Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Dc Piping Revisited......

Posts

Dc Piping Revisited......

#1

Jesper, Denmark

Dc Piping Revisited......

Jesper, Denmark

In the past, I believe that plastic piping was deemed OK for dust collection piping.

I am revamping my system with a new 4 kW blower, sucking through a pre-separator, cobbled together from a Jet DC 1200 tangential inlet, on a steel drum, followed by a pleated filter before the blower.

Mmetal piping will be about twice as expensive as plastiv sewage pipe.

Anyone with plastic piping, any problems with sparks etc.?

Did you run a grounding wire through the piping?

Re: Dc Piping Revisited......

#2

Re: Dc Piping Revisited......

Andy Wright - Allen, TX

been running PVC pipe for several years, and no issues here. I dont have any of my machines grounded, and don't have issues with getting shocked.

Static electricity build-up will vary a lot based on the atmosphere where you are located. I am sure that if I were located in a dry climate then it woul dbe a bigger problem. The best practice is to ground everything, but I can honestly say that after running PVC in two different shops for 10 years I can count the number of times I've been shocked on one hand and that is out of thousands of times I have used my DC.

Re: Dc Piping Revisited......

#3

Re: Dc Piping Revisited......

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

Ungrounded plastic sewer piping in the shop for 10 years: no sparks, no shocks, ever. I do get some electrostatic dust accumulation on the pipes themselves, but I figure that's okay since it serves as an additional ambient air cleaner.

Re: Dc Piping Revisited......

#4

Re: Dc Piping Revisited......

Larry in NW OHIO

Jesper Ever since I started with DC I used PVC or S&D and that must have been 15+ years and have had no problems at all. There is a guy that use to post here years ago that works at MIT or some place like that, I forget, that did reserch on it and came up with no problems with it, I`ll try to find it and let you know the site, unless someone beet`s me to it. We use to email back and forth for a while but sort of got away from it. This will be a good chance to try and find out what he and his family is doing. Also there is no use to ground it eighter. Larry

Re: Dc Piping Revisited......

#5

Plastic OK for one person shops.. *LINK*

Grant in Iowa

This has been rehashed here numerous times. There are concerns with static electricity creating a spark and thus a dust fire/ explosion. The only known occurances of this are MUCH larger industrial systems.

You CANNOT ground an insulator, it is simply not possible. What you can do is ground any metal blast gates or equipment contacting the plastic in an effort to prevent them from building up an electrical charge. Your tools should already be grounded to the shops electrical ground.

Make sure you are happy with where your tools are located before you build permanent ducting. Better to work a year or so with a long flexible hose than to have to change the ducting because the tools are in the wrong places.

Look for Sewer and Discharge pipe and fittings, as they will be cheaper than PVC designed for pressurized use. Plumbing supply houses will carry these in a larger selection than a home center.

Go easy on any glues so you can reconfigure as your tools change or move. some use no glue, some use a small amount of silicone just to seal a joint.

Design your ductwork of an appropriate size for your blower capacity. Not larger, not smaller else you may suffer from inadequate flow. For more on this and an exhaustive bunch of related info see the Bill Pentz website linked below.

Regards,

Grant in Iowa<---needs to assemble ducting too.


Bill Pentz on Dust collection

Re: Dc Piping Revisited......

#6

Re: Dc Piping Revisited......

Bob in NE Ohio

I have used it in three different home shops from 350 to 700 sq ft since 1982 without an issue. Glue and caulk on every joint with a minimum of 90s and blast gates at every outlet keeps everything working fine.

Bob in NE Ohio

Re: Dc Piping Revisited......

#7

Mythbusters

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

The Mythbusters did an excellent job of debunking the static charge on PVC a couple of years ago. From their results web site:

A construction worker accidentally killed himself with static charge after sandblasting an 8 foot PVC pipe.

BUSTED

No static charge built up on the pipe in initial testing. Even after they were converted into a Van de Graaff generator and a Leyden jar, the amount of static electricity produced was too small to actually kill a person. The original circumstances of the myth preclude any significant static buildup � resting the pipe on metal jack stands allows the pipe to discharge to the ground while sand in the air from the sandblasting can dissipate static charge the same way humidity can.

