Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Advice/opinions requested...

Posts

Advice/opinions requested...

#1

Advice/opinions requested...

Brint in Richmond, VA

...because I know you guys provide it willingly. ;-)

Here's my first solid wood box (okay, the base is ply, but the rest is red oak). I know the wood/grain selection is poor, but I'm okay with that (i.e., don't need comments on that aspect).

I'm planning to finish with shellac. I already know some folks prefer finishing prior to assembly, and some after. So my question is, what are the reasons for your preference?

This was also the first time I used a dado blade. When I was setting it up, i thought it was kind of a pain (had to cut a new insert) and wondered if this was better than using a router. Well, I really like the clean cut that the dado blade made, so I was wondering again - do you prefer a dado blade or a router bit for making rabbets - and why?

Thanks for your advice --

Re: Advice/opinions requested...

#2

Re: Advice/opinions requested...

Bill Tindall

I don't see any problem with the wood choice.

I don't think many would finish the box before assembly.

Nothing wrong with either way to make a dado. But if you have both capabilities, a dado blade is faster, cheaper and more convenient than a router in the cases where it can be used. (I say cheaper because router bits get dull quicker than dado blades). Easier to make a stopped dado with a router. Dado blades look scary so I don't go out of my way to use them (a personal quirk). May be safer using a router, but then I shattered a 1/4" bit while cutting a short stopped dado and never found the tip. Nobody needs to tell you which is better for this or that operation. The conclusions will come to you naturally as you acquire experience using each.

Unsolicited advice: if you are going to build boxes acquire some means of making dovetails.

Re: Advice/opinions requested...

#3

Re: Advice/opinions requested...

Bartstar

Hi - some responses to your questions:

1) I only ever pre-finish when making panels that are going to be trapped inside rails/stiles. I do pre-sand in all cases - usually to 180 grit. I rarely apply stain/or finish coats till after glue up. There are major down sides to pre-finishing - you may need to tweek/sand parts of your project after glue up for proper fit and finish. I will often allow for final trimming when building something so that my corners or joints are sanded perfectly flat and smooth. Drawers come to mind as do inset doors and jewelry boxes

2) I prefer to use a dado blade on my table saw in most cases when making dados or rabbits. One exception is on stopped dados or rabbits. There i would use a router bit instead.

Hope this helps.

Bart

Re: Advice/opinions requested...

#4

Re: Advice/opinions requested...

John McGaw

Finishing before assembly is a PITA but it often avoids even larger ones involving glue seepage and access to inside corners. Finishing first is a PITA because keeping finish off of glue surfaces is sometimes difficult but for complex builds I prefer to finish first. Yours looks pretty simple so for that one I probably wouldn't.

I find dado blades to be a serious PITA too. Probably more than most people do because of the design of my weird Robland machine which has virtually zero access. That said, I find it easier to do a lot of straight unstopped dadoes or rabbets using the dado blade than a router, especially ones that can be done on the sliding table.

Re: Advice/opinions requested...

#5

Re: Advice/opinions requested...

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Good Afternoon Brint,

I like your selection of grain pattern, so forgive that comment! I prefer to finish the box after glue-up, simply because I don't have to worry about any finish preventing glued surfaces from sticking. Also, its easier to handle the sides, lid and bottom without having to be super careful about marring the finish during assembly. Further, clamps could mar the finish. Better to get it stuck together, give it a light sanding where necessary, and at the joints, and then apply your favorite finish.

On smaller items, I use a router, either hand held or in a table to plough dados/rabbets. Easy to select the correct diameter bit for a given thickness than to wrestle with shims and blade swapping/test cutting on a table saw.

OTOH, on larger items like carcases I use my table saw, dado blade, and cross cut sled as necessary.

Others skin their cats differently, and I won't argue with their success. Whatever floats your boat. You have to do it different ways to determine what method is best for you.

George

Re: Advice/opinions requested...

#6

Re: Advice/opinions requested...

Larry in NW OHIO

Prefinishing is just about how I usually do mine. According to someone here that will remain nameless ;) , right Bill, not to many here will do it that way for whatever reasons each of us have. Also I mainly use my router for cutting a dado, it`s just I like to use my router. One reason for the prefinishing is if I see something I don`t like it`s easy to redo, and I do alot of that :) Larry

Re: Advice/opinions requested...

#7

In my jungle . . .

steve mackay

I finnish after. My glue never, NEVER sticks to anything other than clear, clean wood. I think its got to do with my (blink-blink) aim (blink-blink).

Re: Advice/opinions requested...

#8

Re: Advice/opinions requested...

Steve in Phoenix

I would be concerned with marring the finished surface during the glue-up and clamping. I say assemble first, then give it its final sanding (and scraping, but that's me). Then clear out some space, clean up, let the dust settle, and doll it up.

By the way, blow out the grain with compressed air before you finish. You won't believe how much dust accumulates in the oak surface.

Re: Advice/opinions requested...

#9

Re: Advice/opinions requested...

