We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
I have a reasonably sizeable glueup to do, a total of 10 loose tenons -- each 3" wide, for a queen headboard. That's a fair amount of glue to apply, though not large, but I need to wrestle some big pieces of wood around.
Plus I have to exercise some care; all finishing will be done so some soft-sided cauls will be involved.
About 4 weeks away, so I have time to order any recommended glue.
I'm not enthused about mixing up that much epoxy, but if that's the consensus, that's what I'll do. I want at least 20 minutes of nonbinding open time, and I don't care how long it takes to set. Temperature shouldn't be an issue here in TX, but if it is I'll fire up a heater.
... or Stephen Shepherd -- or me for that matter -- I'd suggest liquid hide glue. Patrick makes his own and sells it as Old Brown Glue. You can order it directly from him.
You can take as much time as you like, without feeling rushed.
I have to wonder if anybody besides me has ever experienced the panic of having tightbond glue grab before getting the joints closed. I hate that feeling.
Epoxy acts like a lubricant while assembling, and isn't bothered by a bit of movement as long as it is still in a liquid or early jell state, which can be a couple of hours if you need that much time. Just keep it cool.
I have and use both Titebond liquid hide glue and Patrick's Old Brown Glue. They're both great for extended glue-ups. I just did a complicated glue-up of the cubbyholes for a wine cabinet, 38 joints, multiple clamps and very little time, and I was able to adjust it for a long time, maybe the 3/4 hour it took to get everything together. After about a little over a day, however, forget about moving anything because it's set for good. That would be my only caution, it needs to stay clamped for a day.
One added bonus is that clean-up with liquid hide glue is superb. It just takes water and a toothbrush, no matter when you get around to cleaning it.
I have no experience with hide glue, but when I consider the facts that its been around forever, isn't currently on many store shelves, has relatively short shelf life in liquid form, and is water dissolvable after it sets, I don't get inspired with confidence. Does mere humidity weaken this stuff? I'm guessing yes, and humidity is in long supply here.
I live in the mountains of North GA. Before I moved up here, I lived near Atlanta. I think you can make a point that Atlanta has a LOT of humidity. I have a few chairs that have survived Atlanta summers out on my old porch.
Hide glue is not usually available at Home Depot, Lowes or hardware stores - but a lot of woodworking stores still carry it. It has a finite shelf life because it is a protein "solution" - but as long as you buy small bottles and use reasonably close to the expiration date, you should be good.
I've "redissolved" hide glue - but that takes hot water or steam - not cold water or humidity.
If you are making a reasonably close fitting joint and not trying to bridge any gaps, hide glue is preferable in most cases. It is also a LOT easier to clean up on a piece or from your hands.
Ron, I'm in the process of building a king-size headboard for a client. I plan to use Titebond liquid hide glue for it. In fact, I've been using it more and more as my "go-to" glue. As long as it won't be in a bathroom, outdoors, or any other place where the environment is extra moist, it works just fine.
I think once you've tried it you will like it. As someone mentioned, due to its shelf life you're wise to purchase in smaller amounts. I use enough in my shop in the course of a year that I can buy larger bottles and be okay. If you've ever glued something together only to realize it was wrong and you needed to pull it apart, you'll really appreciate the way hide glue allows you to do this even after it dries.
I'm with Keith. I buy West System Epoxy. It's easy to mix. I have both slow and rapid hardener so I can mix it as I need it. The slow hardener gives you enough time to go and have lunch in the middle of a glue up if the weather isn't too hot. It's very thin as mixed from the can so I purchased some thickener to go with it. You can make it as thick as you want.
I had to glue 24 spindles into 2 rings so I thickened the epoxy so it wouldn't run. This let me glue all 24 into 1 ring and then flip it over line the up with the holes in the other ring.
Clean up is easy. After everything was clamped I just wiped around each spindle with alcohol or actetone. Furniture wax acts as a resist and the epoxy can easily be scraped off of any surface that you don't want contaminated.
The claim that hide glue reversability is unique has been repeated, apparently without testing, so many times that it has become accepted as fact by nearly everyone.
I was told by an experienced furniture conservator/restorer that he experienced no difference in the ability to disassemble a hide glue joint compared to a PVA (white or yellow) joint. Indeed, to confirm this claim I steamed a mortise and tenon joint assembled with yellow glue and it came apart easily. I should have known this would be the case as it readily washes out of clothing, or paint brushes, with hot water.
