Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Arbor estimate

Posts

Arbor estimate

#1

Arbor estimate

Chuck Lenz

I had this droped off in my shop about a week ago, as you can see, someone allready tried to do a patch job on it probably a couple years ago the way it looks. It's the top of an arbor, it has 1" dowels that seperate the two arches by about 30". The arches are about 4 ft wide and 3 1/2" square. The arches are laminated with a 3/4" board in the center, with an 1 1/4" board on each side. So heres the question, the materials have been bought, what do you think you'd have to charge to build it ? After a few estimates have been givein I'll tell you the rest of the story of how it ended up in my shop and the price they expect it done for.

Re: Arbor estimate

#2

Re:  Arbor estimate

Chuck Lenz

I plan on useing Liquid Nail and deck screws to laminate it all together.


Re: Arbor estimate

#3

Re:  Arbor estimate

Galen Vetterick

Cannot help on the labor part. I was always ask if I could make the part if they buy the materials. Guess they thought my time was free.

I'm not a big fan of Liquid Nail to laminate parts. I'd use a good yellow water resistant glue like Titebond III. Use the screws if I did not have enough clamps.

Re: Arbor estimate

#4

Ellis Walentine

BTDT

Ellis Walentine

I made some very similar arches many years ago. I'd estimate two days to make them. If you're expected to paint them and install them, too, be sure to add for that.

Ellis

Re: Arbor estimate

#5

Re:  Arbor estimate

Justin Szeliga

Given you've got a good pattern to work from with the one section I'd say it's a days work in the shop figuring cutting, trimming w/a router, & gluing. I'd actually use Gorilla Glue or some urethane glue & clamp things so as to not have a bunch of screw holes to fill that will then let water in to the wood later on.

Re: Arbor estimate

#6

Re:  Arbor estimate

Chuck Lenz

My thoughts on the glue are I checked out the Titebond initially and found out that it isn't recommended for structural use. I also considered Gorrila glue or the equivilent but wasn't sure that I wanted to deal with the mess. The liquid nail I plan on spreading out fairly thin before clamping and scewing. My concerns are that the posts that the arbor sits on are probably as old as the the arbor top that was droped off, so I expect that they aren't real solid. Theres no way of me checking this without driveing 200 miles roiund trip. Another factor is temperature extremes up here in North Dakota -30 to 100 above. The screw heads will be filled and the arbor will be given a couple coats of solid color stain by someone else other than me. I also built a couple arches for an Arbor a few years ago for ourselves, but I can't remember the time it took me to build them, I'll blame it on geting older. I would guess that it was atleast two days, a day for assembly and to let the glue cure up, then another day in shapeing and sanding. Atleast thats what I would think, but it rarely turns out that way and usually takes longer then planed, thats why I'm asking everyone. On another note, I drew up plans for the one that got droped off before the other side falls apart.

Re: Arbor estimate

#7

Re:  Arbor estimate

Sean Troy

Congrats on getting the job offer. I would re-make them with poplar,prime and paint with a good exterior paint.

Re: Arbor estimate

#8

Re:  Pricing

Nat Robison

I'm no contractor that charges for my time but someone recently posted here about hourly charges. They said that most guys (electricians, plumbers, etc.) have a figure that they shoot for to make each day. If they're discounting a part for you, chances are the labor "might take an extra 30 minutes".

I'm a novice and I don't use a lot of nice wood for things but I can make things look decent. If I was given a job that I could do, and considering I have all the tools for the job, I'd probably look to make no less than $150-$200 per 8-9 hour day. The alternative is them hiring someone who needs to maintain a truck, insurance, worker's comp, etc. That's the thing I have to remind myself when using a pro, they generally have a rolling shop that costs $30k-$50k that needs to be supported somehow. Don't discount the investment you've made in your tools when figuring your rate.

Re: Arbor estimate

#9

Clint Searl

Re:  Arbor estimate

Clint Searl

Farm it out to the guy who responds with the lowest estimate if he'll give you a fixed price at that estimate, then charge your client twice that. Sounds like a win-win to me.

Clint

Re: Arbor estimate

#10

Re:  Arbor estimate, heres the deal

Chuck Lenz

Well it looks like I would have to pull teeth on this one to get a price out of you guys, but thats ok, I was really leary of giveing a price also by the way the project was dumped on me. So heres the deal. My sisters husband droped it off one day, it's his parents that live 100 miles away. When he drops it off he asks me if I can do it for $300. I said I don't know, it's custom work. Then he tells me that he told his folks that I charge $15 an hour. Well that was nice of him to decide what I should charge. So to keep the peace I just let it go. So anyway we got the materials and that was $100, the brother inlaw paid for it, now I'm down to only makeing $200 on this deal. Long story short is the brother inlaw and is his folks aren't exactly hurtin for cash, and I've been takein advantage of plenty of times by the brother inlaw, currently he's trying to get daddy's Porshe, and I think he's useing me to score points with him. I just really don't have much motivation to do this project, and was looking for maybe a little light at the end of the tunnel here. I'm afraid I'm going to end up with less then $10 an hour on this whole deal. It's a mess and is closely aproaching my limits like it did about 7 years ago when he came into my shop and I ended up telling him to get the hell out and never comeback. I never wanted it to come to this again, but you start doing some people favors and it doesn't stop, and when I say thats enough then they continue to push for more or I get called every name in the book. I just got done building him a coat rack and pigeon hole cabinet for his garage that I made about $8 an hour on, then spent a day helping him hang cabinets in his garage for free, then I told him that was enough for awhile, but no, he drops this crap off in my lap. I guess I'm just an idiot and a fool for ever thinking that things would be any different after all those years. I'm not retired, and I haven't had steady work in over two years, so this just isn't a hobby to me. I've been a woodworker for around 30 years, and I don't claim to be the best or know it all, but I do know a few things. Hell, the other day I made $50 in two hours tilling some guys garden, it was nice to feel like I was worth something for a change.

