole flat.

Re: New Year's Plane

#34

Re: Wrong color

FredD

The unfinished plane on the bottom of pic , at least on my computer has the pink and white combination I have seen many times in Aromatic Red cedar close to the sap wood.

In your case the mixed unselect would have Red and White and would be more identifiable in a larger piece.

Yellow Birch is a great wood for those like working hardwoods and that is the only kind I work with.

FredD

Re: New Year's Plane

#35

Re: elm-poor

John M in Mid Mich

> We have made whole planes from Ipe.

So, did you glue up 4/4 or 5/4 stock or start from a 4x4? I will probably try an Ipe plane, but wonder which direction to orient the glue up, since I don't have the thick stock.

Re: New Year's Plane

#36

Re: elm-poor

Bill Tindall

will email some pictures tomorrow. Remind me if I forget.