Re: Dc Piping Revisited......

#8

Static or not to static

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

I use pvc drain piping for my DC system and initially there was some static charge in the pipes as they came from the store. This dissipated over a few days as the pipes became a bit dusty. At first I notice a bit of dust clinging to the out side of the pipes in a few areas, but now there is none. I've never been zapped by the buildup. My pvc system is totally ungrounded. All my tools have their three wire plugs and are grounded.

Lee

Re: Dc Piping Revisited......

#9

I guess I'm the Lone Exception

Ken Krawford

I've been using 6" PVC for about 8 years connecting a Bill Pentz inspired cyclone w/ 5 hp motor. When I grab the aluminum blast gate to disconnect from my wide belt sander, I can get a fairly good pop. It seems to be proportional to the length of the the machine has run and ambient humidity. After reading the other posts, I may try grounding my blast gate.

Re: Dc Piping Revisited......

#10

I may be wrong... but...

Scott in Montana

I may be wrong, but I believe the major hazard is not that of an electrical shock, but that of a dust explosion within the system.

And I do know that if you take a dustpan full of sawdust out of the tablesaw and toss it onto a flame, there's a very good chance you will loose your eyebrows... Don't ask me how I know this!

Scott in Montana

Re: Dc Piping Revisited......

#11

Dr. Ron Coles Website

Marvin R. Horn

The website mentioned above is:

http://home.comcast.net/~rodec/woodworking/articles/DC_myths.html

Re: Dc Piping Revisited......

#12

Good Reason

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Not to have a flame burning inside your dust collector! :D

A home DC is not a grain elevator; the piping makes no difference in safety unless, of course, the diameter is too large or too small for the blower. Insufficient air flow from either condition will allow saw dust to accumulate in the pipe. Depending on the run length, smoking hot dust coming off a saw blade could ignite in the bag or the duct. If you're getting smoke off you blade in a cut, it's just good practice to check your DC bag for any smoldering remnants.

Re: Dc Piping Revisited......

#13

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Dc Piping Revisited......

Jesper, Denmark

Thanks Guys, helpful as always.

Plastic piping it is.

Re: Dc Piping Revisited......

#14

Small Suggestion

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Tape (do NOT glue) your joints. If you get something stuck in the piping, you be happier not having to cut pipe to clean out.

Re: Dc Piping Revisited......

#15

Re: Small Suggestion

Barry Irby

I absolutely agree with all those who are in favor of plastic ducting. I have had it in my one man shop for five or more years without a problem with static electricity. There are problems with S&D pipe. It was only available in two sizes, 4" & 6" at the local borg and there were relatively few fittings, but it was substantially cheaper than the plumbing grade version. It is lighter in weight and much easier to handle. There are sleeves or adapter rings that allow the use of plumbing grade fittings with S&D, but some of the more complex fittings were four times as much as the simpler S&D ones so I stuck with the cheaper ones. I did things like use a Wye and 45 rather than a Tee and two 45's rather than an elbow.

I also strongly agree with Mark about leaving the system dry fitted or unglued. I have pulled one or two joints apart more than once to retrieve slivers of wood that got into the system and turned cross ways. And you never know when the urge might strike you to add to or rearrange the system. I have detected almost no loses at fully assembled joints. I have been tempted to get a smoke generator and check them out, but there is no obvious reason. If you must, get some really cheap caulking and caulk the ends of the fittings to the pipes. (Cheap so that you can remove it later.) Trust me, something will come up. My son vac-ed up something and turned the system off and was sure it did not go through the impeller. Sure enough, we found it laying in the last straight run about a foot from sure death. This might be a clear advantage of a cyclone over the other version. The stuff does not go through the impeller on a cyclone.

Re: Dc Piping Revisited......

#16

Re: Dc Piping Revisited......

John Veerkamp

I have had S&D in my shop for 11 years. Never shock or static problem. I did glue some joints, but several critical places I dry fitted the joints and used short self tapping screws to secure the joint. This way if I need to reconfigure or retrieve it is no problem. I have no detectable loss at these joints. Plumbing supply houses have a much wider variety of S&D fittings.