Re: Arbor estimate

#11

Wow...

John E in SC

Wow, Chuck, given that background, I don't think I'd touch that project with a 10 foot pole. It doesn't sound like something you really want to do anyway, and unless you're really hurting for money, probably wouldn't be worth your time. AND, hate to say it, but sounds like it wouldn't really be appreciated anyway. I've done projects for people I consider friends for free, and enjoyed doing it, knowing they have different talents and would do the same for me. Your "clients" don't seem to value your time or effort. I might just say that the more you looked into it, it's not really something you think you can handle, you're too busy, etc. etc. Definitely a no win situation. Good luck.

Re: Arbor estimate

#12

Take advantage of ya once, shame on them.....

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

Take advantage of you once, shame on them----- take advantage of you twice, shame on you.

Then again, how much do you value keeping peace with your sister's husband and his family? Sometimes, being a good person just doesn't pay, but is still the right thing to do.

Just saying.....

Re: Arbor estimate

#14

Re: Wow...

Chuck Lenz

Yeah John, nowdays I know only one guy that I can trust to barter work with, he's a retired electrician. I spent a few days this summer laying landscape bricks for him and his wife at their home on the rivers shore. I know that he will allways return the favor when needed. It's also a good time to sit back and have a beer or two with him after the job is done and shoot the bull.

Re: Arbor estimate

#15

Re: Take advantage of ya once, shame on them.....

Chuck Lenz

I know what your saying Tim, and I will more than likely eat this one again. But thats it, I'm done after that.

Re: Arbor estimate

#16

Re: Take a pass.  It ain't worth it.

Chuck Kettler--Greenwood, IN

I think it was worth the original offer of $300 for your labor. Payment up front. Paint and install extra.

Re: Arbor estimate

#17

Re: Take a pass.  It ain't worth it.

Larry in NW OHIO

You could kind of forget to put glue in it. Larry

Re: Arbor estimate

#18

Re:  Arbor estimate, heres the deal

Brint in Richmond, VA

"I'm sure you know I want to do an especially good job for your folks, and this is a particularly challenging piece -- not that it's beyond my skill level at all, but it's custom work that requires custom attention. And actually, I was recently paid $25/hour for work that's easier than this. I'm happy to do it, and figuring on two 8-hour days to finish it, that's $400 for labor alone. But since you're family, I'll offer a 25% discount and take the $300 you offered when you dropped it off. I'd like to have it up front, please, since I've got some expenses that I need to take care of."



More than one way to skin a cat, and I'm not sayin' mine's the best -- just one option....

Re: Arbor estimate

#19

Somehow, mixing business and family...

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

gets complicated way more often than it gets simple.

Re: Arbor estimate

#20

Re:  Arbor estimate, heres the deal

Joseph Mulherin, Sr

Chuck, I have to agree with the quote Brint just said....say that to your BIL and tell him that if he doesn't like it to take the job to someone else. I was a Union Pipefitter/Plumber and it always happened I was called to fix someone in the family or relative of theirs-in-laws just so they could get the problem fixed at no cost....and it does not foster good relations. What gives with the Sister??? does she not have any say in this???

Re: Arbor estimate

#21

Re:  Arbor estimate, heres the deal

Chuck Lenz

My sister ? Thats another chapter.

Re: Arbor estimate

#22

Clint Searl

Re:  Arbor estimate, heres the deal

Clint Searl

I'm surprised at all the advice to take the job at any price. I think I would call the BIL's parents and tell them that their son doesn't have authority to commit my efforts and that I won't do the repair. No excuse or explanation is necessary. Don't be a wus.

Clint

Re: Arbor estimate

#23

Re:  Arbor estimate, heres the deal

Chuck Lenz

Clint, thats the best reply I've heard so far, and was a consideration till I spoke to my father about it, but obviously he don't get it either.

Re: Arbor estimate

#24

Re: Somehow, mixing business and family...

Chuck Lenz

Your exactly right Bill, you can add friends to that list as well.

Re: Arbor estimate

#25

Re:  Arbor estimate, Thanks for the replies

Chuck Lenz

Like I said before, I'm just going to build the damn thing, get whatever I get out of it and shut the doors. No more BS.