Most of the claims of superiority of hide glue are not supported by fact. There are good reasons that it is not used as widely as PVA glues. However, in the case of joint assembly it does have the advantage of a long assembly time and it seems to "grease" joints like mortise and tenon better during sliding together than the more "grabby" PVA glues. And, experienced hands, it is certainly adequate for any other common woodworking need. If one does a lot of complex assembly and prefers to settle on one glue, hide glue is a good choice. Ditto for shops doing faithful reproduction work or repair. That said, most shops don't use it, or need to use it.
Re: The myth of hide glue reversability uniqueness
David Yoho
I use more hide glue in my shop because I also do repair and restoration work in addition to building new work. I don't use steam or see a real need to in the work I encounter. I've found that simply using a brush to apply hot vinegar or water to a joint where hide glue is used does an adequate job.
I'd be willing to bet an old joint glued with hide glue comes apart sooner than one done with yellow glue with the method I use. But then there's another part to this issue and that's putting the joint back together. If yellow glue was used you'd need to remove as much of the old as possible before applying new. With hide glue that's not necessary as new will stick to the old just fine.
I figured I'd end up with a stronger epoxy vote -- not that this is a democracy thank goodness -- but the old guard has me thinking that I have an appropriate project for trying hide glue for the first time.
It's not a finalized decision yet, but a heavy possibility. Thanks to everyone for weighing in. Some of you took extra time to write really nice opinions, with details I wasn't aware of. What a great place.
Re: The myth of hide glue reversability uniqueness
Steve Schoene
David makes some good points. Another other point is that even liquid hide glue makes joints that are virtually as strong as Titebond, according to Titebond's specification. Of course, hot hide glue, while not providing the same open time ease as liquid, is even stronger. (What PVA glue will bond so firmly to glass that when it shrinks as it cures it breaks chips out of the glass rather than letting go? Well, there is hide glue that will do that, and there is "glue chip glass" sold commercially .) Hide glue is also great for rubbed joints, and of course don't forget hammer veneering--lay veneer without mechanical or vacuum presses.
Glue has two "open time" times. One is how long can the joint be exposed to air before the joint is closed up. If the joint is open too long the surface of the glue dries and it will not bond properly. Temperature and humidity and glue composition most affect this time. If you want longer time work at low temperature and high humidity. If one is organized, it is rare that this time would be exceeded in assembly unless it was exceptionally hot and dry.
The second time, usually 2-3 times longer than the first time, is how long after the joint is closed can the joint be coaxed into position before it sets up rigid. This time is most affected by lumber moisture content, as it is diffusion of water into the wood that results in the glue curing. These times for regular Titebond are 5&10 min. for a total "open time of 15 min. under "average" conditions, what ever "average" is. This time can be extended considerably by adding NO MORE than 5% water. For Titebond Extend the times are 5&15 min. I didn't get data for liquid hide.
It strikes me that if you think you need 20 min to assemble something you lack confidence, experience, practice, and/or a sound assembly strategy. Do a dry fit and see how long it really takes. Get an assistant to help apply glue and use an application technique that is efficient- small brush or spatula for example. Regular yellow or white spreads easily and quickly with a brush, while hide doesn't. Hide spreads nicely with a spatula.
Bill said: "It strikes me that if you think you need 20 min to assemble something you lack confidence, experience, practice, and/or a sound assembly strategy."
Perhaps all of the above is too true. But if I have 20 minutes, I don't need any of the things I'm lacking. From the input received on WoodCentral, it looks like $15 buys me a glue with more than 20 minutes. Those other things can't be obtained with $15 or even $1500.
I was going to add something that Bill already indicated in his response and I think it is an important step that is all too often neglected. Whenever you have a difficult or complex glue-up on a project, it's wise to make a dry run first.
Have all your parts laid out in a manner you find easiest to work with. Just knowing this before starting is important. Next, practice assembly in the order you think best. It's possible you may learn there's a better way than you originally imagined and that will save you time and mistakes during the real deal. Before starting be sure you have everything you need close at hand. I always have the glue, applicator, clamps, and semi-wet sponges ready before I start. Knowing which clamps you'll need and having them ready will also make thing go smoother.
A dry run is the best way to smoke out trouble before it stikes when it matters. It would be a pain to discover you've just about completed your glue-up and something was cut wrong or a joint doesn't go together like it should. Dry fitting your parts is always a smart thing to do.
I have been following this thread, as I usually do when it comes to the discussion of glues. I think it is well known that I am a devoted protein glue supporter. One of the reasons is that it has worked so well for thousands of years. Another is its ability to bond with both mechanical and molecular strength, unlike any synthetic glue (that includes epoxy). More importantly is its ability to be "reversible".
