Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

proof reading is a dying art?

Posts

proof reading is a dying art?

#1

proof reading is a dying art?

FredD

Proofreading is a dying art, wouldn't you say?

Man Kills Self Before Shooting Wife and Daughter

This one I caught in the SGV Tribune the other day and called the Editorial Room and asked who wrote this. It took two or three readings before the editor realized that what he was reading was impossible!!! They put in a correction the next day.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I just couldn't help but send this along. Too funny.

Something Went Wrong in Jet Crash, Expert Says

Really? Ya think?

----------------------------------------------------------------------------

Police Begin Campaign to Run Down Jaywalkers

Now that's taking things a bit far!

-----------------------------------------------------------

Panda Mating Fails; Veterinarian Takes Over

What a guy!

---------------------------------------------------------------

Miners Refuse to Work after Death

No-good-for-nothing' lazy so-and-so's!

------------------------------------------------------

Juvenile Court to Try Shooting Defendant

See if that works any better than a fair trial!

----------------------------------------------------------

War Dims Hope for Peace

I can see where it might have that effect!

----------------------------------------------------------------

If Strike Isn't Settled Quickly, It May Last Awhile

Ya think?!

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

Cold Wave Linked to Temperatures

Who would have thought!

----------------------------------------------------------------

Enfield ( London ) Couple Slain; Police Suspect Homicide

They may be on to something!

------------------------------------------------------------------------

Red Tape Holds Up New Bridges

You mean there's something stronger than duct tape?

----------------------------------------------------------

Man Struck By Lightning: Faces Battery Charge

He probably IS the battery charge!

----------------------------------------------

New Study of Obesity Looks for Larger Test Group

Weren't they fat enough?!

-----------------------------------------------

Astronaut Takes Blame for Gas in Spacecraft

That's what he gets for eating those beans!

---------------- ---------------------------------

Kids Make Nutritious Snacks

Do they taste like chicken?

****************************************

Local High School Dropouts Cut in Half

Chainsaw Massacre all over again!

***************************************************

Hospitals are Sued by 7 Foot Doctors

Boy, are they tall!

*******************************************

And the winner is....

Typhoon Rips Through Cemetery; Hundreds Dead

Did I read that right?

***************************************************

------------------------------------------------------------------------------

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

No virus found in this incoming message.

Checked by AVG - www.avg.com

Version: 8.5.449 / Virus Database: 271.1.1/3219 - Release Date: 10/25/10 18:34:00

Re: proof reading is a dying art?

#2

Re: proof reading is a dying art?

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Good Afternoon Fred,

At one time I was a very good proof reader, but lack of practise eroded my skill. We had to do lots of technical writing, and the work was "dry"to say the least. The very first question I'd ask when somebody put a document in front of me for coordination was "did you proofread and spell check"?

Finding errors in correspondence used to drive me nuts. I could spot an error faster than anyone in the office, and people resent fault finding, even though it supported correspondence policy.

Once I found that somebody had made an error and had lied about it, I'd have them shot. :D Maybe it was a dying art!

George

Re: proof reading is a dying art?

#3

Wonderful, wonderful, wonderful!

Jim Dillon

Re: proof reading is a dying art?

#4

Re: proof reading is a dying art?

Jesse Cloud

I once worked in a large organization that was very careful with correspondence, but things still slipped through the cracks. In that job, I authored a memo to the Directors of the larger offices with details on an upcoming budget process. The memo was approved four levels above me and probably proofed by at least a dozen people. At the last minute, the secretary who was getting ready to mail the memos called me, laughing in spite of herself, to ask "Which are the large orifices?"

Boy, was I redfaced. At least I had a lot of company.

Re: proof reading is a dying art?

#5

Re: proof reading is a dying art?

FredD

>;-))

Re: proof reading is a dying art?

#6

Re: proof reading is a dying art?

John Pappas

While serving in the army many years ago, I was a personal clerk to a Brigadier General. In response to an invitaion to a party that he and his wife could not attend, I typed, "Mrs. B..and I regret that we will be able to attend your party." The General signed it, and it was ready to mail when the General's driver looked at it and suggested that we might not want to mail it as it was. Of course everyone agreed with the seargent.

Re: proof reading is a dying art?

#7

Re: proof reading is a dying art?

John Veerkamp

Poor proofreading and incorrect grammer of news casters are some of my pet peeves. I may be somewhat out of step with the times, but I still think that precision in speaking and writing are vital for good communication.

Re: proof reading is a dying art?

#8

Re: proof reading is a dying art?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I agree; incorrect grammer is a real problem. Almost as bad as poor speling.

Sorry, John - just couldn't resist that straight line you handed us all.

In my first assignment at my old job, we once sent out a job announcement specifying that the requirements included "good command of English grammar and speling." Multiple people proofread it, too.

Re: proof reading is a dying art?

#9

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

That's a good technique.

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Simply don't hire anyone who didn't catch the mistake and/or didn't point it out during their interview.

Jason

Re: proof reading is a dying art?

#10

Re: proof reading is a dying art?

Jim Dillon

John,

Speaking of writing, I thought I had seen it all until I read that there is an active movement afoot to eliminate the teaching of cursive writing skills. The proponents of this philosophy believe that today's child will be using a computer and have little need for learning how to write. This would also free up teachers to do more "important" things. Incredulous, I asked a recently retired middle-school teacher about this and she said that the movement is indeed true and growing. Needless to say, despite the deteriorating legibility of my own writing, I am on the other side of this. Getting old I guess.

Jim

Re: proof reading is a dying art?

