Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Air drying question

Posts

Air drying question

#1

Air drying question

brian chitwood

I recently had an ash tree sawed up and need to air dry this lumber. About 400 bd. ft. Should I stack and dry it in an old shed with not much air movement or outside where it would be exposed to the elements. This is in Wisconsin. Thanks for any help you can give. Brian

Re: Air drying question

#2

Re: Air drying question

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

First: Seal the ends very well. I use wax (hot paraffin or Anchor Seal) for air drying. If you were kiln-drying paint also works.

Second: You need a good straight foundation. I use 2x6 spaced 16oc. If you don't start with a deadnuts straight rack, don't expect straight boards.

Third: You will need to sticker the layers with a white wood. I usually use 1/2 firring strips that I rip in half. You want 3/4" between the layers.

Fourth: If you're drying in a shed, you don't need to tarp the ends to prevent too much air flow that will put more drying stress on the boards and cause checks. If outside, you'll need to wrap the ends of the stack in addition to a top tarp.

Fifth: Get some weight on the top. Cement blocks work nicely, I use 4" solids. I'll use blocks spaced about 2' apart length-wise in three rows along a 4' wide stack.

There are differences of opinion on whether to shuffle the stack over the first 4-6 months. I've tried it both ways and can't say that it makes much difference. I've air dried cherry, poplar, walnut, and hard maple. The cherry was the toughest to keep flat and straight; walnut the easiest.

Good luck!

Re: Air drying question

#3

Re: Air drying question

Grant in Iowa

Hi Brian,

Congrats on the wood haul. I have been drying lumber for about eight years now and I think I have the basics pretty well down.

Conventional wisdom is that for the first few months, the lumber should be stickered and stacked outdoors but covered in order for the majority of the moisture to be released and dissioated in the air. The main reason for this is that the amount of moisture given off by drying lumber is significant, and can create ill effects on surrounding items if the drying is done in a confined space with little air movement. Further, that same moisture can cause molds and mildews to grow on the damp lumber. You need air movement to evaporate moisture as it comes to the surface of each board.

With a small amount of lumber, you can succesfully dry it from the get go inside an enclosed space, so long as you keep air movement going and have a regular air exchange with the outdoors. I have successfully dried green lumber in quantities under about 200 BFt in a 3 car garage with no noticeable issues.

I tried 1100 BFt of green lumber inside my 1400 square foot shop last year, and while the humidity in the space never raised appreciably, I did have a touch of fungal growth on the lumber in the center of the stack. To his credit, Ellis did try to tell me drying that much lumber indoors was a mistake. Lesson learned, I will dry large stacks of lumber outdoors and under a cover from here on out, at least until it is nearly dry.

I suggest your shed would work if you could leave a door open, for air movement, or perhaps run a small fan to circulate air if it is a drafty building.

Best approach is either in a corn crib or similar shaded, well ventilated structure, or outside in a shady area with a wide roof over the top. I made up a sheet metal "roof/ sunshade" about 3 feet longer and two feet wider for drying lumber outdoors. After about 2-3 months, you can move the lumber into a building, but still sticker and stack it for another year or so (for 4/4 lumber). Alternatively, you can have someone kiln dry it for you after it drops below 25% or so Moisture content.

The idea is an area with air movement, out of direct sunlight (or build a roof to accomplish this), and a flat surface so the boards dry straight. You want the moisture out of the wood, but not too fast or too slow. A damp shed with a muddy dirt floor would likely be too slow, while an uncovered pile in direct sunlight would be too fast.

See my lumber stack method and roof below. Note the wide overhang on the roof tin on the right side and ends to limit direct sunlight. This is a total of about 1300 BFt of Cherry, Walnut, and red oak drying next to my shop since about May of this year. My pin type moisture meter now reads around 10% MC, but this doesn't mean the moisture is evenly distributed throughout the lumber yet, which will take another several months to occur. It would be premature to try to use it until the internal moisture is at equilibrium. At this point, I could move it inside, however, as most of the moisture is gone at this point. As such there is little risk to surrounding objects rusting, or of fungus growth/ sticker stain.


