Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Rattle in frame and panel door

Posts

Rattle in frame and panel door

#1

Rattle in frame and panel door

JimG

I screwed up. I made some frame and panel doors for a pantry I am working on. The panels rattle. I put panel barrels in, but I guess they are not tight enough to keep the panel from rattling. I'm wondering if there is anything I can do short of making them over?

I cut the groove in the panel 1/2 in. The panels go in 1/4 in and the barrels are 1/4 in. Apparently the 1/2 in is too much. How deep should the grooves be to keep the panels tight and still allow putting the assembly together without bowing the frame?

Thanks, JimG

Re: Rattle in frame and panel door

#2

Re: Rattle in frame and panel door

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I've never used panel barrels or the other, similar devices; but I bet they're designed to be compressed very slightly on assembly (if at the end grain) or when the wood's at its narrowest (if on the side grain).

I take it you've glued the doors up and can't disassemble them to shim up your grooves. How much play is the between panel and frame? Is there enough room to cram some thin foam weatherstripping in (probably on the back side) with a putty knife?

Re: Rattle in frame and panel door

#3

Re: Rattle in frame and panel door

Thomas Norton

If the "rattle" is just side-side movement you might try pinning the panel on the back side of the door in the center.

Re: Rattle in frame and panel door

#4

Re: Rattle in frame and panel door

Dick Coers

I would center up the panel, then drill a small hole through the back of the rail into the panel. Then tap in a wood toothpick as a dowel. This will keep it centered, stop the rattle, and expansion will go out each way. Or you can wait, and there won't be any rattle this spring anyway.

Re: Rattle in frame and panel door

#5

I'm betting it is not side to side,

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

but a thickness of the edge, relative to the groove.

If you used a euro hinge like Blum, there are some soft closer mechanisms which just clip onto the top of the hinge, that slows the action down in the last couple of inches of closing. They are very cool, and make a noisy kitchen a lot more pleasant.

Re: Rattle in frame and panel door

#6

Dale Lenz

Do as Dick says but use a 1/4" dowel or so

Dale Lenz

Re: Rattle in frame and panel door

#7

Re: Do as Dick says but use a 1/4" dowel or so

Lee Brubaker

I suspect Keith's analysis of the problem is correct ie; rattle occurs when shutting the door hence the movement is front to back rather than side to side. I had this problem on a cabinet door & cut a very thin shim, centered the panel & pressed the shim in at the back between the panel & the side of the groove. End of rattle & it has been that way without further fussing for about 10 years.

Lee

Re: Rattle in frame and panel door

#8

Moses Yoder

Re: Soft Close

Moses Yoder

Blum now has hinges for full inset doors with the soft close mechanism built into the hinge. You can hardly tell the difference between the soft close hinge and a regular hinge until you shut the door. The built in soft close for overlay doors is due out somtime in the first part of 2011. Ultra Cool ;)

Re: Rattle in frame and panel door

#9

Re: Rattle in frame and panel door

Bill Tindall

put a short brad through the back of the frame and into the panel centered, top and bottom.

Wood doesn't expand length ways so the panel can be made to just fit the groove in that direction.

Re: Rattle in frame and panel door

#10

Re: Rattle in frame and panel door

JimG

Thanks all! I should have said the rattle is front to back. Guess I will try to shim it and see how it looks. If I don't like it, I can redo it.

JimG

Re: Rattle in frame and panel door

#11

Another shimming possibility

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

is cotton string - again, depending on how dramatic your gap is.

Re: Rattle in frame and panel door

#12

That is what I would do

Dan Donaldson

This would fix rattles in either direction. The panels will not move appreciably in the long dimension, so you can put a pin in both ends in the center.