Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

OT.Glazing vs Caulking?

Posts

OT.Glazing vs Caulking?

#1

OT.Glazing vs Caulking?

Nelson

I have LOT'S of window panes that need the glazing replaced, I have used glaxing in the past and is a real pain,having talked with several friends and a couple contractors and asked the question why not use caulking because its easier they just give me a funny look and have no reason why not. TIA for any advice.

Re: OT.Glazing vs Caulking?

#2

Not sure caulking is easier...

John in NM

At least not if you want it to come out looking nice. The times I've seen caulking used in place of glazing putty it looked just awful, but then they hadn't been able to do a tidy job with the material.

There must be some kind of replacement for standard glazing putty because last time I went to buy some it was hard to find, but of course that's Albuquerque, may be more common elsewhere.

I always kind of liked traditional glazing, it presents a challenge but it gets much easier with practice.

Re: OT.Glazing vs Caulking?

#3

Jesper, Denmark

Re:.....and if......

Jesper, Denmark

You mess up with the glazing compound, you can take it out, rework it and try again without a big mess.

Re: OT.Glazing vs Caulking?

#4

Re: OT.Glazing vs Caulking?

Joseph Mulherin, Sr

While it is true the points hold the glass in place during sealing with regular caulk and the caulking is for looks as well as sealing the edges of the glass against weather leakage....

I think it is more historical to use the caulk instead of the tube squirting into the glass edges and frame moldings. My suggestion is to just make sure the caulk clay is oiled enough to stay consistant and not chalk out before finishing molding smooth. And it is easier to remove than the tube caulking materials.

My opinion...traditional is better than newer quicker feel easy methods.

Re: OT.Glazing vs Caulking?

#5

Re: OT.Glazing vs Caulking?

Joseph Mulherin, Sr

correction...replace caulking with glazing. Use the traditional materials.

Re: OT.Glazing vs Caulking?

#6

Re: OT.Glazing vs Caulking?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I concur with other folks about using glazing. You want whatever you use to finish out smooth, with a sharp edge at the glass, and it would be very very hard to get that with caulking, which comes out soft.

There are now acrylic glazing compounds to replace the old linseed-oil-based putty. I haven't used them, but they seem to promise quicker drying time so you can paint sooner, coupled with the threat of quicker drying time so you have less time to get your glazing work smoothed out.

Re: OT.Glazing vs Caulking?

#7

Re: OT.Glazing vs Caulking?

Joanne in Point Pleasant

The new glazing compounds (as someone mentioned) are pretty easy to work with. I reglazed all of the 60+ panes in the windows of my shop/barn, so I got a lot of practice and got pretty good at it. With that many panes, I learned not to put too much putty, so beveling the bead got pretty easy and looked good after a while.

Re: OT.Glazing vs Caulking?

#8

Re: OT.Glazing vs Caulking?

Nelson

Thanks for input, Happy New Year.

Re: OT.Glazing vs Caulking?

#9

Re: OT.Glazing vs Caulking?

morris

home depot has glazing in a tube. the nozzle is square instead of round. works ok.