We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
How important is a tension meter for bandsaw blade
Joe Shelton
I use blades that vary from an eighth inch to one inch, and I never know whether I'm cranking too much pressure or not. My saw is a Laguna LT16HD, and has a tensioning scale, but the tech support at Laguna is too ponderous to clarify what the numbers mean.
Meanwhile, how valuable is it, long term, to use an actual gauge to measure tension? And what range of blade thickness and width will a typical gauge fit and work properly with?
Damn; didn't mean to dangle that participle; please excuse my crudity...
Joe
Re: How important is a tension meter for bandsaw blade
Re: How important is a tension meter for bandsaw b
JL
I tension my bandsaw by ear. I can recognize when I'm nearing the right "note" fairly easily. I have a general idea as to which "note" is correct for good performance (pun NOT intended).
You can buy a tension meter that will do about the same as your ear. I'm frugal - I'd prefer to spend my money on other tools.
Re: How important is a tension meter for bandsaw blade
Joe - you're going to get a ton of opinions on this one, so I'll be the first. On and off for about the last 5 years I've debated getting a tension gauge, about $100 + for a good one. I research and research and come to the same conclusion each time: it just ain't worth it. Tension guides on the saws are surprisingly accurate, particularly the more expensive models, and usually will get you close to the optimal setting.
Tension is a much debated subject with no real solution, but my solution has always been: Apply enough tension so that the blade produces the results you expect, make a note of the setting and use it again when you use that blade.
Now, I'm going to sit back and watch the debate.
Doug
Re: How important is a tension meter for bandsaw blade
The only person I ever knew that owned one was the Lenox technical rep. He thought one person among 50 should own one. Then it would be lent among the group to check/calibrate the tension gauge on each saw. One calibrated it would move on to the next participant never to be needed again. That statement ended my debate.
Re: How important is a tension meter for bandsaw blade
Re: How important is a tension meter for bandsaw b
Joe Shelton
Not sure I'm tough enough to do it that way...
I only have two ears; would I have to tune an eighth inch blade using my left ear, then the one inch with my right ear, and just extrapolate for everything between?
No, sorry, don't mean to be a complete smart aleck. But how about give me some more information. Surely you don't do this with the blade under power (or sacrifice an ear doing it), but there still are some gaps in what and how you do it: Blade in the guides, set as it will run? Max blade exposure vertically, or set for the cut you're about to make?
Thanks for your advice.
Joe
Re: How important is a tension meter for bandsaw blade
Re: How important is a tension meter for bandsaw b
Jesse Cloud
Looking forward to the debate.
Whether a tension gauge is worth the $$ begs an earlier question - what is the correct tension. I know woodworkers who produce great work who differ dramatically on this. Michael Fortune, for instance, uses relatively low tension, while others use very high. I have a friend whose rule of thumb is tighten it as hard as you can then give one more push. One blade maker says to tighten it just until the flutter goes away while another gives a precise tension recommendation. Somehow, people use all these methods successfully.
Personally, I lean toward the high tension method, but if thats not getting me the results I seek, I have loosened up on the tension and gotten better results. Doesn't always work. I'm convinced there are gremlins at work here.
For what its worth, I don't own a tension gauge and its not on my Christmas list.
Re: How important is a tension meter for bandsaw blade
Re: How important is a tension meter for bandsaw b
Jon Weisenbach
I had a 14" griz with the riser block for the last 11 years and the simple instructions given on Timberwolf's website is flawless in it's simplicity and no tension gear needed. Try it once and follow it to the fullest and you'll never be sorry!
Re: How important is a tension meter for bandsaw b
JL
But how about give me some more information. Surely you don't do this with the blade under power (or sacrifice an ear doing it), but there still are some gaps in what and how you do it: Blade in the guides, set as it will run? Max blade exposure vertically, or set for the cut you're about to make?
The blade is not under power. It is under tension though. The blade is set in the guides, set as it will run. What I do though is "strum" the blade on the side away from the guides. This is a fairly long "string" that is not "stopped" by guides, thrust bearings or dust collector rubber collars. It is totally reproducible. My 1/2" blade that is in my 18" Rikon saws best at A-flat. (Yes, I have a pitch pipe that I use for singing.)
As I said, you have a fairly long "string". The "string" or blade is going to vibrate quite nicely between the upper and lower wheels. The tension is going to control the "pitch" of the "string".
Re: How important is a tension meter for bandsaw blade
I've never felt the need to tension a bandsaw blade accurately. For one thing, there are several schools of thought as to how much tension is "correct." I'm partial to the low-tension school, with proponents like Art Gschwind of Suffolk Machinery. His definition of tension is "the minimum amount of STRETCH you must apply to the body of the band to make it stable." He details his methodology for tensioning his blades on the Suffolk Machinery website. Worth a read.
