Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

OK, So Who sets the nails in interior trim?

Posts

OK, So Who sets the nails in interior trim?

#1

OK, So Who sets the nails in interior trim?

Barry Irby

My son and I are working on a house I bought at foreclosure. He has worked as a helper for a friend of his who does trim carpentry in new houses. He says he has never seen his friend set a nail in interior trim. He assumes the nail guns set most of them, but if they don't, he does not set them.

I thought the trim carpenter set the nails and the painters only set a few the carpenters missed. So, do the painters set them or the carpenters?

Re: OK, So Who sets the nails in interior trim?

#2

Re: OK, So Who sets the nails in interior trim?

Thomas Norton

As a Carpenter/Woodworker I set all my nails. But on occasion I do miss a few.

Re: OK, So Who sets the nails in interior trim?

#3

Re: OK, So Who sets the nails in interior trim?

Larry in NW OHIO

Barry I`m not a pro, but what ever I do I try and do the job I am doing I do it right. If I`m putting finish nails in, I make sure they are set. That is the job of the person that is nailing. Larry

Re: OK, So Who sets the nails in interior trim?

#4

Ellis Walentine

Carpenter's job

Ellis Walentine

...BUT, the painter owes it to the client to deliver a good job, even if it means he has to set and putty exposed nail heads if the carpenter doesn't. They can all argue over who should be paid for doing it, but if the painter is working on an hourly basis, it prob ably doesn't matter to him. If it's a contract, he can put in a change order to cover the additional time and materials.

This is just the way I used to handle matters like this. Ask FredD how they handled it in California.

Ellis

Re: OK, So Who sets the nails in interior trim?

#5

Re: OK, So Who sets the nails in interior trim?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

"He says he has never seen his friend set a nail in interior trim."

Doesn't make it right. The number of times one trade passes a problem along to another could not be counted unless you're counting in trillions. I bet the painters aren't buying your son's friend any Christmas presents.

Re: OK, So Who sets the nails in interior trim?

#6

Clint Searl

They're both the same guy in this house

Clint Searl

Re: OK, So Who sets the nails in interior trim?

#7

Re: Carpenter's job

del schisler

easy answare you put the trim up . You set the mail's ! Oh you might miss a few but if he was doing my job he would set the nail's. Or this would be last for me. Now if i were the painter i would have to set a few i would say something but not asking for more money but if you were a contractor this may have sone effect on future job's ??? my 2 cent

Re: OK, So Who sets the nails in interior trim?

#9

Not Who, What

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

All trim in my house (installed since it was built) is "gunned", so it's all one operation.

Who fills the sets? He who put'em there.

Re: OK, So Who sets the nails in interior trim?

#10

Moses Yoder

Re: Senco

Moses Yoder

A good Senco gun will set almost 100% of the nails but I have noticed the cheaper brands are more like 90%.

Re: OK, So Who sets the nails in interior trim?

#11

Re: Senco

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Since my FP-25 will drive 2" brads, works just fine for casings and baseboard. I only pull out the finish gun (Bostich) for heavier things like jambs.

Re: OK, So Who sets the nails in interior trim?

#12

Finish the job . . .

steve mackay

you started. If you're installing the nails, finnish the job. The finnisher holds a hammer, the painter holds a brush.

Re: OK, So Who sets the nails in interior trim?

#13

Ellis Walentine

Not the universal rule

Ellis Walentine

I'd say it is up to the carpenter to set the nails, but not necessarily to fill the holes. The most experienced painter who ever worked for me insisted on filling the nail holes in trim work. He was a German guy who could fill holes quickly and invisibly. I think he was using some kind of plumbers putty colored with universal colorant. He preferred to do it himself, since it was so quick, and then he didn't have to worry about salvaging the carpenter's ham-fisted attempt at filling them.

The message might be to assess the skills of your team and figure out the best way to get a good job with the least hassle.

Ellis

Re: OK, So Who sets the nails in interior trim?

#14

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

I agree. *LINK*

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Locally, it's the painter's job to fill the holes without question on painted trim. I don't want to sand off unnecessary gobs of some super-tough spackle that I would never dream of using.

With a stained trim package, it can go either way, though most carpenters I know try to avoid it.

Aw, heck, despite my "no comment" pledge above, I'll comment on setting nails. It's the carpenter's job. Period. If they're hand-nailing, they would be setting every one, so why not when they use a pneumatic nailer? And, if they're using a pneumatic nailer, what percentage of nails left proud is acceptable? 1%? 5%? 50%? Nobody would stand for the last, nor should they accept the first. I've done enough trim work to know that it's a quick double-check to look for proud nails. I have refused to continue on a job prepping trim for paint when I found too many nails left proud. A carpenter subsequently spent the better part of an afternoon setting nails. Now, I'm less likely to get bent out of shape because I bought one of the thingies in the link below. Works great, and easy to keep with me.

Jason


Spring Tool Nail Set

Re: OK, So Who sets the nails in interior trim?

#15

Oh, I agree there . . .

steve mackay

IMHO filling-in is prep for painting and should be done to his satisfaction. His paint job is "on the line".

Re: OK, So Who sets the nails in interior trim?

#16

Re: Not the universal rule

FredD

Well Ellis , your right and to expand on a couple of things.....

It's the Carpenters job to set nails , regardless of the State your living in.

Many times it's pushed off on Painters by a shoddy, badly run job , I wouldn't allow it for a minute, good Painters are hard to find.

You wouldn't hire a Painter to hang trim anymore then you would expect the Carpenter to Paint the house. Union run jobs rarely have that problem because of Jurisdictional agreements.

About the old timer using Putty , you observed a trick long gone nowadays because of the invention of quick setting , lightweight Spackle by Red Devil.

The Painter took a lump of oil based Painters Putty and if it needed tinting , did that and rolled the putty into a ball about the size of a Golf ball, pressed it against the nail hole and slid a thin bladed putty knife under it so fast it looked like Magic.

With the Red Devil , anybody can do a acceptable job of filling nail holes and cracks and run right back and hit it a swipe with sandpaper.

After a little practice , you can fill so evenly that sanding is not needed.

FredD

Re: OK, So Who sets the nails in interior trim?

#17

Re: I agree.

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

My son actually sets his guns so the nail's left a little proud and sets it by hand. This way he can be sure he hit something with the nail. He started it with sheathing nailing, and just kind of adopted it in more areas as he found its virtues.

Slower, maybe; but his work is high quality, and a painter in the area (15 years his elder) suggests him whenever he gets on a paint job that reveals carpentry problems, because he so enjoys the painting after my son's done. Not that I'm a proud dad or anything.