Tool Accuracy
David Frame
Hi All,
Does anyone have any experience with the accuracy of a magnetic digital angle gauge for a tablesaw blade?
And, which of the many gauges sold, gives the best readings?
Thanks for your time,
David Frame Jr.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Tool Accuracy
David Frame
Hi All,
Does anyone have any experience with the accuracy of a magnetic digital angle gauge for a tablesaw blade?
And, which of the many gauges sold, gives the best readings?
Thanks for your time,
David Frame Jr.
Re: Tool Accuracy
Tony - Memphis
I have the Beall unit. I have been very happy with it. I can't vouch for the accuracy. I don't really have a good way to measure it. It is repeatable and consistent. It agrees with some other methods/tools I use to measure angles with. I believe I got it on sale at Woodcraft? Beall claims +/- 0.1�. I have a TS Aligner Jr and they agree.
Tony
Re: Tool Accuracy
FredD
David , I own a Wixey ,use it fairly often, it is accurate enough for the most demanding blade setups for woodworkers..
Couldn't say about it's competition ,though I nearly bought Jerry's swinging gauge and then though hesitation brought on by procrastination , I got the Wixey..
FredD
On making precise cuts
bill tindall
I don't have an answer to your question but the reason I don't could be of interest. I don't know how typical my experience is but for what it is worth.......
When I began woodworking I thought I could set machines up with measurement devices- rulers, protractors, etc. Now, I rarely rely on some measuring instrument to make a setting that needs to be accurate. I either transfer a measurement from what ever needs to be fit or I by trial get to the setting required.
Take for example cutting something to length to exactly fit between two fixed parts. I hold that to be cut up to the opening and scribe with a knife the length on the piece to be cut. Or take the case of a 90 degree miter. I have never been able to set a miter cut to the required precision with measurement devices. I set the blade at near 45 degrees, make a test cut and a test fit, and repeat these steps to get the cut perfect, resulting in a perfect 90 degree miter as confirmed by a quality square. The square is the only accurate measuring tool I regularly use. (I do often use a digital caliper, but not for tool set up.)
Re: Tool Accuracy
JL
I bought a Wixey. It is a good set-up tool for checking out your table saw and possibly aligning it. I have also used it on my jointer fence.
It is reasonable - provided you remember to remove the battery after you finish using it.
save your money
Dick Coers
The Wixey only goes to one decimal place. So to me, I wonder at what point does it jump to the next decimal place. That's .01 degrees they are playing with. .1 degrees on a 3" radius of an extended saw blade is .005". That's about two sheets of paper, and that will make a bad joint. I bought a Beall since it reads two decimal places. A test engineer friend of mine sent his back after doing some extensive testing. I had mine too long to do that. Overall, if you have to run test pieces, even after spending the money for a digital guage, I would not buy the guage.
I agree on all counts
Bruce, a MN Galoot
I have a top notch dial caliper, but mostly what I use it for is transferring dimensions, not taking measurements.
Bill's Got It
David Yoho
David, even though I have owned the complete TS Aligner kit for many years, I rarely use it for setting blade angles. For 45-degree cuts, I might start out using the head of my Starrett combo square to check the angle setting but I usually just set the angle on the saw and sneak up on the right setting with test cuts.
Works for me!
Re: save your money
FredD
The Wixey gauge (notice the spelling) I have reads dead on with the stops of 45 and 90 on my PM saw, so one would have to believe it would also be dead on at 30 degrees and so on.
It also agrees with drafting triangles I used for years and the battery life is a non issue , since it has a automatic shut off.
I have set it for twelve sided boxes and the pieces fit just fine.
That being said . I suppose if one looks hard enough , they could find fault with nearly anything.
That being said , the gauge is more accurate then most woodworkers and it has constant repeatibilty that few if any of us have.
FredD
Re: Tool Accuracy
Dave Paine
I have two Wixey units which look like square blocks. One I purchased and one I got with another Wixey purchase - a digital fence for the table saw.
I also have a digital protractor.
These all are rarely used. I found they are not precise enough for easy use. They do not have the resolution I want. On the table saw fence I can eyeball much closer with my saw mounted tape scale than I can with the Wixey. Shame, if I could get my desired resolution the Wixey would be great for re-setting a cut.
The setup tool I use most is my DIN standard 90 deg square and 45 deg squares I purchased from Grizzly. A much better investment. These are dead on. If I need to cut at an angle, I can get back to 90 deg with the square, then make a test cut on a scrap piece of 3 in deep redwood to check the cut.
I have used the Wixey for some odd-angles. More accurate than table saw scale, but for 90 deg and 45 deg, I calibrate with my squares.
On the utility of dial/digital calipers
bill tindall
One might look askance at having a digital or dial caliper in a wood working shop but mine stays in the bench drawer where it is handy because I use it so often. One of its most useful jobs is measuring screw and nail diameters. The caliper plus a set of number drills has eliminated broken screws, stripped screw heads, split molding, bent brads, etc.
I have used it to measure lumber thickness to ensure the thickness planer is set up right or that my hand planing has not gone out of whack (often it has).
Other uses aren't coming to mind right now but it gets used often.
Squares
Bill Tindall, East TN
I agree, the most important accurate measuring tools to own is a set of squares. I am an advocate of a 4" sliding tee square, a 12 combination square (Starrett or equivalent), plus others depending on what one makes. The place in Lexington KY that sells books and woodworking stuff (Manney's?) used to sell a made in India set of squares for about $75. There were (are?) as accurate as my Starretts and I use all but the largest with regularity. I do wish there were ruled in 1/16ths instead of 64ths. It is mindless to rule woodworking stuff in 64ths. too hard to read. I can easily estimate 64ths from a 1/16 ruling.
