We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
I'm unsure about the scalloped trim at the top (my wife calls it fru-fru), that it may be inconsistent with the overall design. I tried to match the flutes in the "columns", but I may have missed the mark ?
I think the change in appearance from empty to full is very interesting. I appears some of the "effect" of the wonderful work on the shelves is if not lost muted. Great looking work and you still have a little room at the top. perhaps your next project could be a rolling library ladder or a classic step stool out of the same cherry.
That is a lot of work and overall looks good. Since you ask my opinion of the top molding I will share a couple of ideas. I don't think there is enough molding at the top, and I kind of agree with your wife about the dentil mold; it does not really go with the plain shelving. My thought was the flutes don't really go with the plain shelving either. I think if you put some sort of edge profile on the shelves, maybe a simple roundover with bead, the other decoration would look better. At the top I would have used a 4 or 5 inch wide crown mold then put the dentil mold underneath it. But overall it is a nice looking piece and one that you will enjoy using for years.
What a LOT of work! I really like random shelf book cases and yours is really nice. Regarding the molding, yes it could have been done differently, but the whole book case is so darn nice that I would be proud to have it in my house. Thanks for posting.
I like the Oriental feel of the bookshelf arrangement -- reminiscent of the picture recess in a traditional Japanese home, but juxtaposed with classical and modern elements. That was quite a project. Good work!
Very nice, and I agree with a previous post that it's interesting to see the progression from empty/random to full of books.
I agree that the molding is a bit busy -- I think its because the proportion is different. Probably same width as the flutes (I'm guessing at this), but then the molding continues uninterrupted across the top. And of course, much shorter than the fluting on the columns.
I cannot think of suggestion for achieving the effect you're after.
You surely earned all of those kind words--I'd say they are an accurate expressioon of admiration for your skill in design and execution. I'd have loved to be there during glue up--I'd have become "unglued".
I like it a lot. When empty the asymmetry looks great. When full it certainly provides for a wide variety of book sizes whick can be a problem with standard bookcases. Well designed and executed.
Judging by the detail you choose for the capitals of your fluted collumns it looks like you were going for a modern design with a few classical details as inspiration, I would add that the capital detail is very nice and works beautifully with the fluted collumns. Dental mould is usually a detail of a larger moulding rather than a stand alone mould as you have used it. as a stand alone detail, particularly at the top of such a large piece I think it needed to be scaled up a bit. I think if you sized the dental mold more in line with the size of the collumn capitals it would work better as a cornice detail. I would suggest trying a dental moulding with the individual squares somwhare around 5" work better and look less "fru-fru-y".
The random lay out for your shelves is also a nice touch and very well done.
One aspect of working with classical design elements is that our eyes and minds have been conditioned by a couple thousand years of seeing those elements in their traditional proportions based on ancient Greek architecture. We can't help seeing that something isn't as expected even though we might not be able to articulate it. I'm not saying we shouldn't try to combine classical elements in new and pleasing ways, but rather that it is challenging to create a new aesthetic with these traditional building blocks. You've done a very nice job, Yonak. Keep thinking out of the box.
Question: did you do dados for all the shelving? I would think it would be possible to use bisquits to join shelving to the uprights, and shelves to shelves. Great design and beautiful completion of a very intense project.
It's all screwed together .. very little glue used. All the screws are hidden. It's put together in discrete boxes of 1/2" cherry plywood, assembled in my shop then stacked, squeezed into place and tacked with finishing nails and holes filled. That made 1" thick walls. Each shelf piece is supported by its side and back walls. The front edge of each piece was rabbeted, creating a 1/2" channel into which I glued and tacked "T"-shaped trim pieces. It took about 2 1/2 months, working on it when I could.