Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

proof reading is a dying art?

Posts

Re: proof reading is a dying art?

#26

But yet and still,

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I'd rather have good content, written badly, than poor content, written well.

And this is from someone who was more or less adopted by the English department at my old job - and who serves, from time to time, as reader/commenter on an English-professor colleague's research papers.

Re: proof reading is a dying art?

#27

The completely depressing part

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

is that I pick up a word usage or grammatical error in about half of the Associated Press stories that our local paper prints. I would criticize the local paper, except these are buried in the middle of the text; and, in the modern world, in which papers are "typeset" electronically, I'm confident the article was just picked up from the AP feed and planted in the paper with the only editing being where to cut if off.

If the AP isn't even trying to maintain quality...

Re: proof reading is a dying art?

#28

Re: Woodcentral posts are easy...

FredD

"or because a respondent asks for a clarification which causes the original poster to put their inferiority complex on display in a spectacular, often colorful fashion".

That's right up there with " a steaming pile of prose" Jason ;-))

FredD

Re: proof reading is a dying art?

#29

Re: That's a good technique.

FredD

So , Bill did you or anybody catch the mangling of terms in the post I put up about the Female Journalist I know in Contra Costa county?

FredD

Re: proof reading is a dying art?

#30

Have to confess

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

that I missed the word choice, because I got stuck on the incoherence of the sentence.

Some of the particle physicists report that their equations describing how things work down there at the subatomic level work only if you assume time flows both ways*. So these were clearly quantum descendants, born long before their ancestors.

I just couldn't figure out if it was the (quantum) descendants or the Medieval times "...that did this for a living."

*I think it may be more accurate to state it as "nothing in the math requires that time flow forward." But I'm not a physicist, could play one only on a really bad cable TV show, and glazed over in high school math at sines/cosines/tangents.

Re: proof reading is a dying art?

#31

Ellis Walentine

You now have 2 hours to edit

Ellis Walentine

Remind me to change the FAQ file.

And, if you use Firefox as your browser, you get the built-in spell checker.

Ellis

Re: proof reading is a dying art?

#32

Re: Have to confess

FredD

Many miss that one Bill and about the sentence structure, that was the journalist's , not mine.

If you haven't , get a copy of Stephen Hawkins book "A Brief History of Time"

he gives a very simple explanation of how the Past , Present and Future exist at the same time.

FredD

Re: proof reading is a dying art?

#33

Re: But yet and still,

Steve Schoene

The problem is that often poor writing stems from flabby thinking. Knowledge not clearly communicated really isn't knowledge. (Knowledge isn't the same as motor skills, there certainly can be spectacularly skilled people who couldn't explain what they do in words to save their lives.)

Re: proof reading is a dying art?

#34

Re: But yet and still,

FredD

"there certainly can be spectacularly skilled people who couldn't explain what they do in words to save their lives".

Well that explains this , I always wondered why my Wife , though she knows how to get home, couldn't' explain it accurately enough so another person could get here.

You should over hear some of her directions on the phone to some poor person who has never been here. ;-))

I bet she isn't the only one with that problem either.

FredD

Re: proof reading is a dying art?

#35

Re: proof reading is a dying art?

Rob Scrimgeour

I caught this thread a little late, but I feel I have to share this one. Here in the southern region of South Africa we experienced a really bad drought earlier this year, and the local newspaper, (the George Herald) featured the situation as the lead story on the front page, with the sub-heading "Farmers are battling to keep their heads above water in one of the worst droughts to hit the region in 120 years"

Re: proof reading is a dying art?

#36

Well, there's your reason

Henry Higginbotham

Those damn farmers are hoarding all the water! Who do they think they are? Just go take it back. ;)