#11

Moses Yoder

Grammar is spelled with an A

Moses Yoder

John, you spelled "grammar" wrong in your message. I usually just cut people some slack and ignore it, but my pet peeve is the popularity of using the word "seen" when people saw something. It is so bad that I was once corrected on this board for using the word "saw" and told it is supposed to be "seen". "I seen a cat the other day". Simply retarded. In fact, I could understand people using the word "seen" if they actually were mentally retarded but the fact is they are just ignorant usually.

Re: proof reading is a dying art?

#12

Re: Grammar is spelled with an A

John Veerkamp

See even us old farts are getting worse. Two errors in my own short message.

I'll just blame it on my poor typing .

John

Re: proof reading is a dying art?

#13

Ya-but

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

isn't it "funner" this way?

[talk about your pet peeves . . .] ;)

Re: proof reading is a dying art?

#14

A.J. Hamler

...and proofreading is one word   

A.J. Hamler

Re: proof reading is a dying art?

#15

Re: proof reading is a dying art?

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

Apparently, it is on this board. Some postings read like "stream-of-consciousness" prose and I have to suspend all the rules of spelling, grammar and punctuation in order to understand the poster's intent. Why should I have to struggle to understand someone's communication just because he can't be bothered to follow the one set of rules we have in common?

Re: proof reading is a dying art?

#16

Muphry's law in action

Alexandre Grigoriev

Re: proof reading is a dying art?

#17

Exactly

Henry Higginbotham

When you post something, you write it once (and maybe read it and then rewrite it, if the rest of us are lucky). Then, up to several hundred other people may waste time trying to decipher a steaming pile of prose written in all lower case with drive-by punctuation, missing words, curious spelling . . . the list could go on and on.

It wouldn't hurt anyone to put some basic effort into making a post readable. A standard, predictable language is what moves ideas and knowledge from your head to mine, and vice versa. We all make mistakes (and I make my share of 'em), but blowing the whole thing off isn't being "with the times," it's just laziness.

Re: proof reading is a dying art?

#18

"steaming pile of prose" is without a doubt

Bruce, a MN Galoot

some of the best imagery I've seen in a long time. :) Thanks for that!

BTW, while we're on the subject of spelling, inter alia, one of my personal favorites is the curious (mis)spelling of the word "hobbiest." Does this mean there's a "hobbier?"

Re: proof reading is a dying art?

#19

Re: proof reading is a dying art?

John Pappas

"Why should I have to struggle to understand someone's communication just because he can't be bothered to follow the one set of rules we have in common?"

Some very intelligent people are poor spellers. Language skills come easy for some, but not for others. A poster might be from a foreign country and his/her English may indeed be very good considering. These are just a few reeasons why I accept less than perfect posts. Keep in mind this is a woodworking website. For me, it's the content of the post.

Re: proof reading is a dying art?

#20

It's usually not hard to tell

Henry Higginbotham

It's usually not hard to tell who's trying and who's not. It is the content, but expecting everyone else to do your work for you (that is, expecting them to straighten out your mess when you could have done it yourself) is just ____. (Everyone feel free to fill in the blank with whatever blows your skirt up. :) )

Re: proof reading is a dying art?

#21

Re: That's a good technique.

FredD

You would be reducing your pool of prospective employees to a puddle Jason.

Consider that poor Spelling and Grammar are only a part of the equation , introduce Paragraph comprehension which was a part of our high school English course and you get news items like this.

I knew a Contra Costa Times female reporter who had a degree in Journalism report this when my Daughter was a eighth grade student.

She had interviewed a family of European Acrobats that had performed at the Circus in town that week and the head of the family she said " told her his family could trace their descendants back to Medieval times that did this for a living".

I run this item past my Daughter and asked her what was wrong with it and she said" what , Medieval times? Dad, that's just another one of your trick questions."

I got to ask the Principal of her School what did he think about reading in general and did he think that just reading a line was sufficient for a good grade or did they want you to understand what you read?

I also asked him in his school of about five hundred Students ,how did about three hundred and fifty get on the honor roll every six weeks and published in the local paper. Pitiful in a word.

FredD

Re: proof reading is a dying art?

#22

Re: It's usually not hard to tell

Steve Schoene

An edit function might help. I catch errors much better half an hour later--preview is too soon.

Re: proof reading is a dying art?

#23

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Woodcentral posts are easy...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

...to understand in general. I also frequent a truck repair forum for a certain brand, and have learned to wade through posts that would have gotten a first grader flunked.

Sometimes, though, there is no possibility of understanding the very worst posts, and those poor folk get called to the table on their inability to communicate. I have seen posts on said forum with upwards of one hundred words, most of them misspelled, no capitalization nor punctuation, nor any attempt to separate thoughts or phrases.

Posts on Woodcentral may as well have been written by a grammatical post-doctorate expert in comparison. The sad part is that those on the truck forum who post the absolutely unintelligible descriptions of their problem, end up getting mad because either no one helps them (the potential problem solvers don't understand the post and don't try), or because a respondent asks for a clarification which causes the original poster to put their inferiority complex on display in a spectacular, often colorful fashion.

Jason

Re: proof reading is a dying art?

#24

You CAN edit messages *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

If you'll take a minute to establish a profile (see link below to a recent post on the subject, including the link to how to do it), you can edit your messages for 30 minutes after posting. If you realize the problem 31 minutes after...well, you just need to practice saying, "Ooops!" a little faster.


See, here, explains why and links to how

Re: proof reading is a dying art?

#25

Clint Searl

Time ain't the problem....

Clint Searl

....ignorance is.

Clint