Hope I have answered your question in a round about way.

Regards,

Grant in Iowa

Re: Air drying question

#4

less risk outside

Bill Tindall

the elements are not going to affect the lumber and it will continue to dry even when frozen. This time of year there is no risk of it drying too fast. In fact this is a wonderful time of year to dry lumber. Do provide a cover over it. You don't want any rain or melting snow to penetrate the pile from above. Put the best lumber on the bottom and the junk on top to weight it down. It won't dry any straighter than the straightness of the pile you make. Ash dries well so you should not have any problems. Contrary to most armature wood driers, I don't recommend coating the ends as I think it is a waste of time to do so. I have never seen a commercial operation do it and I have never done it except on very thick stock, 3 and 4 ".

In the spring it will be dry enough to go to a kiln or some hot place for final drying.

Re: Air drying question

#5

Re: Air drying question

Dick Coers

No one has mentioned powder post beetles yet. They are the bain of all that air dry. Make sure you have all bark edges off. Ash sap wood is candy to this pest. You might be alright now that it is getting cold, but get that ash in a kiln before it gets warm. If you see any fine dust coming from the edges, get it to a kiln as well.

Re: Air drying question

#6

Re: less risk outside

FredD

Contrary to most armature wood driers, I don't recommend coating the ends as I think it is a waste of time to do so. I have never seen a commercial operation do it and I have never done it except on very thick stock, 3 and 4 ".

Contrary to that statement , I have never been in a Commercial Hardwood lumber yard or yard that catered to Contractors that didn't seal the board ends if they were engaged in the milling of it and if not , the units they purchased elsewere were sealed .

J .E. Higgins in Ca and Nevada for instance are the biggest wholesalers of Hardwood lumber and moulding on the West coast and dry kiln some and buy some and it is all sealed.

Same for White Brothers in Alameda. Ca which is the oldest family owned Wholesale yard in the state if they are still in business.

There was a Kiln operation in Pennslyvania that was profiled not long ago in FWW and it was a very Professional operation that extolled sealing logs and lumber.

Any Lumber units advertised in FWW , such as Northern Hardwoods and the German Beech operation show pictures of their units all sealed.

The only exception to this that I know about are the two sawmills in Kansas that I buy from and they don't , not because they don't think it is important , but because it is labor intensive the way they would go about it and they both have five gallon buckets of Anchorseal and they both do not charge me for the six inches of lumber that has split on both ends , thereby costing them a foot per board.

This is no way to run a sawmill that sells direct , but if you reflect on the background of both company owners ( a Farmer and a college business school graduate) then it is clear why you see wasted lumber in poorly stacked units outside in the weather and like that.

Maybe yards like that are prevalent in your area , but I don't think so , based on the guy who runs one in PA and the well known Hardwood lumber mills back east who advertise in the trade magazines and like the Cotten Brothers in up State New York which I have toured several times when a brother-in-law was the Milling foreman.

So for the woodworkers out there who like to do their own sawing and drying , by all means seal as soon as possible after the tree is cut into log form.

There are many experts like Bruce Hoadley who has some good books on the subject of wood in general and the Department of the Interior who oversees the Forrestry division of the National Park Service

and their rules and reccomendations for cutting and drying and milling wood.

They all mention sealing and various ways to go about it and it's importence.

FredD

Re: Air drying question

#7

Re: less risk outside

R Payne

I've coated the ends with various stuff. And left some uncoated. I've found for most stuff I've air dried (walnut, soft maple, mulberry, pecan, apricot) that coating the ends results in less checking IF the coating material sufficiently slows moisture loss. I've found that paint is nearly worthless for sealing the ends. Wax and yellow glue work well.

I wouldn't go by what a commercial operations does or doesn't do. The reason is they will price the end produce to take into account any loss due to checking. You, not reselling (I assume), will want to maximize the useable lumber out of each piece.

ron

Re: Air drying question

#8

agreed

Bill Tindall

I don't know if they have such things in Wisconsin but here in TN, I have always had to spray ash with insecticide. It is the only lumber I store that these things consistently attack. By the time you see piles of dust the interior of the lumber will be destroyed.