My Opinion David
George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA
I bought and use the Beale Tilt Box a few months ago after it became obvious that I couldn't trust my eyes any more than I could trust my non-Starret guages. For 70 years, my eyes did okay by themselves, even though they did need correction. Strangely, nobody ever criticized me for my lack of accuracy or poorly fitting joints, even when I realized I needed some help setting cutting angles. I really like the convenience and repeatability of the tilt box for set-up work. To me, its fast and easy, no eye strain and no frustration. My cuts are all "close enough" for wood working. My Tilt Box was well worth the very modest investment. It is fortunate that others can discern merits of other devices, because they are as comfortable in their method as I am in mine. More than one way to skin a cat.
George
Re: Tool Accuracy
john lucas
David I find mine quite accurate for what i use it for. I use it to set angles on my miter guage. I set the wixey on the table saw table and zero it. Then I set miter gauge on the table with the sliding rail down. I put the wixey on this and then adjust the angle until the guage reads what i want. it is accurate enough that I do 8 and 12 segmented rings without having to change things.
I use it on my metal lathe to set angles. Zero it on the cross feed table and then put it on the steel I'm cutting. Adjust it until it has the angle I want and then clamp it down. I'm a learning machinist so there is probably a more accurate way to do this but I've found this quite accurate for the jobs I've done.
Re: Tool Accuracy *LINK*
Jesse Cloud
As usual, I'm in agreement with Bill. When I start a project that uses angles other than 90 degrees, I make a "standard" block with my approximation of that angle and use the block to set the blade or miter gauge. What we are usually after is consistency, rather than precision.
The school where I take classes has several wixey gauges. We tried the other day to get them all to register the same angle on a saw blade set at something less than 90 degrees. They varied by a degree or so plus or minus. The same box often could not get the same reading twice. So, my view is that they are reasonable for a 'pretty close' setting, but not mission critical accurate.
Its very important to keep the gauge in the same plane when you move it from where you "zero" it out to where you are measuring an angle.
I know its kinda old school and not NASA accurate, but one of my favorite tools is the Bevel Boss - you can actually read an angle and use it to set your bevel gauge for tool setting.
bevel boss
Re: On the utility of dial/digital calipers
Larry in NW OHIO
Bill Just a note on your No. Drills. Did you get a full set of drills of 115 bits. The one with the standard drills, and the No. set, and the decimal set all in one. I looked for quite a while on Ebay mostly to find one with all off them in and made in the USA. I saw one about 7 months ago, but it got away from me for something like $110. So I kept on looking. The ones made in the USA went for over and way over $100, but I thought I could do better. So a couple of weeks ago I fianally found someone selling them for $65+$13 shipping and made in the US, so I jumped on it. When I got it the first thing I did was make sure they were made in the US. Sure enough stamped on each bit was Made in the USA, and I took my dials and measured a few and they were right on. They really look nice. Larry
Tilt Box
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
I have and use for beveled cuts on both the table saw and the SCMS. I do check it from time-to-time with a Starrett draftsman's adjustable 45� protractor. It's fairly easy to work to a "thou" this way on shorter cuts. I also use the Starrett to check the "stops" on my saws and jointer periodically.
If doing a series of miters, I'll use or make a very accurate outside angle jig (other than 90�) to check the results of the mating cut surfaces. 90� joints are checked with a Starrett try square.
import vs US number drill bits
Bill Tindall, East TN
The cost of US made drill bits should not prevent most woodworkers from owning a set of number drills. The typical use is drilling a pilot hole in wood so if the drill is off0.001", or not perfectly round or what ever it doesn't matter. I consider a set of number drills so critical to my work that if I could not afford a made in US set I would be satisfied with an import set.
Screw machine (short length) number drills... *LINK*
David Barnett
... are my favorites, especially in the flexy smaller diameters, and I prefer 118� (wood, plastic, brass) to 135� (steel), but almost all the sets are the latter, these days. Here's the cheapest number set I've found, if you don't mind a mix of finishes.
Sets are at end of page
Another Tilt Box fan
Lee Schierer McKean, PA
I purchased the Beall Tilt box after considering both it and the Wixey. The Beall reads to .05 degrees and uses a common 9 volt battery. It is a great improvement over eyeballing drafting triangles to the side of the blade when cutting bevels and sure beats trial and error for achieving any other angle. You can still fine tune the cuts to get perfect joints, but it will take fewer test cuts to get there with a Tilt box.
Lee
only way to go beall Tilt Box
del schisler
I have the beall and find it very good. I use it on my drill press bed to drill bit. Set up my fence on the jointer. And the blade on the table saw. And band saw bed. It will measure any thing with a metal bed to another netal item. Wouldn't be with out it.
Might want to check this out
Ellis Walentine
It's coming soon from Bridge City. The digital caliper makes it accurate to a hundredth of a degree.
Ellis
Bridge City makes
Gary Smyth
beautiful stuff, but the cost of that item is? Mostly owing to cost and the artifically determined collector value of "rare" and "pristine" on a new tool, I have yet to meet any person with a Bridge City anything that uses the tool for its intended purpose. All show and no go. To me it's the $ (fill in blank) secreted away non dust collecting paperweight.
I beg to differ
Neal in San Jose
I regularly use one of their 6 inch combo squares (it was a blem I picked up at a tools show) because the numbers are easier to see than my Starrett; one of my ww buddies has several of their tools that he uses and likes, and I gave one of their 6 inch combo squares to another friend and I know he uses it. At least, he uses it when I'm around, LOL.
Rube Goldberg might be proud
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
but it may well be a very clever device.