Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

New Year's Plane

Posts

New Year's Plane

#1

New Year's Plane

John M in Mid Mich

So I'm a little late, having finished this just yesterday, in time to give as a "Christmas" present today. First try at the Krenov plane, as taught in great detail in David Finck's book. The one in the raw at the bottom is my keeper. Want to guess the wood (has been coated with Watco Danish in natural)? The wedges and cross pins are Ipe. The test board and shavings, red oak.


img

Re: New Year's Plane

#2

Hornbeam?  Curly beech?

paul in AZ

Re: New Year's Plane

#3

something to try

Bill Tindall

I rarely "finish" a hand made tool. As soon as it is shaped enough to be functional it gets put to use and I never get back to adding the finishing touches, or finish. To that end I left some Krenov style block planes roughly rectangular with rounded corners. They wound up being more comfy in the hand than the sculpted "first-try" that I made. In this case laziness was beneficial.

BTW, it is easy to modify the construction to wind up with a low angle plane for end grain and a high angle plane for gnarly surfaces.

Another by the way... is a chip breaker any practical use in these planes? In a Stanley plane the chip breaker stabilizes the frail blade but the blades in these things are rigid. I am not convinced a chip breaker actually breaks chips.

Re: New Year's Plane

#4

JL

Is that a "racing profile" on the one in back??

JL

Re: New Year's Plane

#5

Looks more like a boattail speedster  *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA


like this one, for instance

Re: New Year's Plane

#6

Re: Looks more like a boattail speedster

John M in Mid Mich

I agree about the shape being like some Italian speedboat!

Re: New Year's Plane

#7

Re: something to try

John M in Mid Mich

I kind of agree about the finish, but 2 things were in play here: 1) it was a gift; and 2) I knew how good the wood would look. I must say that I was pleasantly surprised at how comfortable this shape felt. I only had it in my possession for testing for a matter of hours, but it felt really good - the upswept front is way better than the knob on my old Stanley. I had initially thought I'd try two different shapes to compare, but now I'm thinking I'll just replicate that shape on the one I'm planning to keep. I also plan to make some more, and I may also try one without a chip breaker. I hope other voices will chime in on your comment about that.

Re: New Year's Plane

#10

Question for the Hand Tool board?

Phil Joines

I don't know enough about planes to guess if a chip breaker is needed but some of the gents on the quiet side would know.

Re: New Year's Plane

#11

Re: New Year's Plane

Steven Bellner

The pitch pockets make it look like Jarrah, but I haven't seen it oiled-up before. It's got to be something pretty hard. Beautiful tool!

Steve in East Tennessee.

Re: New Year's Plane

#13

Not Jarra and not pitch pockets

John M in Mid Mich

Not Jarra and not pitch pockets, those are worm holes. This was a down tree in mid Michigan that I salvaged with chainsaw mill, and either the worms got to it before me or the worms are why it was down in the first place.

Re: New Year's Plane

#14

Re: Question for the Hand Tool board?

John M in Mid Mich

I thought it an interesting paradox when submitting the original post: main board or hand tools? Decided main board since it is a product of nasty, filthy, electric machines. But the question about the chip breaker is most definitely for the hand tool guys and gals. Will post the question there.

Re: New Year's Plane

#15

Re: Looks more like a boattail speedster

John M in Mid Mich

I was thinking more like this...


img

Re: New Year's Plane

#16

Looks like a fruitwood?

John in NM

Cherry or apple maybe?

Very handsome work, I like the shape :D

Re: New Year's Plane

#17

willow?

Tom Sontag - St. Louis

If not, give us a hint, domestic or exotic?

Re: New Year's Plane

#18

No, but thanks.

John M in Mid Mich

Not fruitwood, but thanks for the complement.

Re: New Year's Plane

#19

No, domestic, mid Michigan

John M in Mid Mich

I milled a few boards from a fallen tree.

Re: New Year's Plane

#20

Re: Sycamore??

Larry Clinton Sr.

Re: New Year's Plane

#21

Re:swag choke cherry?

Dale Stansbery

Re: New Year's Plane

#22

Walnut? 

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

Re: New Year's Plane

#24

Sorry

John M in Mid Mich

Sycamore has way more grain in my experience. This is very fine grained.

Re: New Year's Plane

#25

Not

John M in Mid Mich

Have never seen choke cherry wood, but this is not it. Sorry.