Re: Air drying question

#9

Dale Lenz

Re: less risk outside

Dale Lenz

> I've found that paint is nearly worthless for sealing the ends.<

I've been drying lumber since the late 80's and always paint my ends. The only time the paint seems worthless is when I've used aerosol or I've thinned latex. Other than that the paint has 98% of the time kept the lumber ends from checking.

Re: Air drying question

#10

End Sealing

Howard Acheson

Sealing the ends of logs is most effective if applied within 24 hours of felling.

The most effective end sealer is a commercial end sealing product like AnchorSeal. It's a water emulsified paraffin wax that is totally impervious to moisture transfer.

Interior rated oil based paint sometimes works. Exterior paint is designed to let moisture through to prevent the paint cracking and as it ages. Waterbased paints are even more porous than oil based.

Preliminary drying should be done outdoors. Start the stack about 10-12 inches off the ground and lay a "blue" tarp directly on the ground. Orient the stack so that the prevailing breeze blows through the stack. Put a cover on it to keep the elements off the wood. But, leave the sides open for wind flow.

Re: Air drying question

#11

More on end sealing with data

Bill Tindall

If I keep the sun off the ends of piles and don't count inevitable splits from the tree heart I have a 95% rate with no end sealing. Tree hearts split regardless of end treatment, especially in cherry. (Clearly the 95% figure is some approximate guess, see below to see how off this was) But the bottom line is that checks are not enough of an issue that I find it useful trying to prevent the small amount of waste I experience. No harm to end sealing, unless you count the abrasive effects of paint, but don't fret if you don't get around to it. It not in the same league as failing to make the pile level or using enough sticks, or keeping the pile covered.

Virginia Tech did a study on end sealing some years ago. The most important conclusion was that it is worthless unless done before end checks start to develop in the log or lumber, which will occur in as little as one day. Done right it provides some benefit. AnchorSeal stays in business so someone finds it useful. One might suppose it would be applied to the ends of veneer logs , but I have never seen it practiced in this area.

The coloring one typically finds on lumber ends is not to be confused with end sealing. Most commercial lumber has colored ends that is done for "branding" purposes.

Data: I got motivated, whilst waiting for a BLT made with the last of this year's tomato crop, to go inspect some lumber ends. I counted checks in 50 board samples of, ash, maple, cherry, oak and walnut ends (all 4/4, 250 total ends). The end check rate was approximately 15% with no apparent variation among species or whether I dried it or it was from a commercial source with colored ends.

My scrap pile doesn't fill with end cut-offs rejected for end splits. The typical split is about 2" and it becomes part of the selection and trimming process. The loss is so minimal that it isn't worth much effort to mitigate against it.

Re: Air drying question

#12

Thanks!  Great info

brian chitwood

Lots of great information! Will be stacking it outdoors for more airflow! Thanks!

Re: Air drying question

#13

Re: Thanks!  Great info

Brian George

Brian,

You've gotten a lot of feedback on the subject, all of which is valuable. One final thought, the US Forest Products Lab is located at the University of Wisconsin-Madison and has a wealth of information on this and any other subject related to timber processing. Just by googling Forest Product Laboratory you should be able to find them.

Re: Air drying question

#14

Re: More on end sealing with data

Barry Irby

I agree with Bill on this. I read somewhere, either at a Va Tech site or Woodweb that end sealing was not important in the industry. That any minor savings was offset by the cost of the sealant and the labor.

My experince is that I "use" the "damage" as part fo the project in the sense that I leave them on the boards untill the lumber is milled to near completion. Then I trim several inches off the ends. This allows me to cut off any snipe that might have happened as well as splits and staining and make it square.

