We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
I am in the process of completing the arts and crafts nightstand in Issue 159 of Wood Magazine. I like the idea of making the joints dovetailed on the drawer, but was wondering if that would diminish the arts and craft style of this piece of furniture. Any opinions or comments would be greatly appreciated.
Why diminish? I don't know that particular piece but dovetails were a standard joinery method for Arts and Crafts furniture such as that of Gustav Stickley. Sometimes even hand made dovetails on what is mostly factory furniture in an age where most factories would have used machine cut dovetails.
It's likely WOOD magazine that has simplified them away. Their designs are typically meant for beginning and intermediate woodworkers in terms of construction methods.
We just had a program and class taught by some some folks from a shop that does reproduction period furniture. Many times they used the word "copy", which is a foreign concept to me when it comes to furniture making. When they do a reproduction they faithfully copy the piece right down to the species of all the wood used, joinery, hardware etc. There could be all sorts of reasons to copy a piece, ranging from wanting an exact copy so that the outrageously valuable original can be sold, to making a copy because the builder lacks the confidence or talent to make design or construction modifications.
So, to answer your question you need to know why you are building this piece. Is your reason for building it compatible with making design changes? Do you have the experience and confidence to make changes that will result in an attractive piece that has reliable construction? The bottom line is if you need a nightstand and you are inspired by the original, make anything that pleases you, and make it with any joinery that will be reliable. Who would criticize a well executed result?
Well Colonel You did very well on making the reproductions, especially with the originals you had to work with. One of them looks great, but the other, well lets say looks a little well worn. I`ll tell you, you have a great looking family. Larry
Bill you can be sure that Wood Magazine didn't have any goal in publishing exact reproduction plans. They put together something easy to build, "in the style of" Arts and Crafts. Changing such plans should require no gnashing of teeth or detailed introspection. And, in general, most arts and crafts furniture, despite the "return to simple craftsmanship" philosophy of the underlying movement, was mass produced factory furniture. Of course it is the exceptions to the factory production that provide some of the most interesting and rare examples--examples that may be worth reproducing accurately just as a means of "getting into the head" of craftsmen of former days.
"There could be all sorts of reasons to copy a piece, ranging from wanting an exact copy so that the outrageously valuable original can be sold, to making a copy because the builder lacks the confidence or talent to make design or construction modifications. "
Or you might be making eight matched dining chairs or Kitchen cabinets for a Duplex , did I mention fourplex?
There are in this world of woodcraft, pieces that are so good in design and execution that you would only degrade the piece by trying to "improve it" . Sam Maloof's Rocking chairs come to mind.
I have seen many copies or reproductions of Philadelphia High Boys that were faithful to the original concept in design and execution and the craftsmen ranged from Hobbyists to custom Furniture Makers and I believe the skill needed to do this would not embarrass anybody .
Faithful reproductions I also think need more attention to detail and a higher skill level , then drawing a plan and taking a pile of wood and cutting out everything that is not in the plan.
On a much larger scale I have supervised the building of subdivisions whose models and the subsequent production houses had buyers running back and forth with tapes to make sure they got every square inch the contract called for right down to the exact shade of paint and texture of Carpet.
Gosh, I would not hesitate at all to use dovetails for the drawer construction in an A&C-style piece for the simple reason(s) that they are incredibly strong, fun to do, and just plain cool looking. If you have never done dovetails, I would practice a bit on scrap wood of the same thickness and type as your drawer. Otherwise, go for it!
In Bob Lang's books of measured drawings of Craftsman furniture, virtually all the Stickley (Gustav and L.& J.G.) stuff has dovetailed drawers. My copy of Gustav's "Making Authentic Craftsman Furniture" calls for dovetails, too. However, Greene and Greene used a box-joint style for drawer construction.