FredD

Let me say this first Brint, if you are going to continue to use a Dado combo , please do your fingers a favor and get a metal insert for dadoing made for that saw. It is much stronger then a cutout piece of plywood or whatever you used for the insert.

That being said I use shop made zero clearence inserts much of the time for just standard saw ripping and crosscutting when splinter free cutting is required.

No doubt about it, that a Router gives a perfectly flat , tool mark free finish on the bottom of the cut that a Dado never will , but all Rabbets aren't born equal. ;-))

About which is first , a couple of good reasons for doing the finish first have been mentioned by others.

Raised panels are the only one I do first and then only at the stain stage.

I learned to finish on Cases and Furniture that were already assembled .any shop I worked in that did their own finishing , likewise , High End Furniture companies like Baker have a Assembly room , a sanding room , and a finish room in that order , after the piece has set assembled for some time.

Painters that do finish on the job don't have a choice , it's already to go when they get there.

I would agree with Bill , that upgrading your corner joints when you progress a little further will draw attention to the work you put into the piece.

FredD

Re: Advice/opinions requested...

#10

Re: Advice/opinions requested...

Brint in Richmond, VA

Thanks so much to everyone for your responses. I've done a lot of reading (books, magazines) in years past, but nothing beats having a bunch of experienced hands answer precisely the question that one is asking. I was a bit surprised to discover that most people consider both a dado blade and a router bit for different situations. I suppose I had expected answers more along the lines of "pins first/tails first" discussion. ;-)

Bill -- I do plan on learning dovetails (as well as becoming more proficient with hand tools). I wanna knock out just a couple more rabbeted joints before proceeding to the next skill level. ;-)

Bart - you (and others) mentioned a couple of post-glue-up considerations (tweaking, sanding, etc.) that I had forgotten about; thanks for the reminder.

John - I appreciated the distinction between complex and simple builds. That's a good nugget of wisdom I would not have thought of on my on.

Colonel - Yes, marring the finish on glue-up is something else I hadn't considered. (and thanks to you and Bill for the affirmation of the wood - !)

Larry - I always enjoy hearing the "minority" report, and the reasons you give certainly fall within my realm of "expertise" (or, more accurately, lack thereof). I'll definitely keep your comments in mind.

Steve M. - the orthopedist yesterday told me I can expect to get one, maybe two more years out of this hip, and I'm afraid a trip to the optometrist for bifocals is the next appointment I have to make. [blink blink] Noted.

Steve in P. - hadn't thought about using the compressed air. Will certainly do that. Do I need to use a grain-filler, then, before finishing?

Fred - thanks for sharing the "practices of the pros" - that's good to know. Also, I used a Grizzly-issued blank insert made of a composite of some sort to make the zero-clearance for the dado blade (my TS is a second-hand Grizzly 1023Z).

Again, thanks to everyone. I'll post pics when I'm done.

Re: Advice/opinions requested...

#11

To fill or not to fill.......

Bill Tindall

Filling oak leads to a much different look, more formal in my mind. So the decision is not so much that one choice is better but the look you want. Personally, I think white oak does better with filling than red, so I never fill red and almost always fill white. On a case piece I might fill the top and not the sides. For a simple box I would skip filling. On the other hand, if you want to learn filling, a box is as good a choice as any.

There is nothing shameful about machine cut dovetails. I have a kitchen full of them. And there are some moderately expensive to excessively expensive means of cutting them. But that is a whole 'nother discussion.

Re: Advice/opinions requested...

#12

some more input *LINK*

del schisler

i make jewelry box's porbly 500 or so. I use dovetales and pin only. I have 2 router's and 2 router table's . one for tails and other for pin's. That's way faster only one set up. Instead of making the complete box. I make the box part. Now i make the top and bottom. I spray each tell they are finished. Now put the box part on the bottom. I use dry wall screw's for this. I also use the round felt pad's to go over the screw's . Also hide's the screw plus a pad to keep from scratching anything it is set on. Now i put the hinge's on next. and than the top. No scratching of any of the box. It is easer. You can do box joint's also. Here is a link to see what i make. Oh i use lacquer for my finish. Here is the link


http://www.craftforum.com/members/del-schisler-2953/albums/more-jewelry-box-s/

Re: Advice/opinions requested...

#13

Re: Advice/opinions requested...

Steve in Phoenix

Filling is just another option. It all depends on the look you're going for. Filling the pores could be for a fine or elegant look, or the filler could be used to create contrast.

Also, you need to take care with how different finishes react with fillers.

A good book to have on hand is Great Wood Finishes by Jeff Jewitt.

Re: Advice/opinions requested...

#14

Re: Advice/opinions requested...

Ted Wong

I prefinish whenever I can which is about 99% of the time. My main reason being it makes for clean up of glue squeeze out a lot easier.

Cleaning glue squeeze out when it is wet can leave a stain or change of surface texture which may affect how the finish goes on in the corners.

When I put the finish and wax on prior to assembly and glue up I tape off all areas to receive glue. After glue up its easy to use a plane iron and chip off any glue squeeze out at the joints and touch up the finish if needed.