Re: Air drying question

#15

TREAT for POWDER POST

John M in Mid Mich

Hope I'm not too late to add a comment. I've dried lots of ash over the last 10+ years. Powder post beetle is a scourge! When I have been diligent about treating with borate, I've had no problems. When I haven't, I've lost the lumber. There may be seasonal differences, but now I am fanatical about treating. I use a product called Timbor. An alternative product is Boracare, but in my conditions I find Timbor cheaper and easier. I buy it in the 25 lb bucket. It is very safe to use according to the MSDS. Hard to imagine something less toxic to us, but more toxic to the d*%^ed bugs. I use it on all my fresh-cut lumber now: elm, white oak, and cherry also seem particularly susceptible to PPB. Cheap insurance. I'm in the epicenter of the Emerald Ash Borer outbreak, and so have a terrible glut of ash sawlogs. More logs than I can process, more lumber than I can use. Its a sad day for another glorious tree. You can do a search on Timbor and get lots of hits. I'm not recommending the following vendor, only offering it as an example:

http://doyourownpestcontrol.com/timbor.htm


img

Re: Air drying question

#16

Re: More on end sealing with data

FredD

What data Barry , I don't see any.

I looked the last time that V-Tech was mentioned as a source , even looked at UV and both of their Wood Technology labs reported back in email that if the report existed , they couldn't find it.

What I did find though was a wealth of information on the wisdom of end coating logs and lumber as quickly as possible after it was cut.

This ranged from the US Forestry Lab to the Dry Kiln Operators handbook which is a hefty tome put out by the above , not to mention experts of long standing on Wood Technology such as Bruce Hoadley and the author of the handbook and nationally know consultant William T. Simpson.

Check it out and become truly informed.

www.treesearch.fs.fed.us/pubs/7164

FredD

Re: Air drying question

#17

I have the VA Tech report

Bill Tindall

I have seen hundreds of thousand, maybe millions of bdft of lumber drying and I have never seen a stick of it end sealed. The way lumber is processed in a plant an end check isn't very important, it is ripped out. I know that in my work I get insignificant waste from end checks.

Re: Air drying question

#18

Re: TREAT for POWDER POST

Barry Irby

Bora Care and Tim-Bor are manufactured or at least distributed by the same company now. They used to be competitive products. Tim-Boris convenient for this use because it is a powder and stores well and as the low toxicity to humans you mentioned. It is water soluble and will eventually wash off any lumber that gets enough rain on it. BoraCare is a very similar Borate mixed in glycol (anti freeze). The glycol is more toxic to humans than the borate, but they use it as a penetrant. It carries the borate deep into the wood while the tim-bor tends to sit on the surface. I like bora Care better for treating floor joists in existing construction, but I am not sure I would want to mill and sand lumber that was soaked with Glycol.

Re: Air drying question

#19

Re: More on end sealing with data

Barry Irby

Fred, as I recall I found the information on the Wood Website in their knowledge base. About five years ago I cut some walnut and cherry off the family farm and had it milled and stacked it a barn. At the time, I spent a lot of time reading up on the process and while there were many references to end sealing I found a number that said the savings were about 3% to maybe 5% and for many species and many operators it was not economically sound to end seal. I actually bought several gallons of Anchor seal and used it as far as it went, but now I don't know and can't tell which lumber/logs were sealed and which were not.

I wish I had spent the money and time on saying it with Timbor instead. The risk of ends checking is over and that from PPB's is on-going.

Re: Air drying question

#20

Re: More on end sealing with data

FredD

Barry ,

I am glad you mentioned economics , dwell on how many people have purchased and paid for ,say a eight foot hardwood board and discover they only have about seven feet of usable lumber due to end checking, that is the point and Gypo mills which are what they are called in the trade are the only ones that do not end coat , that I am aware of.

Hardwood lumber is all I visit sawmills for , softwood , Veneer logs and so on are not in the discussion, they are milled wet and sold wet.

Bugs are a problem and guys like Leon Nelson who have a controlled environment in a warehouse , with a good Kiln operation and with a slab floor with heat , have little trouble with bugs if they keep a close watch on the Ash.

Air drying exposes the wood to the comings and goings of many insects, mold, mold stain and you are left with a ambient MC of about 15% which stills needs inside storage before it came be used.

That being said, I still think Air Dried wood has a better color , especially Walnut , but I don't have a good source for it.

FredD