The reversibility of protein glues is not well understood. Some wonder, why is that important? Besides the repair issue, it is important when joints break and you need to remove the old glue. With synthetic glues you must remove the glue using chisels and that also will remove wood. With protein glue, you can remove the old glue by applying a hot rag compress. The glue is only reversible when both water and heat are applied to the surface of the glue.
To talk about open or working time is so individual as to be useless. Each project has its assembly procedure. Each shop has its environment. Each worker has his method and tools. Too many variables.
Some of the most difficult assembly projects I have done are chairs. Many or these chairs have been broken over and over, each time repaired by different workers with different glues. Pieces are usually lost or do not fit properly. The last project was 8 gothic chairs which had been glued together with buckets of Gorilla glue and not clamped properly, including stretchers upside down. Horrible.
The proper method is to clean off all the synthetic glue of all the elements and begin to glue each part to the next, over several days. It is not practical to glue the entire chair at once, but systematically in stages.
The working time of Old Brown Glue is extended by heating it up to 120 degrees. I put the liquid glue in a small plastic cup which floats on a larger plastic bucket of hot water. From time to time I change the water. Hot tap water is fine. Using this method I can work for a long time to assemble projects.
Remember, with protein glues, if the glue gels you will have a "cold solder joint" so you need to just wipe off the gelled glue with a hot rag and apply fresh hot glue to continue.
The most impressive thing about liquid protein glues, besides their strength, is how easy it is to clean up.
I refer to my SAPFM article, "Why Not Period Glue?" which is on my Consulting page of my website.
Re: The myth of hide glue reversability uniqueness
FredD
Right on in every point David and any shop or person that does a lot of chair repair will tell you it is far easier when the Chair was initially assembled with Hide glue and for that reason Hide glue is used to repair it.
AS far as strength of bond is concerned , hide glue will stand up to a break test and the wood will fail on either side of the joint before the joint does.
That is all the strength required to make a good long lasting joint in wood.
One of the reasons I suspect some shops are unaware of the uses of Hide glue could be that they are owned or operated by untutored youngsters with no formal training in shops.
"Another is its ability to bond with both mechanical and molecular strength, unlike any synthetic glue (that includes epoxy). "
I asked this very question of a professor from the Wood Science department at VA Tech. (I can no longer remember his name, but if it becomes important I could find out) His lab studies adhesives and bonding and he was invited to this event because he was an authority on wood adhesives. I asked, " does PVA glue bond by wetting the wood (classic adhesion situation) or by mechanical interlocking of the joint by penetration into the wood." "Can't distinguish" was his answer. He went on to explain that one can't avoid penetration into the wood so it is impossible to separate these effects by experiment. Thus, it would seem that both elements are involved.
So, given this contrary opinion, what data supports your claim that PVA adhesives don't "bond with both mechanical and molecular strength", as you worded it?
In any case, it seems a moot point given that both glues are capable of making a butt joint bond stronger than the typical woods involved in this applications.
I need to needle point it on my shop wall to remind myself when I get overconfident in a complex glue up situation. This or that glue won't overcome a lack of proper planning, preparation and practice.
OK, when I got my degree in Physics at UCSD, I had no idea that all the chemistry I suffered through would find an application in my "hobby" as a woodworker. However, I have a fairly good understanding of chemistry at the molecular level.
One thing I understand about all synthetic glues is that they react to a catalyst (which can be water or part B or some other chemical) and thus convert from their initial formulation into a second formulation. Once this catalytic conversion occurs, it is impossible to return them to their original molecular structure. That is why they are not "reversible". Of course, there are stronger chemicals which act to break down the catalyzed glue, like acetone, but that is a different reaction than restoring the glue to its initial state.
Animal protein collagen glues are different, in that they remain the same molecule in each state: solid or liquid. Also, they can transfer from solid to gel to liquid and back again as many times as required, just by adjusting the temperature and moisture. Kind of like water turns to ice and back again.
One of the reasons glue turns from solid to gel to liquid is the covalent bonding action between atoms which are adjacent to each other on the coils of the protein molecule. As a function of temperature, these protein coils expand and contract, and when they reach a certain distance between these specific atoms, covalent bonding occurs which allows the sharing of the electrons in the highest orbit of each atom.
The reason I decided to modify protein glue in the first place was to lower the gel point. I did this by adding a chemical (urea) which attaches to a percentage of the covalent bonding sites, thus allowing the protein coil to cool further before it gels.