Personally, I set my upper blade guide at its highest point and tension the blade until the blade feels tight enough. I gauge it with moderate finger pressure against the side of the blade, halfway between the guides. A deflection of about 1/4" usually works fine. I really don't think it's critical.
Ellis
Re: How important is a tension meter for bandsaw blade
Re: How important is a tension meter for bandsaw b
Jim Dillon
Joe,
The closest I have come to a tension gauge is to buy one of the aftermarket tension springs, then set the tension according to the marks on the band saw. On my older Delta 14-incher, this seems to work just fine and I ended up in the same ball-park as when I followed the good guidance at Timberwolf's site (I use their blades as well). I've occasionally thought about buying a tension gauge when I had a little extra cash, or making the one described in FWW, but couldn't justify the purchase as it looked like a solution for a problem I wasn't having.
Jim
Re: How important is a tension meter for bandsaw blade
Re: How important is a tension meter for bandsaw b
David Hay Denver
If you read Mark Duginske's The Bandsaw Book, he recommends tensioning the blade properly, as one of the many adjustments that affect the cut (IIRC).
However, I had a thought this morning that makes me believe that tension isn't super important. If you think about how a band saw works, the motor is usually attached to the bottom wheel. This means that the bandsaw is pulling the blade through the wood. This isn't much different than the various Japanese pull saws. I've always heard that one of the main reasons pull saws can be so thin is because the work on the pull stroke. I would guess that the blade on a pull saw doesn't have much tension (but I could be wrong about that).
Obviously the analogy doesn't completely work, as pull saws are much wider than a band saw blade. But something to think about.
David
Re: How important is a tension meter for bandsaw blade
If you want to try out a tension gauge make one yourself. Loosen the blade tension. Get a digital micrometer. Set it at a 5 inch (or six inch) span. Lock it. Then attach the two arms to the bandsaw blade with small C clamps. Then zero the digital readout and unlock the micrometer. As you tension the blade the digital micrometer will measure the stretch of the blade. I don't remember the conversion between blade stretch and tension, but you can find it in an article in Fine Woodworking archives.
Sorry for the lack of specific details. I'm not at home and don't have access to the original article so I don't have the numbers for setting up the micrometer or interpreting the stretch results.
For what it's worth, I use the Suffolk method and it works for me.
Good luck.
Re: How important is a tension meter for bandsaw blade
As has been mentioned before, there are too many people getting excellent results with their bandsaws using low tension, high tension, and everything in between for tension to be a critical factor. I used to crank the blade tension as high as I could. I've since come around to Michael Fortune's method of bandsaw set up. He advocates blade tension on the lower end of the spectrum. He uses the 1/4" deflection with moderate pressure from a finger as a good amount of tension to have.
Of course, the $64K question is, "What's moderate pressure?" I had the chance to ask him this, and he defined it as low enough pressure so that your finger doesn't turn white when you push on the bandsaw blade.
Regardless of the results with low or high blade tension, I have seen one benefit to reducing the tension on my bandsaw. It seems to run smoother with less tension on the blade. I have to believe this has to do with less lateral force being placed on the bandsaw wheel bearings, and also due to less flex placed on the spine of the bandsaw.
Re: How important is a tension meter for bandsaw blade
I never felt the need for a Tension meter though they may have their place in doing comparison tests.
What I did do was install a after market Tension release made by Carter. I set the tension to be released for 1/2" and never have changed it for different sizes.
It greatly speeds up blade changes and the Tension is alwasy the same.
I had thought for a while about Tension and the fact that it is a strain on the blade and machine and the fact that the worst sort of strain is a steady one , therefore the Carter Tension release with it's three step device made sense to me and I recommend it.
FredD
Re: How important is a tension meter for bandsaw blade
His technique, somewhat akin to JL's above, is to set the saw up as it will run. Bearings at correct gap, blade at a tension level you feel to be correct.
Then, with power disconnected, open the the saw's case and attempt to deflect the blade on the side away from the bearings (ie, on the blade's ascending run). This manipulation should occur at the mid-point of the run, as nearly as you can manage.
Irrespective of blade width, look for lateral deflection of about 3/8". He says that 1/4" is too tight.
He didn't say anything about the "white knuckle" effect of your pushing on the blade. I infer that to be the part where I learn something.
Thanks to everyone for responding. And I'm grateful to the Laguna rep for the call, and the informative discussion.