Molecular attraction is a very strong force, much stronger than mechanical adhesion. Only protein glues have this ability to bond, while in a liquid state, at a molecular level. There is also some argument that the chemical nature of the protein also will bond with certain materials, like wood, at a molecular level, but I do not have any evidence of that. I do know that, since protein glues are carried by heat and moisture, their natural action is to deeply penetrate the wood fibres, much better than a synthetic glue.
All of this is really not important if you have good wood to wood joints. Almost all glues will produce a bond which is stronger than wood under that situation. The real question is how easy it is to control the working time and how easy is it to clean up.
You wrote: One thing I understand about all synthetic glues is that they react to a catalyst (which can be water or part B or some other chemical) and thus convert from their initial formulation into a second formulation.
While this statement is essentially correct for epoxy, the modified PVA(polyvinyl acetate) glues (TitebondII for example), cyanoacrylate, and urea formaldehyde there are no new chemical bonds formed with PVA glue, for example Titebond yellow and white (which differ only by the addition of a yellow dye and a different emulsion stabilizer).
Titebond and its equivalents are a dispersion of solvent swollen PVA polymer latex(probably in fact a somewhat modified PVA polymer) . A latex in this context is a dispersion of micron sized balls of solvent swollen polymer in water. Upon application the water diffuses into the wood leaving behind the mushy balls of polymer. Because they are mushy they can coalesce into a coherent solvent swollen polymer film which is formulated to wet the wood surface to provide adhesion. Additionally, the polymer film penetrates the wood pores to provide a mechanical bond. Either adhesion or penetration could be sufficient to provide an acceptable bond. This film hardens as the solvent diffuses out to form a tough polymer layer between the wood.
As described, all these porcess result in physical, not chemical changes in the polymer. While it is not possible to reform the latex, it is possible to make the hard film mushy again by addition of solvent, for example hot water, or even heat alone. In the mushy state the bond is reversible, just like the case of protein glue.
It may not have sufficient open time, but I've never had a problem with that, so I'm guessing it'd be ok. One trick is to not follow the instructions - skip the wetting one side part. It'll pick up sufficient moisture from the wood and air to cure, but the time is slowed, maybe 8 hours to cure rather than 4. Like hide glue, the stuff tends to be slippery, so joints go together easier than with PVA's.
I'd probably use poly since the hide glue I use is hot rather than liquid, so the cooling of the glue makes me rush. Whether the glue is weakened by delaying to the stage of gelling or not, I don't know. We have a ton of expertise here on the board though, so maybe I'll find out
I also can't emphasize enough the importance of dry fitting. Its a pain, and often seems like a waste of time, but it can save you from unexpected problems - such as a tenon that's too big (I've had that happen). I also use sub-assemblies as much as possible. Given the number of tenons you mention, that may be an option for you.
Good luck, and show us some pics when you're done!
about water-born adhesives. Some woods are a lot more absorbent and some less so. Some are softer, and may compress to accept the swelling from the water, but some that were tight for the dry fit, can get darn near impossible as they swell, especially with a quick-grab glue, and especially on larger joints.
If a wood swells due to the added moisture in the glue, at the time of gluing, a good argument could be made that it is forever after trying to self destruct due to the shrinkage after the wood regains EMC, and tries to shrink back to the original size. Epoxy has no moisture to change the MC of the wood. Nor other solvent to evaporate, causing shrinkage to the epoxy itself.
Over the course of ~ 25 years of using epoxy for M&T joints, I have not ever had the need to ever take one of my pieces apart, and wonder how often others do when I read a lot of claims of the benefits of being able to do so. I guess I am just lucky maybe. But epoxy will soften when heated to ~ 200� if you ever needed to.
I'm sure it bonds more from a mechanical level than the others, but with a M&T, there is enough surface area to an already mechanical joint, that there is not likely to be any problem with properly sized and engineered joints. And if the joint is loose fitting, which may sometimes happen, epoxy may even be improved by a thicker glue-line.
I don't use epoxy for edge gluing, but I have done projects where I managed to assemble several hundred joints at a time, when I liked having control of my set time, that I just can't imagine ever doing with another adhesive. If you squirm the joint a little after starting to jell. No problem. With PVA, I don't think you will get full bond, and I don't know about hide glue.
If you guys are happy using the other glue, I am happy for you, but I think there is plenty of room for working epoxy into your bag of tricks. You can pay twice as much for the usual brands advertised in the magazines as what I use.
Someone a while back, I think on this forum, stated that additives weakened epoxy, when the opposite is true. There are many additives to change the properties of the many different mixes of resin and hardeners to customize it for whatever you need. Most of it is more brittle alone, and too thin.
Well, there is my 2�, now who needs a soap box? ha K